Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you losing income due to the actor strike?

39 replies

IamfeelingFrustrated · 23/07/2023 14:41

If I wrong - can someone please correct me. But my understanding is the actors could have striked for example two days a week - keeping productions (and other associated businesses) operational for three days a week until they reached an agreement. But instead they have decided to go on a full strike and so now all the other professions related to the film industry are suddenly losing their jobs as production companies stand these other film related professions down. It’s very common in the industry to be on contracts associated with each film - the film stops working completely so the other industries stop working completely. By this I mean camera technicians, make up and hair artists, runners etc etc.
IABU - I think it’s ok for the actors to go on a full strike and the fact other related professions are losing their jobs is a necessary consequence.
IANBU - sure the actors can protest and strike but could have chosen an option where the other professions working on their set did not lose their jobs as a consequence.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mumonthemove10 · 24/07/2023 09:11

Well I suppose the relevance is that the actors union chose to strike. The surrounding workers don’t have that choice (whether they support the strike or not). Like if the train drivers, for example, chose to strike then every job within the train station -cleaners/shops/cafes etc- all had to shut indefinitely as wellwithout pay on one days notice.

Quveas · 24/07/2023 09:01

You do all know that most US actors are mostly also self-employed? So not clear what relevance the employment status of other production members have has to anything.

bellamountain · 24/07/2023 08:57

@whataweirdo absolutely agree. These strikes aren't really inconveniencing the public are they? We have enough to watch nowadays that if nothing new gets made for a while, then really, does it actually matter. Even the streaming companies have enough material. These strikes should have consulted the thousands of people also involved in the film industry, they have been given no consideration at all and yes they are self employed.

Quveas · 24/07/2023 08:51

IamfeelingFrustrated · 24/07/2023 07:26

However, the teachers have never just decided to stop working completely until they got what they wanted. You really can’t compare teachers striking adhocally and the loss of parent pay on these days to the full and indefinite actors strike that is resulting in some parents immediately losing their full income indefinitely.
If anything this supports my point - if the teachers can strike adhocally so they don’t cause full disruption to their students and parents - why can’t actors think about how they can strike and get what they want without causing supporting industries to suddenly have zero income.

You really don't get it, do you? It is up to the people taking industrial action to decide what their action will comprise of, and how much it inconveniences other people is not remotely a factor - it is about winning.

Teachers don't call all out strikes because their unions know that they would lose the ballots - there are very few groups that would support all out strike because it means that their own members will lose all their pay too. It takes desperation to call an all out strike - you are so concerned about the loss of all their pay for others, but the actors (and the writers) are also losing all their pay. Nobody makes that choice lightly.

Strikes are about winning, and you go for winning or you don't go out at all. Half-hearted measures don't work - in fact you could argue that the "occasional strike days" strategy is why the government find it so easy to ignore them - they are only mildly inconvenienced, and a bunch of occasionally pissed off parents are easy to manage.

You also haven't factored in that this action is taking place in the USA, where labour laws and attitudes are very different, employment rights are poor and working conditions far, far worse than people in other developed nations expect to see. Comparing people taking indistrial action in the USA - where such measures are actually quite uncommon - to industrial action in the UK is like comparing apples and oranges.

Personally, I think that conflating pay and AI is actually a tactical error, because I suspect that the latter is unwinnable and so requires a more nuanced approach. Technology has never been stopped by industrial action - the Luddites proved that. And I also think that an all out indefinite strike could push employers in the opposite direction, and into looking at ways to reduce reliance on actors. I would have gone after pay and conditions, which are more winnable, and look at other strategies to manage AI. Any undertakings the employers might give on AI probably won't be worth the paper they are written on. But it isn't up to me.

whataweirdo · 24/07/2023 08:21

Maybe people don’t understand that most of these people working on any production are self-employed.
It isn’t the case of people on the payroll continuing to get paid. These people cannot work if the production is shut down, and so cannot invoice for their work, and therefore have no income.

whataweirdo · 24/07/2023 08:11

@MissTrip82 i don’t think it’s the same. Like when tube/ train drivers strike, commuters and parents have the option of making alternative arrangements even if these arrangements are inconvenient.
In many cases, employers and most of the public are sympathetic to the people who are inconvenienced by the strikes and try to make allowances (maybe someone has to start work later or work from home on these days). There are some employers who are not sympathetic but the majority of good people would agree that these employers are unreasonable.

The actors strike means that the majority of the people working on the same production (and who have not decided or even been consulted on the strike) suddenly find themselves with no income, for an unknown amount of time. That means no money coming in, for the foreseeable future. I think it’s very different.

IamfeelingFrustrated · 24/07/2023 07:26

MissTrip82 · 24/07/2023 02:56

I mean this will be true for many parents who lost pay because they couldn’t work when their kid’s teacher was on strike, many of whom will earn less than you.

This is the reality of striking, it’s meant to hurt and it will always involve hurting people beyond the target, it’s impossible to avoid if the strike is meaningful.

However, the teachers have never just decided to stop working completely until they got what they wanted. You really can’t compare teachers striking adhocally and the loss of parent pay on these days to the full and indefinite actors strike that is resulting in some parents immediately losing their full income indefinitely.
If anything this supports my point - if the teachers can strike adhocally so they don’t cause full disruption to their students and parents - why can’t actors think about how they can strike and get what they want without causing supporting industries to suddenly have zero income.

OP posts:
MissTrip82 · 24/07/2023 02:56

whataweirdo · 23/07/2023 16:16

I am a teacher who supports teacher strikes and often have to defend my choice to friends and family members.

However, if my striking meant support staff would also not get paid, I would definitely not strike.

My DP works in the film industry and now has no work. Our rent is going up. Everything is going up. We used all of our savings during Covid when he couldn't work and had no income. I am surprised there is little media coverage of the wider impact these strikes are having.

I mean this will be true for many parents who lost pay because they couldn’t work when their kid’s teacher was on strike, many of whom will earn less than you.

This is the reality of striking, it’s meant to hurt and it will always involve hurting people beyond the target, it’s impossible to avoid if the strike is meaningful.

DdraigGoch · 24/07/2023 02:05

but your comment about actors not being needed? Although I can’t see that ever happening as I think there is always going to be a market for human connection…. and so what if actors aren’t needed? How many professions over the centuries have and come and gone because the market demanded something else? The basic principle of business is demand = supply. If humankind wants to see actors then actors will always be in demand.

The big name actors will always be there, but what about the bit parts and extras?

jcyclops · 24/07/2023 01:12

I'm not aiming to denigrate the female players, as the French video does show fantastic skills, but people who watch a lot of football would immediately spot "something wrong" with the French video, but they might initially struggle to identify exactly what it is. The producer's mistake was to superimpose images of players like Mbappe and Griezmann on the women's action, and these players are amongst the world's greatest. In the clip, their play looks somewhat slow, stilted and clumsy compared to their normal levels. I think it would have totally worked it if they had used average male players from the French squad, rather than their world class superstars.

IamfeelingFrustrated · 23/07/2023 22:20

Quveas · 23/07/2023 22:01

You do understand that the purpose of industrial action is not to mildly inconvenience?

Perhaps those others need to look at the issues here. For example, who needs construction workers for sites if AI can create the sites for nothing? But regardless - it is a fundamental right to withdraw your labour. End of.

yes it’s a fundamental right to withdraw labour…but not ‘end of’… because it’s also a fundamental right for freedom of expression and it does need to be said the way actors are striking are causing people in associated industries to lose their income immediately ie this week. People keep saying if AI comes in they will lose their jobs then…yes maybe but it would be a gradual process and these associated industries will have time to create other income streams. I am not against the principal of the actors striking or why they are striking - I just think little thought has gone into how to get what they want without maybe putting other people in the industry in a position of immediately losing their jobs as the productions are shutting down projects.

OP posts:
VeniVidiWeeWee · 23/07/2023 22:16

Quveas · 23/07/2023 22:01

You do understand that the purpose of industrial action is not to mildly inconvenience?

Perhaps those others need to look at the issues here. For example, who needs construction workers for sites if AI can create the sites for nothing? But regardless - it is a fundamental right to withdraw your labour. End of.

And it's a fundamental right of employers to have a lock-out. End of.

Quveas · 23/07/2023 22:01

You do understand that the purpose of industrial action is not to mildly inconvenience?

Perhaps those others need to look at the issues here. For example, who needs construction workers for sites if AI can create the sites for nothing? But regardless - it is a fundamental right to withdraw your labour. End of.

wordler · 23/07/2023 22:00

If the actors don’t strike effectively to support the lower paid actors and the writers then there will be no decent film or TV industry in a few years time.

thebellagio · 23/07/2023 21:54

@IamfeelingFrustrated in principle, I don’t disagree with your overall point that too many sidelined professions are being inadvertently hurt. You’re absolutely right, but from what I’ve read, I do believe that the writers and actors are right to strike.

I believe that theatre actors will be safe, but if a studio can get away with actors the will. With so many remakes, do they need writers now or can they just use the original scripts yet not compensate the original writers? I genuinely don’t know, but I do remember it took bloody years for a return to output after the last writer strike

IamfeelingFrustrated · 23/07/2023 21:45

thebellagio · 23/07/2023 16:05

Can I suggest reading this article and then watching the YouTube video of the French women’s World Cup advert?

https://www.usmagazine.com/entertainment/news/french-soccer-ad-goes-viral-ahead-of-the-womens-world-cup/

look at how they’ve used AI to create existing footage so it looks like the men scoring, when it reality it was the ladies. Does it really not scare you to see how these deep fakes can be used to literally manipulate reality and distort the truth? They literally won’t need actors anymore. Already you can see through films like the fast franchise how the use of CGI is overtaking everything to create stunts, so why would you need actors when you could create them all on a computer screen?

let alone the fact that writers are also faced with the prospect of AI taking their work and creating scripts.

simultaneously while none of them are getting paid for their work.

seriously this should scare all of us,

I think it’s important that people’s rights are protected in terms of their talent being used for AI without their permission or royalties….but your comment about actors not being needed? Although I can’t see that ever happening as I think there is always going to be a market for human connection…. and so what if actors aren’t needed? How many professions over the centuries have and come and gone because the market demanded something else? The basic principle of business is demand = supply. If humankind wants to see actors then actors will always be in demand.

OP posts:
fabricstash · 23/07/2023 21:36

The screenwriters were already on strike so things had already slowed down before the actor strikes. Screenwriters make much less money with streaming even with a hit series. They are also v worried about AI. I know people who work in the art/construction side in uk and have not worked since much earlier in year but as it is contract to contract they have a big rainy day fund. However the funds won’t last forever.

IamfeelingFrustrated · 23/07/2023 21:33

TheModHatter · 23/07/2023 16:02

My BIL, who works freelance on a crucial aspect of production has lost work and has no income. Having paid for a long term accommodation to see him to what was supposed to be the end of this contract. Big outlay, no income.

I’m not sure that the right people are feeling the pressure.

This is exactly what I mean. I agree - I don’t think the right people are feeling the pressure and it’s individuals who have suddenly lost all their income who are getting the most pressure. I don’t have the answers but surely penalising this group of people is not one of them. A poster made a comment about AI affecting some of these people…not if they have had to move out of the industry because they need to feed their families.

OP posts:
IamfeelingFrustrated · 23/07/2023 21:28

FourEyesGood · 23/07/2023 15:31

A strike is useless unless it’s causes disruption. Its purpose is to put pressure on the people at the top to stop implementing harmful policies or change.
Surely anyone who works within the film industry cannot be in favour of the use of AI instead of emptying humans for the creative jobs? You mentioned runners and make-up artists in your OP; these people will be entirely redundant if the use of AI in film is not restricted.

I don’t think anyone is saying don’t strike - it’s that if the actors only stopped working a few days a week that would hurt productions companies but would mean the associated industries could still earn some income. As it stands - what disruption is being created for the production companies by actors standing down completely? The production companies have reduced their costs by just shutting down whole movies. The disruption you are talking about is disruption for the people in associated industries - putting pressure on the associated industries with these people now not having any incomes to support their families. But these associated industries have zero leverage.
If the teachers striked everyday for weeks / months - all the support staff would still get paid. But this is not what happens in the film industry.

OP posts:
Middlelanehogger · 23/07/2023 18:53

What exactly are the demands of the actors in this strike?

"Never use AI in a film" is, uh... well, call me in 10 years and let me know how that goes.

thebellagio · 23/07/2023 18:46

Is it hysteria tho @bellamountain?

how much of the cinema these days is now filmed in front of a green screen? How many of the stunts are done by CGI not by trained stunt men? The stunts on the fast and furious franchise have got more outlandish because it’s all being created by computer, not on a set.

did you watch the link I posted earlier of the French video promoting the French women’s football team and how they literally showed how they used AI to turn the women into the men’s team? The fact that actors have to strike to protest their likeness, their voices being used in ways that they’ve never agreed to is disturbing.

bellamountain · 23/07/2023 17:48

The actors are only in part striking because of AI, they are in the main striking to support the writers. However, they should show the same level of solidarity to all other professions in the film industry.

AI has also been in use for years. It won't take over the film industry. That is typical Mumsnet hysteria.

Tiqtaq · 23/07/2023 17:13

I support strikes in general.
There is way too much money and power in the hands of way too few individuals and we need to stand together to fight this. There is inevitably a short term cost and short term pain involved.
If you are angry with the strikers your anger is in my opinion misplaced.

Maddy70 · 23/07/2023 17:09

Strikes have to have the maximum impact otherwise there is no point

gogomoto · 23/07/2023 16:57

@Sapphire387

A lot of production is in the U.K. /outside of the USA so has impact far and wide. Local hotel manager is moaning hes had a 40 room block booking cancelled for tomorrow.

Swipe left for the next trending thread