Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To miss dd's birthday to help out family?

163 replies

StressBallPit · 24/07/2023 11:46

I feel really shitty about this but can't make up my mind if it's actually not such a big deal or if I've got my priorities all screwed up.

My parents live abroad and DM has recently had a stroke. She is likely to make a good recovery but at the moment requires 24h care and supervision. My sister is there at the moment to help out my parents but she will have to leave soon. Ideally, once she leaves I'd like to go there for a couple of weeks to help my parents. Unfortunately, this would mean missing dd's birthday. If I stay for her birthday my parents will be for 5 days without any help, which I think would be very, very hard on them. Also, if I leave after her birthday I will then be away when she goes back to school, which dh would find difficult to manage (getting two little kids ready and school/ nursery run).

DD insists that I'm here for her birthday. (She's turning 8). We are thinking of arranging her party before that so I will be there for that but not for her actual birthday. I thought I could tell her that her and me will do something special when I'm back.

Yabu: Birthdays are very important at this age and missing it will tell her that she is not a priority for you.

Yabnu: helping family in a medical emergency trumps birthdays. DD will just have to suck it up and learn that while she is very impo

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StressBallPit · 26/07/2023 09:26

rookiemere · 25/07/2023 07:33

I think you should go, but I hate this undercurrent from some that DD is a spoiled brat because she wants her DM there for her birthday and it will serve her jolly right and teach her a life lesson if she isn't.

Of course she wants her DM there, she loves her, soon enough she'll not care. Yes she needs to understand why you won't be there, but she's still allowed to feel disappointed by that.

No, she's not spoilt at all and even if she had got upset or made a fuss I wouldn't have blamed her. She's allowed to feel upset and disappointed.

I told her yesterday that I probably wasn't going to be there for her actual birthday and she took it very well. At first she said I must not miss it but when I said we will do something special just her and me later she was fine with that. In fact, she said she wants to wait to open her presents from me for when I'm back. I'd love to be there for that but I think that wouldn't be very nice for dh. I'll get her a present from my parents' place that we can open together when I'm back.

Thanks everyone for helping me figure this out!!

OP posts:
TerrorAustralis · 25/07/2023 08:46

rookiemere · 25/07/2023 07:33

I think you should go, but I hate this undercurrent from some that DD is a spoiled brat because she wants her DM there for her birthday and it will serve her jolly right and teach her a life lesson if she isn't.

Of course she wants her DM there, she loves her, soon enough she'll not care. Yes she needs to understand why you won't be there, but she's still allowed to feel disappointed by that.

I don't think anyone is saying a child is spoiled because they want their parent with them on their birthday. It's that a child will become spoiled and entitled if their wishes are always prioritised over the needs of others. And right now, the OP's parents' needs are quite significant.

As you say, she will probably be disappointed, but learning that sometimes we are disappointed and learning to manage disappointment is part of building resilience.

Kids whose parents try to protect them from every disappointment in life aren't doing them any favours.

mrsplum2015 · 25/07/2023 07:48

@MooFroo I think it is very difficult to understand people's circumstances unless you know all the details.
While that decision may have seemed callous to you I don't think you are likely to have had the whole history of family relationships or be privy to the persons conversations with her mother, who may have told her to go on the holiday and make the most of the life she has.

People have a range of relationships with family and a range of attitudes to death. I found it odd that my friend rushed back to the other side of the world for a funeral of a distant relative leaving her very young children for two weeks but i wouldn't presume to say she was wrong.

rookiemere · 25/07/2023 07:33

I think you should go, but I hate this undercurrent from some that DD is a spoiled brat because she wants her DM there for her birthday and it will serve her jolly right and teach her a life lesson if she isn't.

Of course she wants her DM there, she loves her, soon enough she'll not care. Yes she needs to understand why you won't be there, but she's still allowed to feel disappointed by that.

Zinfandelfoot · 25/07/2023 07:18

I think you’re making the right decision.
Good luck OP

StressBallPit · 25/07/2023 06:06

Thanks everyone for sharing your views. Yes, i will go early. The post I wrote on how much they are struggling made it really clear to me that I have to. The posters who mentioned long term care are right. I need to go to sort that out and going early is the only way all of us, that is me, sister and parents can be in the same room to discuss everything (we live in 3 different countries).

OP posts:
SlippySarah · 25/07/2023 05:31

I would 100% go and help my parents and set an example to my DC of how important it is to care for others. My DS is eight and would be totally fine spending his birthday with his Dad if I left presents and had a video call with him. Can her Dad take her out for a treat, maybe with a friend?

rwalker · 25/07/2023 05:14

Go to your mum
I can’t get over the fact some people think a birthday takes priority over your sick mum

I’m sure she’ll still celebrate it without you

TimeToMoveIt · 25/07/2023 03:25

I'd go to your parents , 8 is old enough to understand that have grandparents need you right now

No wonder we have so many self centred , self observed teens and young adults these days

TerrorAustralis · 25/07/2023 02:58

Alargeoneplease89 · 25/07/2023 00:30

Yup! No wonder we are turning into a self obessed entitled society. Goodness if my child seemed to be precious over a birthday, then their grandparents health, I would be concerned.

As I said before I left my 5 year old when my dad was dying on his birthday and it was a long trip, he is now 14 and still a sweet natured and empathic boy.

Exactly! I despair at some of these responses.

How will a child ever develop resilience if they never experience any disappointment in their lives?

These kids of parents who wouldn’t miss a birthday for anything will be posting in 30 years’ time “AIBU DH went to his dying mother’s bedside instead of treating me on my b’day”.

billy1966 · 25/07/2023 00:59

I must say at 8 I absolutely think it is both reasonable and possible to explain that Granny is ill.

Definitely have the special meal for 4 before you go and another one when you return as she was so understanding.

Life happens sometimes and overtakes plans.

Go and help your parents.

Nothing wrong with a special present.

I honestly don't think this is that huge a deal if you explain it clearly and have the special meal around the actual date.

Alargeoneplease89 · 25/07/2023 00:30

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/07/2023 20:09

Some of the posts on here at batshit. You can see why some adults become so incredibly precious about their birthdays... they are obviously taught that birthdays are somehow sacred from an early age.

Yup! No wonder we are turning into a self obessed entitled society. Goodness if my child seemed to be precious over a birthday, then their grandparents health, I would be concerned.

As I said before I left my 5 year old when my dad was dying on his birthday and it was a long trip, he is now 14 and still a sweet natured and empathic boy.

MooFroo · 25/07/2023 00:28

MeinKraft · 24/07/2023 12:06

YANBU. I think you will be setting a good example to your DD if you teach her that sometimes we have to make personal sacrifices to support our family.

Absolutely! Celebrations can be done anytime

I’ll never forget a work colleague who had a terminally ill mum in hospital who had possibly days left and still chose to go on her family holiday to not disappoint kids.
Her mum passed while she was away

mrsplum2015 · 25/07/2023 00:17

I wouldn't go.

Your dd only has one mother. Your dm has two daughters and a husband. What is going to change while you are there to resolve the situation, which sounds untenable? Meaning you are going to feel bad about leaving.

Why can't your dsis stay another couple of nights to partly bridge the gap?

Your father is making a choice about how to care for your dm, which isn't sustainable, and if he won't listen to reason you will have to leave him to manage it as the adult he is I'm afraid.

By supporting him to not use the support system available and not looking after himself you are not actually helping.

Unless you are going to go over with the intent to insist he lets the carers do their job and he gets a full night sleep each night or look at residential care for her I don't see what you're going to achieve other than leave yourself and your father exhausted (not to mention your dh who is presumably juggling a full time job and 2 young dc) and make your dd upset.

Mariposista · 24/07/2023 22:45

DogsParty · 24/07/2023 15:58

Sometimes the ill person or their family may want their ill relative home, but it’s better for family to be realistic about what is needed.

A woman I used to work with ended up in very bad health herself trying to look after her elderly parents.

This is very true. But a care home should be used if the patient has very specific needs, and trying to meet them in the community would put both the patient and the relative at risk (as it has in the case you talk of). This happened with my mum too when my gran was on EOL care - the strain it took on her (and me) as we tried to do it all ourselves with just basic domiciliary care, looking back was foolish.
However, putting mum in residential care to placate a spoilt 8 year old on her birthday does not sound like a good enough reason.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/07/2023 20:09

Some of the posts on here at batshit. You can see why some adults become so incredibly precious about their birthdays... they are obviously taught that birthdays are somehow sacred from an early age.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/07/2023 19:33

Clymene · 24/07/2023 18:00

It's very obvious the people who have never tried to arrange care for elderly people on this thread

^This.

OP your DD will be disappointed initially but organise and extra treat with you when you return. She will then have three birthday events instead of two as an appreciation of missing you on the day. She hopefully will also appreciate in time that sometimes we have to put others first, even when its disappointing.

I'm shocked at some of the responses on this thread. As adults looking back at your life would you really want to have demanded a parent be at your birthday knowing that it left your grandparents in such an emergency?

ditalini · 24/07/2023 19:18

sleepyscientist · 24/07/2023 18:57

Where are they I see Spain is mentioned. Can DH and the kids not get an airbnb for a few nights over the birthday. It's hot but it's not so bad kids can't go, it would also be a distraction for your dad if he got to see them whilst you care for mum.

I don't know life or death I would be there in a heart beat, or if it was something that would likely impact recovery. But mum having to put up with rough handed carers if she was likely to make a good recovery I would likely expect her to get on with it and go out after DD birthday. How does your dad feel it's sounds like he's happy with you coming later.

Spain was only mentioned by a random poster who made up a story in their head.

sleepyscientist · 24/07/2023 18:57

Where are they I see Spain is mentioned. Can DH and the kids not get an airbnb for a few nights over the birthday. It's hot but it's not so bad kids can't go, it would also be a distraction for your dad if he got to see them whilst you care for mum.

I don't know life or death I would be there in a heart beat, or if it was something that would likely impact recovery. But mum having to put up with rough handed carers if she was likely to make a good recovery I would likely expect her to get on with it and go out after DD birthday. How does your dad feel it's sounds like he's happy with you coming later.

lanthanum · 24/07/2023 18:10

Marmite27 · 24/07/2023 11:58

I wouldn’t miss my DC’s 8th birthday, they’d be devastated.

I did miss DD's 8th birthday, and she was absolutely fine about it. I was away for a hobby-related activity - so far less reason than here. There was a free day the day before DD's birthday, so she and DH came to visit and we did presents and an outing then. Her party was later anyway - August birthday parties don't usually work.

Let DD select her "official birthday" date and make a big fuss of her then. If she also gets some special treatment on her actual birthday, she'll get a better deal than normal.

FairAcre · 24/07/2023 18:10

strongcupofTea · 24/07/2023 14:18

I wouldn't miss my daughters birthday personally. Your parents chose to live away from family in Spain so they should have made contingency plans for this type of thing. They'll have to get in carers.

Have you actually read any of the posts or just jumped in with a stupid comment?

Clymene · 24/07/2023 18:00

It's very obvious the people who have never tried to arrange care for elderly people on this thread

CurlewKate · 24/07/2023 17:52

@Flossflower "Have you ever had a child that has talked non stop for a couple of months about their birthday?"
Yes I have. I also hope that I have children who understand that sometimes other people take precedence, and would be disappointed but understanding. Ans who would trust me when I said that their birthday will still happen, but maybe a little later. I would feel as if I had failed as a parent if I had raised a
NT 8 year old who couldn't do that.

olympicsrock · 24/07/2023 17:47

It’s a hard situation.
I think the decision is very clearly to go to your parents. It sounds like they need you massively.

You can FaceTime, leave special card and gifts , eta h her open presents . You could even let her have a second birthday like the Queen did !

Sorry that you are having such a tough time.

Nazzywish · 24/07/2023 17:44

Yanbu- your daughter will learn that sometimes in life mummy has other responsibilities and that's fine,if anything it's a good teaching opportunity for you to show her how to put another person first who is in more need and in this case your mum, at 8 years old they get it. Show her what family ties mean and one day she will be that daughter that's there for you when needed hopefully. Teaches her patience and love.although I'm sure she already has this but never hurts to reinforce via a real life lesson.