Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Everyone loves her-how do you become like this?

356 replies

Backinthesummerof1995 · 23/07/2023 09:52

One of the school mums/women in my area is so loved by everyone, super popular but in that nice way as in, people just adore her. She’s v confident and quite loud, but also great fun and a genuinely nice person.
I know lots of people with a great bunch of friends, but almost literally everyone loves her and she has friends in every set of people. I’ve not seen this to this extent before. They write things on her sm (birthday etc) about her being a truly beautiful person inside and out.
How do you become a person like this?

OP posts:
FlyingMonkeyNever · 23/07/2023 13:14

HappySonHappyMum · 23/07/2023 12:11

I don't know about everyone loving me - but I do have one of those faces that older people are happy to chat to! I can guarantee if I'm waiting at a bus stop the OAP that's there will always start up a conversation and I'll know their life story by the time I get off the bus. And this is in London - where no one talks to anyone!

This is me too. I also live in London and occasionally end up in conversation with strangers on public transport. It last happened yesterday. I got on the tube and someone had left their umbrella between empty seats opposite me. 20 mins later the umbrella was still there, so I decided to take it. Woman sitting next to the umbrella look surprised that I had taken it, so I explained that it been left there before she got on the tube. She said it wasn’t there when she got on the tube. I said it was as I got on at X Station. Conversation then flowed about the bloody rain and why we were both in the West End yesterday. We had a laugh.

I’m not always lovely as I also say the shit stuff, the not so good aspects of my life and the stuff no one else has the balls to say.

My DH and DC always rib me about how I talk too much and take ages talking to people in the supermarket, library, restaurant, street, etc. I take it as a compliment.

My mum’s also very chatty although she’ll strike up conversations with people serving her in shops whilst on the phone during her lunch break, which is annoying as I’m left left hanging on hold having to listen, esp. when I’m on my lunch break, trying to work or just busy with the kids/home life. My mum also can’t keep a secret, likes to gossip and suffers from extreme FOMO. Anything told to me in confidence stays with me.

A few of my work colleagues are also friends who I spend time with outside of work, including inviting them to a big Birthday Party several years ago. I left and then went back to this particular workplace because I missed working with them, the grass definitely wasn’t greener and the money was better.

I can be loud but I’m also an introvert who likes spending time alone. I like spending time alone in nature, going to the cinema alone and having quiet time to reflect. I enjoy spending time at home when DH and the DC are all out. I walk around the park alone or go to the cinema alone day on my off work whilst our youngest two DC are at school.

I also work in a caring role, with a high and pressured workload, and where I’m exposed to others trauma, so I ensure I schedule in time for ‘self-care/me-time’.

A friend told me that they would like to be like me when they grow up, which I think may be the biggest compliment I’ve received, as I had an difficult upbringing, went to State schools, had my first child at 20, struggled through Uni whilst working PT as a working single parent, and generally haven’t always made the best choices, esp. when I was young and naive.

RunningFromInsanity · 23/07/2023 13:13

Verbena17 · 23/07/2023 11:46

That’s surely a bit hard over over-trying? 😂
Actually writing down on your phone what someone has said? Surely if they’re a good friend, you would automatically remember stuff they’d told you? 🤔

I find I can be forgetful when it comes to other peoples lives. Obviously I remember the big important stuff but I find remembering the smaller stuff that is still important to them, really makes the difference.

I started doing it as I was aware that as a big personality I can tend to dominant conversations, so I made a conscious effort to change and this really helps.

littlebopeepp234 · 23/07/2023 13:12

I know of a few people like this.

There seems to be 2 groups of them:

The ones who are loud, mouthy and get attention just because they are not afraid to voice their opinion and always have some sort of gossip to tell people and always the ring leader in a large group while everyone stands round in a circle listening to them.

Then there are the ones who are just truly lovely people inside and out, always nice and pleasant to people and in general just a ‘people magnet’ who seem to attract groups of people who are interested in what they have to say.

The only upsetting/ irritating thing for me is i feel that both groups take too much of the attention away from other people, just because they have ‘the gift of the gab’. Like in work group discussions, they are always the ones talking the most while everyone stays quiet and listens to them but as soon as I try to put my opinion across, I’m unheard, taken no notice of and talked over.

I see myself as a nice, friendly person who is always polite and approachable and will talk to anyone. But it’s as if nobody notices me or really cares. I really don’t get it to be honest.

truthhurts23 · 23/07/2023 13:11

poor her sounds exhausting
i would think it has something to do with being authentically yourself, but it only works if your authentic self is likeable and charismatic
some people are just genuinely likeable and some people learned it as a skill
even some narcissistic people are very likeable people

Mayhem3 · 23/07/2023 13:11

SerafinasGoose · 23/07/2023 12:49

This is probably why you are not as well liked as the woman in question because you see bitchy behaviour but refuse to acknowledge it.

You know nothing about me whatsoever. You have no idea whether or not people choose to associate with me. I'm pixels on the internet. (Pixels that generally tend not to spell out the word 'b-i-t-c-h', or other unpleasant pejoratives used to describe women.

It's a mere online discussion. No need to make it so personal.

I’m not trying to make it personal but you’re having a hard time understanding how someone can truly be a genuinely nice person without being fake.

Lots of people are genuinely nice people and therefore people are drawn to them.

It doesn’t mean we’re not perfect, it just means we’re not nice to your face and then bitch about you behind your backs.

Its really sad to see so many posters on here who associates her being nice with her being fake.
But that says more about them than this woman.

I think it’s very contradictory that you won’t use the word bitchy because you find it misogynistic but will happily imply that a woman but be fake if she’s acting like a nice person.

User1789 · 23/07/2023 13:10

TheYearOfSmallThings · 23/07/2023 10:30

She sounds socially adept and confident besides being fun and a good friend. The "fun and a good friend" bits are what make people truly like her, whereas the "socially adept and confident" traits are the ones that make people identify her as dominant and want to be publicly identified with her.

They might like you just as much but not feel the need to broadcast it because that serves no purpose if you have very average social status.

I agree. I also think there are a number of aspects of luck here. These women are often quite, or even very attractive, but often in a non-threatening way to other women. I have never encountered one of these women who was either ugly, or a complete sexpot. They are often women who, for whatever reason, have a stable, similarly pleasant long-term partner or at least positive family situation.

I would also say that while I sometimes wonder what it would take for me to be more like this, I am actually quite shy, and friends have pointed out I would probably hate the attention and demands.

I also wonder if there is a degree of poor boundaries with some of these women. While I have managed to form meaningful friendships with some I have met, I have often ended up squeezed out by people who more selfishly and insistently demanded more of their time.

WandaWonder · 23/07/2023 13:09

At least I have some good news to take from this thread, we can get rid of all the paid qualified mental health professionals and just hand it all over to free random posters to diagnose by MN posts

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/07/2023 13:07

Mutabiliss · Today 10:51
It's called charisma. It's a rare, fortunate quality and you can't learn it, people are like that from childhood. I know two people with it (in different areas of life) and they're both very outgoing, both performers as a hobby and work in sales by day, both very popular, everyone loves them. They're funny, engaging and positive.

I just enjoy their company and accept that I'm not like that at all 😂”

This. It also helps, I think, if they have benefitted from a comfortable, supportive upbringing and a good education. Both of those things build confidence and self-esteem.

Hohumitsreallyallthereis · 23/07/2023 13:07

I am close to someone like this. Smart. Kind. Great sense and f humour but also just completely genuine. She doesn’t try to be anything she’s not and I just feel good when I spend time with her. I think the fact that she is also very articulate and a great listener also helps her.

She really is just one of the nicest people I know and spending time with her is a pleasure.

Devonshiregal · 23/07/2023 13:07

SerafinasGoose · 23/07/2023 12:46

Note how often this word is used about women. Now note how often it's used about men.

Yes, this the reason I have an issue with it. It's misogynistic.

Behaviour which in women is lambasted as 'bitchy' or 'bossy' is often viewed in much milder terms as 'assertiveness' when the same behaviour is engaged in by men.

If you don't like someone's behaviour the right thing to do is either challenge the deed (not the person) in an adult manner, or to withdraw and disengage. You can do both these things without turning it into a playground fight or calling people pejorative names.

And it's very easy not to involve yourself in idle gossip. You say nothing. And if someone tries to draw you into it, you don't reciprocate.

I'd have thought the above self-explanatory, but I suppose it depends where you want to expend your energies.

Oh gosh I think you must just be much more zen than I am. I mean I’m not mean or gossipy person and I dont remember the last time I had any sort of issue with someone else.. but if someone is a dick (is this word allowed?) to me, I need to vent to my boyfriend about it.

I think we are perfectly capable of acknowledging the difference between saying someone is “bitchy” and the general issue of women being judged by different standards to men. (And I have certainly been called “a bitch” when a man would just be called assertive/authoritative so totally with you on that being a problem)

words often have several uses or even meanings. And someone can be bitchy without being a bitch. Personally I feel the word bitchy is very descriptively useful for getting my meaning across and will continue to use it.

Mari9999 · 23/07/2023 13:04

@Backinthesummerof1995
I think that there are some people who give generously of their time and do so without complaint or expectation of return. They are warm and accepting and people overlook whatever flaws they might have because they are always present in such a positive way.

Rabbithole90 · 23/07/2023 13:03

Ginmonkeyagain · 23/07/2023 11:06

I have a close friend like this. She is very charismatic and energetic and is the key person in every friendship group (eg the one everyone wants at their birthday/wedding/drinks)

She is very confident, capable and thoughtful - she makes a lot of effort to contact people, support them through difficult times, always invites people to interesting things, remembers to call them etc. She is that person you could call at 2am in a crisis and she would know what to do.

However as someone who has known her since university and is very close to her I know this comes at a price. She is underneath not a particularly confident person so she needs to surround herself with people and always be busy and feel liked. She can often give too much of herself and then get upset or disappointed when others aren't as generous with their time as her.

I am one of the few people who sees the real her underneath the confidence and capability.

She is underneath not a particularly confident person so she needs to surround herself with people and always be busy and feel liked. She can often give too much of herself and then get upset or disappointed when others aren't as generous with their time as her

This. I have a friend like this too. She is needy for attention/People's time/to be constantly surrounded by people. She cannot bear to be alone, not even for an hour. I find her overbearing. I also think she does things for her own benefit, but others see it as she will do a favour for anyone. Yes, if there is something in it for her - either financial gain/not be left on her own or its just something for her to do/a favour subsequently owed to her. Everything she does has an alternative motive, IMO. To quote her "X has asked me to do Y for her. That's a favour in my back pocket that X will owe me".

midsomermurderess · 23/07/2023 13:02

Siameasy · 23/07/2023 12:32

I’m suspicious of charisma and charm as they can indicate a sociopath
I know a guy who is genuinely so nice but not lame and he is just really reasonable and kind.
Charismatic people make others feel good so we tend to assign God status to them. The woman described does sound genuine but IME some of these types are flaky or insincere

For God sake. Lay of the self-help books.

SerafinasGoose · 23/07/2023 13:01

Mosaic123 · 23/07/2023 12:54

No one has mentioned religion. I am not religious but a know a few people who are and are particularly lovely in that they are nice about whatever goes on in someone's life, forgiving and kind and always look on the bright side of things.

Pollyanna types who, if you lost a leg would say that it was lucky because you have another one.

They are pretty annoying.

I'm not saying all religious people are like this but I know two or three (of different religions) and they are so damm positive and accepting about everything, it's quite annoying. If you were their friend and asked them their opinion about something you could never quite be sure of their reply. It would be bound to be super positive and enthusiastic.

I'm leaving religion out of my response as I don't think the behaviour you describe is reducible to religious types. But focusing on what you say in your second paragraph, what is it they call this? 'Toxic positivity', or words to that effect.

There are arguments that this form of behaviour can be highly injurious to others' mental health.

LoobyDop · 23/07/2023 13:00

Being outgoing, positive and interested in other people, but never pushy or overbearing. I think to pull it off without being a total mess of repressed rage and anxiety, you’d also need to be fundamentally happy and secure. Sounds obvious, but it’s a lot easier to be positive about other people when you feel good about yourself.

steff13 · 23/07/2023 13:00

I'm kind of like this. I really just love people. My sister-in-law says that I come across as warm and that's why strangers like to talk to me. The irony is that I'm pretty introverted, but because of my job I have to be a bit outgoing, so I've developed that skill even though it's against my nature. I'm not loud, though, I'm pretty quiet.

Saracen · 23/07/2023 12:57

Haven't RTFT. Have given it some thought. I have known a few people like this.

They genuinely care more about making other people happy than about what anyone thinks of them. They concentrate fully on the person they are talking to - when their attention is directed at you, you feel like the most important person in the world. They remember details about you, because they care. They do stuff for people if they think it would help, without worrying about whether it might make them look nosy, trying-too-hard, or weird.

This puts you in a Catch-22, OP, because if your goal is for people to like you then you won't be thinking first and foremost about THEM, which is what would make them like you.

Mosaic123 · 23/07/2023 12:54

No one has mentioned religion. I am not religious but a know a few people who are and are particularly lovely in that they are nice about whatever goes on in someone's life, forgiving and kind and always look on the bright side of things.

Pollyanna types who, if you lost a leg would say that it was lucky because you have another one.

They are pretty annoying.

I'm not saying all religious people are like this but I know two or three (of different religions) and they are so damm positive and accepting about everything, it's quite annoying. If you were their friend and asked them their opinion about something you could never quite be sure of their reply. It would be bound to be super positive and enthusiastic.

Coffeetree · 23/07/2023 12:53

garlictwist · 23/07/2023 10:50

I'd love to be like this and have spent my life trying to be. But the reality is I am morose, shy and give off massive "fuck off" vibes. I think it's just about being confident and having energy.

You are me. And I do think I'm genuinely a kind person who appreciates people and I try to have good values and be a good friend. But I don't have that charisma X factor. It used to bother me but honestly it takes all kinds. Nothing wrong with being the quiet one.

Ormally · 23/07/2023 12:51

The one person I knew like this, I met around the age of 19.
They had had real hardship through their early years but this had given them a determination and self-belief, as well as a non-judgmental side. They worked in quite social jobs (had been since the age of about 15), and no doubt had to be self-controlled and quick thinking about dealing with unwelcome attention. Most - perhaps all - male friends or colleagues would have thought they had won the lottery if she'd dated them. She was also - and I think this does have to be part of it - very physically beautiful.

What I noticed about her style over time - when having chance to see or hear their interactions - was that it could be, underneath the charm, quite subtly manipulative, too. Speaking to someone about tax codes - got her way, probably successfully in getting the other party to bend the rules a bit. Exchange with a doctor about a test that would be very, very unlikely to be arranged for someone of that age - yep, didn't take long (not that this was a bad thing, it's just that most of the population would be sent away and told: no, it won't be; not old enough). There are certainly other examples here, but too specific.
That does point to confidence, quick reactions, and self-value to a fairly high extent, I suppose.

SerafinasGoose · 23/07/2023 12:49

Mayhem3 · 23/07/2023 12:39

I’m not sure why you wouldn’t use the word bitchy if someone was acting that way.

Why not just be honest.
This is probably why you are not as well liked as the woman in question because you see bitchy behaviour but refuse to acknowledge it.
That’s not a person people want to be associated with.

You come across as fake if you refuse to believe that some people can be bitchy.

I find it sad that if a women is seen as being well liked and a nice person it must be because she’s being fake.

This is probably why you are not as well liked as the woman in question because you see bitchy behaviour but refuse to acknowledge it.

You know nothing about me whatsoever. You have no idea whether or not people choose to associate with me. I'm pixels on the internet. (Pixels that generally tend not to spell out the word 'b-i-t-c-h', or other unpleasant pejoratives used to describe women.

It's a mere online discussion. No need to make it so personal.

Verbena17 · 23/07/2023 12:49

KittensandPerverts · 23/07/2023 12:03

I couldn't think of anything worse than everyone wanting to be friends with me and strangers queuing up to pour out their life stories that I don't give a shit about. Thank God for my resting bitch face.

Love it! 😂🙌

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/07/2023 12:47

I think you’re either like it or you’re not - sorry!

I know someone whose son is a massively magnetic personality and other kids are just drawn to him - he isn’t doing anything it’s just the way he is.

Im not like it so not saying it in a smug way. I get on with people fine but I’m not someone who everyone thinks is amazing. I’m average likability I guess!

SerafinasGoose · 23/07/2023 12:46

Devonshiregal · 23/07/2023 12:36

So what word would you use to describe this sort of behaviour? Genuinely asking as it is a word everyone knows what it means. You know exactly what sort of behaviour is being described when it is used. I mean, is it because it’s traditionally been used for women you have an issue with it? I’d used it to describe a man’s behaviour too if they were, indeed’ being bitchy.

you can’t pretend some women (and some men) aren’t [insert new word here]? So what do you suggest we all use.

ps aren’t most words which are used negatively going to come from a historically insulting place because they are (of course) insulting? How do we be honest and [bitch] about our foes if we aren’t allowed to use words that have ever been thought of as insulting?

Note how often this word is used about women. Now note how often it's used about men.

Yes, this the reason I have an issue with it. It's misogynistic.

Behaviour which in women is lambasted as 'bitchy' or 'bossy' is often viewed in much milder terms as 'assertiveness' when the same behaviour is engaged in by men.

If you don't like someone's behaviour the right thing to do is either challenge the deed (not the person) in an adult manner, or to withdraw and disengage. You can do both these things without turning it into a playground fight or calling people pejorative names.

And it's very easy not to involve yourself in idle gossip. You say nothing. And if someone tries to draw you into it, you don't reciprocate.

I'd have thought the above self-explanatory, but I suppose it depends where you want to expend your energies.

DahliaMacNamara · 23/07/2023 12:45

One of my friends is a bit like this. Not loud, but outgoing, easy company and easy on the eye too. Most people do love her, genuinely, but I was surprised recently to discover that she has her detractors. I don't know what their problem is, but hey. Can't please everyone. I don't suppose she's that bothered.

I could never become like her. I look too grumpy for a start, and unless there's immediate chemistry I can give off the wrong vibes at first. I've never really wanted to be different, though.