Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.

718 replies

TRexTara · 22/07/2023 12:38

I don't know what these people think they are achieving. I think the mum was in a cab which looks like an electric car anyway, they refuse to let her get past.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/23127608/furious-mum-screams-baby-hospital-just-stop-oil/?utmcampaign=nativeeshare&utmsource=sharebarrnative&utmmedium=sharebarr_native

OP posts:
Thread gallery
43
noodlebugz · 23/07/2023 21:06

Edit - FUNDING

noodlebugz · 23/07/2023 21:05

They’re just making everyone hate them. It doesn’t bear thinking about the what ifs if that baby had been super unwell. (I took my baby in a taxi to the hospital this year, he deteriorated in a and e and ended up in resus though I really don’t think we were ambulance unwell when we set off for hospital).
I bet the oil companies are finding just stop oil as it just makes them come accross as a bunch of out of touch soulless p**s that it really damages any genuine environmental cause.

ivykaty44 · 23/07/2023 20:16

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 17:55

What? Of course the cost of investment, operations and maintenance is a factor driving how much money renewables NEEDS or does not need!

so if oil is more expensive you think £20 Ben more should be spent? Make up your mind

ATerrorofLeftovers · 23/07/2023 19:47

Sigmama · 23/07/2023 18:56

Op, they are not 'winding everyone up and making the uk angry', they are winding you up and making you angry, as well as some others, but thankfully you are not everyone

If you think the majority of the UK population condone preventing babies from attending hospital appointments, stopping ambulances conveying desperately ill people to hospital and people being by the bedside of their dying parent, then you are living in cloud cuckoo land.

The majority of people are decent people with a sense of common humanity. Getting their backs up with idiotic, short-sighted student-level ‘protests’ that achieve the square root of fuck all that’s of any practical use is massively counterproductive. It’s switching people off from being concerned about climate change and making it look like a fringe subject only extremist idiots are interested in.

Don’t confuse the seriousness of climate change and the need to take action urgently with effective protest. This is serious enough that we need nuanced, intelligent pressure and to move the Overton window so that it becomes an issue on the doorstep when politicians come canvassing. It’s not an issue where any old shit will do.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 19:22

AIBot · 23/07/2023 18:31

I agree @LittleApartmentOnThePrairie - but the thread seems to be descending into a situation where some posters are planting misleading or false statements in order to make people feel that the UK has done enough and to encourage apathy.

Do people reading this thread trust the UN, the Met Office, NASA, universities, the Royal Society or randoms on a message board?

Right, every link you have posted is to a FAQ on the existence and cause of climate change. Not one of those organisations you listed has come out and claimed that the U.K. has not done enough towards reducing climate change causing emissions. Not one.

Talk about misleading!

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 19:14

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 18:02

We do not have our house in order!! Bullshit. We are investing in and subsidising new oil. We are not investing in renewables nearly as much. We are not insulating our homes. We are not collectively reducing our consumption. We are one of the worlds highest carbon emitters when you consider us globally.

We are investing in and subsidising new oil.
Ok, so “new oil” is not “more oil”, they’re a key misunderstanding you are not getting. Yes, we are licensing new sources of oil because each oil well does not have a limitless supply of oil. In total, even with the new oil sources, we will be using much less oil.

We are not investing in renewables nearly as much
When you view the £ investment in terms of return on investment by energy produced, we are investing more into renewables than into oil & gas. The proof is in the fact that 50% of our energy sources are now carbon zero renewables, up from 20% since 2010.

We are not collectively reducing our consumption.
Yes we have been and are. See charts (which I realise I have posted to you almost a dozen times now. You need to look at them.)

We are one of the worlds highest carbon emitters when you consider us globally
No, we are right at the world average for per capita, but this includes countries with low incomes, no infrastructure, high disease burden, war, malnutrition and so on. Compared to our peers in terms of the quality of life we have and infrastructure, the other high income countries, we are emitting less than HALF that average. JSO and XR don’t like that because it proves we do not have to sacrifice our modern lifestyle to reduce carbon emissions dramatically (more charts)

JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
DdraigGoch · 23/07/2023 19:02

What the differences between the metrics tell us is that the average Brit is reasonably clean
That should have read.

DdraigGoch · 23/07/2023 18:59

We are one of the worlds highest carbon emitters when you consider us globally.

42nd on the list if you're measuring per capita, or 12th in gross terms. So not in the top ten by any definition. What the differences between the metrics is that the average Brit is reasonably clean, it's the sheer number of us that is the issue. This country is overpopulated and overcrowded.

We can (and should) do better, of course. I notice that France is doing a fair bit better than us, whereas Germany's emissions are appalling. France is mostly nuclear powered, which Germany burnes lignite; we should follow the French example and build nuclear power stations.

I don't expect that many JSO protesters are part of Greens for Nuclear Power though.

JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
JSO prevent a mum taking her baby to hospital.
Sigmama · 23/07/2023 18:56

Op, they are not 'winding everyone up and making the uk angry', they are winding you up and making you angry, as well as some others, but thankfully you are not everyone

BordoisAgain · 23/07/2023 18:49

For the avoidance of doubt. I know climate change exists, I know we (globally and nationally) need to reduce carbon emissions.

I don't accept that the protests by JSO are doing anything to achieve anything and are hypocritical, self-serving and counter-productive.

MaybeNextTime8 · 23/07/2023 18:46

Sorry, posted too soon! Just not as immediate as someone caught in traffic. I don't always agree with their methods, but it's a serious issue for us all

MaybeNextTime8 · 23/07/2023 18:44

Honestly, many people are going to die due to climate change - it's just not as

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 18:37

AIBot · 23/07/2023 18:31

I agree @LittleApartmentOnThePrairie - but the thread seems to be descending into a situation where some posters are planting misleading or false statements in order to make people feel that the UK has done enough and to encourage apathy.

Do people reading this thread trust the UN, the Met Office, NASA, universities, the Royal Society or randoms on a message board?

How are they false when the posts are including charts?

I’ve just opened your links talking about climate change generally. I know about that. I’ve changed my habits due to that.

I don’t need convincing it exists

AIBot · 23/07/2023 18:31

I agree @LittleApartmentOnThePrairie - but the thread seems to be descending into a situation where some posters are planting misleading or false statements in order to make people feel that the UK has done enough and to encourage apathy.

Do people reading this thread trust the UN, the Met Office, NASA, universities, the Royal Society or randoms on a message board?

Causes of climate change

The evidence is clear: the main cause of climate change is burning fossil fuels such as oil, gas, and coal. When burnt, fossil fuels release carbon dioxide into the air, causing the planet to heat up.

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/climate-change/causes-of-climate-change

BordoisAgain · 23/07/2023 18:30

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 18:02

We do not have our house in order!! Bullshit. We are investing in and subsidising new oil. We are not investing in renewables nearly as much. We are not insulating our homes. We are not collectively reducing our consumption. We are one of the worlds highest carbon emitters when you consider us globally.

So what are protests that increase the amount of carbon being emitted doing exactly?

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 18:09

They have an assigned purpose, of course they are there to push their aims

That language is not factual or useful.

I can only take info from people who are really factual and clear

There’s so many people dialling up what they say for effect I just have to filter. That JSO press release is mad but the CCC suffers from it too

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 18:05

StefanosHill

The CCC aren’t lobbying.

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 18:04

Comparatively we are doing well though. There’s loads of charts posted below.

They show the U.K. factually not through lobbyists’ language

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 18:02

We do not have our house in order!! Bullshit. We are investing in and subsidising new oil. We are not investing in renewables nearly as much. We are not insulating our homes. We are not collectively reducing our consumption. We are one of the worlds highest carbon emitters when you consider us globally.

StefanosHill · 23/07/2023 18:00

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 17:49

OK. So the CCC that is a publicly funded advisory group, whose job is to advise the Government on its climate policy said;

‘But strategies in place are unlikely to deliver the required emission cuts and last year’s announcements on new fossil fuel projects have tarnished Britain's reputation as a climate leader, an annual progress report by the Climate Change Committee (CCC) said on Wednesday.’ June 2023

But the facts show we are leading, all those posts below.

‘Tarnished’ really?

Why do these statements sound so non factual and loaded. I get it’s their job and reason for existing but as pp said we have our house in order

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 18:00

https://www.theccc.org.uk/2021/09/08/uk-climate-risk-state-of-the-nation-webinar-series/

Here you go. If you look at these you will see the words

‘However, despite over 3,000 pages of new detail, the Climate Change Committee’s confidence in the UK meeting its goals from 2030 onwards is now markedly less than it was in our previous assessment a year ago. A key opportunity to push a faster pace of progress has been missed.’

‘Time is now very short to achieve this change of pace. Glimmers of the Net Zero transition can be seen in growing sales of new electric cars and the continued deployment of renewable capacity, but the scale up of action overall is worryingly slow.’

‘The Government continues to place their reliance on technological solutions that have not been deployed at scale, in preference to more straightforward encouragement of people to reduce high-carbon activities. The Committee has again flagged the risks of a policy programme that amongst other things is too slow to plant trees and roll-out heat pumps.’

‘Yet, there has been little progress in addressing the increasing risks from overheating in our houses, health and care facilities, schools and prisons.’

‘the assessment found that current adaptation measures are inadequate to match the scale of key risks to the natural environment, including risks to terrestrial and freshwater species and habitats, soils, and natural carbon stores and sequestration.’

‘Despite this, and despite the attempts from private finance to help achieve Net Zero and diversify portfolios, there are still barriers to making public and private finance available for adaptation.’

‘Out of 15 relevant major UK Government announcements linked to addressing climate change made over the past three years, only four have included integrated plans and goals on adapting to climate change alongside goals and plans for reducing emissions.’

UK Climate Risk - State of the Nation webinar series - Climate Change Committee

The UK Climate Risk – State of the Nation series delves into the Independent Assessment of UK Climate…

https://www.theccc.org.uk/2021/09/08/uk-climate-risk-state-of-the-nation-webinar-series/

bellac11 · 23/07/2023 17:57

Havent read the full thread, its domestic terrorism and should be dealt with as such

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 17:56

The UK has done, and is doing a lot to reduce its emissions - both per capita and in total. It's high time that certain countries pulled their weight too, be they China, Russia, or the US.

Yes, yes yes! We have done and are doing our bit. If there is to be any calling out a la JSO it shouldn’t be directed inwards, but outwards to those who are not doing their bit.

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 17:55

ivykaty44 · 23/07/2023 17:52

This is for investment and support, so whether its cheaper or less expensive shouldn't be a factor

What? Of course the cost of investment, operations and maintenance is a factor driving how much money renewables NEEDS or does not need!

MillicentBystandr · 23/07/2023 17:54

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 23/07/2023 17:49

OK. So the CCC that is a publicly funded advisory group, whose job is to advise the Government on its climate policy said;

‘But strategies in place are unlikely to deliver the required emission cuts and last year’s announcements on new fossil fuel projects have tarnished Britain's reputation as a climate leader, an annual progress report by the Climate Change Committee (CCC) said on Wednesday.’ June 2023

Well, now you are quoting them out of context, that “unlikely to deliver the required emissions cuts” is referring directly to our self imposed goal of net zero by 2050.

Which by the way, whether we meet it or not, it will have zero impact on climate change globally as our contribution to global CO2 emissions is less than 1%.

So the ‘required emission cuts’ are not the cuts required to avert climate disaster…they are the cuts required to reach an ambitious goal we set for ourselves, that even if we do not meet it we have still done far more than over 95% of the rest of the planet.