Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really!? Gove!? and a sensible suggestion!? Inner city housing

111 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 11:01

Gove appears to be making the first sensible suggestion of his career - more housing in inner cities, relaxing planning laws to allow this to happen.

This is desperately needed - we are in a vicious circle of needing parking because people can't live close to where they work, then people not being able to live close to where they work because so much space is needed for parking....

We need to get out of this, we need to put an end to the culture of driving in to work, and get rid of the inner city car parks, and put the land to better use.

We also need to get rid of the on street parking, and the awful concreting over of grass to park on front gardens, and start to scale back on the need and expectations of car ownership altogether.

More housing where it is actually needed is the first steps towards that - decades late, but better than nothing

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Godwindar · 25/07/2023 11:36

UsingChangeofName · 24/07/2023 22:56

other than the very large and richer urban city centres like Leeds, Manchester, London and Birmingham?

Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha at the perception that Birmingham is a rich City Grin

Try googling Equal pay Claims.
Or just look up the IMD figures.

But I agree that public sector workers don't travel into the City Centre to work. This is because the Local Council closed the buildings during covid, and realised how much money it saved them, so no longer have them.

I assure you, Birmingham is much more prosperous in many ways than the other city I live in or have lived in - it sustains a major city centre retail market - you will find most other cities outside the ones I mentioned, no longer have that... All the major cities have extreme poverty though.

IWillSayThisOnlyNow · 25/07/2023 09:48

Gove's track record on building projects in his own constituency isn't reflecting his statements this morning. Lots of new developments all crammed into one small area, the poorest area, but almost no social housing, prices out of reach for many local families, no infrastructure improvements, not enough parking, bus routes getting cancelled, village amenities collapsing under the weight of extra people (health centre, pharmacy, for example).

UsingChangeofName · 24/07/2023 22:56

other than the very large and richer urban city centres like Leeds, Manchester, London and Birmingham?

Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha at the perception that Birmingham is a rich City Grin

Try googling Equal pay Claims.
Or just look up the IMD figures.

But I agree that public sector workers don't travel into the City Centre to work. This is because the Local Council closed the buildings during covid, and realised how much money it saved them, so no longer have them.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 24/07/2023 21:32

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 19:50

I do live in a city, and it isn't green spaces that these plans are about- it is spaces like empty commercial properties, car parks, etc

If that’s true, that’s great - is there a link to what spaces the Gove Creature is referring to?
Your reference to not needing inner car parks might be relevant if only people from outside of the inner city didn’t need access to the inner city. And I’d they do, you need an inner city council that isn’t closing down and selling off the park and ride car parks - eg Canterbury under the previous incumbent Ben Fitter-Harding…
Also, inner city building still requires infrastructure in place BEFORE the residential building takes place. There is a former department store in the nearest city to me that has obtained planning permission without any regard for sewerage disposal. Currently - after planning has been granted - the plan is for lorries to remove sewer waste twice a day, through the city streets… unless the Gove Creature is legislating against this kind of bodge, he can fuck off.

StormShadow · 24/07/2023 20:43

LoobyDop · 24/07/2023 18:18

The problem with poor build quality isn’t restricted to flats- houses are just as bad. But as PP have said, leasehold makes getting anything sorted in a flat far more difficult.

What we need is a proper mix of housing. Large family houses, small family houses, large apartments and small apartments. It should be a legal requirement that every home has access to private outdoor space, even if only a small balcony (but a proper one, not the Juliet kind). We need to be more creative and inspiring with the way new builds are done. Some of the developments around Manchester in the last few years have been really interesting, especially where old mills have been converted and have included lots of communal space- gardens, gyms, laundry areas, big entertaining spaces that residents can borrow. But at the same time they still throwing up horrible multistorey shoeboxes with no balconies. And I completely agree that we need to stop the sale of proper to people not resident in the UK. Our land should be too important to us for it to be crammed full of giant Chinese and Russian piggybanks.

That's true too, lots of new houses are crap as well. And that's an important point to make.

It's just that they're less likely than flats to be leasehold rather than freehold, and people are a bit less vulnerable to the downsides of shit construction standards when the living is less communal. A lot of new builds have tiny gardens, but it's still an outside space. The walls are often paper thin in new build houses too, but you'll share them with fewer/no people. There's also been no house equivalent of the cladding fiasco.

Ponoka7 · 24/07/2023 20:10

House building shouldn't be allowed unless there are GPs, schools, services available. We are having three hundred houses built around us. I phoned the GP at 8 this morning, it'll be Thursday before I get an appointment for my partner. I've (and my GC) had to attend A&E three times because I needed antibiotics. We've all had to go to the Walk in, a taxi ride away, for things that the GP could deal with. The wait is around three hours, that's about to rise along with the population. The situation is the same in the two other GPs that serve this area. Around five years ago it was decided to move shops, M&S, Smyths, Argos etc onto a retail park served by an hourly bus. If you have to get to work on a bank holiday, Sunday, Christmas Eve etc it's a taxi. We had no arriva buses all last summer because of the strikes, it took every penny of a lot of people's disposable income. They've since awarded Arriva even more routes, so if the same thing happens we'll be even more screwed.

Godwindar · 24/07/2023 20:01

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 11:01

Gove appears to be making the first sensible suggestion of his career - more housing in inner cities, relaxing planning laws to allow this to happen.

This is desperately needed - we are in a vicious circle of needing parking because people can't live close to where they work, then people not being able to live close to where they work because so much space is needed for parking....

We need to get out of this, we need to put an end to the culture of driving in to work, and get rid of the inner city car parks, and put the land to better use.

We also need to get rid of the on street parking, and the awful concreting over of grass to park on front gardens, and start to scale back on the need and expectations of car ownership altogether.

More housing where it is actually needed is the first steps towards that - decades late, but better than nothing

I can't think of anyone I know, public sector jobs in the main, who works in a city centre. Which city are you thinking of that has lots of workers travelling in to work, other than the very large and richer urban city centres like Leeds, Manchester, London and Birmingham? Which tend to have better transport links in anyway? In my area, the University, main hospitals and the schools moved out of the city centre decade ago. The private sector is relatively limited.

bellac11 · 24/07/2023 19:59

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/07/2023 11:39

There would be less of a problem if there wasn’t such a British obsession around big houses over practical apartments and if more people’s aspirations and expectations around housing were more realistic. You only have to read an MN property thread to realise that what too many British people think should be the norm for every family is a detached house with two reception rooms, upstairs and downstairs bathrooms and toilets and en-suites aplenty, a big kitchen diner, enough bedrooms to have one for each child and one kept solely for occasional guests, a huge back as well as landed frontage, and off-street parking for three cars. But you can’t build those for everyone who wants them either cheaply or on small plots of land or on urban brownfield sites.

Anyone with any sense does not want a leasehold property. Service charges, maintenance rip offs, ground rent, plus often limited outside space.

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 19:51

and actually, there is often more recreational green space in cities than in the countryside - completely beside the point

OP posts:
orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 19:50

JRHartley72 · 24/07/2023 18:25

You clearly don't live in an inner city because if you did you'd know that the few bits of green space we do have are really precious and if you are going to stick families in buildings cheek to jowl you have to give them some outdoor space. Overall this is a terrible idea. There's far more green space outside of cities that would be far more suitable and the only reason the Tories are suggesting these is because they know all the Nimbies vote Tory and inner cities tend to vote Labour.

I do live in a city, and it isn't green spaces that these plans are about- it is spaces like empty commercial properties, car parks, etc

OP posts:
LoobyDop · 24/07/2023 19:34

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 18:21

I am not sure leasehold makes getting reapairs sorted in a flat harder - you need a legal system to collect money and define responsibilties for repairs. It doesn't neccesarily have to be leasehold but you need something.

You need consensus that the work needs to be done, on the budget, on how many quotes you will get and then who will do the work. You need a lengthy process for dealing with leaseholders who refuse to pay their share. All that is significantly more difficult than having control over all those things yourself.

SingingNettles · 24/07/2023 18:37

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/07/2023 11:39

There would be less of a problem if there wasn’t such a British obsession around big houses over practical apartments and if more people’s aspirations and expectations around housing were more realistic. You only have to read an MN property thread to realise that what too many British people think should be the norm for every family is a detached house with two reception rooms, upstairs and downstairs bathrooms and toilets and en-suites aplenty, a big kitchen diner, enough bedrooms to have one for each child and one kept solely for occasional guests, a huge back as well as landed frontage, and off-street parking for three cars. But you can’t build those for everyone who wants them either cheaply or on small plots of land or on urban brownfield sites.

Is this really a British obsession? British homes are famously small.

SingingNettles · 24/07/2023 18:29

It’s a topic I’m pretty ignorant on tbh, but I’ve seen Gove drawing praise from across the political spectrum re. housing for a few years now.

JRHartley72 · 24/07/2023 18:25

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 11:01

Gove appears to be making the first sensible suggestion of his career - more housing in inner cities, relaxing planning laws to allow this to happen.

This is desperately needed - we are in a vicious circle of needing parking because people can't live close to where they work, then people not being able to live close to where they work because so much space is needed for parking....

We need to get out of this, we need to put an end to the culture of driving in to work, and get rid of the inner city car parks, and put the land to better use.

We also need to get rid of the on street parking, and the awful concreting over of grass to park on front gardens, and start to scale back on the need and expectations of car ownership altogether.

More housing where it is actually needed is the first steps towards that - decades late, but better than nothing

You clearly don't live in an inner city because if you did you'd know that the few bits of green space we do have are really precious and if you are going to stick families in buildings cheek to jowl you have to give them some outdoor space. Overall this is a terrible idea. There's far more green space outside of cities that would be far more suitable and the only reason the Tories are suggesting these is because they know all the Nimbies vote Tory and inner cities tend to vote Labour.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 18:21

I am not sure leasehold makes getting reapairs sorted in a flat harder - you need a legal system to collect money and define responsibilties for repairs. It doesn't neccesarily have to be leasehold but you need something.

LoobyDop · 24/07/2023 18:18

The problem with poor build quality isn’t restricted to flats- houses are just as bad. But as PP have said, leasehold makes getting anything sorted in a flat far more difficult.

What we need is a proper mix of housing. Large family houses, small family houses, large apartments and small apartments. It should be a legal requirement that every home has access to private outdoor space, even if only a small balcony (but a proper one, not the Juliet kind). We need to be more creative and inspiring with the way new builds are done. Some of the developments around Manchester in the last few years have been really interesting, especially where old mills have been converted and have included lots of communal space- gardens, gyms, laundry areas, big entertaining spaces that residents can borrow. But at the same time they still throwing up horrible multistorey shoeboxes with no balconies. And I completely agree that we need to stop the sale of proper to people not resident in the UK. Our land should be too important to us for it to be crammed full of giant Chinese and Russian piggybanks.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 17:23

@StormShadow Oh I agree - I jut get ittitated by the assumption that all flats are "rabbit hutches" some of it is true and some of it is just born of snobbery.

LindorDoubleChoc · 24/07/2023 17:19

I want to see less ownership of second, third, multiple homes. Stop being so greedy and selfish people!

StormShadow · 24/07/2023 17:14

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 17:03

I do live in a nice flat yes - and would love to see that standard of building come back for flats. The problem is because flats are seen an an inferior option or a temporary pit stop in life then they don't get built properly. It is a self fulfilling prophecy.

Well, take it from someone who did live in multiple examples of poorer quality newbuild flats, rabbit hutch with paper thin walls is a painfully accurate take on some of them!

The idea that correctly describing them as such means flats don't get built properly is a pretty far fetched one, though. If anything, downplaying the situation is more likely to do that. We build the rabbit hutches because it suits developers. Of course they'd like the idea that there isn't a problem because hey, some of the older flats in this country are great quality, and the people who live in them are pleased with them. Nothing to see here, let's keep being shit!

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 17:04

As for paper thin walls - I have to use a hammer drill to put up curtain rails. 😂

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 17:03

I do live in a nice flat yes - and would love to see that standard of building come back for flats. The problem is because flats are seen an an inferior option or a temporary pit stop in life then they don't get built properly. It is a self fulfilling prophecy.

StormShadow · 24/07/2023 16:55

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 16:50

@StormShadow Not all flats are new build and not all new builts are terrible - there are lots and lots of solidly built blocks of good sized flats - lots from the first part of the twentieth century.

Constantly referring to flats at "rabbit hutches" is a bit ignorant and pretty insulting to those of us who have build decent lives in a flat.

Nah, it's not. We do build rabbit hutches with paper thin walls. I used the present tense there for a reason, and you talking about what we used to build reinforces my point. If we did still make them like that, if you could point to that quality of development now, the situation would be very different. But it isn't.

Fwiw, I have actually lived in said rabbit hutches. It sounds from this like you live in a rather nicer standard of flat?

UsingChangeofName · 24/07/2023 16:52

Absolutely agree @Hufflepods

Near where I live, the City Council turned down a developer's proposal to build 800 houses on a golf course, only to have it overturned by National Government. So that is going to be probably 3000 more people not able to get registered with a dentist, or a Doctor (or to be able to get an appointment, if local doctors are forced to take them), people complaining about not getting school places etc. as well as a busy city losing hundreds of mature trees, and just green, breathing space.

I wish we had FAR more stringent planning laws, compelling any new developments to include green spaces, community meeting spaces, and proper facilities that every community needs. Plus enough parking, rather than just pretending nobody will use a car if they don't build communities with enough parking space.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/07/2023 16:50

@StormShadow Not all flats are new build and not all new builts are terrible - there are lots and lots of solidly built blocks of good sized flats - lots from the first part of the twentieth century.

Constantly referring to flats at "rabbit hutches" is a bit ignorant and pretty insulting to those of us who have build decent lives in a flat.

DandelionBurdockAndGin · 24/07/2023 16:37

When we first moved here I said to DH it was a shame all the old grand building with shops often at ground level going to rack and ruin - they could be flats as near train station several cities are very commutable.

Since then a quango was set up to do just that and there are now many flats in town center - they do rent or sell for a pretty penny but the building have had remedial repairs made so should last longer.

Where I grew up brown field sites have been cleaned and built on for decades - suppose high house prices help recoup costs there. There had been a big industrial estate at end of nearby town to village I grew up in got cleaned up and build huge estate there - then farmers between that and village sold up - and now there're building in-between.

Near IL there a brown field site next to a country park took multiple planning applications and an appeal to Secretary of state to get permission for an estate - which does now have pretty much everything schools hotel business park.

So I think this has been happening for a while - but there's can still be opposition to it.