Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that pregnancy care SHOULD be focused on helping women to have healthy babies?

110 replies

CatusFlatus · 23/07/2023 14:48

This article in a medical journal advocates the taking of testosterone by trans-identified females during pregnancy, despite the proven and potential risks to the unborn child.

The claim that ‘gendered’ pregnancy care is too focused on helping women to have healthy babies and that it is acceptable for transmen to continue taking testosterone during pregnancy, despite the proven and potential risks to the foetus because of, for example, concerns the transman has about being mis-gendered or their desire to be regarded as a pregnant man.

They claim that the desire for ‘normal foetal outcomes’ is problematic because it is born of a wish to protect babies “From becoming anything other than ‘normal’” and reflects the “Historical and ongoing social practices for creating ‘ideal’ and normative bodies.”

This is insane.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Weefreetiffany · 25/07/2023 19:56

@ChopperC110P If testosterone was supposed to be in the body in the constant, unvarying high amounts required for trans medical use then that would be the usual state of things in pregnancy.

But it’s not like that, so why would you force it and assume it’s fine because you can’t prove the absence of harm? That’s not how this works. We minimise risk in pregnancy. We can’t eliminate risk but we try not to add anything that disrupts what’s needed for healthy gestation. You don’t want to hear it, but it’s obvious to anyone without an agenda that this includes not adding huge amounts of medical testosterone to a pregnancy.

stealtheatingtunnocks · 25/07/2023 18:46

@ChopperC110P you have got to be trying to wind us up.

you are either deluded because you have a gender issue and have/want a baby and want to ignore the current NHS advice and common sense, or you are just here to try and get the vipers wound up.

either way, I’m done with chatting to you because you are tedious.

lifeturnsonadime · 25/07/2023 18:27

Why not pick on females who eat spicy foods, or get their hair dyed, or eat a vegan diet? These have no evidence of harm too…

Since when were those licensed and prescribed drugs?

ChopperC110P · 25/07/2023 17:39

stealtheatingtunnocks · 25/07/2023 17:31

There’s no evidence because it would be unethical to do the studies. Your bias is showing.

Quite the contrary, your bias towards illogical extremes is showing.

It is impossible for a pregnant female to avoid everything that has evidence of harm plus everything that has no evidence of harm to a foetus. You’d have to live on air, literally.

Which begs the question, of all the things where there is no evidence of harm, why the outrage over testosterone? Why pick on transmen?

Why not pick on females who eat spicy foods, or get their hair dyed, or eat a vegan diet? These have no evidence of harm too…

stealtheatingtunnocks · 25/07/2023 17:31

There’s no evidence because it would be unethical to do the studies. Your bias is showing.

ChopperC110P · 25/07/2023 17:22

Oysterbabe · 25/07/2023 08:50

According to half the people on here a pregnant woman should be able to do whatever she wants with her body, including killing the baby the day before it's born. I don't know how they can also object if the mother wants to take testosterone.

Yes, the hypocrisy is not lost on me.

Its holding trans females to a higher standard than other females, because they are trans. There is no scientific proof that testosterone harms a human baby, it’s a category B substance and doctors have the discretion to recommend a transman stop or keep taking testosterone.

Theres no evidence to suggest a full ban on testosterone in pregnancy. And to say there should be one is an illogical departure from how medical guidelines are done.

Weefreetiffany · 25/07/2023 12:10

nothingcomestonothing · 25/07/2023 08:00

You can tie yourself in knots to justify this but it is immoral and wrong.
Well that’s a matter of opinion. I logically choose not to accept a risk as existing until it has been proven to exist. You emotionally choose to see risk even when it’s not been proven to exist.

That's the TRA argument about everything though, isn't it? Do it until you can show it's dangerous, rather than don't do it until you can show it's safe. Like males in women's rugby, or women's changing rooms - 'let us do what we want until you can prove it's dangerous'. Then when women are harmed, it's 'well that's a one off/not very many harms/harm to people I don't care about, so it's still okay'. Followed by 'well it's still what I want so ignore the harms to people who aren't me'.

'I'm okay with risking the wellbeing of my child to have something I wish for' isn't generally seen as a sign of great parenting.

Exactly this.

lifeturnsonadime · 25/07/2023 11:31

TheKeatingFive · 25/07/2023 11:00

According to half the people on here a pregnant woman should be able to do whatever she wants with her body, including killing the baby the day before it's born. I don't know how they can also object if the mother wants to take testosterone.

It's not even remotely accurate to suggest that 'half the people on here' agree with killing a baby the day before it's born.

I agree and isn't it somewhat contradictory for people who are seemingly concerned that this could happen, from the point of view of the rights of the child, are unconcerned that unborn children are being used like lab rats to experiment on whether this is safe?

The child's safety is therefore seen as less important than the cosmetic wishes of the mother.

That's unethical, and highly selfish.

Madamfrog · 25/07/2023 11:29

If a woman is identifying as a man why is she having a baby at all? Men can't have babies.

TheKeatingFive · 25/07/2023 11:00

According to half the people on here a pregnant woman should be able to do whatever she wants with her body, including killing the baby the day before it's born. I don't know how they can also object if the mother wants to take testosterone.

It's not even remotely accurate to suggest that 'half the people on here' agree with killing a baby the day before it's born.

stealtheatingtunnocks · 25/07/2023 10:19

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 21:04

Depends on the dosage. The study you posted didn’t have genital deformities until the highest doses. We have no idea how that rat dose translates to a human dose.

Then we agree. We don’t know what is safe.

you think that means “fuck around and find out” and I think it means “absolute ban”

you are warbling on about semantics, this isn’t a high school debate, this is the next generation and your argument is focussed on the wants of the mother (appropriate use of legally accurate term, see the McConnell judgement) and not on risks to the baby.

are you a female person with a gender difference who has been/is/wants to be pregnant?

lifeturnsonadime · 25/07/2023 09:13

Calling the unborn a child a foetus to justify this is vile.
It is a foetus. It’s not a child. I take it you are pro-life too with your views.

I am pro - choice any time for any reason. But this is very different as you well known. This child is intended to be born. And in this instance the mother is being selfish by taking a risk on her child's health for her own gender feelings.

That's selfish.

DameKatyDenisesClagnuts · 25/07/2023 09:09

TheKeatingFive · 23/07/2023 18:38

I believe thalidomide is used for some cancers (amongst other illnesses), I suppose doctors weigh up the risks and benefits to both parent and child.

Do we have any evidence that doctors are still prescribing thalidomide to pregnant women? In any circs?

They absolutely are not, it is totally contraindicated in pregnancy and in the very rare cases where a woman who could become pregnant has to take it (pretty much unheard of as the cancer it is used to treat generally affects older age groups) the woman must agree to a pregnancy prevention plan

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/07/2023 08:57

Oysterbabe · 25/07/2023 08:50

According to half the people on here a pregnant woman should be able to do whatever she wants with her body, including killing the baby the day before it's born. I don't know how they can also object if the mother wants to take testosterone.

Two different things - terminating a pregnancy is one thing that should be performed with care to ensure safety for the mother and to make sure the foetus does not feel anything. But if there is going to be a living human infant at the end of it, they should not be subjected to in utero experimentation for the furtherment of eugenics/to find causes and 'cures' for neurodiversity and 'enhancing' physical/mental attributes under a cloak of #bekind.

Oysterbabe · 25/07/2023 08:50

According to half the people on here a pregnant woman should be able to do whatever she wants with her body, including killing the baby the day before it's born. I don't know how they can also object if the mother wants to take testosterone.

nothingcomestonothing · 25/07/2023 08:00

You can tie yourself in knots to justify this but it is immoral and wrong.
Well that’s a matter of opinion. I logically choose not to accept a risk as existing until it has been proven to exist. You emotionally choose to see risk even when it’s not been proven to exist.

That's the TRA argument about everything though, isn't it? Do it until you can show it's dangerous, rather than don't do it until you can show it's safe. Like males in women's rugby, or women's changing rooms - 'let us do what we want until you can prove it's dangerous'. Then when women are harmed, it's 'well that's a one off/not very many harms/harm to people I don't care about, so it's still okay'. Followed by 'well it's still what I want so ignore the harms to people who aren't me'.

'I'm okay with risking the wellbeing of my child to have something I wish for' isn't generally seen as a sign of great parenting.

Glowie · 25/07/2023 07:53

@ChopperC110P

Your logic is flawed. Undertaking an action which may have a negative effect (and for all you know it is extremely negative) is still a net negative, as opposed to the neutral position of not undertaking it.
Put another way, if what you're doing might harm your unborn child, then it is immoral to not spin the wheel as few times as possible.

Also, said neutral position (i.e. NOT taking potentially harmful hormones) being akin to eugenics is ridiculous.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 25/07/2023 06:54

Detransitioners (female) report that when they stop taking testosterone they still have deep voices and facial hair for the rest of their lives. I don't understand why any woman saying she wants to live as a man would become pregnant, but given this does happen, why would they need to go on taking testosterone in pregnancy given the above?

ChopperC110P · 25/07/2023 06:35

There is a risk to the unborn child for what is simply a cosmetic benefit to the mother.

There is a “potential unknown risk” that is not a definite and known risk., it means there may be no risk. So you cannot say that there is definitely a risk. Furthermore, testosterone is not just cosmetic for those with gender dysphoria.

So you only get the idea they are being treated more favourably if you exaggerate the existence of risk and downplay the need for their medication.

Calling the unborn a child a foetus to justify this is vile.
It is a foetus. It’s not a child. I take it you are pro-life too with your views.

You can tie yourself in knots to justify this but it is immoral and wrong.
Well that’s a matter of opinion. I logically choose not to accept a risk as existing until it has been proven to exist. You emotionally choose to see risk even when it’s not been proven to exist.

if a woman wants to have a baby she should suspend trying to look like a man. she should also stop drinking and smoking and eating soft cheeses and so on and so on but again we let women choose and these items are far more dangerous and risky to a foetus than any hypothetical unproven risk from testosterone.

ChopperC110P · 25/07/2023 06:26

Thelnebriati · 24/07/2023 21:39

When and why did people become ok with medical experiments in an unborn fetus? Are they trying to change the law to make that legal?

I’d say right about the time it became acceptable for a mother to kill her unborn foetus that it also became acceptable for a mother to choose to take any substances that are not proven to be harmful and some that are proven harmful.

ChopperC110P · 25/07/2023 06:23

maddening · 24/07/2023 21:27

Taking drugs known to cause a defect is more like eugenics than not taking the drugs. This isn't trying to prevent ND births- it is actively causing them.

But they are not known to the level needed of scientific proof to cause any defects? Trying to prevent the hypothetical possibility of ND births is paranoid eugenics because being ND is not a defect.

Thelnebriati · 24/07/2023 22:32

I'm thinking about their constantly pushing the idea of artificial wombs, which are also currently illegal due to the same human rights legislation.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 22:09

Thelnebriati · 24/07/2023 21:39

When and why did people become ok with medical experiments in an unborn fetus? Are they trying to change the law to make that legal?

It does make you wonder if these women are simply pawns in a bigger agenda here.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 22:09

Sorry I posted too soon. Should have said 'she should suspend trying to look like a man for the duration of the pregnancy for the sake of the child.

I judge any woman who puts their baby at risk like this, and any medic who sanctions such abuse.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/07/2023 22:06

ChopperC110P · 24/07/2023 21:06

It’s not more favourably because again, testosterone is currently a category B medication.

It’s not like thalidomide which is category X.

Of course it's treating women who identify as trans more favourably.

There is a risk to the unborn child for what is simply a cosmetic benefit to the mother.

Calling the unborn a child a foetus to justify this is vile.

There are no other instances where this happens.

You can tie yourself in knots to justify this but it is immoral and wrong.

if a woman wants to have a baby she should suspend trying to look like a man.

Swipe left for the next trending thread