Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say DH is being unreasonable?

111 replies

TheLostNights · 23/07/2023 22:04

Looking to hire a sitter and found a guy who looks great on one of the childcare sites. The problem? DH.
He doesn't want a guy looking after our school aged girls. Only open to female sitters which we have had in the past. I am really fed up at his attitude. Aibu to say he is being totally unreasonable?

OP posts:
EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:41

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:37

But that's the thing... its men who build up trust who are ones who then hurt children and women

Dads, uncles, older brothers, grandads. All people who you trust. Until they do something.

A random man who has decided his calling is to be a child care provider is no different. You work to build that trust and confidence with them but they could still turn around and hurt the child. The same with a female provider.

But the male provider is more likely to harm that child than a female provider.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:39

There is always someone on these threads who will say they've only ever experienced sexual harassment from women. As though the women reading will be convinced that all the harassment from men they and their friend have experienced from men on a spectrum from catcalling to unwanted touching, sexual aggression, coercion and abuse isn't the reality for girls from primary age upwards. As though we'll dismiss the fact that every week we see in the news women being raped, abducted and killed by men and we don't see it the other way around. As though by acknowledging this reality, we are saying that women are perfect and never offend. As though by acknowledging this reality we are saying we hate men. It's pretty transparent.

DonnaBanana · 24/07/2023 09:38

I wouldn’t, for all the reasons listed by others already. It cuts both ways though. I wouldn’t be keen to have another woman repair my boiler or something. It is just what it is and why some professions are heavily gender biased.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:37

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:31

That is true and I wondered if someone would bring it up. The difference is trust, and of course it can be misplaced and shattered. I do know that statistically speaking I'm more at risk going home to my male partner than from stranger attack but I also know that I feel completely safe with him. There is nothing in the world that is risk-free. But it's because I don't believe that all men are predators that I do have men in my life. I'll still take precautions though, because I know from experience that some of them are.

I wouldn't put myself or my daughters in the position of being alone and vulnerable with an unknown man. I am happy for us to know, love, trust, respect and adore men - in our lives we will work with them, be friends with them, have sex with them - but that doesn't mean pretending there is never any threat. Hiring a male babysitter is an unnecessary risk so I won't take it. For a heterosexual woman, having a relationship with a man feels a lot more worth it.

But that's the thing... its men who build up trust who are ones who then hurt children and women

Dads, uncles, older brothers, grandads. All people who you trust. Until they do something.

A random man who has decided his calling is to be a child care provider is no different. You work to build that trust and confidence with them but they could still turn around and hurt the child. The same with a female provider.

MissTrip82 · 24/07/2023 09:34

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 24/07/2023 07:04

Is his name Sandy and is your husband's name Ross?

All these hysterical responses are ridiculous. The op has gone through a well respected official website (sitters.com) to find a qualified childcare expert. Who's sex doesn't matter does it? Come on people. What on earth would you do if your child had a male teacher?

A lot of misogyny here for someone pretending to be progressive.

Women expressing our opinions aren’t hysterical, that’s a misogynistic trope.

Theres a vast difference between a teacher or nursery worker and someone alone in your home with your children. But you know that. You just think you’re not like all those crazy women who unfortunately know almost all sexual predators are men. You know that too, you’re just pretending to be puzzled as to our reasoning. Goodness me you’re so much smarter and better than these stupid women, you’ve really shown us.

TurnerP · 24/07/2023 09:32

JMSA · 24/07/2023 09:29

What a very odd point. Your daughter could develop a crush on ANYONE, so to lessen the odds you'd rather steer clear of male babysitters.
You'd better start building the Rapunzel tower now then ...

I wasn't sure how old the children were
My friend once had a crush on her teacher... He then slept with her

JMSA · 24/07/2023 09:31

This was never going to go down well on a predominantly man-hating site.
Hope you manage to find someone that ALL the family are happy with, OP.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:31

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:20

Statistically, since we like to use that without any evidence or showing the statistics, it is family members who are the most risk to children

So by that logic, yes male family members should be kept apart from female ones....

That is true and I wondered if someone would bring it up. The difference is trust, and of course it can be misplaced and shattered. I do know that statistically speaking I'm more at risk going home to my male partner than from stranger attack but I also know that I feel completely safe with him. There is nothing in the world that is risk-free. But it's because I don't believe that all men are predators that I do have men in my life. I'll still take precautions though, because I know from experience that some of them are.

I wouldn't put myself or my daughters in the position of being alone and vulnerable with an unknown man. I am happy for us to know, love, trust, respect and adore men - in our lives we will work with them, be friends with them, have sex with them - but that doesn't mean pretending there is never any threat. Hiring a male babysitter is an unnecessary risk so I won't take it. For a heterosexual woman, having a relationship with a man feels a lot more worth it.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:29

Just as a counter to all this "all women have experienced sexual abuse from men"

The only time I've ever been touched without consent that I can recall was by a drunk woman touching my boobs after making a comment about how big they were. Maybe I'm just really good at suppressing all the memories of all the men assaulting me though...

I also know of blokes who've had women grab and touch them at an event "as a joke" who said after "If I'd acted like that around them, grabbed them whilst laughing and acting like it was a joke, I'd have been arrested"....

Women aren't saints either. The only way to absolutely make sure you're child isn't going to be harmed or assaulted it for you and you alone to looked after them, not even another member of family, male or female.

JMSA · 24/07/2023 09:29

TurnerP · 23/07/2023 23:24

I would feel concerned if something were to happen to one daughter that would mean close physical contact, eg first aid, or an accident that requires bathing
Depending on age of daughters, I also wouldn't want a crush to develop

What a very odd point. Your daughter could develop a crush on ANYONE, so to lessen the odds you'd rather steer clear of male babysitters.
You'd better start building the Rapunzel tower now then ...

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 24/07/2023 09:20

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:12

Lots of MN is based on all men are predators

No one has said that. But the vast majority of predators are men. That’s a fact.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:20

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 08:40

Which part of any of my posts advocate keeping men segregated from women? Why would not hiring a male babysitter equate to exiling fathers and brother from the family home or stopping men from becoming teachers?

Your post is a wild extrapolation of what I've said. I am happy for my kids to have male teachers; I wouldn't hire a male babysitter. Because statistically it's riskier than hiring a woman. That's not really something anyone can deny! It doesn't mean I think all men are a threat.

Statistically, since we like to use that without any evidence or showing the statistics, it is family members who are the most risk to children

So by that logic, yes male family members should be kept apart from female ones....

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:18

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:12

Lots of MN is based on all men are predators

I would say that virtually all women have experienced sexually predatory behaviour from men. So we don't think all men are predators, but we know that some are and we take steps in our lives to protect ourselves against it. It doesn't mean shunning all men or living in constant fear, but it does mean we might avoid certain situations or plan in some protection. So if put the chain on a hotel bedroom door while I sleep in there alone, it's not because I'm hysterical or convinced the male receptionist is a rapist. But just in case, I do it anyway.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:13

I think equating a male babysitter to a male teacher is like asking a woman why she's happy to go into the office all day with male colleagues but not for a run in the woods alone at 11pm. Ok, either situation you might get sexually assaulted and most likely you won't. But one is more likely than the other.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:12

BettyRoodBoy · 23/07/2023 23:05

Being male does not automatically make someone a predator.

No-one thinks that, and obviously there are great male childminders - it'd be very odd if there weren't! My youngest went to nursery with male staff. It's slightly different from being left alone at home with them.

Lots of MN is based on all men are predators

BettyRoodBoy · 24/07/2023 09:11

Iwouldlikesomecake · 24/07/2023 07:41

All the people saying ‘I wouldn’t hire anyone off the internet to look after my child’ but the amount of threads on here where people are mocked and castigated if they can’t get a babysitter because ‘you can just go on sitters.co.uk and hire someone’ 🤔

Yes, almost as if this is a massive site with thousands of different people with different opinions!

Maiden2021 · 24/07/2023 09:11

My mother wouldn't even leave my then toddler double orphaned niece with my male adult cousin whom my mother brought up in our house as her son. As mum was retired but in a choir, she didn't go away with the choir for 2 hours at a town nearby because of that.

I admired my mother. Statistics are clear that it is male in close contact (not talking nursery/ school teachers here) who are likely to abuse women, especially those in position of trust to them.

Yeah, those who won't hire babysitters/minders off the Internet- where do you find them?

FAOD I have not hired anyone off the internet.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:11

You're asking MN where all men are evil sex pests. Don't expect a balanced view...

As if some random woman off the same site couldn't also be a risk. As if women haven't been used to mask child exploitation. As if they may be less risk sexually (and let's be honest, figures regarding sexual abuse are skewed by the fact we still don't believe women could sexually assault anyone) but they are statistically more likely to kill a baby. As if there aren't numerous cases of female nurses who've hurt and injured babies in their care.

He has glowing references, a DBS check (which is, yes, only valid on the day its made but is the only way we have to do these checks at the moment and every childcare provider from teachers to Scout leaders to childminders has them and its usually enough), qualifications... he sounds great.

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 24/07/2023 09:02

onefinemess · 24/07/2023 08:51

Then you're a saying one thing and doing another.

If you think a male babysitter IS going to abuse children, then you can't also say that a male teacher won't.

You ARE branding all man as sexual predators, but you won't admit it because you can see how unreasonable it makes you sound.

She didn’t say a male babysitter is going to abuse children. She said a male babysitter is more likely to abuse children than a female babysitter. The vast majority of sexual abuse is committed by men. My daughter had a male teacher last term; she was never alone with him. If I hired a male babysitter to come into our house, she would be alone with him. Therefore, a higher risk situation. Most rational people take steps to reduce risk. Not hiring a male babysitter to be at home with my child is one of those steps.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 08:59

onefinemess · 24/07/2023 08:51

Then you're a saying one thing and doing another.

If you think a male babysitter IS going to abuse children, then you can't also say that a male teacher won't.

You ARE branding all man as sexual predators, but you won't admit it because you can see how unreasonable it makes you sound.

Well no. I've explained how a school is a very different environment to a home, and that a male teacher - for his own protection - won't be alone one on one with children (you always, male or female, keep a door open or have another adult in the room so you can't be accused of anything). So a male teacher doesn't pose a risk in the way a male babysitter alone in a house with children can.

I also never said a male babysitter WILL abuse a child. There are lots of precautions I take in life against things that MIGHT happen.

I wonder if you misread the phrase in my post about 98% of sexual offences being committed by men? I said it doesn't mean all men are sexual predators, but it means almost all sexual predators are men. So a female babysitter is less likely to be a sexual predator than a male one - that isn't the same thing as saying a male babysitter is likely to be one or definitely is one. But the risk is lower with a woman.

A child alone with a a babysitter is in a vulnerable position. It's a situation in which I would be extremely careful.

MyTruthIsOut · 24/07/2023 08:57

RedHelenB · 24/07/2023 08:10

Why would they be terrified? Have they never met a man before?

What a really stupid thing to say.

yeah…..being left alone in their house at night with a man they’ve never met before is “just like meeting a man.”

How ridiculous are you?!

onefinemess · 24/07/2023 08:51

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 08:40

Which part of any of my posts advocate keeping men segregated from women? Why would not hiring a male babysitter equate to exiling fathers and brother from the family home or stopping men from becoming teachers?

Your post is a wild extrapolation of what I've said. I am happy for my kids to have male teachers; I wouldn't hire a male babysitter. Because statistically it's riskier than hiring a woman. That's not really something anyone can deny! It doesn't mean I think all men are a threat.

Then you're a saying one thing and doing another.

If you think a male babysitter IS going to abuse children, then you can't also say that a male teacher won't.

You ARE branding all man as sexual predators, but you won't admit it because you can see how unreasonable it makes you sound.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 08:40

onefinemess · 24/07/2023 08:29

So, all fathers and brothers should be kept away from children?

No male teachers?

Doctors or nurses?

What age are all your sons when you you sit down with them and accuse them of being sexual predators?

How do you word it?

Should we keep male teenagers away from their siblings?

No wonder there is a mental health crisis amongst young males.

What an utterly fucking toxic way to write off half the people on the planet.

Imagine being branded a sexual predator just for existing!

Which part of any of my posts advocate keeping men segregated from women? Why would not hiring a male babysitter equate to exiling fathers and brother from the family home or stopping men from becoming teachers?

Your post is a wild extrapolation of what I've said. I am happy for my kids to have male teachers; I wouldn't hire a male babysitter. Because statistically it's riskier than hiring a woman. That's not really something anyone can deny! It doesn't mean I think all men are a threat.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 08:33

And as for that fear being 'pushed onto' the children; I learned to be wary when I was primary aged and men would shout sexual comments from their car windows. Secondary age, when even those trustworthy professional men in suits stared and rubbed up close to girls in school uniform on the bus. I don't need to outline all the instances of aggression and predatory behaviour; I'm assuming all women have experienced it in every sphere of their lives. The fear doesn't have to be manufactured and forced onto us. We learn it from what happens to us. I'm not advocating a fear and distrust of all men all the time. But we all take care to try to keep ourselves safe and we all know how a lack of risk assessment is used against girls and women later. What were you wearing, how much did you drink, why were you alone in that place at that time etc etc. If a woman does leave her kids with a male sitter who abuses them, be sure she'll get castigated for having done it. So it's not unreasonable to just not hire him in the first place.

onefinemess · 24/07/2023 08:29

EdwardianTable · 23/07/2023 22:11

You want to hire a man off the internet to look after your daughters? 98% of sexual crime is committed by men. It doesn't mean all men are sex offenders, but pretty much all sex offenders are men. So no, I would never do this and certainly don't think your husband is unreasonable to refuse.

So, all fathers and brothers should be kept away from children?

No male teachers?

Doctors or nurses?

What age are all your sons when you you sit down with them and accuse them of being sexual predators?

How do you word it?

Should we keep male teenagers away from their siblings?

No wonder there is a mental health crisis amongst young males.

What an utterly fucking toxic way to write off half the people on the planet.

Imagine being branded a sexual predator just for existing!

Swipe left for the next trending thread