Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really!? Gove!? and a sensible suggestion!? Inner city housing

111 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 11:01

Gove appears to be making the first sensible suggestion of his career - more housing in inner cities, relaxing planning laws to allow this to happen.

This is desperately needed - we are in a vicious circle of needing parking because people can't live close to where they work, then people not being able to live close to where they work because so much space is needed for parking....

We need to get out of this, we need to put an end to the culture of driving in to work, and get rid of the inner city car parks, and put the land to better use.

We also need to get rid of the on street parking, and the awful concreting over of grass to park on front gardens, and start to scale back on the need and expectations of car ownership altogether.

More housing where it is actually needed is the first steps towards that - decades late, but better than nothing

OP posts:
MereDintofPandiculation · 24/07/2023 13:57

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 24/07/2023 12:26

I very think it depends where up you live. I live in a northern town outside Manchester. Absolutely dead on its feet. Our M and S shut in April, no other department stores, rest just vape, charity, bargain basement type. Falling over yourself avoiding beggars and unfortunate homeless. For a town of 300,000 it’s a disgrace and footfall has dropped dramatically. And yet our council thinks building hundreds of housing association houses and flats is the answer. How it will regenerate the place who knows. A lot of these tenants won’t have the disposable income to spend and if they did, there are hardly any decent shops or amenities anyway. Most seem to think it will just become yet another no go area.

That's really interesting. I live in a town on the edge of a Northern city. We're crying out for smaller homes for downsizers and for people starting out on the property ladder. But the only thing developers are prepared to build are 5 bed "executive homes" with rural outlook.

Plenty of planning permissions have been given, but the pace of building is abysmal. Developers admit that they only build what they can sell. so they get permission for large areas of 5 bed homes and then release them at a trickle to maintain profits.

The low rate of housebuilding can't be put solely at the door of "Nymbies".

calmcoco · 24/07/2023 13:56

This policy announcement is bullshit. They want to cram people into shit city centre housing with reduced planning laws.

It's bollocks.

And people are right to reference Grenfell.

Families don't want to live in tiny flat in city centres. The shortage is family housing.

Theunamedcat · 24/07/2023 13:54

So we house people but where will they work? I live in a town with zero local jobs unless you want to voulenteer in a charity shop your options are sainsbury's (out of town no bus stop) tescos (edge of town by a bus stop) morrisons (edge of town no bus stop) or aldi (in-between two towns with a bus stop) HOWEVER buses cost a fucking fortune and the prices are going up again plus they stop running at 6pm so you cannot "work locally" and get to work AND BACK on a bus we also have a train station which is well used (unless they are striking) by people commuting OUT of town for work its not exactly central or easy to get to but it does have a car park

Basically we need to redesign the UK from scratch or stop implementing policies that assume your in London with good transport systems

Trying to get the population to stop using cars is Unreasonable our A&E is 45 minutes away (because our local one ws shut by the government) we have no local ambulance station and a taxi is out of financial reach for most the town should we just die? Or should we be allowed access to a car? and yes we were promised public transport to the hospital when they removed ours this promised transport lasted a year and has now stopped so.....you need a car

CornishGem1975 · 24/07/2023 13:51

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 13:49

@CornishGem1975 which planning requirements specifically do you think need to be changed or abolished then?

I'm not saying any do!

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 13:49

@CornishGem1975 which planning requirements specifically do you think need to be changed or abolished then?

CornishGem1975 · 24/07/2023 13:46

Of course relaxing planning laws doesn't mean relaxing ALL planning laws. They won't be relaxing the Fire Safety Regulations, it will be more about the hoops you have to jump through for planning permissions, allowing changes of use etc just like they did for extensions and permitted development rules.

StefanosHill · 24/07/2023 13:45

Agree with slight majority yabu

I’m glad to hear someone say not build over green spaces. We need those

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 13:43

hattie43 · 24/07/2023 13:20

Relaxing planning laws is not the same as bad building using poor quality materials

It absolutely can be the same though. Fire regulations are part of planning laws.

BubziOwl · 24/07/2023 13:42

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/07/2023 11:39

There would be less of a problem if there wasn’t such a British obsession around big houses over practical apartments and if more people’s aspirations and expectations around housing were more realistic. You only have to read an MN property thread to realise that what too many British people think should be the norm for every family is a detached house with two reception rooms, upstairs and downstairs bathrooms and toilets and en-suites aplenty, a big kitchen diner, enough bedrooms to have one for each child and one kept solely for occasional guests, a huge back as well as landed frontage, and off-street parking for three cars. But you can’t build those for everyone who wants them either cheaply or on small plots of land or on urban brownfield sites.

I must say I agree with this. I'd love a bigger living space of course, but ultimately it's not necessary is it?

dreamingbohemian · 24/07/2023 13:37

I think you're being very naive, you're seriously suggesting that people should be dependent on public transport?

Why is that naive?

I'm in my 50s, I don't even know how to drive. Somehow I survived!

Obviously not every place has good public transport and not everyone can take it. But there is no reason why half the households in London need to have a car. There's no reason why we need so many huge SUVs driving in the city. We need to normalise not having a car and improve public transport more and more, everywhere.

MotherOfRatios · 24/07/2023 13:23

It's a mix of issues

building more in the short term won't help private renters because foreign investors snap them up and rent out for high prices. They also make 2 bed flats into 4 bed HMO's and it needs stopping.

some new build flats are tiny especially with people working from home. You can often get a desk and everything you need for a bedroom in these bedrooms.

Also, I think we need to think about the impacts of building near busy roads and highly polluted areas because it has health impacts.

Twyford · 24/07/2023 13:23

I agree that Gove is probably the most sensible member of the current government. He was a total dickhead when he was in education, but was actually quite good when he moved to Justice. That's probably why he never made it to Leader, he's much too sensible for the current Tory party.

endofthelinefinally · 24/07/2023 13:22

ExtraOnions · 24/07/2023 12:16

Manchester City Centre, block after block of expensive empty flats, bought as investments by foreign based consortiums … whilst people who might actually want to live & spend money in the city centre are driven out by the prices.

This is a big problem. If these properties were available for local people to buy, prices would fall.

hattie43 · 24/07/2023 13:20

mirages08 · 24/07/2023 13:01

"Relaxing planning laws"

Grenfell anyone ?

🤬🤬

Relaxing planning laws is not the same as bad building using poor quality materials

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 24/07/2023 13:17

The problem with large blocks of flats is the incompatibility of lifestyles. A nurse on nights doesn't want 3 kids thumping about above their bedroom and the flat with 3 kids doesn't want a noisy dinner party above them every Friday til midnight. I know it's normal in other countries (many who have better weather than us!) but I don't know how we shift that culture.

Echobelly · 24/07/2023 13:11

I've been saying this even before COVID but it's especially true after , having seen how vulnerable city centres are if tourism/work is all they rely on. Obviously the difficulty is mechanisms to make it affordable as the land value is so insanely high. But if a way could be found to make affordable city centre housing, filling in empty spots, adding extra stories - I'm sure there would be huge economic advantages to have many more 'ordinary' people living in town centres, not having to commute huge distances, using amenties etc

RosieBurdock · 24/07/2023 13:07

The tories will be pretending to care about the housing crisis and various other things until the next election. If they win they'll go back to not caring. I hope people aren't fooled.

Maddy70 · 24/07/2023 13:05

I'm absolutely against relaxing planning laws. Planning laws are there for a reason

Better to improve public transport links so no need for Cars. I no longer live in the UK and have driven 3 times in the time I've lived here because of heavy investment into public transport. We have a 24 hr bus and train system that is reliable and frequent. Every 10-15 mins

kitsuneghost · 24/07/2023 13:03

Another issue is many households have 2 adults with careers
It is not always possible for them both to get a job in their subject in the same city.
This is quite often why people stay somewhere in the middle and both drive opposite directions.

Also is my work that is rural, not my home - so would still need a car even if I lived city centre

Hunkydory99 · 24/07/2023 13:01

Except what Gove announced is nothing new. Brownfield housing fund & brownfield land release fund have been around for several years targeting inner city brownfield sites with visibility issues to bring forward housing. The problem is we can’t see to make inner city living with families and kids attractive or successful in the way European Cities do. Also often a lack of green spaces, schools and school places and doctors surgery again puts people off living in cities for any length of time.

mirages08 · 24/07/2023 13:01

"Relaxing planning laws"

Grenfell anyone ?

🤬🤬

monpetitlapin · 24/07/2023 13:01

BarbaraofSeville · 24/07/2023 12:52

@Badbadbunny @monpetitlapin - Great minds, eh?

So why is it not happening? Why is there still the concentration in investment in the SE?

What happened to 'levelling up'? There were talks of a cross rail style high speed rail line linking Liverpool and Hull via Manchester, and Leeds, but it's been quietly dropped.

Oh that's a real shame. I know HS2 is ongoing, I have mixed feelings about it because I know the country needs it to reduce dependency on cars, but living in an area where I can see the environmental destruction they're wreaking with it, it's hard to watch it get built at the expense of the immediate landscape (and it's just so unnecessarily wide given that they don't plan any stations around here).

hattie43 · 24/07/2023 13:00

Gove also needs to ban Leasehold status as that's become a dirty word because of such abuse of the tenure . I'd rather rent than get caught in a leasehold nightmare .
The Tories won't though , as too many of them plus the crown make handsome sums from exploiting people

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 13:00

@hattie43 it actually isn't cheaper to reuse existing buildings. If it was, that is what developers would do. It involves a huge amount of coordination and money to strip older buildings of things like asbestos, then they are built around older models of services so trying to cram contemporary services into an older building doesn't work well either, never mind the cost.

gogomoto · 24/07/2023 12:59

Do you really think people will choose not to have cars though? Plus we need parking for those of us who don't like in the city and need to visit, we can't use public transport because it stops too early!