Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.

718 replies

TRexTara · 22/07/2023 12:38

I don't know what these people think they are achieving. I think the mum was in a cab which looks like an electric car anyway, they refuse to let her get past.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/23127608/furious-mum-screams-baby-hospital-just-stop-oil/?utmcampaign=nativeeshare&utmsource=sharebarrnative&utmmedium=sharebarr_native

OP posts:
Thread gallery
43
StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 13:09

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 12:54

No, I’m going by the CO2 and other greenhouse emissions data gathered abd published by REAL climate scientists for the past fifty years.

The £20bn in investment to oil companies isn’t investing in burning more oil or generating CO2 emissions because those have been cut by almost half down to 1850 levels.

As I said upthread as an example we need millions of barrels of oil just to run our wind farms. We don’t burn all the fossil fuels, we process them into lubricants and materials necessary for the operation of carbon neutral energy generation. We also need oil for the production of all medicinal ointments and lotions. It’s huge in the cosmetic industry as well. Oil is also needed to manufacture fertiliser so we can grow enough crops on less land to feed the population.

That’s what JSO and you do not get, that drilling for oil and having oil doesn’t mean it’s all going to be burned to generate electricity or for petrol in cars creating CO2.

I don’t think the 100 licenses is a lie, it’s just not the massive problem you think it is as oil licenses and oil doesn’t automatically mean more CO2 emissions. And the facts and data show that CO2 emissions in the U.K. have been reduced faster here than by everyone else in the entire world except for two other smaller countries.

We are making changes at home but this is the insight that makes me question JSO

We are doing well in the U.K.

AIBot · 23/07/2023 13:05

From the LA Times - we still get more than 80% of our energy from burning fossil fuels. Global greenhouse gas emissions have rebounded, climbing to new all-time highs after a brief downturn during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Global greenhouse gas emissions at all-time high, study finds

Scientists say world is burning through ‘carbon budget’ that can be emitted while staying below 1.5C

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jun/08/global-greenhouse-gas-emissions-at-all-time-high-study-finds

Azaeleasinbloom · 23/07/2023 13:02

@MillicentBystandr

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/07/2023 13:00

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 23/07/2023 12:41

@Thebestwaytoscareatory why are you still alive then?

Ah that old chestnut, how long did it take you to come up with such a witty and insightful retort?

I'm still alive because I don't want to die surprisingly.

Plus it's much better that someone like me, who's willing to make changes and campaign for global action and equality, is around than someone who thinks it's their god given right to over consume and do whatever the fuck they want, while the poorest in the world suffer the consequences of their greed.

If I killed myself I wouldn't be able to call-out idiots like that and make them feel uncomfortable would I?

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 12:54

ivykaty44 · 23/07/2023 07:04

You think successive governments have been telling you the truth?

do you think that giving £20 billion more to fossil fuel producers than renewables in the last 8 years is a lie?

£20 billion would have paid for every household in the U.K. to have solar panels on the roof

do you think that the process of the U.K. government awarding over 100 licences to companies hoping to extract oil since 2021 is a lie

No, I’m going by the CO2 and other greenhouse emissions data gathered abd published by REAL climate scientists for the past fifty years.

The £20bn in investment to oil companies isn’t investing in burning more oil or generating CO2 emissions because those have been cut by almost half down to 1850 levels.

As I said upthread as an example we need millions of barrels of oil just to run our wind farms. We don’t burn all the fossil fuels, we process them into lubricants and materials necessary for the operation of carbon neutral energy generation. We also need oil for the production of all medicinal ointments and lotions. It’s huge in the cosmetic industry as well. Oil is also needed to manufacture fertiliser so we can grow enough crops on less land to feed the population.

That’s what JSO and you do not get, that drilling for oil and having oil doesn’t mean it’s all going to be burned to generate electricity or for petrol in cars creating CO2.

I don’t think the 100 licenses is a lie, it’s just not the massive problem you think it is as oil licenses and oil doesn’t automatically mean more CO2 emissions. And the facts and data show that CO2 emissions in the U.K. have been reduced faster here than by everyone else in the entire world except for two other smaller countries.

AIBot · 23/07/2023 12:50

WildUnchartedWaters · 23/07/2023 12:37

What?

No.

Do you always advise the victims of peoples shittu behaviour to go and SUPPORT their cause?

By urging politicians to stop new fossil fuel licences, you’d be supporting the stances of all the climate scientists and universities around the world with any scientific credibility, thousands of humanitarian charities around the world who are dealing with the aftermath of climate related disasters. Thousands of nature charities around the world who are witnessing nature destruction and trying to slow it down, including the Wildlife Trusts and the RSPB.

Suggestions of what we can do from one of the worlds top universities for science:
https://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action/amp-index.html

JSO are an insignificant UK pressure group.

9 things you can do about climate change

With so many experts on climate change here at Imperial, many people ask us what they personally can do about it?

https://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action/amp-index.html

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/07/2023 12:50

WildUnchartedWaters · 23/07/2023 12:38

But that's a silly point

I can be affected by climate change without being a fan girl of a shower of numpties. It's not one or the other

What's a silly point?

That we're too selfish, as a collective, to do what is needed to avoid the catastrophic impacts of climate change or that I'll find it funny when the naysayers realise they're well and truly fucked?

Don't think either are silly tbh, maybe the latter is a bit childish but if I'm going to suffer I want those who exasperated the situation to suffer too. If the posters outraged at JSO, most of whom aren't even affected by the road blocks, redirected their ire towards the government and demanded they took action on climate change JSO wouldn't need to protest.

WildUnchartedWaters · 23/07/2023 12:44

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 12:41

I don’t think just telling people what to be irritated by works.

That’s the problem for JSO they really do irritate people rather than get support for their cause

My blood pressure is fine though, it’s not like it’s me in that video. I doubt the mother’s is low in the moment

These cool kids go through life telling people not to get annoyed and taking sides with the other person, I assume. Perhaps they could start posting that on threads, irs a life changer.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 23/07/2023 12:41

@Thebestwaytoscareatory why are you still alive then?

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 12:41

AIBot · 23/07/2023 12:31

But annoyance at individuals achieves very little other than raising the blood pressure. Channel it into holding the fossil fuel industry and their enablers in Parliament and the press to account.

I don’t think just telling people what to be irritated by works.

That’s the problem for JSO they really do irritate people rather than get support for their cause

My blood pressure is fine though, it’s not like it’s me in that video. I doubt the mother’s is low in the moment

WildUnchartedWaters · 23/07/2023 12:38

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/07/2023 12:36

Humans have done far more damage ro polar bear populations (and pretty much every other species too) than anything else. Anthropogenic climate change is just another way we go about killing things.

On a planetary level burning us out of existence will just be some short-term pain for long-term gain.

It's beyond clear that we are far too selfish to even act in our own best interests, let alone another species, so as long as we are the dominant species we will decimate everything else on this planet.

It will be funny to see all the "oh how terrible are JSO protesters" and "I'm not changing my lifestyle / diet / habits" posters coming back on here to moan about how awful it is that they can't find fresh water to drink or enough food to feed their families once the shit really hits the fan though. They'll do it without a hint of irony too.

But that's a silly point

I can be affected by climate change without being a fan girl of a shower of numpties. It's not one or the other

WildUnchartedWaters · 23/07/2023 12:37

AIBot · 23/07/2023 12:31

But annoyance at individuals achieves very little other than raising the blood pressure. Channel it into holding the fossil fuel industry and their enablers in Parliament and the press to account.

What?

No.

Do you always advise the victims of peoples shittu behaviour to go and SUPPORT their cause?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/07/2023 12:36

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/07/2023 11:57

PostItInABook · Yesterday 20:14
The human race needs clearing out quite frankly. We are a disgrace as a species. Climate change is a good thing for the world overall. Get rid of all of us and let the more civilised creatures take over”

Bollocks. Climate change is good for the world overall? Yea, bring it on.
Tell that to polar bears.

Humans have done far more damage ro polar bear populations (and pretty much every other species too) than anything else. Anthropogenic climate change is just another way we go about killing things.

On a planetary level burning us out of existence will just be some short-term pain for long-term gain.

It's beyond clear that we are far too selfish to even act in our own best interests, let alone another species, so as long as we are the dominant species we will decimate everything else on this planet.

It will be funny to see all the "oh how terrible are JSO protesters" and "I'm not changing my lifestyle / diet / habits" posters coming back on here to moan about how awful it is that they can't find fresh water to drink or enough food to feed their families once the shit really hits the fan though. They'll do it without a hint of irony too.

AIBot · 23/07/2023 12:31

But annoyance at individuals achieves very little other than raising the blood pressure. Channel it into holding the fossil fuel industry and their enablers in Parliament and the press to account.

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 12:12

AIBot · 23/07/2023 12:03

Yes. Feeding peoples’ sense of outrage sells papers. The food shortages, fires and floods that will increase as time passes are genuinely scary, and for some people, the outrage these stories bring helps them avoid thinking about the actual issues for a while. I have found myself doing this but now try to stand back and ask what purpose my outrage is serving.

The logic goes something like - ‘that’s outrageous, these people at JSO doing this antisocial thing are doing it for the climate. and I don’t support their actions, so why should I support climate action?’

It feels like media manipulation and given the links between politicians, press and oil companies, I’m taking a more sceptical stance when I see this kind of thing. I personally try to focus on what I can do to make the future less bleak for my children.

I personally try to focus on what I can do to make the future less bleak for my children

Me too, in a low key way. Although that has zero to do with JSO. My sympathy is with the mother here. I’m not sure they are helping, they just seem to be a handy way to get people annoyed

BordoisAgain · 23/07/2023 12:11

If JSO were actually serious about reducing emissions and reducing reliance on fossil fuels then they would be lobbying and protesting against the people and institutions who actually have the clout to do something about it.

Maybe when they start protesting outside the Chinese embassy (for example), blocking the entrance and spraying orange paint, etc. then I might start believing they actually believe in their own cause.

As it stands at the moment, they are just a group of privileged hypocritical wankers who are acting in their own smug self interest and deluding themselves they are actually 'doing something'.

WildUnchartedWaters · 23/07/2023 12:07

People can write pages and pages about climate change all they like. Nobody is denying that.

What we are asking is what these shower of numpties are doing about it rather than pjssing absolutely everyone off.

Even the fence sitters on here who insist o arguing tiny points havent got anything to say.

I've yet to see anyone, here or online, or them themselves, show me what it is they're actually doing.

AIBot · 23/07/2023 12:03

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 11:08

That’s slightly different to pp which was a broader

‘But climate change catastrophes abroad don’t relate to people here and won’t sell papers’

Someone said on another thread the climate crisis will be the three fs - flood, fires and food shortages

I think the media is covering those, because they are a big deal, but because they sell papers so I don’t agree with that line

On press coverage for that specific issue you may be right, I haven’t given it enough thought yet to say either way

Yes. Feeding peoples’ sense of outrage sells papers. The food shortages, fires and floods that will increase as time passes are genuinely scary, and for some people, the outrage these stories bring helps them avoid thinking about the actual issues for a while. I have found myself doing this but now try to stand back and ask what purpose my outrage is serving.

The logic goes something like - ‘that’s outrageous, these people at JSO doing this antisocial thing are doing it for the climate. and I don’t support their actions, so why should I support climate action?’

It feels like media manipulation and given the links between politicians, press and oil companies, I’m taking a more sceptical stance when I see this kind of thing. I personally try to focus on what I can do to make the future less bleak for my children.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/07/2023 11:57

PostItInABook · Yesterday 20:14
The human race needs clearing out quite frankly. We are a disgrace as a species. Climate change is a good thing for the world overall. Get rid of all of us and let the more civilised creatures take over”

Bollocks. Climate change is good for the world overall? Yea, bring it on.
Tell that to polar bears.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/07/2023 11:53

BeeHappy12 · Yesterday 19:15

I mean lots of reasons like a dermatology appointment for eczema as one example”

You really are clutching at straws now. Have you any idea of the misery eczema can cause?

No one has any right to prevent another person (or animal for that matter) from accessing medical treatment, however minor you may speculate their condition to be.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/07/2023 11:38

Flickersy · Yesterday 17:04
If your child was that ill why would you waste time arguing when you could ask the taxi driver to turn around and take a side street? JSO are a pain but they don't block all the roads - just go round.

I rather suspect the baby was not in a critical state.”

What do you base your suspicion on?

Did you not see the film? The taxi was surrounded by other vehicles in a jam caused by JSO.

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 11:13

Plus funding and political links are in both directions. Either renewable profits or not, interested parties give money.

So donations are there, I would have to look at other things over that

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 11:08

AIBot · 23/07/2023 10:58

There is some press coverage of the government’s links to fossil fuel companies reported in the Guardian, but its circulation is not large compared to the tabloids, who are still peddling the falsehood that we need to extract all we can from the North Sea for UK energy security.

Imagine if the Daily Mail told the truth about fossil fuel subsidies, the links between firms and political parties, and reported accurately on green energy - how it would help the economy AND consumers with the cost of living crisis as well as cutting carbon.

That’s slightly different to pp which was a broader

‘But climate change catastrophes abroad don’t relate to people here and won’t sell papers’

Someone said on another thread the climate crisis will be the three fs - flood, fires and food shortages

I think the media is covering those, because they are a big deal, but because they sell papers so I don’t agree with that line

On press coverage for that specific issue you may be right, I haven’t given it enough thought yet to say either way

AIBot · 23/07/2023 10:58

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 10:36

News about these catastrophes are international and not limited to British papers btw.

Of course not.

But it’s interesting the criticism is taking both forms. I’ve read more criticism of U.K. media using it to sell news than not. But then again that’s part of mn decides U.K. gets it wrong theme that never dies.

I’d say it can’t be both overplayed and ignored but the reality probably is that both do sell.

The JSO scenario because they irritate people and the catastrophes, which are leading news. I don’t think the idea you went with that it’s not being covered is true at all. You just need to turn on the radio etc

There is some press coverage of the government’s links to fossil fuel companies reported in the Guardian, but its circulation is not large compared to the tabloids, who are still peddling the falsehood that we need to extract all we can from the North Sea for UK energy security.

Imagine if the Daily Mail told the truth about fossil fuel subsidies, the links between firms and political parties, and reported accurately on green energy - how it would help the economy AND consumers with the cost of living crisis as well as cutting carbon.

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 10:36

VaccineSticker · 23/07/2023 10:31

You are talking about climate change deniers who want to downplay these disasters and/or people who choose to want to ignore them as it’s too painful to fathom.
News about these catastrophes are international and not limited to British papers btw.

News about these catastrophes are international and not limited to British papers btw.

Of course not.

But it’s interesting the criticism is taking both forms. I’ve read more criticism of U.K. media using it to sell news than not. But then again that’s part of mn decides U.K. gets it wrong theme that never dies.

I’d say it can’t be both overplayed and ignored but the reality probably is that both do sell.

The JSO scenario because they irritate people and the catastrophes, which are leading news. I don’t think the idea you went with that it’s not being covered is true at all. You just need to turn on the radio etc