Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that pregnancy care SHOULD be focused on helping women to have healthy babies?

110 replies

CatusFlatus · 23/07/2023 14:48

This article in a medical journal advocates the taking of testosterone by trans-identified females during pregnancy, despite the proven and potential risks to the unborn child.

The claim that ‘gendered’ pregnancy care is too focused on helping women to have healthy babies and that it is acceptable for transmen to continue taking testosterone during pregnancy, despite the proven and potential risks to the foetus because of, for example, concerns the transman has about being mis-gendered or their desire to be regarded as a pregnant man.

They claim that the desire for ‘normal foetal outcomes’ is problematic because it is born of a wish to protect babies “From becoming anything other than ‘normal’” and reflects the “Historical and ongoing social practices for creating ‘ideal’ and normative bodies.”

This is insane.

OP posts:
ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 17:27

WomenShouldStillWinWomensSports · 24/07/2023 17:19

The study you quoted literally says testosterone is associated with fetal growth restriction and that, while you are correct it's not crossing the placenta, it is instead affecting the function of the placenta (which the baby is dependent on for continued survival until birth).

Fetal growth restriction is a serious threat to fetal survival, as is placental failure. Low birth weight is associated with all sorts of poor neonatal outcomes.

The paper was just looking at the mechanism of action.

Also, not one baby rat pup was lost due to IUGR. So in the end, it wasn’t a threat to their survival.

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 17:23

WomenShouldStillWinWomensSports · 24/07/2023 17:19

The study you quoted literally says testosterone is associated with fetal growth restriction and that, while you are correct it's not crossing the placenta, it is instead affecting the function of the placenta (which the baby is dependent on for continued survival until birth).

Fetal growth restriction is a serious threat to fetal survival, as is placental failure. Low birth weight is associated with all sorts of poor neonatal outcomes.

The paper was just looking at the mechanism of action.

Again, associated which isn’t a causal link and also only in RATS who don’t have one foetus but five or six.

WomenShouldStillWinWomensSports · 24/07/2023 17:19

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 17:09

That’s a fair point, and I’m no expert but I do know that maternal testosterone levels in the blood to not transfer directly to the foetus. The aromatase enzyme in the placenta, converts androgens including testosterone into estrogens, which is adjusted accordingly so that a male fetus gets more testosterone and the female fetus is protected from direct transfer of maternal testosterone

A study was done on rats where they doubled the amount of testosterone in the maternal blood (testosterone already goes up by 70% in females when pregnant, so this was double the higher pregnancy level) and it had no impact on the level of testosterone in the foetus. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3162507/

The study you quoted literally says testosterone is associated with fetal growth restriction and that, while you are correct it's not crossing the placenta, it is instead affecting the function of the placenta (which the baby is dependent on for continued survival until birth).

Fetal growth restriction is a serious threat to fetal survival, as is placental failure. Low birth weight is associated with all sorts of poor neonatal outcomes.

The paper was just looking at the mechanism of action.

WomenShouldStillWinWomensSports · 24/07/2023 17:15

They need to sort out their double standards and put babies and women first in all of this shitshow. They wouldn't even let me take my life-saving mental health medication during pregnancy/breastfeeding and I almost died 7 times (and the baby almost died with me). That medication has a good safety profile and is recommended to continue it during pregnancy/BF but they "didn't want to take the risk" and fuck my baby's (and my) actual survival.

But idiots who need to feel all manly can put babies at risk with untested cytotoxic drugs (and all hormones are classed as cytotoxic pharmaceutically speaking). And instead of saying anything they've decided the benefit (to the transperson's feelz) outweighs the risk (to the baby).

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 17:09

stealtheatingtunnocks · 24/07/2023 16:53

The paper is written by sociologists with a gender bias.

it would be interesting to see what an endocrinologist or obstetrician had to say about their findings. In fact, you know those “reaction videos? Can we get that? Live reaction to this fresh hell?

That’s a fair point, and I’m no expert but I do know that maternal testosterone levels in the blood to not transfer directly to the foetus. The aromatase enzyme in the placenta, converts androgens including testosterone into estrogens, which is adjusted accordingly so that a male fetus gets more testosterone and the female fetus is protected from direct transfer of maternal testosterone

A study was done on rats where they doubled the amount of testosterone in the maternal blood (testosterone already goes up by 70% in females when pregnant, so this was double the higher pregnancy level) and it had no impact on the level of testosterone in the foetus. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3162507/

Prenatal testosterone-induced fetal growth restriction is associated with down-regulation of rat placental amino acid transport

Exposure of pregnant mothers to elevated concentrations of circulating testosterone levels is associated with fetal growth restriction and delivery of small-for-gestational-age babies. We examined whether maternal testosterone crosses the placenta to ....

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3162507/

stealtheatingtunnocks · 24/07/2023 16:53

The paper is written by sociologists with a gender bias.

it would be interesting to see what an endocrinologist or obstetrician had to say about their findings. In fact, you know those “reaction videos? Can we get that? Live reaction to this fresh hell?

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 16:49

midgetastic · 24/07/2023 16:26

Well the nhs for starters

All the NHS says is
“Testosterone and pregnancyTaking testosterone in pregnancy is not recommended.
Do not stop taking testosterone before talking with the doctor who is prescribing it for you.
If you stop taking testosterone you’ll probably start to have periods. You may also notice changes in your body shape around your hips, chest and thighs.”
https://www.nhs.uk/pregnancy/having-a-baby-if-you-are-lgbt-plus/testosterone-and-pregnancy/

Nothing about “causing a range of birth defects” or that “you should stop it immediately you become pregnant” as you have stated.

In fact it says “do not stop taking testosterone” until you’ve talked to the doctor and then says ‘if you stop’ implying that not everyone will need to stop…

nhs.uk

Testosterone and pregnancy

Read more about how testosterone therapy can affect your fertility and why it is not recommended to take testosterone if you’re pregnant.

https://www.nhs.uk/pregnancy/having-a-baby-if-you-are-lgbt-plus/testosterone-and-pregnancy/

MotherOfCatBoy · 24/07/2023 16:45

Ffs. I really think pregnancy, after an initial period, is all in. That is, there should be everywhere a right to termination, no questions asked, for a certain time limit - that’s a whole other debate but let’s just accept that for the sake of argument - and after that if you’ve decided to go ahead with the pregnancy, it’s all in, with the foetus fully protected (barring conditions which are life threatening for the mother within the term of the pregnancy and immediately post partum). How can you be a parent if you don’t put the baby first? Have these people no idea what is entailed once it’s born? Your life is not your own, and that’s just the way it is for a while. Babies need nurturing.

Nanaof1 · 24/07/2023 16:33

TheNameIsDickDarlington · 23/07/2023 18:41

If someone wants to "live as a man" for their mental health then surely they wouldn't want to go through pregnancy at all just like a "biological male" couldn't.

That's a good thought. And, if a transman has a baby that ends up with disabilities due to hormone treatment, the baby and the citizens get to pay for that choice. Of course, it's the same if a woman takes illegal drugs or drinks too. The innocent pay the price.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/07/2023 16:29

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 16:13

No. It’s like many things in category B.
“Animal reproduction studies have failed to demonstrate a risk to the fetus and there are no adequate and well-controlled studies in pregnant women.”

Which why pretending to be kind to transmen who are pregnant would be an absolute goldmine for companies, as it would hoy the Ethics of carrying out such experiments on foetuses straight out of the nearest window. 'Oh, but we're monitoring outcomes meticulously'. Well, you wouldn't, wouldn't you - you don't know when you'll be able to carry out human experimentation again, do you?

midgetastic · 24/07/2023 16:26

Well the nhs for starters

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 16:17

midgetastic · 24/07/2023 08:29

Other sources suggest it causes a range of birth defects and you shouj stop it immediately you become pregnant

Such as? I did a quick search and found only hypothesised associations.

nothingcomestonothing · 24/07/2023 16:16

Rainbowshit · 24/07/2023 00:17

Is there no end to the selfishness and narcissism of the trans movement. 🤬🤬

Current evidence suggests that no, there is not Angry

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 16:13

maddening · 24/07/2023 08:19

So are you under the impression that there have been sufficient cases for long term testing, trials and investigation for anyone to say this and true level of conviction what any long term harms are?

No. It’s like many things in category B.
“Animal reproduction studies have failed to demonstrate a risk to the fetus and there are no adequate and well-controlled studies in pregnant women.”

Intothewoodswithallthegoods · 24/07/2023 15:42

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 07:14

I have ASD & ADHD & am not straight but think it’s society and it’s stupid, baffling rules plus NT/straight people bullying me that have made my life miserable. I wouldn’t want to change me though.

Oh I hear you. People talk about those with autism being rigid, intolerant, lacking empathy. I’ve been on the receiving end of all of these from supposedly NT people, while we’re expected to be understanding of society’s rules and get no understanding in return.

If there was a pill I could take, I really don’t think I would. I’d love to have been born NT though, or at least ND in a way that was much more obvious. My life has been wasted on social anxiety, depression, being told I’m rude, lazy, unlikeable, grumpy, too sensitive, too emotional, etc etc etc ad nauseam. “Mild” AuADHD is absolutely no joke.

Wetandhorrible · 24/07/2023 08:37

I am disabled (not from birth,for full disclosure) but it impacts my life significantly, and life would be easier and essentially better if I wasn't. Anyone saying otherwise either has never come across disability/chronic I'll health, or hasn't got the emotional honest of saying "I appreciate my life and it is good, but would be better without illness or disability".

midgetastic · 24/07/2023 08:29

Other sources suggest it causes a range of birth defects and you shouj stop it immediately you become pregnant

VestaTilley · 24/07/2023 08:26

YANBU. Taking testosterone in pregnancy should be illegal.

maddening · 24/07/2023 08:21

And the levels of testosterone in pcos women is nowhere near those taken by transmen

maddening · 24/07/2023 08:19

ChopperC110P · 23/07/2023 18:49

The paper says that the risk to a foetus’/baby is that they may have higher chance of being LGB or have ASD. I don’t think that any of that means a baby is unhealthy.

So are you under the impression that there have been sufficient cases for long term testing, trials and investigation for anyone to say this and true level of conviction what any long term harms are?

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 08:09

@GreyDuck
Yes I agree it is an interesting debate. However please note that the scientific literature on female babies born to women with PCOS later developing PCOS themselves hasn’t identified a cause other than genetic factors. There is hypothetical speculation that the excess testosterone might possibly also be a factor but nothing has been shown positively linking excess testosterone in th womb as a cause of PCOS.

GreyDuck · 24/07/2023 08:04

I think the ethical/philosophical questions it raises are interesting, and very much in need of debate. (How far should we go to promote societal norms?)
But I find the scientific/medical aspects of the article very weak. PCOS doesn't just cause women to appear unnaceptable to society (not my opinion-paraphased from article), it's linked with infertility, diabetes, increased risk of blood clots.
The autism /ADHD debate doesn't surprise me. I've seen similar kickback against other medications known to cause these conditions.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 24/07/2023 07:53

It’s all virtue signalling bollocks. It won’t happen

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 07:42

Wowokthanks · 24/07/2023 07:27

I'm sorry, but I know women who give up coffee, certain foods- ie cheeses, alcohol, and change their medication for their MH (last pregnancy I came off of my antidepressants and chose to be monitored by health professionals for my OCD and Depression)
Instead of allowing any risk to my inborn child.

I do not agree with taming testosterone that has not been absolutely ruled out to be OK during pregnancy.

I know in theory it's very easy to make these judgements on people when we aren't in their exact situation, but if you choose to have a baby, some of the sacrifices come during pregnancy for the wellbeing of your children.

The difference is that those foods/chemicals have proven risks to the unborn child that have been exhaustively studied with causal links, amount of exposure determined and so on.

That isn’t the case for excess testosterone and looking at studies of PCOS women who naturally have excess testosterone there haven’t been any health risks per se linked to testosterone as opposed to say genetic or other environmental factors for a slightly higher association of their children being later diagnosed with PCOS, ASD or ADHD or having a non straight sexuality.

Wowokthanks · 24/07/2023 07:27

I'm sorry, but I know women who give up coffee, certain foods- ie cheeses, alcohol, and change their medication for their MH (last pregnancy I came off of my antidepressants and chose to be monitored by health professionals for my OCD and Depression)
Instead of allowing any risk to my inborn child.

I do not agree with taming testosterone that has not been absolutely ruled out to be OK during pregnancy.

I know in theory it's very easy to make these judgements on people when we aren't in their exact situation, but if you choose to have a baby, some of the sacrifices come during pregnancy for the wellbeing of your children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread