Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not rehome my pets despite lowering their quality of life?

119 replies

bakingtouch · 23/07/2023 13:53

I need this thread as a very clear wake up call if that's what's needed.

I've just broken up with my long term partner and have moved out of the house we were renting. I've recently moved into a ground floor flat that has accepted my pets. It has a garden bit out the front albeit concrete but my dog has no issue toileting there (obvs I clean)

They're all adjusting well (2 cats and a dog) and they're honestly my world, especially after the breakup, I'd feel so isolated without them. They're 7, 5 and 4. The dog is 4.

I'm having to go back to in office work full time (was at home 2/5 days before). On those 3 days my dog would get picked up by a service that offered a 2 hour play date service and dropped home again, with other dogs, but the best I can do now is have my mum pop in to let him out to the toilet. They've always been on KatKin and Butternut Box but this is massively going to have to change, my outgoings on my own are simply exceeding my salary so I'm having to cut back and they're going to need to go on a cheap food.

I do feel awful overall. They're life is going to be very different, but they're going to be happier with me still, right? Sad or is it best to give them up to someone who can offer them a lot more?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NoTouch · 25/07/2023 18:27

BlushBlue · 25/07/2023 16:24

We are at home all day and our dogs spend a lot of time sleep now they're not puppies. Keep them!

They "sleep" during the day when they need a rest from stimulation or they are bored stiff and there is nothing else to do but wait for hours on end for something to happen. OPs dog, at home alone all day, day after day, they are not being stimulated at all so it means it is the latter.

So while it is not any bother for your neighbours, your soft furnishings, or even their owner it doesn't mean it is nice, or even a barely adequate life for a young dog.

BlushBlue · 25/07/2023 16:24

We are at home all day and our dogs spend a lot of time sleep now they're not puppies. Keep them!

thishasnotmyweek · 25/07/2023 16:22

I would try borrow my doggy, my mum is on it after her dog died and she couldn't afford a new one.

She works from home and has a lovely dog from not far away that comes round a few times a week while the owner is at work. Both her and the dog love it!

Blondeshavemorefun · 25/07/2023 16:15

What area are you in roughly op

Can you post on your local Fb town group asking if anyone would like to walk your dog once a day or have a cuppa
Ans cuddle with a neighbour

stevalnamechanger · 25/07/2023 08:37

Sign up to BorrowMyDoggy and see if anyone local would like to have them whilst they work from home

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 24/07/2023 22:43

We always leave BBC6 Music on for our cat (who even if we’re at home will often snooze in another room during the day - she’s only an evening lapcat) because she’s an indie kit.

PlinkPlonkFizz · 24/07/2023 22:27

The food as everyone has said, is not an issue at all. I had to reappraise why we were eating Aldi and Lidl but pets were getting top notch nosh. Now they eat grain free generic supermarket stuff but it's still good quality.

It will be tough going getting up early every single weekday to walk your dog before work. Then when you get home, another long walk without fail. I've never used BorrowmyDoggy but it sounds like it will suit your situation. I think I would cut out other expenses even to afford 1-2'days of daycare or a walker to break up the week.

There are other things you can do for your dog too - BBC Radio 2 on low for company, make puzzle bundles out of cardboard/ treats / sellotape for your dog to have fun ripping apart, filled frozen giant Kong's for breakfast as you leave the dog so she'll spend an hour or two licking that, all these things will help the dog pass the time without fretting.

The cats will miss you but they have each other to interact with, so it's not quite as bad.
Hope things work out ok for you.

FastFood · 24/07/2023 22:07

Florabundance · 24/07/2023 15:23

I had to leave an abusive relationship and chose to take our dog away with me because the idea of leaving my much loved (doggy) girl with a mentally unbalanced alcoholic was unthinkable. It was a struggle, living in an Air BnB lodge the size of a garden shed wasn't easy and there were times when I seriously questioned whether I'd done the right thing by her, but 18 months on we couldn't be happier, we live in a little house in a peaceful village and I found a job that fitted around her. If the cost of dog food is a concern then do as I do and make your own in batches using frozen mixed veg and beef or turkey mince for the freezer, very easy to do and so much cheaper. You can do it !!

Oh my heart ♥️
So so lovely to read that, well done for turning your life around!

FastFood · 24/07/2023 22:01

Oh and just adding: I had great experiences with borrowmydoggy, and even made a friend. Never had any issue with it, and my old dog had a lot of different borrowers, all absolutely lovely people.
Definitely worth a try!

FastFood · 24/07/2023 21:54

Not saying its ideal but long days alone are pretty standard for dogs in many countries. At least your mum is going to take your dog out for toilet and a bit of company.

Personally I'd go along with it, and see how the dog reacts but I have a feeling he'll be fine as long as he's with you and the cats. And I think you need your pets as much as they need you now.

Take care and good luck with your new life x

Est1990 · 24/07/2023 21:47

I think you are doing great! Dont rehome!🤗

I'm not familiar with cats though but i guess what some were saying about the cat flap might be a good idea.

P.S Just this morning i was reading on one of those dog support groups someone saying they leave their dog in the crate for 6 hours during the day and some people dare to say it was acceptable 😑

underneaththeash · 24/07/2023 21:37

Well the food is a complete waste of money any way.

Ginandpanic · 24/07/2023 21:31

i also gave up butternut box when my marriage ended but I kept the dogs and 3 years on my life is different again. Your situation now could be temporary, you could get another job wfh, you could find a new partner, move, get a lodger, you’ve no idea.
keep them, do your best.
maybe ask in local groups if you can share dog walks with someone? There might be someone who does shifts that would help you out and vice versa?

Muckysmucky · 24/07/2023 21:24

NoTouch · 24/07/2023 16:49

If done responsibly rehoming can work. There are lots of posters on here who have rescued/rehomed with very positive outcomes.

No one should under estimate the impact perhaps 8+ years of monotonous boredom and loneliness for most of its life starting from just 4 years old can do to a dog. Better to rehome now before the dog starts developing behavioural problems that will make it harder for him to find a new home.

The reality is a dog in this situation, for 5 days a week consistently for years, will only be getting quality engagement or stimulation with its human for perhaps 1-2 hours a day tops! 22+ hours a day "sleeping" or waiting is no life for an active young dog.

THIS
Just because a dog is not tearing the house apart doesn’t mean it isn’t being harmed by such lengthy periods of being left.

Part of loving our pets is ensuring they get all their needs met not just food and water that includes stimulation and emotional care.

On the days I work away from
home I ensure my dog is taken out for a minimum of two hours in total (usually as two separate visits) and if I couldn’t afford this I would either change job, find another dog care solution or rehome. I genuinely would because I care about my dog more than how much I love him.

We have also personally had two rescues who came to us precisely because their existing family couldn’t be with them in the day

PostItInABook · 24/07/2023 18:01

NoTouch · 24/07/2023 16:53

I was one of the posters that said that as I always view cats as much more independent. I have never owned one (or had one own me!), but any I have known, if they have access to outdoors they are out so much they are at getting stimulation. Although they might wander and find themselves a new owner if there needs are not met!

They would not be imprisoned in solitary confinement like a dog would be.

But the cats are being locked in with each other and a dog when the owner is not at home so they cannot come and go as they please, nor escape each other or a dog if they want/need to. A one bed flat is generally pretty small also. If they are used to coming and going whenever, this change may lead to increased stress.

ScribblingPixie · 24/07/2023 16:55

I wouldn't worry about the Butternut Box either. I mean, it's great but in part it's for the owner as you feel good about feeding meals you recognise as delicious rather than 'dog food' which may actually be just as nutritious.

NoTouch · 24/07/2023 16:53

PostItInABook · 24/07/2023 16:38

It’s a surprise to me that everyone is saying the cats won’t care.

I was one of the posters that said that as I always view cats as much more independent. I have never owned one (or had one own me!), but any I have known, if they have access to outdoors they are out so much they are at getting stimulation. Although they might wander and find themselves a new owner if there needs are not met!

They would not be imprisoned in solitary confinement like a dog would be.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 24/07/2023 16:52

They'll be ok.

Can you take the dog for a long evening walk?

I had to go to work fulltime for a while while my dogs were young; not ideal but they napped a lot.

Can you get a cheap webcam so you can check on them via a phone app? Might ease your mind.

ScribblingPixie · 24/07/2023 16:50

Another vote for Borrowmydoggy. We met three people who were nice but not a perfect match then a totally lovely lady who works from home & loves the company of our dog, acts almost as an extra owner.

NoTouch · 24/07/2023 16:49

minipie · 24/07/2023 16:20

It's a surprise to me that everyone is saying that leaving a young dog on its own for hours at a time every day is fine. Of course he'll get used it. He shouldn't have to though

I think people are weighing it up against the reality of the rehoming situation

If done responsibly rehoming can work. There are lots of posters on here who have rescued/rehomed with very positive outcomes.

No one should under estimate the impact perhaps 8+ years of monotonous boredom and loneliness for most of its life starting from just 4 years old can do to a dog. Better to rehome now before the dog starts developing behavioural problems that will make it harder for him to find a new home.

The reality is a dog in this situation, for 5 days a week consistently for years, will only be getting quality engagement or stimulation with its human for perhaps 1-2 hours a day tops! 22+ hours a day "sleeping" or waiting is no life for an active young dog.

NoChanceYouMetalBastard · 24/07/2023 16:43

OP, we used Borrow my Doggy and had nothing but positive experiences.

You can meet the people first. Go for a walk with them and your dog first. Yes, you do have to trust the person somewhat but it isn't much different than a dog walker, and you often see dog walkers standing in parks with 10 dogs all over the place while they are looking down at their 'phone.

We had 3 regulars who borrowed our dog.

PostItInABook · 24/07/2023 16:38

CovertImage · 24/07/2023 16:19

I agree. It's a surprise to me that everyone is saying that leaving a young dog on its own for hours at a time every day is fine. Of course he'll get used it. He shouldn't have to though

I wonder if there'd be the same responses in the Doghouse rather than AIBU

It’s a surprise to me that everyone is saying the cats won’t care.

PostItInABook · 24/07/2023 16:35

If your cats are used to coming and going when they please then changing that to keep them indoors for a long period of the day is not going to work. Coupled with limited space to coexist, they will become very unhappy. Will your landlord consider a cat flap installed into a window if you pay for it and for it to be returned to pre-moving in state when/if you move out?

Verv · 24/07/2023 16:28

I think you should keep them.
You're organising care for them while youre at work, which is significantly more responsible than many people.
They know you and they love you, and you love them. Walks before and after work and they should snooze for a large part of the day while youre away.

Muckysmucky · 24/07/2023 16:26

I don’t necessarily think you should rehome them but I think your dog in particular is getting a rough deal being alone in a flat so many hours sorry.

I think you might need to have a very careful rethink about finances and cut back any other way at all to afford some daycare or at least a 30 min midday walk for him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread