Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To miss dd's birthday to help out family?

163 replies

StressBallPit · 24/07/2023 11:46

I feel really shitty about this but can't make up my mind if it's actually not such a big deal or if I've got my priorities all screwed up.

My parents live abroad and DM has recently had a stroke. She is likely to make a good recovery but at the moment requires 24h care and supervision. My sister is there at the moment to help out my parents but she will have to leave soon. Ideally, once she leaves I'd like to go there for a couple of weeks to help my parents. Unfortunately, this would mean missing dd's birthday. If I stay for her birthday my parents will be for 5 days without any help, which I think would be very, very hard on them. Also, if I leave after her birthday I will then be away when she goes back to school, which dh would find difficult to manage (getting two little kids ready and school/ nursery run).

DD insists that I'm here for her birthday. (She's turning 8). We are thinking of arranging her party before that so I will be there for that but not for her actual birthday. I thought I could tell her that her and me will do something special when I'm back.

Yabu: Birthdays are very important at this age and missing it will tell her that she is not a priority for you.

Yabnu: helping family in a medical emergency trumps birthdays. DD will just have to suck it up and learn that while she is very impo

OP posts:
cptartapp · 24/07/2023 14:24

I would go to your parents but strictly on a short term basis and use the time to plan longer term care. The current set up is not sustainable and not fair. If DM can't be left and carers can't be arranged within the two planned weeks they would have to consider residential care.
What were you parents' plans for managing illness or coping as they aged and became frail when they moved?

HoldOnMiGenna · 24/07/2023 14:22

Five years ago, I had cousins over from Long Island, The Bronx and Brooklyn visiting .
After a few days, two of them asked me nervously " where are the elders?". They had noticed the British invisibility of inconvenient old people.
I told them that old people and notions of parenting outside of the parameters of atomised affirmation are hated by the class of people that hold the cultural power in the UK and for whom strident authoritarian insecurity which translates into a fear of being disliked is their main purview.
This thread has not proven me wrong.

Lacucuracha · 24/07/2023 14:21

strongcupofTea · 24/07/2023 14:18

I wouldn't miss my daughters birthday personally. Your parents chose to live away from family in Spain so they should have made contingency plans for this type of thing. They'll have to get in carers.

Eh? OP says she chose to move away from their country.

strongcupofTea · 24/07/2023 14:18

I wouldn't miss my daughters birthday personally. Your parents chose to live away from family in Spain so they should have made contingency plans for this type of thing. They'll have to get in carers.

Zinfandelfoot · 24/07/2023 14:16

Go take care of your mum, your DD will have more birthdays that you will be there for. Arrange a lovely day out or party for her before you go and perhaps a couple extra presents under her bed to open on her birthday. A few FaceTime calls on the day. It will be hard for her to understand but I would try to explain that granny is unwell and needs to be taken care of but that doesn’t mean she is less important. Her birthday will still be celebrated.

StressBallPit · 24/07/2023 14:16

BiscuitsandPuffin · 24/07/2023 13:32

The DM literally already has carers looking after her. OP thinks she needs to be out there to "organise" things. Apparently her DF can just sit around doing nothing because he's a man and even though there are carers and he has capacity, he apparently can't be burdened with the organising even though he's said he's fine to do this.

No, it's got nothing to do with him being a man. He's barely slept for more than an hour for the last month because he and my sister are the only ones that can somewhat calm dm down. When she isn't calm she is a danger to herself (as in she tries to get up, which she isn't meant to do as she can't walk yet or she tries to pull her wires off her, etc). The carers are not able to prevent that without being extremely heavy handed which my dad doesn't want so he is with her 24/7. She isn't herself at the moment and she is barely sleeping, which means that my dad doesn't get much sleep either. As I said he is not in very good health either so we are worried about him as well. She currently needs more than one family member to be around to do all the things the carers can't do. It's a very complex situation and I don't want to go into the details because it's not relevant.

What is relevant is that my parents are struggling massively and are suffering. I can help them and make their life a bit easier by missing DD's birthday or I can go later and have them struggle on their own for a few days in the hope that they will be able to hang on without either of them getting worse till I get there.

OP posts:
Annaisatwat · 24/07/2023 14:15

Over the last few years, I put my dad first. I missed my youngest childs first birthday as I was driving an 8 hour round trip as he’d been taken into hospital (I had to fight to get him diagnosed with dementia). I missed my eldest sons graduation, my middle child’s 8th birthday. All dealing with him. I missed so much of my toddlers first 18 months caring for him and fighting for him to get care.

It was seeing my 8 year old upset that I was always running off 4 hours away to him that made me think enough was enough and I drew a line a refused to do anything else. I’m an only child with no other family so it meant him going into a home.

This is your time with your child and you will never get it back.

Obviously, my experience has clouded my view. But I wish I’d put my own children first from the beginning.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/07/2023 14:12

Its a life lesson for DD. Tough to learn, but necessary. Birthdays dont trump everything else.

rookiemere · 24/07/2023 14:08

Also OP may not be 100% needed to provide care, but her DM has had a stroke of course she wants to be there.

W1h · 24/07/2023 14:07

EsmeSusanOgg · 24/07/2023 13:57

Yup. The amount of posters who think OP's mum is dying and does not have care in place is quite substantial.

I think OP and her sister are best placed to decide how much support their parents need. When my Mum had a stroke my Dad was hospitalised within a week due to becoming ill himself from the shock and stress. And that was with me there supporting (and importantly being there to get my Dad to hospital when it became necessary). He would also have sworn blind he could have coped but I knew he was starting to struggle with certain things beforehand and in that situation required support.

Having seen how quickly my, not that old, parents went from healthy and active, to both being hospitalised, I definitely wouldn't let either of my parents go through something similar alone. And they're both fully recovered and happily living their lives independent of me again now. Whereas the outcome might have been quite different if I hadn't temporarily stepped up to help out and been there when needed.

DancingInLines · 24/07/2023 14:06

I wouldn’t miss my child’s birthday at that age. Your parents are adults and have carers.

I’d go after your daughters birthday, your husband will actually have to cope with his two children going back to school.

Remaker · 24/07/2023 14:05

DH missed our DC’s 10th birthday because he was attending MIL’s funeral abroad. We got the rest of the family involved to make it really special and while she does remember it as a sad birthday she was fine.

However, as someone who has been caring for an elderly parent recently I would encourage you to also think beyond this immediate crisis time. Presumably your DSis and yourself will not be able to be going back and forth endlessly to help. It might actually be better for your parents to have a few days on their own to work out what they need help with, what’s working and what’s not. Otherwise there might be a temptation to just let you and your sibling take care of everything and then you’ll be leaving and your parents won’t feel capable of managing. That’s how it has worked out with my DM who is very capable but prefers to let others do everything for her, which isn’t always practical. She needs some gentle encouragement to make the most of her abilities.

Maddy70 · 24/07/2023 14:04

It's just a day that she won't remember in a few year.s. Just go !

Howdoesitworkagain · 24/07/2023 14:02

100% stick around for my daughter’s birthday and then go. And I wouldn’t be fretting about my husband “coping” with back to school and nursery arrangements. Why are the men so helpless in this scenario?! Expect more from them.

Mix56 · 24/07/2023 14:02

Do the Bday before leaving.
tell your DD, that this is YOUR MUMMY, & that she needs you.

EsmeSusanOgg · 24/07/2023 13:57

BiscuitsandPuffin · 24/07/2023 13:32

The DM literally already has carers looking after her. OP thinks she needs to be out there to "organise" things. Apparently her DF can just sit around doing nothing because he's a man and even though there are carers and he has capacity, he apparently can't be burdened with the organising even though he's said he's fine to do this.

Yup. The amount of posters who think OP's mum is dying and does not have care in place is quite substantial.

CoffeeMama1 · 24/07/2023 13:55

Right so as someone who doesn't have the best relationship with either parent, you have a duty to your family.
If your parents live abroad did they move there or did you move away? I'm sorry but personally I'd arrange some care for them but that's it. Your daughter will remember you missing her birthday and as a parent you should be showing your daughter that nothris more important than her. Adults have a responsibility to look after themselves and sort themselves out, you can help but you can't be in two places at once and its unreasonable of them to expect you to drop everything if they live in a different country.

HermioneKipper · 24/07/2023 13:54

You poor thing, this all sounds so stressful.

Unfortunately for your daughter your ill mother definitely trumps her birthday.

if you’re there for the party and then she’s treated by her dad on the day itself then that’s fine if say. And then an extra special treat with you when you get back.

EsmeSusanOgg · 24/07/2023 13:53

TrueScrumptious · 24/07/2023 13:28

Well, I didn’t, because my workplace doesn’t allow leave over the period of her birthday -Christmas time. Anyway, if there are two parents, only one would take time off, not both.

But we are talking about the summer holidays here. And that is not an experience I have come across.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/07/2023 13:45

OP, go and be with your parents. They need you more at this particular time.

It's very unlucky for your dd, but honestly, it's just a birthday. It isn't that big of a deal.

My own mum missed my ninth birthday in very similar circumstances (helping elderly parents through a health crisis). I was gutted not to have her there for my party or for my birthday, and it does stand out in my memory as being the worst birthday ever.

However, in the grand scheme of things, I think a child who is generally loved and well cared for is more than capable of dealing with the minor disappointment of a crap birthday. Yes, she will miss you and it won't be the same without you, but in time, she will understand why difficult choices sometimes have to be made.

I am not scarred by my experience of a birthday without my mum, and I wouldn't have hesitated to miss dd's birthday if similar circumstances had arisen. She is loved and she is important, but she needs to learn that sometimes, other things will need to take priority and that's OK. It's just a birthday...

W1h · 24/07/2023 13:44

I actually wouldn't do as others are suggesting and bring her party forward - I'd arrange that for her actual birthday as a good distraction from the fact that you aren't there (assuming you have enough adults available to help you out and provide adequate supervision) - at most kids parties my experience is they don't really care about what adults are there, they're too busy having fun with their friends. And have a special family day out/ early celebration before you go.

Also make sure that if you have any family traditions that you personally normally implement/manage (i.e. rather than your dh) that your DH is given explicit instructions (and reminders if your DH is likely to forget) so your dd isn't upset that she doesn't get her birthday breakfast pancakes or whatever because you aren't there.

Clymene · 24/07/2023 13:41

dm is not cooperating with the carers (not her fault, the personality changes are part of her injury), her needs are quite complex at the moment, and it's all very hard on my dad who isn't in the best of health either.

That sounds a very difficult situation. I would be there like a shot and I know my children would absolutely understand that would be worth missing a birthday for.

jeaux90 · 24/07/2023 13:34

Am I missing something here OP?

You say your dad isn't in the best of health but surely he is capable of sorting the carers etc out? It sounds very much like you and your sister are feeling like you need to step in whilst he sounds perfectly able to do it and insisting that you stay for her birthday. Did your DF actually ask for help?

I would let him get on with it and stay for your DDs birthday like he said!

ditalini · 24/07/2023 13:32

EsmeSusanOgg · 24/07/2023 13:26

That seems odd, and highly improbable. Taking a day off in the middle of the summer holidays is pretty usual for parents of young children. I think you are stretching here. I don't know anyone who either grew up a child with a holiday birthday, or are parents to a child with a holiday birthday who do not take off their child's birthday.

Hello!

My dad went to work on my birthday unless a) we were on family holiday or b) it was the weekend because all that boring stuff - rotas, limited holiday availability, etc. My mum was a teacher so she was off.

I wasn't the only one. Plus had plenty of friends around to celebrate with.

BiscuitsandPuffin · 24/07/2023 13:32

PizzaPlease7 · 24/07/2023 13:27

All of this! ^^

Haven’t read all the replies but I’m shocked at how many “8 is a tricky age you shouldn’t go” and “what an impossible situation!!” Posts there are. Gosh it really is a no brainer. No wonder there’s so many entitled kids nowadays! You go and help your parents, DD will understand (if not right now, when she’s a bit older). Party before is a good compromise.

The DM literally already has carers looking after her. OP thinks she needs to be out there to "organise" things. Apparently her DF can just sit around doing nothing because he's a man and even though there are carers and he has capacity, he apparently can't be burdened with the organising even though he's said he's fine to do this.