Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really!? Gove!? and a sensible suggestion!? Inner city housing

111 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 11:01

Gove appears to be making the first sensible suggestion of his career - more housing in inner cities, relaxing planning laws to allow this to happen.

This is desperately needed - we are in a vicious circle of needing parking because people can't live close to where they work, then people not being able to live close to where they work because so much space is needed for parking....

We need to get out of this, we need to put an end to the culture of driving in to work, and get rid of the inner city car parks, and put the land to better use.

We also need to get rid of the on street parking, and the awful concreting over of grass to park on front gardens, and start to scale back on the need and expectations of car ownership altogether.

More housing where it is actually needed is the first steps towards that - decades late, but better than nothing

OP posts:
StormShadow · 24/07/2023 16:17

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/07/2023 11:39

There would be less of a problem if there wasn’t such a British obsession around big houses over practical apartments and if more people’s aspirations and expectations around housing were more realistic. You only have to read an MN property thread to realise that what too many British people think should be the norm for every family is a detached house with two reception rooms, upstairs and downstairs bathrooms and toilets and en-suites aplenty, a big kitchen diner, enough bedrooms to have one for each child and one kept solely for occasional guests, a huge back as well as landed frontage, and off-street parking for three cars. But you can’t build those for everyone who wants them either cheaply or on small plots of land or on urban brownfield sites.

Of course British people tend to aspire to houses.

Because we build hutches with paper thin walls instead of the good quality, well sized, well soundproofed apartments Europe often does so well. We have a whole batshit leasehold system that in many cases means buying a flat is taking a greater financial risk than buying a house. We've lumbered tens of thousands of flat owners with a cladding fiasco that makes their properties essentially unsellable. Then we also had lockdowns that meant access to public outdoor leisure spaces was withdrawn or severely limited, whereas people with a private outdoor leisure space were able to carry on using it- and not all flats lack gardens and not all houses have them, but there's a definite correlation.

Which has all combined to mean flats have been a demonstrably worse bet than houses over the past few years. And naturally, people respond to those incentives.

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 16:15

UsingChangeofName · 24/07/2023 15:51

I do agree with this.

Don't want to try to comment too much on specifically what Gove has or hasn't said, not having pored over the detail, but one thing they seem to forget with plans to get developers to chuck up loads of housing is that all those residents needs facilities........ Schools, Doctors, dentists, shops, hairdressers / barbers, community meeting places for everything from toddler groups right through to dementia groups, stroke clubs, lunch clubs etc, including Scout huts, playing fields, a hall for choirs to rehearse in for people to knit and natter in or people to play badminton in or organise a residents association or a Cllrs Ward meeting, or a Christmas Fete in. Grass to kick a ball about on, or just sit out and breathe. Sports pitches and space to run or to learn to ride a bike,

This is exactly why we need good planning laws and not less though. Decent planning regulations can account for the extra pressure on the local services and community and either put requirements into the development specifically, or require them to channel money to the local council.

StillWantingADog · 24/07/2023 15:59

I think Gove is a slime and disagree with him on many many things, but on this particular point, he’s right.
I wouldn’t trust any Tory government to deliver it though, and I doubt they’ll have time to before they’re booted out. He probably knows that. The truth is that it’s far more profitable for developers to develop open fields than brownfield sites.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 15:57

We seem to have forgotten how to build flats for living in.

We own a 2 bed flat in a1930s block - we have a large communal garden, big private balconies, garages and all flats have plently of built in storage. We hardly get any of the fabled noise as the flats are a solid as hell.

As for leasehold "ripoff" - well leasehold/commonhold/whatever if you own a flat you do have to have some way of organising and paying for the repair and maintenance of communal areas.

UsingChangeofName · 24/07/2023 15:51

Badbadbunny · 24/07/2023 15:16

@Theunamedcat

Basically we need to redesign the UK from scratch or stop implementing policies that assume your in London with good transport systems

Nail on the head. We need different planning policies for different regions. One size DOESN'T fit all, and we need politicians and decision makers to start to understand that the country doesn't consist solely within the M25!

I do agree with this.

Don't want to try to comment too much on specifically what Gove has or hasn't said, not having pored over the detail, but one thing they seem to forget with plans to get developers to chuck up loads of housing is that all those residents needs facilities........ Schools, Doctors, dentists, shops, hairdressers / barbers, community meeting places for everything from toddler groups right through to dementia groups, stroke clubs, lunch clubs etc, including Scout huts, playing fields, a hall for choirs to rehearse in for people to knit and natter in or people to play badminton in or organise a residents association or a Cllrs Ward meeting, or a Christmas Fete in. Grass to kick a ball about on, or just sit out and breathe. Sports pitches and space to run or to learn to ride a bike,

KnittedCardi · 24/07/2023 15:27

Nimbys and planners are seemingly still against though. My local town has had a run down, semi empty, town centre space for years. It's become run down because as companies move out, they are boarded up, as it's been in the pipeline for so long. And years go by. And it's one of the most expensive part of the country to rent or buy. But the locals don't want it to be built up. Oh, it's not in keeping...... what? This area was all built in the 50's and 60's and desperately needs updating, but no...... we want to keep it.

So almost past the post until the last local elections when there was a concerted effort by all parties to say they wouldn't trust the others. Result is that all the independents lost (they wanted some changes, then were going to give permission), the Conservatives lost (they were going to give permission), and the Lib Dems won, and they are against. Great. Well done everyone. No new single dwellings in the town centre for key workers, right next to the train and bus station then.

Alicetheowl · 24/07/2023 15:21

I suspect WFH might solve some of these problems. There will be loads of empty offices. Before Covid companies had traditional offices. They are now realising that paying rent on buildings, and lighting and heating, so that people could sit together staring at screens and market stuff, or do reports, or prepare legal documents like wills for people who may not even be in the same city, is a waste of money when we now have cheap laptops and broadband.

Loads of empty office buildings with few companies wanting them. They will be converted into houses and flats.

Badbadbunny · 24/07/2023 15:21

Dontcallmescarface · 24/07/2023 15:14

So lots of building being proposed in cities/towns but none in the country. I guess in the future that would mean that there will be no young people left in villages as there would be no affordable housing just a glut of holiday lets and 2nd homes.

Not just in the country. "Touristy" towns and cities are already getting bad with holiday lets owners buying up whatever properties come on the market to rent out for tourists. Even worse are the Uni towns and cities where student rental landlords buy up all the local homes to rent out to students.

We need either laws to stop landlords/holiday let owners buying up homes or they need to be taxed until the pips squeak to try to stop them doing it.

In some towns and cities, it's literally impossible for young people to rent or buy homes and they're ending up with stupidly long/expensive commutes or having to do flat shares - that's if they can actually get viewings and get accepted by the seller/landlord. My son has had to offer 12 months rent in advance AND pay more than asking rent to get his flat - agent said there'd be no hope if he didn't as the demand was so high and others were offering higher rents and payments in advance. What hope is there for those without savings if payments in advance is now the norm in these "popular" places?

endofthelinefinally · 24/07/2023 15:20

I would rather see very tough penalties for bad landlords (local councils are among the worst) via vigilant inspections and vetting. I have a friend and a family member who buy and renovate derelict properties and turn them into really lovely homes. They charge a reasonable rent and look after the properties promptly and carefully. One place needed adaptations - a walk in shower and grab rails, ramp to front door. Everything done properly and quickly. There are good landlords around and those rental properties are needed. Not everyone needs or wants to buy a property and have all the expense and hassle of repairing and maintaining it.

Badbadbunny · 24/07/2023 15:16

@Theunamedcat

Basically we need to redesign the UK from scratch or stop implementing policies that assume your in London with good transport systems

Nail on the head. We need different planning policies for different regions. One size DOESN'T fit all, and we need politicians and decision makers to start to understand that the country doesn't consist solely within the M25!

Dontcallmescarface · 24/07/2023 15:14

So lots of building being proposed in cities/towns but none in the country. I guess in the future that would mean that there will be no young people left in villages as there would be no affordable housing just a glut of holiday lets and 2nd homes.

Smashedsmashed · 24/07/2023 14:48

The UK birth rate is already reduced.
So why should people stop having children.
In my immediate family, siblings etc. We aren’t replacing ourselves.
Also I don’t want to live in a flat, it’s bad enough having neighbours. Don’t want another family etc above me. Or buying in and having to pay lease and expensive service charge.

LakieLady · 24/07/2023 14:45

Secondly, ending the requirement it seems for all small scale city/town development (20 or fewer dwellings) to include retail or commercial property.

I didn't know that was a thing, but it explains why a new development of flats near me has 2 retail units on the ground floor, one of which has been empty for over a year.

There have been a few developments where commercial property has been converted into flats here, and in a bigger town a few miles away. A former colleague now lives in a flat where she used to work when it was offices.

If the offices are no longer required, it seems like an excellent idea to me.

Hiddiddleyho · 24/07/2023 14:41

I don't disagree with Gove here, but it's just fiddling round the edges. I can't see this government, or labour either, making the bigger changes that will make a bigger difference. I hope they bring back regional planning though.

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 14:38

nebulae · 24/07/2023 14:35

I largely agree with Gove's suggestions but it's only part of the solution. We need to stop overseas investors hoovering up properties. We need to introduce heavy penalties for properties that are left empty. We need heavy taxes on people with multiple homes, such as a relative of mine who has three houses she flits between (plus two others that she rents out). We need to limit the number of air bnb type places. We need to start building the type of homes that people actually want.

Would it be possible for these new builds to come with a ban on "buy to let" mortgages?

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 24/07/2023 14:36

user1477391263 · 24/07/2023 11:07

I’ll probably horrify a lot of people on here by saying that Gove has had a lot of sensible ideas in his career, IMO. I don’t agree with all his ideas re education and I get he isn’t popular with a lot of teachers. However, the shift back towards a knowledge-focused curriculum was actually really good and necessary, and Gove also stayed the course and continued the push towards proper phonics teaching, which we are now benefiting from (see PIRLS results recently).

Totally agree with this idea of his. I live outside the UK in a central area with good PT and do not have a car (and yes, I have two children). It’s absolutely not the lifestyle for everyone, but some of us like this way of life and thrive this way - why not expand the range of housing available and create more options for more types of people?

Gove has had some utterly stinking ideas.

He also has consistently surprisingly had good ones too. He was surprisingly well regarded whilst at DEFRA.

Education and Brexit are his two really big gaffs though.

nebulae · 24/07/2023 14:35

I largely agree with Gove's suggestions but it's only part of the solution. We need to stop overseas investors hoovering up properties. We need to introduce heavy penalties for properties that are left empty. We need heavy taxes on people with multiple homes, such as a relative of mine who has three houses she flits between (plus two others that she rents out). We need to limit the number of air bnb type places. We need to start building the type of homes that people actually want.

loislovesstewie · 24/07/2023 14:33

LlynTegid · 24/07/2023 14:26

@loislovesstewie A proportion of claims are rejected.

I realise that, once a person becomes a refugee , i.e they area given leave to remain they are then given notice to leave the accommodation provided under the provisions of the asylum rules. Where do they then go? They can present as homeless as they have that right, if they are successful in that application then the L/A might house them, they might be offered help with a deposit to rent privately. But tinkering around with small amounts of house building isn't solving the issue of the huge shortfall in accommodation, and Gove's plans won't do that.

Im99912 · 24/07/2023 14:28

My son looked at a 2 bed flat bed build
the second “Bedrooom” you could fit a single bed but no wardrobe / or other bedroom furniture
maybe a small side chest of drawers

my other half has an ex council flat that he bought and rents out
both the bedrooms are huge easily fit a kingsize bed wardrobes and chest of drawers and have plenty of floor space left

LlynTegid · 24/07/2023 14:27

The person who noted non-resident overseas purchasing (aka spending ill gotten gains) has a point too.

LlynTegid · 24/07/2023 14:26

@loislovesstewie A proportion of claims are rejected.

loislovesstewie · 24/07/2023 14:24

So where would all the asylum seekers who have had their claims processed and become refugees now live? They then have exactly the same rights to benefits and social housing.Without huge deposits private housing is mostly out of reach.

Brk · 24/07/2023 14:19

LlynTegid · 24/07/2023 11:14

It's really on focusing on a small amount of the housing issue.

You'd make much more impact on ending short term holiday lets (Air BnB and the like) and ending any more second homes. Secondly, ending the requirement it seems for all small scale city/town development (20 or fewer dwellings) to include retail or commercial property.

I'm not keen on abandoning planning permission being required- I'd prefer a requirement that it must be granted unless certain conditions are not met, the burden of proof being that they are not.

Finally, if the government processed asylum claims promptly, a lot of hotel space would be freed which could replace the holiday lets I referred to above, and/or provide housing.

Good points here

Simonjt · 24/07/2023 14:16

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 24/07/2023 13:17

The problem with large blocks of flats is the incompatibility of lifestyles. A nurse on nights doesn't want 3 kids thumping about above their bedroom and the flat with 3 kids doesn't want a noisy dinner party above them every Friday til midnight. I know it's normal in other countries (many who have better weather than us!) but I don't know how we shift that culture.

We live in a flat, we don’t hear anything from our neighbours above or below. It isn’t lifestyle thats the issue, its lax planning laws meaning sufficient soundproofing isn’t required when homes are built/buildings adapted to residential dwellings.

loislovesstewie · 24/07/2023 14:13

I think you will be in favour of relaxing planning laws until absolute monstrosities are built, your property is overlooked by a block of flats and all the flats are glorified rabbit hutches. And the properties are bought up by investors who let them on AST , not owner occupiers or social housing. And if there's no out side space for families to actually be outside their rabbit hutches and social issues arise.