I couldn’t get ds2 down to sleep I the early evening when he was born despite never having had any problems with ds1. Got very frustrating as it meant that either I was incredibly late to get ds1 bathed and into bed or dh needed to do it - and meant that it pushed supper much too late for dh and me.
in the end I thought sod this and didn’t put ds2 down to sleep at 6-7pm when ds1 went to bed, but let him sit up in ds1’s high chair - which was a comfy one that you adjust to lay back if he fell asleep (which occasionally happened during the day). Whilst I don’t ever remember him falling asleep in it in an evening, ds was happy to sit there quite quietly just being awake and watching/listening to dh and myself - we didn’t give him much to do or watch - we had our stuff on the tv if there was stuff we wanted to watch (back in the day when you had to watch tv or miss your favourite programmes!), there were a couple of little fiddle toys that he had if he wanted, but he was usually just happy to be awake and with us.
meant dh and I had our evening together, to catch up on the day, chat, watch tv etc etc and then when it was time (11ish)for bed I’d take ds2 up with me and give him a feed - buafter which he would fall asleep easily and I could go to sleep at a reasonable time…
worked so much better for us - not sure I could have coped if I’d had to spend hours trying and failing to put ds2 down in the early evening - lots of people were horrified but it worked for us and ds2 was happy and thrived. I couldn’t have done it with ds1 - he needed his sleep but his brother was completely different so we went with what worked for him.
I think this carried on until he was about 5-6, when he decided himself that he was tired and wanted to go to bed at the same time ds1 went to sleep rather than when we did! (I had always changed him ready for bed when he ds1 went to bed, to get that bit of the bedtime ritual in. He was also bf and would wake up several times a night to feed- don’t think he reliably slept through the night until he was at least 5 and would still occasionally wake up for no apparent reason. We did migrate from milk to water once bf stopped (ant 3) and he would drink at that as needed if/when he woke up.
probably worth mentioning as some others have also observed with their dc who were similar - ds2 is now mid teens, ridiculously bright, has dyslexia and dyspraxia and sleeps better than ds1! He still takes a bottle of water up to bed with him!’