Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that pregnancy care SHOULD be focused on helping women to have healthy babies?

110 replies

CatusFlatus · 23/07/2023 14:48

This article in a medical journal advocates the taking of testosterone by trans-identified females during pregnancy, despite the proven and potential risks to the unborn child.

The claim that ‘gendered’ pregnancy care is too focused on helping women to have healthy babies and that it is acceptable for transmen to continue taking testosterone during pregnancy, despite the proven and potential risks to the foetus because of, for example, concerns the transman has about being mis-gendered or their desire to be regarded as a pregnant man.

They claim that the desire for ‘normal foetal outcomes’ is problematic because it is born of a wish to protect babies “From becoming anything other than ‘normal’” and reflects the “Historical and ongoing social practices for creating ‘ideal’ and normative bodies.”

This is insane.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 24/07/2023 21:39

When and why did people become ok with medical experiments in an unborn fetus? Are they trying to change the law to make that legal?

Brk · 24/07/2023 21:37

Right, who’s going to tell the transmen that when they’re pregnant they look female, whether or not they have facial hair?

maddening · 24/07/2023 21:29

Teder · 24/07/2023 21:17

I think I’m explaining this badly. I am not saying it is prescribed. I am saying if a pregnant woman with cancer required it, there are options e.g. alternative medication. There aren’t really any options with testosterone (if a trans person did take it pre pregnancy) - it’s either yes or no, there’s no alternative. So, in a nutshell, thalidomide and testosterone are not as comparable.

They have the choice not to get pregnant if they know they have to stop taking testosterone which they take as they choose to present as a trans man.

maddening · 24/07/2023 21:27

ChopperC110P · 23/07/2023 19:28

Crickets 🦗?

So, in light of the fact there are causal links or proven risks to the physical health of a foetus from excess testosterone, does anyone else think that the outrage is a bit overblown?

When we start defining ‘healthy’ as potentially more likely to be straight and NT….that’s eugenics territory imho.

Taking drugs known to cause a defect is more like eugenics than not taking the drugs. This isn't trying to prevent ND births- it is actively causing them.

TheKeatingFive · 24/07/2023 21:24

So, in a nutshell, thalidomide and testosterone are not as comparable.

Well no, but because Testosterone is not being used to treat illness. It can be stopped without any risks to the mother. So it's entirely about privileging the mother's feelings about themselves over the baby's health.

Teder · 24/07/2023 21:17

TheKeatingFive · 24/07/2023 18:44

I have heard nothing to suggest that Thalidomide is being prescribed to pregnant women suffering from cancer these days.

Can anyone confirm that it is?

I think I’m explaining this badly. I am not saying it is prescribed. I am saying if a pregnant woman with cancer required it, there are options e.g. alternative medication. There aren’t really any options with testosterone (if a trans person did take it pre pregnancy) - it’s either yes or no, there’s no alternative. So, in a nutshell, thalidomide and testosterone are not as comparable.

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 21:08

ladyvimes · 24/07/2023 19:07

Surely no one hopes for a neuro divergent child?!

I honestly did not care if my DC were NT or ND. I don’t think being ND makes me a freak or unhealthy,

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 21:06

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 18:06

Are you seriously conflating a persons ability to purchase alcohol and cigarettes to prescribed and controlled medication.

You are deluded if you think that any of this is fair or equitable or the rights of an unborn child are not considered in medical ethics.

The same arguments about the rights of the foetus can be used for any controlled medication, but they aren't because women who identify as trans are being treated more favourably than other women, some of these women are seriously ill.

It’s not more favourably because again, testosterone is currently a category B medication.

It’s not like thalidomide which is category X.

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 21:04

stealtheatingtunnocks · 24/07/2023 18:17

Those rat pups will have been born with genital deformities. Genital abnormalities in rats exposed to pre natal testosterone

being bathed in abnormal levels of testosterone during development is going to cause problems for that person, we don’t know which ones.

very few mothers to be would knowingly take substances which will harm their unborn child. taking testosterone while building a body that belongs to someone else is so selfish that I think it means you are unfit to parent. It shows an inability to put the needs of the baby before your own wants.

you are not going to be the person who pays the price for taking a known teratogen.

it is morally corrupt

Depends on the dosage. The study you posted didn’t have genital deformities until the highest doses. We have no idea how that rat dose translates to a human dose.

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 19:14

ThreeB · 24/07/2023 19:07

Thalidomide isn't prescribed to pregnant women and there are stringent safeguards (including pregnancy tests every 4 weeks) during treatment to ensure safety. Men also have to use safeguarding measures if their partner is able to get pregnant. Pregnant women are not even able to touch thalidomide due to the risks

exactly - when we have had thalidomide in the house, we had to confirm that there were no fertile women living there, and my sister, who was fertile, was advised not to stay - I was ok because I had had a hysterectomy

ThreeB · 24/07/2023 19:07

Thalidomide isn't prescribed to pregnant women and there are stringent safeguards (including pregnancy tests every 4 weeks) during treatment to ensure safety. Men also have to use safeguarding measures if their partner is able to get pregnant. Pregnant women are not even able to touch thalidomide due to the risks

ladyvimes · 24/07/2023 19:07

ChopperC110P · 23/07/2023 19:28

Crickets 🦗?

So, in light of the fact there are causal links or proven risks to the physical health of a foetus from excess testosterone, does anyone else think that the outrage is a bit overblown?

When we start defining ‘healthy’ as potentially more likely to be straight and NT….that’s eugenics territory imho.

Surely no one hopes for a neuro divergent child?!

TheKeatingFive · 24/07/2023 18:44

I have heard nothing to suggest that Thalidomide is being prescribed to pregnant women suffering from cancer these days.

Can anyone confirm that it is?

Teder · 24/07/2023 18:41

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 18:11

under no circumstances does any doctor ever prescribe thalidomide to a pregnant woman

So then the patient - with their doctor - weighs up the risk of not treating their cancer (or other illness) with Thalidomide or is offered an alternative or may have a medical termination. I guess a trans person has to consider their options too.

stealtheatingtunnocks · 24/07/2023 18:23

it is not ok to do this on purpose. Trans men who fall pregnant must stop taking cross sex hormones. They must not say they have stopped and buy it on the black market instead.

Women are advised fo make lifestyle changes in pregnancy. Gender doesn’t change that.

Testosterone is a teratogen

Pregnancy in transgender men

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8412429/

stealtheatingtunnocks · 24/07/2023 18:17

Those rat pups will have been born with genital deformities. Genital abnormalities in rats exposed to pre natal testosterone

being bathed in abnormal levels of testosterone during development is going to cause problems for that person, we don’t know which ones.

very few mothers to be would knowingly take substances which will harm their unborn child. taking testosterone while building a body that belongs to someone else is so selfish that I think it means you are unfit to parent. It shows an inability to put the needs of the baby before your own wants.

you are not going to be the person who pays the price for taking a known teratogen.

it is morally corrupt

Effects of prenatal testosterone propionate on the sexual development of male and female rats: a dose-response study - PubMed

Testosterone plays a major role in male sexual development. Exposure of females to testosterone in utero can induce masculine characteristics such as anovulation, increased anogenital distance (AGD), absence of nipples, retention of male-like tissues,...

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11752687/

orangeleavesinautumn · 24/07/2023 18:11

Teder · 23/07/2023 18:28

I believe thalidomide is used for some cancers (amongst other illnesses), I suppose doctors weigh up the risks and benefits to both parent and child.

under no circumstances does any doctor ever prescribe thalidomide to a pregnant woman

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 18:06

Are you seriously conflating a persons ability to purchase alcohol and cigarettes to prescribed and controlled medication.

You are deluded if you think that any of this is fair or equitable or the rights of an unborn child are not considered in medical ethics.

The same arguments about the rights of the foetus can be used for any controlled medication, but they aren't because women who identify as trans are being treated more favourably than other women, some of these women are seriously ill.

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 18:01

The baby can't consent.
Consent is not required from an unborn foetus nor are they capable of consent for anything from the mother burping to the mother terminating the life of the foetus. So let’s not pretend that consent of a foetus is of any consideration at all.

There isn't any proof about lots of things that are prohibited in pregnancy either This is not true. There is scientific proof behind everything prohibited.

this is a category of women getting special treatment in pregnancy because they identify as trans. No, it’s not at all. You were pregnant, could you go out and buy alcohol and cigarettes? Why yes you could, and you could smoke like a chimney and drink like a fish and those are known and proven to be extremely harmful to a foetus. I do not think that a transman taking testosterone which is not proven to be harmful at all and even animal studies do not show any long term risks is “special treatment”. If anything, it’s you holding them to a different standard by thinking it should be banned.

babayhaga · 24/07/2023 17:56

TheNameIsDickDarlington · 23/07/2023 18:41

If someone wants to "live as a man" for their mental health then surely they wouldn't want to go through pregnancy at all just like a "biological male" couldn't.

They love the attention though.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 17:55

Consent. Every transman is consenting. And precedent as we are all live experiments for tons of things…I mean look at history. Leaded petrol, lead paint, asbestos, various vaccines, GMO foods, etc

The baby can't consent.

There isn't any proof about lots of things that are prohibited in pregnancy either, this is a category of women getting special treatment in pregnancy because they identify as trans.

You say yourself that there isn't any proof (yet) that testosterone is harmful, but who cares about the baby eh, so long as the trans persons gender feelings are taken cared of?

Most vulnerable and discriminated against they are NOT.

babayhaga · 24/07/2023 17:55

Gerrataere · 23/07/2023 18:22

I believe a woman’s body is her own right to do with when pregnant, but much like smoking warnings on cigarette packets the information for all women of all risks of what is put in their system should be made. If a woman decides that taking testosterone and living as a trans man is for their ultimate welfare then so be it, but it should always be clear that taking medication could affect the typical development of a foetus. There’s no point in ‘be kind’ if you’re being sued to hell by a patient who’s child has disabilities that could have been avoided if given the right medical information.

And I think doctors have the right to say no. Their training, their brains and their licence.

Doctors, say no to these women who want to take male hormones for their mental helath illness whereby they can't accept they are females.

It's not their bodies they are affecting, it's the unborn child.

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 17:53

Sorry meant to clear the quote before posting

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 17:50

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 17:31

Why do you think it is OK ChopperC110P to carry out what is essentially live experimentation in this manner when we don't know the outcomes for the babies?

Why do you think it is OK when mothers with health issues are told that they must stop their medication even if stopping their medication harms them?

Why do you think that a person's identity outweighs potential unknown risks to babies?

I just don't follow the logic at all. If a transman is giving birth they are not living as a man when doing a thing that only females can do, so I just don't get it. I personally think it is selfish and defies all logic. It is another example of how trans identifying people have special rules which doesn't at all sit with this notion of them being the most discriminated against / vulnerable proportion of society.

Why do you think it is OK ChopperC110P to carry out what is essentially live experimentation in this manner when we don't know the outcomes for the babies?
Consent. Every transman is consenting. And precedent as we are all live experiments for tons of things…I mean look at history. Leaded petrol, lead paint, asbestos, various vaccines, GMO foods, etc

Why do you think it is OK when mothers with health issues are told that they must stop their medication even if stopping their medication harms them?
Because presumably a doctor is telling them and the medication is actually proven to be harmful to the foetus in controlled studies with human females and not an unknown potential. History hasn’t been kind to us with unknown potential risks—- it was once thought that going over 20mph in a car could potentially cause our uteruses to fall out of our bodies and cause a miscarriage so pregnant women were not recommended to ride in or drive cars.

Why do you think that a person's identity outweighs potential unknown risks to babies?
I think most needs outweigh ‘potential unknown risks’….your desire to go on holiday outweighs the ‘potential unknown risks’ of going to a foreign country does it not? And even the known risks too! And besides, other animal studies have shown a net benefit to elevated maternal testosterone levels to offspring…it’s a big unknown and we don’t ban things for potential unknowns. We don’t even ban alcohol in pregnancy and that is beyond proven to be very risky to the foetus.

I just don't follow the logic at all. If a transman is giving birth they are not living as a man when doing a thing that only females can do, so I just don't get it. I personally think it is selfish and defies all logic. It is another example of how trans identifying people have special rules which doesn't at all sit with this notion of them being the most discriminated against / vulnerable proportion of society.

You aren’t following the logic because that is not the logic being used. You are thinking of this as a question of living as a man or woman, when it should he approached the same way we approach any substance in pregnancy.

The logic being is there any proof that elevated testosterone levels are harmful to a foetus? There isn’t any (yet) there are only associations and some animal studies that show short term growth reduction but post natal catch up and long term gain.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 17:31

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 17:23

Again, associated which isn’t a causal link and also only in RATS who don’t have one foetus but five or six.

Why do you think it is OK ChopperC110P to carry out what is essentially live experimentation in this manner when we don't know the outcomes for the babies?

Why do you think it is OK when mothers with health issues are told that they must stop their medication even if stopping their medication harms them?

Why do you think that a person's identity outweighs potential unknown risks to babies?

I just don't follow the logic at all. If a transman is giving birth they are not living as a man when doing a thing that only females can do, so I just don't get it. I personally think it is selfish and defies all logic. It is another example of how trans identifying people have special rules which doesn't at all sit with this notion of them being the most discriminated against / vulnerable proportion of society.

Swipe left for the next trending thread