Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really!? Gove!? and a sensible suggestion!? Inner city housing

111 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 11:01

Gove appears to be making the first sensible suggestion of his career - more housing in inner cities, relaxing planning laws to allow this to happen.

This is desperately needed - we are in a vicious circle of needing parking because people can't live close to where they work, then people not being able to live close to where they work because so much space is needed for parking....

We need to get out of this, we need to put an end to the culture of driving in to work, and get rid of the inner city car parks, and put the land to better use.

We also need to get rid of the on street parking, and the awful concreting over of grass to park on front gardens, and start to scale back on the need and expectations of car ownership altogether.

More housing where it is actually needed is the first steps towards that - decades late, but better than nothing

OP posts:
hattie43 · 24/07/2023 12:58

The whole planning system needs revisiting . I think his idea is sensible , it'll be cheaper to reuse existing buildings and stop towns from being ghost towns . If the areas were paved and a cafe culture got going with bars / restaurants I can see it being popular . Imagine strolling out your front door, after a hard days work , to a restaurant for a meal . No taxi required . Then stroll home .
I also think more needs to be done to relax planning in rural areas . Why can a barn that housed cows be converted but not a barn housing horses etc etc .
Our local council has rejected two recent applications because of this nitrates neutrality rubbish yes really no build because 5km away could be nesting birds . How does that help the economy grow and local builders etc get some earnings .

monpetitlapin · 24/07/2023 12:58

Badbadbunny · 24/07/2023 12:49

@monpetitlapin

I think instead of just focusing on cities like London and Manchester (amazing as they are), they need to properly develop more of the smaller cities in the UK, not by just adding housing estates without even a corner shop or primary school (or bus stop), but by properly developing places so they can actually support the people they house and so people aren't just living there, but are thriving and happy. Plonking houses or flats down and calling it a "development" is a total cop out.

Not just smaller cities, but what about all the run down towns? And it's not just shops and schools, people need decent jobs too. Far too much centralisation of "corporate" jobs in the big cities like London and Manchester. We need to spread people out more. The smaller cities and towns all have infrastructure and just need people, and those people need jobs. Solve that and you can start to reverse the centralisation that has served London well but ruined many regions of the country.

Definitely.

monpetitlapin · 24/07/2023 12:56

@BarbaraofSeville absolutely. I was trying to point out that, although they're amazing because of all the amenities, "inner cities" aren't the be all and end all (I think I explained a bit better in my second post), and that it would be better and more sustainable for the entire population if we fully developed smaller towns and cities so people actually want to live there and spend time in them rather than using them as somewhere to kip between getting trains to work.

I want to live near the good stuff, I just don't think keeping the good stuff in one or two places and moving the people closer to it will work as well as improving local infrastructure and making more towns and cities have better amenities.

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 12:55

@BarbaraofSeville There used to be what was known as the 'Parker Morris' standards.

Which was scrapped as a minimum standard by ... you guessed it a Conservative government.

Hmm, it's almost like Gove is trying to lower the bar even further.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/07/2023 12:52

@Badbadbunny @monpetitlapin - Great minds, eh?

So why is it not happening? Why is there still the concentration in investment in the SE?

What happened to 'levelling up'? There were talks of a cross rail style high speed rail line linking Liverpool and Hull via Manchester, and Leeds, but it's been quietly dropped.

Remotecontrolatmyside · 24/07/2023 12:51

user1477391263 · 24/07/2023 11:35

Strong disagree. Getting wrapped up in endless gate keeping about “housing has to be affordable” “housing has to be this” “housing has to be that” is how you end up with nothing being built, which is the mess that the UK is currently in. The UK has already wasted decades stuck in these circular arguments while building next to nothing.

In Tokyo, where I live, they’ve just built A LOT instead of worrying about, is it affordable/luxury/social housing, or whatever. The ultimate long-term result is more affordable housing for everyone, because even building “luxury” housing eventually exerts downward pressure on prices for everyone.

https://takes.jamesomalley.co.uk/p/building-luxury-homes-for-millionaires

I'm not sure Toyko housing is one to aspire to https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20190718-the-arms-length-flats-of-tokyo

The arm’s-length flats of Tokyo

How the capital's cash-strapped young people afford big city living.

https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20190718-the-arms-length-flats-of-tokyo

Badbadbunny · 24/07/2023 12:49

@monpetitlapin

I think instead of just focusing on cities like London and Manchester (amazing as they are), they need to properly develop more of the smaller cities in the UK, not by just adding housing estates without even a corner shop or primary school (or bus stop), but by properly developing places so they can actually support the people they house and so people aren't just living there, but are thriving and happy. Plonking houses or flats down and calling it a "development" is a total cop out.

Not just smaller cities, but what about all the run down towns? And it's not just shops and schools, people need decent jobs too. Far too much centralisation of "corporate" jobs in the big cities like London and Manchester. We need to spread people out more. The smaller cities and towns all have infrastructure and just need people, and those people need jobs. Solve that and you can start to reverse the centralisation that has served London well but ruined many regions of the country.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/07/2023 12:48

^Never mind fitting it all into one city centre.
Someone has to live on the periphery, we can't house 68 million people in Zones 1-2^

And we have to remember that plenty of people don't want to live in zones 1-2 or anywhere near it. So we need to stop cramming all the jobs, opportunities and resources there. There's been lots of talk about '15 minute cities' and people are up in arms because they can't afford to live close to the amenities.

But what I thought they were talking about and what it should mean is that they build the amenities (employment, medical facilities, shops etc) close to where people now live, so they don't have to travel to a more distant city to access them (and also spread more evenly around the country, so people don't feel they're missing out if they don't live in the SE).

Plus they also need to have a lot more secure bike storage, because a lot of people will be in a similar position to what I am. I live in a village with limited facilities but there is a small town about 2 miles away. Which is a little bit too far to walk there and back in a timely fashion a lot of the time. But I could cycle, but there is nowhere secure to leave my bike when I get there, so I end up driving.

Spirallingdownwards · 24/07/2023 12:46

His suggestion of building an extra 250k house in Cambridge a city of only 140 000 people is ridiculous

monpetitlapin · 24/07/2023 12:45

On a personal note I would ADORE being able to live in the centre of London with my family, I wouldn't need a car because there's just so much to do on your doorstep, I'd use one of those car hire places if I needed to leave the city, access to great schools, food, theatre, musea, parks, shops, music venues, cinemas, libraries, etc right on our doorstep.

It would be phenomenal. But we'd need a 3 bedroom place to fit us all in. And so many people want the same that any affordable developments would immediately be swamped with applications. The limiting factor is the price for a reason. Prices are dictated by what people are willing to pay for the property, and there are simply so many people willing to pay high amounts that it will never be a reality for people like us (who earn too much to qualify for social housing but nowhere near enough to buy a house near where we rent atm).

I think instead of just focusing on cities like London and Manchester (amazing as they are), they need to properly develop more of the smaller cities in the UK, not by just adding housing estates without even a corner shop or primary school (or bus stop), but by properly developing places so they can actually support the people they house and so people aren't just living there, but are thriving and happy. Plonking houses or flats down and calling it a "development" is a total cop out.

There are so many soulless commuter towns that could really be amazing places to live if they just had more going on in their own town centres.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/07/2023 12:43

LoobyDop · 24/07/2023 12:34

I’d like to be confident that “brownfield” actually means ex-industrial land, rather than bits of green space that happen to be within city limits.

And I echo what a PP said about needing to change people’s attitudes to living in flats. We own a large (more than 1k sq ft) flat in a really popular area. New kitchen and bathrooms. Really nice views, balcony, and none of the windows are overlooked. We tried to sell it earlier this year, and barely got any interest because people would rather have a smaller house in a less nice area for the same price. And Grenfell, the appalling state of leasehold rules and lockdown have made that worse.

But brownfield sites that were operating prior to about 1970 are often incredibly polluted. I've worked on some and there's all sorts of shit buried on the site that has to be removed and often sent to specialist landfill before the site can be used for housing. Lead, radioactive material, organic matter etc. Removing this type of stuff is very very expensive and time consuming.

BigGreen · 24/07/2023 12:40

I don't think flats will ever be desirable without leasehold being abolished, which this government promised to do (but of course, didn't do).

BarbaraofSeville · 24/07/2023 12:39

Something key that needs to happen in UK building regs is increasing the minimum size that can be called a 'bedroom' and making it mandatory to have a set amount of storage space per square meter of living space. This needs to happen across houses and apartments, so if someone is renting/buying a 2 bedroom flat, they are getting 2 fully functional bedrooms, a living space, a cooking space, a washing space and decent room for storage. Thatcould adequately house a family of 4...but that also won't happen because greed abounds

There used to be what was known as the 'Parker Morris' standards.

We currently live in a 2 bed ex council semi that I believe is built in line with these. We've also had a council flat that was also the same. Both built post WW2.

While the kitchen and bathroom in our current house are quite small, we have a large walk in cupboard off the kitchen and the same in our bedroom. Both bedrooms are doubles, not huge, but enough. All the houses on our estate also have an outside brick built store, that could be used for storing bikes, gardening equipment, coal, that sort of thing.

The living room is very large - around 6 m x 4 m - originally there was a serving hatch between the kitchen and the living room, so it could function as a living room/diner, but sadly this was blocked up before we moved in.

The flat we lived in had a serving hatch, which I really missed when we moved. These need to come back into fashion (yes I know we could just open ours up, but I mean in more general, which they might do if people move away from open plan living due to higher energy costs.

LoobyDop · 24/07/2023 12:34

I’d like to be confident that “brownfield” actually means ex-industrial land, rather than bits of green space that happen to be within city limits.

And I echo what a PP said about needing to change people’s attitudes to living in flats. We own a large (more than 1k sq ft) flat in a really popular area. New kitchen and bathrooms. Really nice views, balcony, and none of the windows are overlooked. We tried to sell it earlier this year, and barely got any interest because people would rather have a smaller house in a less nice area for the same price. And Grenfell, the appalling state of leasehold rules and lockdown have made that worse.

monpetitlapin · 24/07/2023 12:30

AmeliaEarhart · 24/07/2023 11:30

Not sure if the flats are family sized, or affordable to people on average incomes though.

Yes, this is an issue. All very well throwing up masses of 1 or 2 bed “luxury” flats with open plan living areas that are only affordable to young professional couples with double incomes and no childcare costs, but where do people go for the next stages of their lives? Lots of people are happy to raise their families in densely populated, walkable urban areas, but often the housing stock is not suitable.

Exactly! And those people still have the same jobs (usually) and now need to drive to work (but hey let's get rid of parking).
I saw an OU video for one of their maths modules that showed if everyone had an "average sized" family home with space for parking, we would need several planets to fit everyone in. Never mind fitting it all into one city centre.
Someone has to live on the periphery, we can't house 68 million people in Zones 1-2!

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 12:29

Beezknees · 24/07/2023 12:28

It ought to be social housing with tight rent controls. Otherwise it will just be more unaffordable places for everyday people.

yes, to this,

OP posts:
Girasoli · 24/07/2023 12:28

They are doing this a lot in my city, lots of 2/3 bed shared ownership flats popping up in the city centre. We looked around a couple and they were nice/practical with DC - had balconies and storage space etc (Didn't go for it in the end as there was no parking for the shared ownership option).

Beezknees · 24/07/2023 12:28

It ought to be social housing with tight rent controls. Otherwise it will just be more unaffordable places for everyday people.

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 24/07/2023 12:26

I very think it depends where up you live. I live in a northern town outside Manchester. Absolutely dead on its feet. Our M and S shut in April, no other department stores, rest just vape, charity, bargain basement type. Falling over yourself avoiding beggars and unfortunate homeless. For a town of 300,000 it’s a disgrace and footfall has dropped dramatically. And yet our council thinks building hundreds of housing association houses and flats is the answer. How it will regenerate the place who knows. A lot of these tenants won’t have the disposable income to spend and if they did, there are hardly any decent shops or amenities anyway. Most seem to think it will just become yet another no go area.

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 12:20

@LittleLegsKeepGoing Exactly. UK wide planning regs have optional requirements for things like bedroom size, whereas something like The London Plan actually have minimum planning requirements for bedroom sizes.

The UK actually needs more and better planning regulations not less.

Many developers will build to the lowest common denominator if you let them. Removing planning regulations only lines their pockets, it doesn't provide the UK with better housing.

ExtraOnions · 24/07/2023 12:16

Manchester City Centre, block after block of expensive empty flats, bought as investments by foreign based consortiums … whilst people who might actually want to live & spend money in the city centre are driven out by the prices.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 24/07/2023 12:14

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/07/2023 11:39

There would be less of a problem if there wasn’t such a British obsession around big houses over practical apartments and if more people’s aspirations and expectations around housing were more realistic. You only have to read an MN property thread to realise that what too many British people think should be the norm for every family is a detached house with two reception rooms, upstairs and downstairs bathrooms and toilets and en-suites aplenty, a big kitchen diner, enough bedrooms to have one for each child and one kept solely for occasional guests, a huge back as well as landed frontage, and off-street parking for three cars. But you can’t build those for everyone who wants them either cheaply or on small plots of land or on urban brownfield sites.

There's a middle ground that's not being met though. We fortunately live in a flat built in the 70s. Even the smallest bedroom is big enough for a single bed, wardrobe and chest of drawers. I'd love to have a garden etc but we are comfortably housed beyond that. There are 3 built in storage cupboards and room for normal furniture options.

Modern apartments and houses built from the 90s onwards have an atrociously small living footprint. No storage options, absolutely tiny room measurements where a 'bedroom' can't actually fit a normal single bed. This places most "2 bedroom" properties firmly in the category of only being suitable for a couple with the 2nd room used as a study/office/wardrobe. Meaning finding a family home even 2 adults and 1 child becomes even more competitive.

Something key that needs to happen in UK building regs is increasing the minimum size that can be called a 'bedroom' and making it mandatory to have a set amount of storage space per square meter of living space. This needs to happen across houses and apartments, so if someone is renting/buying a 2 bedroom flat, they are getting 2 fully functional bedrooms, a living space, a cooking space, a washing space and decent room for storage. That could adequately house a family of 4...but that also won't happen because greed abounds.

onefinemess · 24/07/2023 12:13

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 11:01

Gove appears to be making the first sensible suggestion of his career - more housing in inner cities, relaxing planning laws to allow this to happen.

This is desperately needed - we are in a vicious circle of needing parking because people can't live close to where they work, then people not being able to live close to where they work because so much space is needed for parking....

We need to get out of this, we need to put an end to the culture of driving in to work, and get rid of the inner city car parks, and put the land to better use.

We also need to get rid of the on street parking, and the awful concreting over of grass to park on front gardens, and start to scale back on the need and expectations of car ownership altogether.

More housing where it is actually needed is the first steps towards that - decades late, but better than nothing

I think you're being very naive, you're seriously suggesting that people should be dependent on public transport?.

Look at the train strikes for an idea on the reality of that.

I live in a city and I won't be giving up my car.

You might like the idea of being squeezed into a sardine tin of a flat (because that's what these "homes" will be) but I don't.

It will create huge ghettos.

The solution is for people to stop having children. Reduce the population and you reduce the pollution.

Just Stop Oil should be, Just Stop Children.

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/07/2023 11:39

There would be less of a problem if there wasn’t such a British obsession around big houses over practical apartments and if more people’s aspirations and expectations around housing were more realistic. You only have to read an MN property thread to realise that what too many British people think should be the norm for every family is a detached house with two reception rooms, upstairs and downstairs bathrooms and toilets and en-suites aplenty, a big kitchen diner, enough bedrooms to have one for each child and one kept solely for occasional guests, a huge back as well as landed frontage, and off-street parking for three cars. But you can’t build those for everyone who wants them either cheaply or on small plots of land or on urban brownfield sites.

user1477391263 · 24/07/2023 11:35

endofthelinefinally · 24/07/2023 11:16

This is where there needs to be strict rules enforced. Unfortunately there is a lot of corruption and incompetence in planning. Building firms should be heavily fined if they don't fulfil the social housing part of their contracts. They get away with far too much.
And we should stop foreign investors buying up loads of properties and leaving them empty. In other countries this is against the law and strictly enforced.

Strong disagree. Getting wrapped up in endless gate keeping about “housing has to be affordable” “housing has to be this” “housing has to be that” is how you end up with nothing being built, which is the mess that the UK is currently in. The UK has already wasted decades stuck in these circular arguments while building next to nothing.

In Tokyo, where I live, they’ve just built A LOT instead of worrying about, is it affordable/luxury/social housing, or whatever. The ultimate long-term result is more affordable housing for everyone, because even building “luxury” housing eventually exerts downward pressure on prices for everyone.

https://takes.jamesomalley.co.uk/p/building-luxury-homes-for-millionaires

Building luxury homes for millionaires is good for poor people

Yes In My Back Yard!

https://takes.jamesomalley.co.uk/p/building-luxury-homes-for-millionaires