Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your opinion on my day job vs contractor work dilemma?

31 replies

fourtriangles · 24/07/2023 11:37

Any views on my work dilemma would be gratefully received. These are the two options-

Option one: Normal work contract, four days per week, all of it in the office 9 to 5 with no wfh option. Office is a 45 to 55 minute commute each way. Contract has the usual annual leave, bank holidays, pension etc.

Option two: Work as an independent contractor doing similar role. Work from home except for one day per week on site. Average income across the month would be same/ a bit higher depending on how much I take on but no bank holidays, annual leave etc. There is no chance of work drying up.

From a family point of view, option two would mean that most of the week I would be home in the morning when DC (early secondary age) leave and afternoon when they get back from school. I absolutely love wfh and hate feeling trapped in an office all day, hate commuting and with winter coming this will involve driving in dark mornings and evenings. I feel with option two I will have much more flexibility in how I use my time across the day/ week, can be there more for DC, will be much less tired from commuting. The only drawback is being out of the "comfort" of a work contract with paid leave. My DH has as secure full time job that pays less than mine but we could survive on if we had to.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LittleBearPad · 24/07/2023 20:48

Option 2 but make sure you get paid ‘enough’

MurielThrockmorton · 24/07/2023 20:41

I was once told to take a couple of zeros off the salary and that gives you your day rate equivalent, it seems not far off for me. There's some stuff here about day rates www.ipse.co.uk/policy/freelance-confidence-index-hub/freelancer-confidence-index-q1-2022.html - I thought I'd seen a whole report about day rates in different sectors by them but I can't find it now.

titchy · 24/07/2023 20:37

Maybe if you say what your salary is roughly, then others can give you some guidance as to what to charge per day (or the hourly equivalent of a day). I'm on £70k and if contracting I'd expect to charge £500 to £700 a day depending on role if that helps.

fourtriangles · 24/07/2023 20:22

Thank you everyone. This is all really useful. Again it’s a somewhat niche situation but I definitely am outside of IR35, I will be getting further advice in relation to tax. In terms of the day rate, would anyone be able to share what they consider high? Based on the actual hours of work it would take me, my rate would be about 30% more but I won’t be paid for filler employee stuff like meetings. And I’m actually fine with that because I want to be at home and to not be captive in an outside office all day.

OP posts:
titchy · 24/07/2023 16:50

fourtriangles · 24/07/2023 12:06

Thanks. It's actually difficult to compare the two in terms of pay as with option one it is a fixed salary but I have to be in the office for fixed hours. With option two, I take on specific projects I am paid for. I think I could take on two of these per week and bring in a slightly higher salary but I would be at home and also have more time to play with- I don't think it would take me a full 8 hours per day to get these done. So with option two I would probably spend slightly fewer hours working than option one.

Am not a contractor but those I know charge roughly double their hourly rate as a contractor compared to their rate as an employee. So you should be charging your projects on the same basis, with as accurate an estimate as to the hours needed as you can.

Illegallyblonder · 24/07/2023 14:02

I'm a contractor, outside IR35, on a high day rate, taking short to medium term contracts. I love it and will never commute again. I work remotely with the odd day in an office but only when I need to, for example to meet people 121. Some key points:

  • Ensure your day rate is high enough. I was recently offered what sounded like a huge amount a day inside IR35 but it wasn't enough because although I work for less than that now I am working outside IR35 and so my take home is higher
  • You need a professional accountancy practice specialising in contractors. There are plenty of them about. They calculate all your corporation tax, VAT, payments and manage all your pay, invoicing etc. They will tell you what to pay to HMRC and when and will complete tax returns on your behalf for a fee. I pay about £200 a month for this
  • You need insurance. I have employers liability, indemnity insurance and also have insurance against an HMRC investigation around IR35
  • My CEST determination shows I'm outside IR35, not all companies will go for it though, although I never have trouble getting work - I have a niche skillset though too. You can find the template on the HMRC website
  • You need to keep savings as you can be let go at any time. Likewise, you need to factor holidays in - if you don't work you don't get paid but it's easy to therefore never take time off and that leads to burnout. Make sure you take time off as often as you need to
  • If you need private medical cover, pay for it. We pay £360 a month for 2 adults

I never want a perm job again and I never want to commute again and never will. Secondary school aged children need you just as much if not more than little kids and so it'll be good to be around more for them, even if you are WFH.

You are in a great position to do this as your dh has a perm job and you could survive on his salary.

Check also that any agent isn't taking a huge margin - a friend found out recently that although she was being paid £500 a day her agent was getting an extra £200 - the client was paying £700. She renegotiated direct with the client and the agent reduced his margin and increased her pay.

Good luck!

jeaux90 · 24/07/2023 13:48

Another thing to consider is private health insurance as well as pension but I'd do option 2 definitely.

D20 · 24/07/2023 13:45

I’ve done both and generally speaking your contractor rate has to be at least 30% higher to make it worth the risk.

You also must factor in payment on account of your tax bill https://www.gov.uk/understand-self-assessment-bill/payments-on-account having to pay 50% more tax than you had calculated can be a bit of a surprise.

Understand your Self Assessment tax bill

Understand your Self Assessment tax bill - tax you owe, balancing payments, payments on account

https://www.gov.uk/understand-self-assessment-bill/payments-on-account

Hoppinggreen · 24/07/2023 13:44

Also do you need liability and/or indemnity insurance?

Hoppinggreen · 24/07/2023 13:42

I’ve been employed and a Contractor, I prefer the latter but need to earn a lot more for the equivalent wage due to no paid holidays , sickness pension etc so you should be on 25% plus more as a Contractor
I have just done an IR35 review requested by one of our clients and we are outside but if there was just 1 of us doing as you describe it’s unlikely we would be so be careful- something isn’t just outside IR35 because the company says it is

Fightyouforthatpie · 24/07/2023 13:36

As advised by Previous Posters - please take care. If you are outside IR35 this implies you'll be running your own limited company - you need to read up and be fully informed about that.
Also I've heard of people being offered an outside IR35 role, only to find once the role starts that it is assessed as inside, which will likely result in a lower income for you.

fourtriangles · 24/07/2023 12:11

I will be outside of IR35. When I say per project, they are not exactly projects but pieces of work, they will each take the same amount of time to do. I'm in a very specific niche area so apologies if it seems I'm being mysterious. Something I could compare it to is being an Oftsed inspector and being paid per school review (I totally do not do that job but to give an idea).

OP posts:
Work2live · 24/07/2023 12:08

Agree with pp who say you should be earning more as a contractor.

Will you be inside or outside IR35?? Will you be paid an hourly or daily rate?? Depending on the type of work you do, don’t be drawn into being paid on a ‘per project’ basis.

fourtriangles · 24/07/2023 12:06

Thanks. It's actually difficult to compare the two in terms of pay as with option one it is a fixed salary but I have to be in the office for fixed hours. With option two, I take on specific projects I am paid for. I think I could take on two of these per week and bring in a slightly higher salary but I would be at home and also have more time to play with- I don't think it would take me a full 8 hours per day to get these done. So with option two I would probably spend slightly fewer hours working than option one.

OP posts:
Fieldofbrokenpromises · 24/07/2023 12:06

What form of “independent contractor” would you be? Taking an inside IR35 contract actually means you are deemed employee so subject to all the same direction and control, but not entitled to any employment rights.
As others said, income should be considerably more than a permie role to take account of the loss of benefits and rights - also be very careful about rates - many rates are quoted as a day rate but they omit to warn you that employers NI will be deducted from the quoted rate (even though that’s not strictly legal).

In short, make sure you know exactly what you are signing up for - contract work is a very complex area and many employers and agencies don’t know what they are talking about so don’t trust advice from them.

Janella · 24/07/2023 12:04

Option 2 and factor in an accountant to help with all the tax stuff? Eg corp tax, income tax etc.

I would ditch commuting in a heartbeat if my job allowed it, it's infuriating and a total waste of personal resource IF the same role can be done from home.

parietal · 24/07/2023 12:02

Option 2 BUT your pay should definitely be higher. you have to factor in the pensions contributions and leave etc. otherwise you are just getting underpaid to get the wfh option.

fourtriangles · 24/07/2023 12:00

Thanks so much, these are all really good points. I do have some savings set aside already but I could work on putting an amount aside specifically to cover any periods without income. I have fairly decent pension provision built up already but will definitely look at adding to this.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 24/07/2023 11:59

First thing is to crunch the numbers re the contracting option as with the recent expansion in the scope of IR35, you may find yourself having to be paid via an umbrella company, and bearing all the "employer" costs yourself, i.e. employers NIC, workplace pension, apprenticeship levy, umbrella processing costs, as well as not qualifying for holiday pay, statutory sick pay, paid notice periods, and having to pay for your own equipment etc.

The pay is normally a lot higher for contracting roles to compensate for all that, usually a minimum of 25% and often more like 50% higher.

Obviously if money is less important than convenience etc., then getting a lower "take home" pay may be a price worth paying, but at least check out the numbers so that you can compare properly.

Peony654 · 24/07/2023 11:58

Option 2, if you have savings/can save to cover if you couldn't work or couldn't get work. And can make pension contributions on a par with what the employer would have done. and consider an insurance policy that could cover serious illness?

The3Ls · 24/07/2023 11:55

Just jumped to option two. 100% no regrets. Look at vanguard for pension and AXA for income insurance. It is tax deductible - lots is including generous WFH allowance from tax office and commuting costs the day you do go in . You ll be surprised your income might not be as low as you think

LegendsBeyond · 24/07/2023 11:55

Option 2, as long as you have a good chunk of savings to cover lean periods/sickness. Also think about pension.

kategrogen · 24/07/2023 11:53

100% option 2. Make sure your day rate is high enough that it covers a standard amount of leave/sick days, and if possible, enough for you to contribute to your own pension.

The comfort factor is a myth. I've been contracting in this way for ten years and had work throughout. Friends who were more nervous and so took full time employment have been made redundant and it's sometimes taken then several months to find a new job. Because they were employed and thought they were 'safe', they didn't have savings to cover this.

if you can try to save enough to cover periods of low work - ideally to pay the bills for 6 months - then this should provide you the same comfort that a full time job would, but without all the drawbacks of working in the office etc.

MurielThrockmorton · 24/07/2023 11:53

If you're going to be self-employed you'll need to consider whether you meet HMRC rules, www.gov.uk/guidance/check-employment-status-for-tax

titchy · 24/07/2023 11:51

Option 2 and increase your rates - if your income is the same as if you were employed, you're not charging enough.