Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say DH is being unreasonable?

111 replies

TheLostNights · 23/07/2023 22:04

Looking to hire a sitter and found a guy who looks great on one of the childcare sites. The problem? DH.
He doesn't want a guy looking after our school aged girls. Only open to female sitters which we have had in the past. I am really fed up at his attitude. Aibu to say he is being totally unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 12:47

Hysterical isn't just a word though, it is loaded with medical misogyny and history. And here it's been applied to women expressing the very reasonable opinion that a male babysitter poses an inherently greater risk than a female one. Hysterical is a word often used to describe women expressing their feelings, thoughts and opinions and it's intended to diminish and minimise them.

The thing is, women know we get blamed of we're assaulted (why did you walk that route, wear that dress, get drunk etc) but we get called hysterical when we try to mitigate the risk of assault (how dare you label all men as predators!) If a woman hired a male babysitter and he did abuse her children, she'd be castigated for inviting him into her home and leaving her innocent children with him while she went off and enjoyed herself. Choose not to hire one and get called hysterical and a man-hater. Sounds pretty misogynistic to me.

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 24/07/2023 12:25

MissTrip82 · 24/07/2023 09:34

A lot of misogyny here for someone pretending to be progressive.

Women expressing our opinions aren’t hysterical, that’s a misogynistic trope.

Theres a vast difference between a teacher or nursery worker and someone alone in your home with your children. But you know that. You just think you’re not like all those crazy women who unfortunately know almost all sexual predators are men. You know that too, you’re just pretending to be puzzled as to our reasoning. Goodness me you’re so much smarter and better than these stupid women, you’ve really shown us.

  1. There's no way to know the sex or gender of a poster on the Internet.
  2. Hysterical is just a word.
  3. I am no smarter than anyone else of average intelligence, just pragmatic and try to be balanced and reasonable.
  4. I am aware men can be sexual predators. This does not mean I would not hire a qualified male to care for my children.
  5. Sometimes you need childcare and as long as you do all the checks (qualifications, valid dbs certificate, reviews from other families, using a reputable website) your able to, what else are you supposed to do?
Maiden2021 · 24/07/2023 10:40

@MoyoGaza Yes, I also feel sorry for the Dh but I didn't want to post any further as clearly there are those who think he is being unreasonable.

I would be traumatised by this, won't be able to focus on my day and could lose my job over this. Why would anyone put their spouse who's clearly expressed a reasonable concern through this?

*flee- fled in floods of tears as I refused to let the children and parents see me crying. I had to be strong for them. I had to establish another trusting relationship with them which they needed to feel was permanent and not temporary. The discussions over those details are conducted in a way that the kids still feel they are mere relaying a story and we couldn't react. It was the only way I knew they would be able to tell the judges the next day (with defence lawyer trying all tricks including that they can't remember, it's what social workers told them to say etc etc) and get the monsters sent to jail.

MoyoGaza · 24/07/2023 10:33

I actually feel sorry for the husband. He says he is not comfortable with something and that is entirely reasonable and most folks here actually agree with him. But for some reason, it’s not enough for his wife to accept that, she needs validation on a public forum.
Even if your hold a different view to your spouse’s, you lose nothing by going with his instincts. Don’t feel the need to prove how reasonable you are or how unreasonable he is.
Please respect your husband’s feelings on certain matters. All this intellectualising about the babysitter’s qualifications etc means nothing if your heart is not right. Not all issues are ‘head’ problems to be solved by proving this or that - DSB check etc.
Please submit yourself to the wisdom of your husband and in this case, to the wisdom of crowds!

BettyRoodBoy · 24/07/2023 10:28

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:12

Lots of MN is based on all men are predators

So you think these are mothers that knowingly had children with predators?

I think you just can't tell the difference between "all men are predators" and "being male is a higher risk factor for committing abuse than being female, sex being just one of a number of risk factors, none of which can predict the future"

PoshPineapple · 24/07/2023 10:25

Sorry, I know in this day and age it's probably considered a terrible stance, but I would NOT have left my school aged girls (or boys for that matter) with an unknown male.

It's crap that we even have to think along these lines, but sadly we do.

Maiden2021 · 24/07/2023 10:24

Ok. I think I should disclose my previous work as I don't want people to feel torn. For 3 years, 2 decades ago, I was the main legal adviser at a Women and Child Abuse Centre in a Commonwealth country. I took those cases to court. There were times I would flee to my other colleagues' offices as soon as I had met a family with an abused child relaying what the person who was trusted by them and their parents did to them. It was sad to see the sadness in the parents' eyes. Most of the kids were so young that their accounts can be classed as unreliable in court- they know how to choose their victims. And in between Pol!ce and social workers who deal with them for about a year before the case comes to me, you approach their evidence with care and sometimes they have grown up a bit by then.

Mothers described how their outgoing children started being withdrawn, not engaging, not wanting to play with other children. And still, sometimes mothers have no idea why and it carries on. So, the best way to deal with that is to remove the risks as much as humanly possible. It doesn't;t happen overnight. It can even take a year before it starts, by then the abuser has worked out how to do it and what character your child has.

It remains with the kids and their parents forever. Don't risk it.

As a person, I am very trusting. However, I can see if my sitters were male and they started doing something to me when so young and not knowing any different, I would have thought it was part of the care I ws supposed to receive. As they would still play with them ( I loved playing), feed them etc etc. Don't take these unnecessary risk. In the words of one judge who was, in a motor vehicle case not clear if the prosecution had proved their case beyond doubt, he said: : I would rather have a guilty person free, than imprison an innocent person.' So, for the large number of wonderful males in trustworthy relationships with kids, there are those who are not trustworthy'. But how will you know?! So, why on earth take the chance for your kids/daughters to be the unlucky ones?

MyTruthIsOut · 24/07/2023 10:14

Notimeforaname · 24/07/2023 10:09

Of course I would hire him if he was the best for the job.
Good friend of mine works in a creche. A lot of the dads had a problem with him but tough, they had the option to take their kids out and find alternative care..nobody did in the end, they just shut up about it eventually when the realised he wasn't kidnapping, abusing or hurting the kids 🙄.

Why do people keep likening the OPs scenario to one where there is a male teacher or a male carer at nursery?!

There is a very big difference between a known member of male staff being in a busy environment with other adults there too, and an unknown male being alone inside inside a house with two young girls.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 10:13

Whenever male teachers/nannies/nursery workers are mentioned on these threads they are always so amazing and fun and so much better at the job than women and everyone loves them so much! Apparently no mediocre men ever go into childcare. There is a male teacher at my kids' school who is great, but so are the women. People are good at their jobs, shocker.

Anyway, a male teacher or nursery worker is not in the same position as a male babysitter in terms of vulnerability so it's just not relevant.

Notimeforaname · 24/07/2023 10:09

Of course I would hire him if he was the best for the job.
Good friend of mine works in a creche. A lot of the dads had a problem with him but tough, they had the option to take their kids out and find alternative care..nobody did in the end, they just shut up about it eventually when the realised he wasn't kidnapping, abusing or hurting the kids 🙄.

Lifecanbebeautiful12 · 24/07/2023 10:08

*concerning

tennesseewhiskey1 · 24/07/2023 10:07

Torn as we’ve had a male babysitter (he was a teacher in my children’s school) and 2 of my friends have male nannies - they are amazing and every single child I know wants to go to theirs to play as they are so engaging.

Lifecanbebeautiful12 · 24/07/2023 10:06

Sorry but I find it conferencing that any mother would even consider hiring an unknown male babysitter for their young children, qualifications and references or not. It is a huge and unnecessary risk. And no, I don’t believe ‘all men are predators’ but the vast majority of predators are men and it is your job as a mother to protect your children from any harm. Inviting a man into your home to have unsupervised access to your children is just bizarre. I know it isn’t a very modern view but it is, unfortunately, reality.

Maiden2021 · 24/07/2023 10:06

*iro not 'bro'

Maiden2021 · 24/07/2023 10:06

PeskyRooks · 24/07/2023 09:54

Interesting that the person who absolutely didn't want a male babysitter in this scenario was the DH also a man.

So all this MN are man haters seems irrelevant.

Thank you for highlighting this point too bro her DH- very very relevant. Men have the measures of other men than women would ever have.

My brother was so strict with the care his two daughters got, unlike his son. Swimming pool, proper supervision etc etc . I even thought it was a bit excessive at times, but I respected his views. So I knew I wouldn't make them travel to me to a foreign holiday with other adult kids without an adult accompanying them. It opened my eyes.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 10:03

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:53

Also
There are stories of women sexually abusing others. Of female teachers sleeping with male pupils (these usually have a lot of comments like "Good on ya lad" below).

But equally males being assaulted, sexually or physically, by women are still a long way off being believed in the same way women are when they report abuse. So you wouldn't hear as much. Because the men are either too embarrassed and ashamed to report it (because how could they let a weak and feeble woman assault them) or they weren't believed (you probably wanted her. Who wouldn't? Look at her)

I'd rather we acknowledged that we can all harm and hurt each other and work towards anyone who harms or assaults another being punished than get so caught up in the narrative of men are evil that we allow women to get away with the same crimes....

Male victims of assault are still more likely to have been assaulted by men. I wouldn't hire a male babysitter to look after sons either.

Catusrusty · 24/07/2023 09:59

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:41

But the male provider is more likely to harm that child than a female provider.

Exactly.

He might be personally lovely and completely professional, or he might be a paedophile who has worked his way into a role that gives him access to children. It certainly wouldn't be the first time.

Hiring a man puts your child at more risk.

I would personally do anything to lower risk to my child, because I love my child more than anything and frankly fuck the woke people that think I should blindly put my faith in a man to be kind. But OP you're a cool progressive mum and you think putting your kids at a higher risk is worth it. You do you.

Or you've written a goady post to make mum's who weigh the risks of childcare options out to be sexists.

@EdwardianTable you could not be more right. There's always someone who comes along, totally ignoring the statistics around sexual violence to tell us all that women are bad and a threat too so don't be so nasty to all the men. They totally ignore the power dynamic between men and women. Honestly it's so disingenuous and predictably boring, and let's face it, it won't give 99 per cent of women pause for thought because they know exactly where danger lies and it isn't in being sexually assaulted by other women. It's like the ridiculous male stripper thread all over again.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:56

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:48

Actually I mentioned it to make the point the women can sexually assault other women and that is relevant.

But women are far less likely to sexually assault than men are.

In answer to your other point about causing other types of harm, well I have never and would never hire babysitters online and this is a reason why. If I had to do it, I'd choose a woman but I don't. I can't make my children's world entirely risk-free. I do have to let them go on playdates and be looked after by people I trust but can never fully know and that's part of life. We can't eliminate every possibility of harm. But we can reduce it as best we can while balancing the need for a normal life. Not hiring male babysitters is one way in which I choose to reduce the risk; I do accept that risk of harm still exists and always will.

PeskyRooks · 24/07/2023 09:54

Interesting that the person who absolutely didn't want a male babysitter in this scenario was the DH also a man.

So all this MN are man haters seems irrelevant.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:53

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:48

Actually I mentioned it to make the point the women can sexually assault other women and that is relevant.

Also
There are stories of women sexually abusing others. Of female teachers sleeping with male pupils (these usually have a lot of comments like "Good on ya lad" below).

But equally males being assaulted, sexually or physically, by women are still a long way off being believed in the same way women are when they report abuse. So you wouldn't hear as much. Because the men are either too embarrassed and ashamed to report it (because how could they let a weak and feeble woman assault them) or they weren't believed (you probably wanted her. Who wouldn't? Look at her)

I'd rather we acknowledged that we can all harm and hurt each other and work towards anyone who harms or assaults another being punished than get so caught up in the narrative of men are evil that we allow women to get away with the same crimes....

NotBotheredAnymore · 24/07/2023 09:52

millymollymoomoo · 24/07/2023 07:54

It’s not some random man off the internet ! He’s a professional qualified person! Pretty outrageous the level of sexism
sbd discrimination

tjete Are not enough men in the childcare / nursery/primary school settings and this attitude is why! My daughters best nursery worker and school teacher were both male and were brilliant

It’s not some random man off the internet !

Time you found a dictionary.
Random - an unknown, unspecified, or odd person.
Unknown or unexpected.
Something that’s random is lacking in order, plan, or purpose. It happens totally by chance.

Having a male carer in a public setting is not the same as one in a private home, away from other people. But you know that.

StephanieSuperpowers · 24/07/2023 09:51

I wouldn't offer my children up to experiment with the notion that men are being unfairly stereotyped as far more likely to commit sex crimes. I'd recommend that you listen to your husband and do the same.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:49

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:41

But the male provider is more likely to harm that child than a female provider.

Depends how you mean harm

Women are more likely to kill children, even ones that aren't their own. Plenty of stories of nurses harming babies in their care...

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/07/2023 09:48

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:39

There is always someone on these threads who will say they've only ever experienced sexual harassment from women. As though the women reading will be convinced that all the harassment from men they and their friend have experienced from men on a spectrum from catcalling to unwanted touching, sexual aggression, coercion and abuse isn't the reality for girls from primary age upwards. As though we'll dismiss the fact that every week we see in the news women being raped, abducted and killed by men and we don't see it the other way around. As though by acknowledging this reality, we are saying that women are perfect and never offend. As though by acknowledging this reality we are saying we hate men. It's pretty transparent.

Actually I mentioned it to make the point the women can sexually assault other women and that is relevant.

EdwardianTable · 24/07/2023 09:42

I would happily have a woman repair my boiler @DonnaBanana . It's not the same thing at all!

Swipe left for the next trending thread