Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grammar and teachers

238 replies

Usersooty · 22/07/2023 17:36

I went to a popular theme park last week. Masses of school trips.

I heard so many teachers/TA’s speaking using grammatically incorrect language. It really shocked me and as we waited in (endless) queues I listened to lots of “we haven’t got no snacks”, “we’ll go toilet after this” etc etc.

I have never heard a single member of staff at my childrens schools speak like this. I’d be really concerned if they did.

It made me quite sad for the children being taught/supported academically by them.

I didn’t stare, I didn’t comment. I wasn’t rude at all. Prepared to get flamed, but AIBU to be surprised by this?

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 23/07/2023 07:52

You don't need to be highly educated to use correct grammar. It is taught at primary school!

Not really. It wasn't much until the SATs reforms about 7 years ago, and even since those, certain specific grammar is crammed for the SATs and then it's dropped. I certainly wouldn't call it a well-rounded education in how to speak and write grammatically correct English. I'm 51 and have been an MFL teacher for 27 years. I learned all my English grammar via Latin and MFL, and for all my career we have had to explain English grammar in order to help teach MFL grammar.

i don't know if there was a golden age when British kids really were taught English grammar properly, but if so it was certainly before my parents' generation.

2mummies1baby · 23/07/2023 07:05

Gwenhwyfar · 22/07/2023 20:44

Then they weren't taught the standard written language adequately. Someone using it in speech doesn't mean that they wouldn't know how to use a different register in writing. As mentioned above, children code switch, and so do adults.

It's incredibly difficult to teach children standard English when they've spent their entire lives hearing people speak non-standard English. I have been a teacher for 10 years (upper KS2) and am yet to meet a child who can code switch.

supersop60 · 23/07/2023 06:33

Gwenhwyfar · 22/07/2023 19:50

"There is a huge difference between accents (the way words are pronounced), dialects (a language specific to a geographical area), and bad grammar/sloppy English."

Sounds like you don't understand what a dialect is. Do some basic research and you will see that dialects have their own grammar.

I do understand that. I'm a Black Country girl myself. There's a time and place, and I would never speak in my dialect to my students. I would also correct them if they spoke to me in bad grammar. Eg Yo am, should be You are.

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 23/07/2023 00:53

tulippa · 23/07/2023 00:29

What is 'properly'? The dialect spoken in affluent areas of London and the Southeast?

Plenty of people from the North and Midlands speak perfectly correct grammar. Many of them do.

tulippa · 23/07/2023 00:29

homeishere · 22/07/2023 21:23

Of course you’re not being unreasonable. Teachers should speak properly. Children learn constantly from those around them, and correct grammar has nothing to do with local dialect and everything to do with a proper education.

But you’ll have plenty on here flaming you for being snobbish. Just be glad your children don’t attend those schools!

What is 'properly'? The dialect spoken in affluent areas of London and the Southeast?

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 22/07/2023 23:38

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 23:33

@MyGuineaPigIs007 no offence taken . It really is that bad, we even struggle to get teachers in , which is why I have been covering so many lessons.

The expectations are high, but the desire for things to actually change and support are low. That's what bothers me. Even OP's only "solution " to the problem was some pie in the sky, "if I was in government I would..." but nothing tangible or realistic.

You pay peanuts, you get monkeys. I'm a very well trained and educated monkey, and would still fall massively short from some people's expectations of school staff.

It's such a shame and I can understand the strikes.

Flowers
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 23:33

@MyGuineaPigIs007 no offence taken . It really is that bad, we even struggle to get teachers in , which is why I have been covering so many lessons.

The expectations are high, but the desire for things to actually change and support are low. That's what bothers me. Even OP's only "solution " to the problem was some pie in the sky, "if I was in government I would..." but nothing tangible or realistic.

You pay peanuts, you get monkeys. I'm a very well trained and educated monkey, and would still fall massively short from some people's expectations of school staff.

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 22/07/2023 23:18

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 23:04

@MyGuineaPigIs007 the thing is, a lot of teachers use their regional dialects, which aren't standard English. They also went to school, went to uni, went through teacher training, many of them passed with flying colours and they still use it. So yes, in a way you do expect higher standards from TAs than a bog standard education in primary school. Also, let's not forget that grammar was entirely dismissed for a period of time and it took a while to actually implement and actually show results when it came back "in", so once again , if they are a certain age , it would only be TA's that had a higher education that picked up the rules.

As an aside, when I first started as a TA , there was a lot of competition and at the very least we had to write a letter on the spot and be able to accurately and quickly do the Maths and Reading SATS papers. Schools back then could afford to be picky since the job wasn't too bad and pretty basic , despite the wage being low. Now we are massively struggling to recruit, which is to be expected since I've spent entire weeks this year teaching for at least half a day in different classes different subjects.

Ah, I see. I hadn't realised the recruiting issue was so dire. Apologies for any offence I may have caused.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 23:04

@MyGuineaPigIs007 the thing is, a lot of teachers use their regional dialects, which aren't standard English. They also went to school, went to uni, went through teacher training, many of them passed with flying colours and they still use it. So yes, in a way you do expect higher standards from TAs than a bog standard education in primary school. Also, let's not forget that grammar was entirely dismissed for a period of time and it took a while to actually implement and actually show results when it came back "in", so once again , if they are a certain age , it would only be TA's that had a higher education that picked up the rules.

As an aside, when I first started as a TA , there was a lot of competition and at the very least we had to write a letter on the spot and be able to accurately and quickly do the Maths and Reading SATS papers. Schools back then could afford to be picky since the job wasn't too bad and pretty basic , despite the wage being low. Now we are massively struggling to recruit, which is to be expected since I've spent entire weeks this year teaching for at least half a day in different classes different subjects.

surreygirl1987 · 22/07/2023 23:01

Oh ffs really! I say things like "go toilet" "were'z me mam", "I live an ouse, "am going t'uddersfield", "get ya coat on", "I'll eat owt". But I wouldn't write it down like that! 🙄
Eevrbody talked like that when I was growing up. Even my teachers

But you might write it down like that if that was ALL you were ever exposed to! If you hear standard English elsewhere, or read a reasonable amount, then that's fine - but if you are ONLY exposed to non-standard English, then obviously that is going to form the basis of your ability to communicate in any context!

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 22/07/2023 22:43

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 22:16

@MyGuineaPigIs007 you try and recruit highly educated,very well spoken TA's with great and extensive subject knowledge for 14k a year(if lucky). And for that generous sum also expect them to teach, do interventions, be spat ,sworn and kicked at and so on. Go on.

I do agree TAs are underpaid and I think it's disgusting . Most of them so such a great job, my sister has been both a TA and a teacher. But it's not hard to learn basic grammar, and it should be a minimum requirement.

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 22/07/2023 22:41

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 22:16

@MyGuineaPigIs007 you try and recruit highly educated,very well spoken TA's with great and extensive subject knowledge for 14k a year(if lucky). And for that generous sum also expect them to teach, do interventions, be spat ,sworn and kicked at and so on. Go on.

You don't need to be highly educated to use correct grammar. It is taught at primary school!

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 22:16

@MyGuineaPigIs007 you try and recruit highly educated,very well spoken TA's with great and extensive subject knowledge for 14k a year(if lucky). And for that generous sum also expect them to teach, do interventions, be spat ,sworn and kicked at and so on. Go on.

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 22/07/2023 22:08

Houseplantmad · 22/07/2023 17:47

Have you seen what TAs are paid?

Whatever they are paid they should do their job properly including setting an example for children by using correct grammar, speaking The Kings English.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 22/07/2023 22:06

homeishere · 22/07/2023 21:23

Of course you’re not being unreasonable. Teachers should speak properly. Children learn constantly from those around them, and correct grammar has nothing to do with local dialect and everything to do with a proper education.

But you’ll have plenty on here flaming you for being snobbish. Just be glad your children don’t attend those schools!

"We/you was" is part of some local dialects for example. Obviously not standard English, but still a dialect.

Sherrystrull · 22/07/2023 21:52

surreygirl1987 · 22/07/2023 21:36

It's possible to use accent, dialect and standard English, and the differences between them as teaching points

Well yes of course. That is very valuable and I would be surprised if any school DIDN'T cover elements of this - we certainly do. But this isn't the same as being regularly exposed to standard English!

All schools will cover it. It's part of the National curriculum. I also think there is a massive difference between the occasional member of staff speaking in a non standard way and worrying that children aren't regularly exposed to standard English.

saraclara · 22/07/2023 21:38

LolaSmiles · 22/07/2023 19:39

From the update posts it sounds like the OP is seeking a thread to rubbish the education system and the staff within it.

I wish I thought she was.

Before I left teaching, I was incredibly frustrated by the SPAG level of some of the teaching staff at my school (including the head). It was really embarrassing to see class information put on the website littered with spelling and grammar errors. Each class teacher had to put a weekly news item on their page, and some made me wince. I ended up asking to be given access to edit the site at the end of each Friday (hopefully before parents had chance to see the errors!)

Our TAs were amazing at what we needed from them, but yes, their grammar in speech could be VERY poor. That didn't worry me in our sector (many children being non-verbal anyway) but I can quite imagine that in the mainstream schools in our area (once voted the shittest town in the UK) there would be the same issue.

Realistically, the recruitment issues are reducing the pool of talent, both in teaching and classroom support. I'd be among the first to say that SPAG isn't everything (particularly in TAs - one of my best ever was almost functionally illiterate) but pretending it isn't an issue in some areas and some school phases (am I right in thinking that you're in secondary?) is unhelpful.

surreygirl1987 · 22/07/2023 21:36

It's possible to use accent, dialect and standard English, and the differences between them as teaching points

Well yes of course. That is very valuable and I would be surprised if any school DIDN'T cover elements of this - we certainly do. But this isn't the same as being regularly exposed to standard English!

supersonicginandtonic · 22/07/2023 21:36

Oh ffs really! I say things like "go toilet" "were'z me mam", "I live an ouse, "am going t'uddersfield", "get ya coat on", "I'll eat owt". But I wouldn't write it down like that! 🙄
Eevrbody talked like that when I was growing up. Even my teachers

surreygirl1987 · 22/07/2023 21:34

I’m a TA in a prestigious grammar school, and I work with one of the most inspirational English teachers you could ever hope to meet. I have a regional accent-he trusts me completely to support his pupils.

But you're talking about accent. That is different.

OoohLaLaLa · 22/07/2023 21:33

How do you know the job titles?

user9630721458 · 22/07/2023 21:30

I do actually get the point that children can learn to speak and write in different ways. My teen's conversations are almost a different language to me, with lots of 'bruv' and 'innit.' I haven't seen him try to write an essay that way, or talk to adults like that. It's pretty interesting really.

homeishere · 22/07/2023 21:23

Of course you’re not being unreasonable. Teachers should speak properly. Children learn constantly from those around them, and correct grammar has nothing to do with local dialect and everything to do with a proper education.

But you’ll have plenty on here flaming you for being snobbish. Just be glad your children don’t attend those schools!

Sherrystrull · 22/07/2023 21:21

It's possible to use accent, dialect and standard English, and the differences between them as teaching points.

For example, I explain to my class how the ways things I say in my accent are different from how others may say them and are different from how we spell and write them in formal writing.

Take the word 'basket' for example. The children know it is spelt with an 'e' while in our accent we say it as as 'I'.

It forms discussions and lessons about the wonders and intricacies of English and is actually useful learning for all children as they meet people who speak in completely different ways.

onlyamam · 22/07/2023 21:16

Usersooty · 22/07/2023 18:19

@Antoninus I think teaching children correct grammar and being able to use it while they are at work is a basic requirement for teachers.

I have been a parent through 5 schools now and have never heard a member of staff speak in such a lazy manner. Ever. Lots of accents. Lots of staff who were not born in this country. But all professionals who used grammar correctly.

Well, if you've been a parent through five schools you must be an expert on teaching.

I've been a patient in five hospitals and I'm a consultant paediatrician.

Swipe left for the next trending thread