Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Giving in to tantruming 3 year old

91 replies

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:10

3 year old DD just had a horrible tantrum over what to wear to nursery this rainy morning - my DH let her put on shorts and no socks, then there was a huge to-do when we both tried to put her rain suit and socks on when it was time to leave. Fighting to get her into it - and me pissed off with DH for letting this happen in the first place. Then she started to scream that she wanted trousers on instead of shorts, and DH started to unzip her rain suit... I felt like I was going to go bananas, and told him he was just letting her know that she could have a tantrum and we would give in. He also barked at me not to twist her arm getting her suit on - after she'd whacked me in the face.
Just a standard horrible morning with a pre schooler I guess? She's really not normally as bad as that though - and I just feel pissed off with DH being 'the patient one', but then teaching her tantrums are fine basically :/
I'm probably horrible and grumpy

OP posts:
queenMab99 · 24/07/2023 10:04

I wouldn't like my bare legs in a rainsuit, and I am not particularly sensitive. The thought makes me shudder.

Intriguedbythis · 24/07/2023 10:04

@CosyKnits i couldn’t agree more.

5childrenand · 24/07/2023 10:03

So you also have a tiny baby at home ie your dd’s life has just changed completely. Totally understandable she’s exerting control over what she can. Going forward find ways to give her (limited) choice and pick your battles. Safety = non negotiable. Getting a bit wet = not a big deal. Being on the same page with your DH (or at least her thinking you are) = crucial

Dixiechickonhols · 24/07/2023 10:03

With your update it sounds much less like clothes and more 3yr old wanting to stay home with mum with sibling. But they are 3 aren’t can’t say that in words.
With a month old you’ve all had a lot of change to contend with.
Can you agree you’ll lay out outfit night before. Not too many choices so red or blue top to go with trousers/socks/underwear you’ve put out.
If dh dealing I’d leave it to him then it’s not as intense 2 v 1 little one babble.
Easier said than done but quite no nonsense tone, chop chop not please put your shoes on…what about the red shoes..mummy will be sad if you don’t..

Mrsjayy · 24/07/2023 10:00

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:56

No, I definitely don't have time for multiple shoes! We definitely need to be on the same page (mostly we are!), you're right

It was a stressful morning and anxiety probably was high because you wanted out the door. You need to speak to her dad without her in earshot about it.

Lolapusht · 24/07/2023 09:59

It’s not teaching her she gets what she wants by tantruming, but you are teaching her not to express her feelings and that showing negative feelings is wrong. That’s going to lead to frustration on her part that will probably come out as anger which will be interpreted as being naughty so she’ll be punished which will make her angry etc, etc.

Toddlers usually have a small window when the meltdown is actually about the thing that upset them. After that they don’t like how their emotions are making them feel which is when they can really lose it. They’re not being manipulative or naughty, they just don’t have the emotional knowledge to deal with the situation (as an aside, you’re expecting your toddler to have control of their emotions which is something neither you nor your husband could do in the moment). If you get into a punitive spiral when they’re melting down, they don’t get the reassurance that the big feelings are ok to have so they’ll be programmed to panic when they have negative feelings. Defuse the heat and teach her how to behave after she’s settled down.

If she doesn’t have her rain suit on she’ll get wet 🤷🏻‍♀️

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 09:58

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:55

I didn't lose my shit. I told DH that this was helping to reinforce tantrums pay off, that's all - when I saw him go to take her suit off. Where did you get me losing my shit from?

It's pretty evident that you did considering how irrationally pissed off at your DH for being patient you were, you said "I was going to go bananas" and the fact that you were still angry enough about this to post a thread and label it as your DH "giving in"!

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:56

No, I definitely don't have time for multiple shoes! We definitely need to be on the same page (mostly we are!), you're right

OP posts:
Singleandproud · 24/07/2023 09:55

All behaviour is communication and children make adults feel the way the are feeling. Child feels out of control, scream and tantrum now parents feel out of control.

Toddlers are not manipulative, that is putting a very adult spin on what is essentially instinctive behaviour.

Two of you getting DD ready was too much. Keep a bag packed with spare clothes for all weather types then change DDs clothes when you get to nursery if they aren't appropriate, she'll be calmer.

If crying and tantrumming escalates your own emotions then wear ear plugs/headphones and reduce the sensory input you are receiving to keep yourself calm. I am like your DH and find being zen is the answer to most toddler behaviour but it took time and practise to get there. At any age if you let your own behaviour escalate to that of the child/ teen you are on to a losing battle.

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:55

Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 09:51

Your reaction is the problem here, not your DH. You totally lost control, your husband seen it, your daughter seen it and all you are doing is reinforcing the idea that losing your shit is an acceptable way to deal with things.

I didn't lose my shit. I told DH that this was helping to reinforce tantrums pay off, that's all - when I saw him go to take her suit off. Where did you get me losing my shit from?

OP posts:
Mrsjayy · 24/07/2023 09:53

You and her dad need to be on the same page or it's just upsetting and confusing for her. Bugger putting multiple pairs of shoes on nobody has time for that! .

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:52

Also, I wasn't getting her dressed - I've got a month old baby to deal with. I was only helping with shoes and rainsuit when they were about to leave.

OP posts:
PinkButtercups · 24/07/2023 09:52

PoshPineapple · 24/07/2023 09:50

This reminds me of a friend, years ago....

Twin boys, aged 3, nearly 4. Both had a strop when being 'forced' to wear something appropriate for the weather and as soon as Dad dressed them, they tore the clothes straight off again.

In the end, Dad calmly said 'fuck this' and plonked them both in their birthday suits in their car seats and drove them to where they going with them completely stark naked. He drove the journey with the car aircon on, and surprise surprise, when they got to nursery, they couldn't wait to put their clothes on. Still makes me laugh now when I think about it!

Yeah, that's not funny.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 24/07/2023 09:51

Fir the future pick your battles, natural consequences and limited(acceptable) choices. Talk to your husband, come up with a plan and make sure you support each other.

So for clothes the blue or purple leggings? Or leggings or tracksuit bottoms? And just keep repeating.

If you missed that chance, let her be in shorts or the strappy dress or whatever and pack extra clothes. Let her be a bit wet/cold. It won't kill her , and then you /preschool can get her changed.

Puddle suit was only absolutely necessary if you walk to nursery and it was pissing down. Otherwise same thing, just pack it for later.

It's not about giving in, it's about getting things done with the least stress possible with all of you, otherwise situations escalate and it becomes very easy to be trapped in a negative circle.

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:51

Helpful responses otherwise, thanks guys. I am definitely the more no nonsense parent, and while I admire DH's ability to ask her what she wants etc., sometimes we just need to get somewhere on time and can't be faffing around taking on and off different pairs of shoes... but I recognise I could have just let her get a bit wet today, and packed extra clothes for nursery! Ahh, hindsight

OP posts:
Hufflepods · 24/07/2023 09:51

Your reaction is the problem here, not your DH. You totally lost control, your husband seen it, your daughter seen it and all you are doing is reinforcing the idea that losing your shit is an acceptable way to deal with things.

PoshPineapple · 24/07/2023 09:50

This reminds me of a friend, years ago....

Twin boys, aged 3, nearly 4. Both had a strop when being 'forced' to wear something appropriate for the weather and as soon as Dad dressed them, they tore the clothes straight off again.

In the end, Dad calmly said 'fuck this' and plonked them both in their birthday suits in their car seats and drove them to where they going with them completely stark naked. He drove the journey with the car aircon on, and surprise surprise, when they got to nursery, they couldn't wait to put their clothes on. Still makes me laugh now when I think about it!

SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2023 09:50

Why were two of you getting her dressed?

Mrsjayy · 24/07/2023 09:49

Why were you both involved it sounds chaos clothes off/,on/off again. Give her a choice of 2 appropriate outfits if you want her to have choice do it then night before and then the "little miss boutique " is closed and one of you gets her organised. Remember 2 choices she can't cope with anything else resulting her to get upset.

CatLoaf · 24/07/2023 09:48

Clarification, I did NOT twist her arm! I was getting her into her rain suit. She lashed out at my face before that, but I wasn't retaliating by twisting my daughter’s arm ffs!

OP posts:
Pitpatwaddlepat · 24/07/2023 09:45

Previous posters are reading the arm twisting as intentional- I had read it that you were trying to get her arm into the sleeve and then your husband had said that you were twisting it.
Obviously if you intentionally twisted her arm then you need to work on yourself immediately since harming a child is not remotely ok.

Jongleterre · 24/07/2023 09:44

I solved the clothing tantrums with my daughter by getting three of everything laid out and she got to choose which socks, which knickers, bottoms, top, coat and footwear.

Sometimes I would pretend I didn't like her choice as she went to pick something just to give her the satisfaction of making her feel she'd got one over on me by getting excited about choosing that item!

They are funny little things at that age. So determined to prove they know best!

Thirty5 · 24/07/2023 09:44

You are the adults, you should be taking control of the situation, but more importantly than that you need to be saying the same thing and not squabbling. Her behaviour is a consequence. Sounds like you are both a bit afraid of setting her off.

DontEatCrisps · 24/07/2023 09:42

Sorry you e had a difficult morning.

I agree with pp that it’s generally best to let one parent deal. Tantrums are difficult but it helps not to think in terms of “giving in” or letting her get her way and more about calmly managing the situation so that she learns to regulate her emotions. That’s not saying you have to do whatever thing it is she wants- obviously that’s not always practical- but really that’s secondary to gently helping her be calm.

I read something once that takes about it in terms of expanding circles- you’re the parent and have a circle of calm, she’s the child with a circle of anger. You need to gently expand your calm circle so that she’s drawn inside it, and resist being drawn into her angry circle (eg the arm twisting)- wish I could remember where I read it as it explains it much better than this.

Hannahsbananas · 24/07/2023 09:42

You should have kept out of it when your husband was already dealing with it, really.
You added nothing but stress to the situation and you actually twisted her arm in the process, which you appear to be trying to justify?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread