Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.

718 replies

TRexTara · 22/07/2023 12:38

I don't know what these people think they are achieving. I think the mum was in a cab which looks like an electric car anyway, they refuse to let her get past.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/23127608/furious-mum-screams-baby-hospital-just-stop-oil/?utmcampaign=nativeeshare&utmsource=sharebarrnative&utmmedium=sharebarr_native

OP posts:
Thread gallery
43
BordoisAgain · 23/07/2023 14:07

Yep, as I said in my post, when they start protesting the people and institutions who actually have the clout to make the changes they want then I might start believing they actually want change instead of their own smug self satisfying virtue signalling.

Wanderingowl · 23/07/2023 14:05

Decades of global scientific research, using multiple models, shows without a doubt, that we are causing global warming.

It really, really, really doesn't. I'm not a climate change denier, in fact I have a 30 year history of serious environmental activism. But in the last few years I've actually started to read the scientific papers and the surveys of scientists and have realised that we are constantly been shown the absolute worst case scenario, taken from poorly gathered data, as if it was a sure thing. We are constantly being told that there is scientific consensus, when no such consensus exists.

The main actual consensus is that we have nowhere near enough accurate data or time spent on climatology to have any genuine clue what effect human activity is having on the global climate. It's a field of science in it's very real infancy and we are not a point where we can make anything close to accurate predictions. Any scientist claiming to know for a fact what is happening, is bullshitting. All that exist are theories, early theories, not even true scientific theories. Because, far, far, far too much is still unknown.

It doesn't mean that we aren't causing damage to the environment. Because we are and a lot of changes in the technologies we use need to be made. We are an extremely polluting species and that has very real consequences. We have to get better and until we do, people and other living things will suffer the consequences. But, by focussing on the unknown as if we actually know. By lying about things we can't possibly know. What happens is that we ignore real issues due to looking at a 'bigger picture' that possibly doesn't exist.

JudgeJ · 23/07/2023 13:58

I think the point being made is these idiots wouldnt try this shit in Russia, america or China or Scotland or in lower class areas

Or round here where there are plenty of slurry trucks fully loaded!

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:54

NoNonsensePotato · 23/07/2023 13:51

They also blinded/severely maimed innocent postal workers who were unfortunate enough to have the letter bombs go off while handling the post.

Exactly. Shocking the number of people who think the suffragettes got us thr vote. They set us back. They just claimed credit after the fact. JSO is cut from the same cloth. They’ll set us back and when we keep succeeding despite them, they’ll try and claim credit.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:52

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:28

MillicentBystandr

Actually, the current government de-invested in Climate Change policies, maintained oil subsidies, gave the go ahead to new oil exploration etc etc. Its own advisors say it’s not doing enough. You are misinformed.

No, they have not. Nothing wrong with oil subsidies or new oil exploration because we need oil for many industries that do not involve burning the oil. If you don’t burn it, you don’t produce CO2 which means it’s carbon zero.

Mariposa26 · 23/07/2023 13:51

ivykaty44 · 22/07/2023 14:43

you've been conditioned to only travel by car, but im the foolish one. its quicker to travel by bike taxi than it is by motorised taxi in London - but don't let fact get in the way of your poor insults

How is she taking her baby on a bike taxi?

NoNonsensePotato · 23/07/2023 13:51

They also blinded/severely maimed innocent postal workers who were unfortunate enough to have the letter bombs go off while handling the post.

NoNonsensePotato · 23/07/2023 13:49

MillicentBystandr · 22/07/2023 15:13

The suffragettes didn’t win us the vote. 😟

It was the suffragists who got women the vote.

The suffragettes were terrorists of the ISIS variety. They planted bombs in public places (churches, the Theatre Royal, etc) and would've killed loads of innocent civilians had their bombs successfully detonated.

It's literally no better than the Manchester Arena bombing.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:49

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:41

MillicentBystandr

The ‘what about other countries?’ is just a feeble excuse not to change.

I have written to my MP and signed countless petitions over the last decades and my experience is that on those matters it is rare that government has acted in line with what is needed in terms of climate change.

It’s not an excuse because we have already changed and are on track to get to net zero by 2050. That’s no small feat in a country with the population growth we have. Please look at the data - it is so obvious that we have changed and this occurred over thirty years ago. It’s our history, not our future.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:47

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:38

MillicentBystandr · Today 13:35
Yet, still the Government has made decision after decision that put the profits of the oil industry first. They have made policies that put profit before people and planet - relentlessly. It’s own advisors say it’s not doing enough.

They really haven’t done that. Yes, more needs to be done but let’s not erase all the good work that has been accomplished so far and is being done.

Erm. They absolutely have. There has been some movement in the right direction in the last decade. But not nearly enough.

So the #1 cause of climate change is CO2 emissions. You are saying we’ve only made progress “in the right direction in the last decade”

Do you think the sort of reductions we have actually accomplished since 1990 would have been possible without the government prioritising reduction of CO2 emissions? By, how did you say relentlessly prioritising profits and oil companies over the environment?

Sorry, but if they had done what you accuse them of, then CO2 emissions would have increased on a business as usual line. They would not have decreased so dramatically.

JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
WildUnchartedWaters · 23/07/2023 13:42

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:41

MillicentBystandr

The ‘what about other countries?’ is just a feeble excuse not to change.

I have written to my MP and signed countless petitions over the last decades and my experience is that on those matters it is rare that government has acted in line with what is needed in terms of climate change.

I think the point being made is these idiots wouldnt try this shit in Russia, america or China or Scotland or in lower class areas

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:41

MillicentBystandr

The ‘what about other countries?’ is just a feeble excuse not to change.

I have written to my MP and signed countless petitions over the last decades and my experience is that on those matters it is rare that government has acted in line with what is needed in terms of climate change.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:41

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:36

BordoisAgain

Why the Chinese embassy? We emit more carbon per capita. And we buy tons of shit from China. China are investing VERY heavily in green technologies. Which is exactly what we should have been/should be doing. The ‘what about China’ argument doesn’t wash.

It also doesn’t make sense. Even if the above wasn’t the case. Why compare ourselves to the worst counties and emulate them? Why not look to the countries that are doing well and compare and learn? Or the countries effected first and worst and consider our duty?

We (the U.K.) don’t emit more carbon per capita than China.
But I agree in the sense that China is by no means one of the worst performing.

JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:38

MillicentBystandr · Today 13:35
Yet, still the Government has made decision after decision that put the profits of the oil industry first. They have made policies that put profit before people and planet - relentlessly. It’s own advisors say it’s not doing enough.

They really haven’t done that. Yes, more needs to be done but let’s not erase all the good work that has been accomplished so far and is being done.

Erm. They absolutely have. There has been some movement in the right direction in the last decade. But not nearly enough.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:37

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:31

MillicentBystandr

The figures you quote show some progress. But it is not enough. It’s own advisors say the UK Government are not doing enough. And, there could have been, could be, much more robust measures.

Like what? Seriously?! At some point we need to look to the rest of the world to do their bit. The U.K. is less than 1% of global emissions, when we get to net zero in 2050 it will have NO impact on climate change, and NO impact on global emissions. Our house is in order.

What needs to be done is really up to the rest of the world, and upthread I had listed the biggest carbon emitters that have a lot of work to do just to catch up to us.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:36

BordoisAgain

Why the Chinese embassy? We emit more carbon per capita. And we buy tons of shit from China. China are investing VERY heavily in green technologies. Which is exactly what we should have been/should be doing. The ‘what about China’ argument doesn’t wash.

It also doesn’t make sense. Even if the above wasn’t the case. Why compare ourselves to the worst counties and emulate them? Why not look to the countries that are doing well and compare and learn? Or the countries effected first and worst and consider our duty?

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:35

Yet, still the Government has made decision after decision that put the profits of the oil industry first. They have made policies that put profit before people and planet - relentlessly. It’s own advisors say it’s not doing enough.

They really haven’t done that. Yes, more needs to be done but let’s not erase all the good work that has been accomplished so far and is being done.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:31

MillicentBystandr

The figures you quote show some progress. But it is not enough. It’s own advisors say the UK Government are not doing enough. And, there could have been, could be, much more robust measures.

AIBot · 23/07/2023 13:29

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:17

If the posters outraged at JSO, most of whom aren't even affected by the road blocks, redirected their ire towards the government and demanded they took action on climate change JSO wouldn't need to protest.

The successive U.K. Governments have taken action on climate change for the past 30yrs and with great success. That’s why JSO doesn’t need to protest.

Why hello Tory party HQ 😂👋

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:28

MillicentBystandr

Actually, the current government de-invested in Climate Change policies, maintained oil subsidies, gave the go ahead to new oil exploration etc etc. Its own advisors say it’s not doing enough. You are misinformed.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:27

AIBot · 23/07/2023 13:05

From the LA Times - we still get more than 80% of our energy from burning fossil fuels. Global greenhouse gas emissions have rebounded, climbing to new all-time highs after a brief downturn during the COVID-19 pandemic.

“We” = the globe
As I said, we and our government are a world leader on cutting carbon emissions and transitioning away from fossil fuels.

Ive quoted the 43% stat for our energy production with carbon zero sources, this was in 2022. However as you can see, yet more progress has been made:

As of 2023, the most recent data from the National Grid (released in 2020) indicated that zero carbon sources generated around 50% of the electricity produced in the UK; this has increased from a meagre 20% back in 2010.
https://energyguide.org.uk/electricity-generation-uk-sources/?amp=1

Electricity Generation UK Sources in 2023

Where and how does the UK generate it's electricity? Is it all renewables? Or still mostly fossil fuels? Here we will explore the latest official figures.

https://energyguide.org.uk/electricity-generation-uk-sources/?amp=1

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:17

If the posters outraged at JSO, most of whom aren't even affected by the road blocks, redirected their ire towards the government and demanded they took action on climate change JSO wouldn't need to protest.

The successive U.K. Governments have taken action on climate change for the past 30yrs and with great success. That’s why JSO doesn’t need to protest.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:13

StefanosHill

The Government’s own advisors say we are not doing near enough, fast enough.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 13:13

AIBot · 23/07/2023 08:43

This is the problem isn’t it @ivykaty44

Oil and gas from the North Sea is sold on the open market so won’t lower our bills or improve energy security. All it will do is enrich the companies involved and any politicians taking backhanders. And make climate change worse.

If every household where it’s possible had rooftop solar panels, and UK solar firms were doing the installations, it would help the economy AND consumers with the cost of living crisis as well as cutting carbon. But until we get a change of government, where politicians are not in bed with fossil fuel companies, we cannot as a nation leverage these win win scenarios.

Oil and gas from the North Sea is sold on the open market so won’t lower our bills or improve energy security

More oil and gas plus the ability to store it will improve our energy security and lower bills. Right now we import more oil and far more gas than we export. This means our domestic consumption exceeds our domestic production of oil and gas.

The primary reason we export any oil or gas and our domestic energy bills are so high is because we do not have storage capacity.

(The UK imported £30.0 billion of oil in 2021 and exported £28.3 billion of oil. The UK imported £19.6 billion of gas in 2021 and exported £3.4 billion of gas.)

All it will do is enrich the companies involved and any politicians taking backhanders. And make climate change worse.

It won’t enrich them any more than they are already, right now they are charging profit on top of the cost+profit paid to foreign suppliers of oil and tons of gas. It won’t make climate change worse because more domestic oil and especially gas is only going to replace our dependency on imports while we are decreasing our use for energy production. Over half our electricity is now produced by carbon neutral green technologies like wind and solar- and that is only going to keep increasing.

If every household where it’s possible had rooftop solar panels, and UK solar firms were doing the installations, it would help the economy AND consumers with the cost of living crisis as well as cutting carbon.

No, it would increase carbon and pollution to be so dependent on roof top solar panels on everyone’s home. Due to long dark winters, and dark nights solar panels would need batteries to store excess energy generated in the sunlight. These batteries are an environmental nightmare both in terms of carbon to manufacture and the pollution caused by disposal at end of life. We do much better to not leave it to the individual, but have it done by large companies (which should be nationalised) and have our nation grid fed by a mix of green technologies so that solar can provide real time energy when it is sunny/day time and the other means like wind can pick up when solar is not producing (night, winter, etc). We also need power distribution centres because you can overload the grid on a super sunny day if everyone in the country had solar panels…and so we need solar and wind farms to be adjustable, able to be turned off and on to keep the power flow on the grid stable.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 13:10

So I’m not currently a JSO activist. BUT for the last 30 plus years I have signed petitions, donated to Greenpeace, joined in peaceful protests, written to my MP, changed my personal habits, supported others to do the same.

Decades of global scientific research, using multiple models, shows without a doubt, that we are causing global warming. Even the oil industry has finally admitted this. In turn that causes climate chaos and breakdown. The tiny minority of scientists that have any doubt are either not climate scientists and/or funded by the oil industry or linked in some way.

Yet, still the Government has made decision after decision that put the profits of the oil industry first. They have made policies that put profit before people and planet - relentlessly. It’s own advisors say it’s not doing enough.

We have already seen wilder weather. Increases in deaths and mortality. Crop failures. In this country. Across the world we have also seen mass migration as people move from areas that have become uninhabitable. All of this will get worse. We will no longer be able to guarantee enough food and water to keep our children alive. There will be more war and conflict over resources. There will more dangerous heatwaves, fires, floods and hurricanes. Sea levels will rise displacing millions and lessening the amount of habitable land further. I could go on.

Children across the world have already died due to climate changes and climate breakdown (eg recently two children were swept away by floods as three months worth of rain fell in Canada, causing floods).

So, critics of JSO. Tell me exactly what else I can do, other than acts of civil disobedience like this, because I am at a loss. I feel I’ve done every other possible thing.

I want to look my DC in the eye and say ‘I did what I could’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread