Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you losing income due to the actor strike?

39 replies

IamfeelingFrustrated · 23/07/2023 14:41

If I wrong - can someone please correct me. But my understanding is the actors could have striked for example two days a week - keeping productions (and other associated businesses) operational for three days a week until they reached an agreement. But instead they have decided to go on a full strike and so now all the other professions related to the film industry are suddenly losing their jobs as production companies stand these other film related professions down. It’s very common in the industry to be on contracts associated with each film - the film stops working completely so the other industries stop working completely. By this I mean camera technicians, make up and hair artists, runners etc etc.
IABU - I think it’s ok for the actors to go on a full strike and the fact other related professions are losing their jobs is a necessary consequence.
IANBU - sure the actors can protest and strike but could have chosen an option where the other professions working on their set did not lose their jobs as a consequence.

OP posts:
thebellagio · 23/07/2023 16:43

Sirzy · 23/07/2023 16:21

But the thing is as tough as it is if the AI and similar take over then all of those jobs would be even more at risk. The action is to protect the industry as a whole

Exactly this.

to the op who says their DH constructs film sets - if the actors don’t strike over the growing use of AI, film sets literally won’t exist in 3-5 years time. Entire movies will be created virtually, therefore the actors strike will be the best thing to try and save your husbands career in the long term

MistressoftheDarkSide · 23/07/2023 16:37

My son works for a company that does the barriers and fencing for big events. Due to the cancelling of premiers in London his hours have been severely reduced and the long term future is in doubt which is worrying.

While this is concerning we do think the reasons are important though. If human creativity is going to be replaced by AI and other technological innovations it will be awful.

It will damage the economy and the human psyche.

I also think the speed of change in other areas will create a massive ripple effect and the ability to progress in one’s life will be dependent on one’s ability to code and implement said technology. Not so many of these people will be needed; not everyone is going to be able to take up the more manual jobs.

There’s an awful lot to unpick here and I am a bit groggy so can’t really expand.

In short, I agree with the principles of the striking actors, and I think we’re going to see a lot of disruption over lots of industries as redundancies start happening.

Strange and interesting times indeed.

trevthecat · 23/07/2023 16:31

My dh works for a TV and film construction company, he is a tradesman working in building the sets. So far he shouldn't be affected, the manager has some other bits for them to work on too, adverts for sport brands using footballers etc so we should be OK, for now.

Sirzy · 23/07/2023 16:21

But the thing is as tough as it is if the AI and similar take over then all of those jobs would be even more at risk. The action is to protect the industry as a whole

whataweirdo · 23/07/2023 16:16

I am a teacher who supports teacher strikes and often have to defend my choice to friends and family members.

However, if my striking meant support staff would also not get paid, I would definitely not strike.

My DP works in the film industry and now has no work. Our rent is going up. Everything is going up. We used all of our savings during Covid when he couldn't work and had no income. I am surprised there is little media coverage of the wider impact these strikes are having.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 23/07/2023 16:08

We have been affected but I agree with the strikes and the way that they are being carried out. AI isn’t just a threat to the actors, it’s a threat to everyone involved.

thebellagio · 23/07/2023 16:05

Can I suggest reading this article and then watching the YouTube video of the French women’s World Cup advert?

https://www.usmagazine.com/entertainment/news/french-soccer-ad-goes-viral-ahead-of-the-womens-world-cup/

look at how they’ve used AI to create existing footage so it looks like the men scoring, when it reality it was the ladies. Does it really not scare you to see how these deep fakes can be used to literally manipulate reality and distort the truth? They literally won’t need actors anymore. Already you can see through films like the fast franchise how the use of CGI is overtaking everything to create stunts, so why would you need actors when you could create them all on a computer screen?

let alone the fact that writers are also faced with the prospect of AI taking their work and creating scripts.

simultaneously while none of them are getting paid for their work.

seriously this should scare all of us,

French Soccer Ad Goes Viral Ahead of the Women’s World Cup

Ahead of the Women’s World Cup a French soccer ad went viral after it pointed out gender biases in the sport

https://www.usmagazine.com/entertainment/news/french-soccer-ad-goes-viral-ahead-of-the-womens-world-cup/

Sapphire387 · 23/07/2023 16:03

I thought this was a US-based strike - is it also having a large impact over here then?

TheModHatter · 23/07/2023 16:02

My BIL, who works freelance on a crucial aspect of production has lost work and has no income. Having paid for a long term accommodation to see him to what was supposed to be the end of this contract. Big outlay, no income.

I’m not sure that the right people are feeling the pressure.

bellamountain · 23/07/2023 15:58

My brother works in construction on film sets. Without construction there would be no sets and therefore no films. The work construction produce is very physically exhausting and can be dangerous working at heights. My brother is now out of work and has a mortgage and a young family. I think the actors are being unreasonable definitely.

Mumonthemove10 · 23/07/2023 15:51

As an aside though, my colleagues on various productions have been stood down indefinitely, unpaid obviously, with anything from a days to a weeks notice. If this was happening in other industries that have recently been striking ie education, transport etc, there would be a national outrage. However, like we were treated in covid, there’s a complete indifference to us. The reaction, even from my wider circle outside the industry, is ‘oh that’s nice you get more time home with the kids’ rather than, ‘so everyone’s effectively been sacked and you’ve lost all employment for the next six months with zero notice’
My mortgage has just gone up by nearly £500 a month so it’s been terrible timing for my family(we both work in the industry)

Mumonthemove10 · 23/07/2023 15:43

Hi, I’ve had two jobs fall through at the last minute due to the strikes. I am now having to travel overseas to work away from my family for a month and just hope it all goes ahead too otherwise things are going to get v tight for us. However, I can’t imagine any HETV or MMP going ahead on a three day week basis. So much of their budgets are equipment hire and studio hire(one of the many reasons they are so reluctant to reduce the. 12hr day) so I imagine it’s more cost effective to shut down and stop paying people than spread it out with currently no end in sight.
I do think it’s worth it though for the long term implications for the industry as a whole

FourEyesGood · 23/07/2023 15:31

A strike is useless unless it’s causes disruption. Its purpose is to put pressure on the people at the top to stop implementing harmful policies or change.
Surely anyone who works within the film industry cannot be in favour of the use of AI instead of emptying humans for the creative jobs? You mentioned runners and make-up artists in your OP; these people will be entirely redundant if the use of AI in film is not restricted.

IamfeelingFrustrated · 23/07/2023 15:13

Unless this has been because my phone is slow to update - there’s been six votes hugely in favour of ‘IABU - I think it’s ok for the actors to go on a full strike and the fact other related professions are losing their jobs is a necessary consequence.’
But not a single supporting comment as to why this is ok and why it was not better for the actors to strike in a more staggered way so that related professions did lose their jobs.
I would appreciate others people’s views. We can’t be the only family in a film related industry affected by the strike and now worried about the future.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread