Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is there anything we can do re DVLA fine?

85 replies

CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 12:11

Hi all,

Back in December we reserved a car at a local dealership you know one of those £100 fees so no one else could have it but then our funding fell through and I cancelled the deposit (which we didn't get back anyway even though they said we would but whatever) and told them we couldn't get the car.

For some reason though the dealership put all our details onto the car and when we received the v5c I contacted the dealership and they said they'd sort it but we've been fined £172 for non payment of tax and even though we have sent all the proof to the DVLA they are not accepting that we never bought the car and was not the registered keepers.

I've contacted the dealers but they aren't much help. I really don't know what to do. I suspect I'll need to just pay the fine but it seems unfair when I didn't own/buy the car so it wasn't my responsibility to tax it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 16:00

@onefinemess sorry I didn't finish but surely you can't just register someone to a car without their permission nor knowledge?

OP posts:
Topseyt123 · 22/07/2023 15:59

When you write your bullet point letter to the DVLA as discussed upthread make sure you copy the dealer in on it, and also send a copy to your MP, who I think you should ask to step in here without further delay.

I wouldn't pay the fine. That would probably look as though you were admitting responsibility in this, which you aren't and mustn't. Just be clear why you have not paid it and keep all correspondence.

CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 15:58

onefinemess · 22/07/2023 15:56

OP, most of the advice you have been given so far is either incorrect or bordering on nonsense.

The V5 is just a record of liability, whoever is named on the V5 is responsible for all fines, fees and taxes relating to the vehicle. The V5 is nothing to do with ownership. That's why when you lease or PCP a car you don't get the V5, it stays with the lease company.

You, as the person named on the V5, ARE responsible for the fine, and YOU WILL have to pay it.

There is a massive GDPR breach on the part of the garage for giving you the new owners details.

As long as you are the registered keeper YOU will be responsible for any speeding fines (NIP will be sent to you and you will be responsible if you don't fill it out) parking tickets, toll charges, the lot.

If the new owner has questionable morals, they might not be interested in fixing this issue, at the moment they are immune from all speeding fines and parking tickets. The private parking tickets are particularly troublesome as they take ages to sort out. This "small" issue has the potential to bankrupt you, trash your credit rating, have bailiffs or County Court officers at your door to sieze your property and basically ruin your life.

Simple solution is this. Fill out the new keeper section of the form, saying the vehicle is "in trade" at the dealership you used, send it off to the DVLA, they will send confirmation of change of keeper to you within 14 days. That sorts your first problem.

Next, pay the fine (you have no choice in this) and than pop into the dealership and ask to be reimbursed, if they refuse, your only option will be to take them to court, but you will win so don't worry about that.

Do not ignore this, do not discuss any further with the dealership.

You are.responsible for the fine, there is no way around this, the DVLA are correct and won't back down.

Fair enough.

Is there anything I can do after I've paid the fine though such as the fact the dealership used my details without my permission to register me as the registered keeper?

OP posts:
onefinemess · 22/07/2023 15:56

OP, most of the advice you have been given so far is either incorrect or bordering on nonsense.

The V5 is just a record of liability, whoever is named on the V5 is responsible for all fines, fees and taxes relating to the vehicle. The V5 is nothing to do with ownership. That's why when you lease or PCP a car you don't get the V5, it stays with the lease company.

You, as the person named on the V5, ARE responsible for the fine, and YOU WILL have to pay it.

There is a massive GDPR breach on the part of the garage for giving you the new owners details.

As long as you are the registered keeper YOU will be responsible for any speeding fines (NIP will be sent to you and you will be responsible if you don't fill it out) parking tickets, toll charges, the lot.

If the new owner has questionable morals, they might not be interested in fixing this issue, at the moment they are immune from all speeding fines and parking tickets. The private parking tickets are particularly troublesome as they take ages to sort out. This "small" issue has the potential to bankrupt you, trash your credit rating, have bailiffs or County Court officers at your door to sieze your property and basically ruin your life.

Simple solution is this. Fill out the new keeper section of the form, saying the vehicle is "in trade" at the dealership you used, send it off to the DVLA, they will send confirmation of change of keeper to you within 14 days. That sorts your first problem.

Next, pay the fine (you have no choice in this) and than pop into the dealership and ask to be reimbursed, if they refuse, your only option will be to take them to court, but you will win so don't worry about that.

Do not ignore this, do not discuss any further with the dealership.

You are.responsible for the fine, there is no way around this, the DVLA are correct and won't back down.

junglejane66 · 22/07/2023 15:53

FixTheBone · 22/07/2023 14:46

It wasn't my sister.

She did get the reminder.

It took so long to sort that the fine was issued anyway. Nobody would engage in rational conversation , and you can't do anything online without the number on the v5c, which the dealer had lost.

He only needed the green slip, your brother should have kept the other bit, still lesson learned

maddening · 22/07/2023 15:32

If you have the vc5 still I think you could force the dealer to pay the fine and return your deposit as goodwill for their fuck up as pp suggested. They will have another pissed off Customer who has paid them for the car but is not the legal owner - how are they taxing it? Tell them that unless they resolve your issue you are taking it further and alerting the other customer to the issue also.

CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 15:32

itsgettingweird · 22/07/2023 15:29

Surely the only way they could have transferred registered keeper of the car to you is if you signed?

So if you never purchased the car how did they transfer it to you?

I didn't sign anything, I didn't buy the car.

I left £100 holding fee, cancelled it and received the V5C in March.

The dealers know it was their error, they had an invoice all set up for us for when we were going to pick it up but we cancelled and then they had the new owners invoice and somehow put all our details instead of new owners.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 22/07/2023 15:29

Surely the only way they could have transferred registered keeper of the car to you is if you signed?

So if you never purchased the car how did they transfer it to you?

Daffidale · 22/07/2023 15:27

I suspect that neither the new owner nor the dealer can register it to them, because it’s currently registered to you. Or at least they need you to participate on that process. Hence Mr Dodgy Dealer asking you to try taking the form to the post office to transfer ownership.

I agree with @nevynevster - you hold some cards here! The dealer and new owner need your help to fix this. Try DVLA again as suggested. But also agree tell the dealer they need to cover the fine (and I’d cheekily ask for your deposit back too, as compensation for the time and hassle) before you will do ANYTHING to help them fix the mess they’ve made.

Daisymay2 · 22/07/2023 15:27

This maybe a bizarre thought, but could the dealers have told DVLA that you are the people that bought the car in January in error? That’s why the real owner hasn’t taxed it? Maybe the dealer still had your details associated with the car on some paperwork.

CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 15:15

Guinefort · 22/07/2023 15:14

Did the garage sell the car to new owners in January? This is very odd, because who would buy a car without the V5 (it's like the golden rule of car buying - no V5 no sale!). Also, surely the people who purchased it would know they needed to register it and pay tax from the day they bought it. So why did the issue only come to light when you received a V5 in your name in March and contacted the garage to let them know at that point?!

Apologies if I've misunderstood. It sounds very dodgy of the garage tbh.

I genuinely have no idea what's happened to be honest.

According to the invoice orders the new owner picked it up in January and I received the V5C in March.

I don't know why the new owners haven't registered it either.

OP posts:
Guinefort · 22/07/2023 15:14

Did the garage sell the car to new owners in January? This is very odd, because who would buy a car without the V5 (it's like the golden rule of car buying - no V5 no sale!). Also, surely the people who purchased it would know they needed to register it and pay tax from the day they bought it. So why did the issue only come to light when you received a V5 in your name in March and contacted the garage to let them know at that point?!

Apologies if I've misunderstood. It sounds very dodgy of the garage tbh.

BestIsWest · 22/07/2023 14:54

As others have said, write to your MP.

earsup · 22/07/2023 14:50

how odd they transferred car to you with just a small deposit....i have found dvla quite helpful, ask for a manager and sort out over phone. good luck.

FixTheBone · 22/07/2023 14:46

junglejane66 · 22/07/2023 14:04

If the dealer hadn't changed the V5C details it would have still be in you sister's name so the ved reminder and 'last chance' would have come to her surely and could have sorted it. Plus you can notify DVLA on line you sold the car, which is better than relying on the dealer to do it and forgetting.

It wasn't my sister.

She did get the reminder.

It took so long to sort that the fine was issued anyway. Nobody would engage in rational conversation , and you can't do anything online without the number on the v5c, which the dealer had lost.

QuestionableMouse · 22/07/2023 14:35

The dealership is at fault.

They registered a car in your name before the sale was complete.

Writing to the DVLA and using bullet points to explain ia what I'd do - you're presenting your information in a confusing way so sticking just to the facts may help. I think you should actually speak to a lawyer and let them deal with it for you.

If you pay the fine yourself, I'd look at perusing the dealership for the costs through small claims court.

CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 14:31

@nevynevster I know it's not the DVLAs problem and I appreciate that.

They've sold the car, I have all the new owners details but I don't really know how to go about it?

Why would they need me if they've already sold it? They've caused so much trouble and they don't care.

I didn't even push back on the holding fee as I felt bad for cancelling.

Bloody Nora, I don't know what to do really.

OP posts:
nevynevster · 22/07/2023 14:25

DVLA are in the right. You are responsible for tax on the vehicle and it was not paid hence the fine. They won't waive it I suspect as they are correct according to their documentation.

As someone else suggested you need to go to the Dealership in person. You need to present them the fine and explain they must pay it as it was their error that caused it. If they don't then you will not fill in anything and then they will have sold a car that they were not entitled to sell and they will be in a very sticky situation with the new owner. As basically they sold a car they didn't in fact own.

You hold the cards here as you are the official keeper of this vehicle! So they need you to help them fix this. You need to see them paying the fine there and then online or else you will not be doing anything and you will be contacting the new owner to inform them that they do not in fact own the car as the dealer was not entitled to sell it. And that unless this fine is paid then you won't be doing any paperwork.

CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 14:24

Totaly · 22/07/2023 14:21

It’s states on there that you must register the vehicle to consider it yours - did you do this?

If not use their wording in your email

Also what is the likely hood of you going to court? I would definitely go down that route.

No, I didn't register anything.

As mentioned all I did was pay the holding fee and leave our details and then I called to say we can't have the car anymore and they said fine and put the phone down and kept our deposit and then we heard nothing until March when I received the V5C and the tax fine at the same time so I contacted the dealership and DVLA and yeah, we're still on it.

I don't know if it's worth seeking legal advice really. I'm really thankful for mumsnet.

OP posts:
Totaly · 22/07/2023 14:21

It’s states on there that you must register the vehicle to consider it yours - did you do this?

If not use their wording in your email

Also what is the likely hood of you going to court? I would definitely go down that route.

CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 14:18

Ourshoddyhouse · 22/07/2023 14:16

Contrary to popular belief, a V5C isn't actually proof of ownership. According to the DVLA, having your name on the document merely indicates you are the one 'who is responsible for registering and taxing the vehicle', not necessarily the one who owns it.

I appreciate that but if the DVLA want me to pay the fine for not taxing the car .. are they assuming I'm the owner?

It's all confusing tbh.

Is there anything we can do re DVLA fine?
OP posts:
CuriousLadyBird · 22/07/2023 14:17

hedgehoglurker · 22/07/2023 14:15

How have you contacted the dvla to explain this? You've not been very clear on here, so perhaps they've had similar trouble in deciphering what has happened.

It might help to write to them. Put each step in bullet points about how this mess has occurred. Don't include anything unnecessary that didn't actually happen - sending to new owner, etc.

  • Paid £100 holding deposit on xx/xx/xx to [dealership].

  • Decided against purchase on xx/xx/xx, £100 holding deposit forfeited. Prospective sale cancelled by dealership.

  • Vehicle never in my possession or ownership.

  • V5C received in post on xx/xx/xx. Immediately contacted dealer who promised to rectify their mistake.

  • Dealer asked me to register New Keeper at Post Office with V5C, but I refused as I no longer had document and didn't think I should as I was never the owner.

  • Fine received...

  • Contacted DVLA ...

Etc.

Include copies of relevant documents and correspondence with the dealer.

Send recorded delivery or at least get proof of posting.

Good luck. I wouldn't pay the fine, but make sure you keep evidence that you have been trying to deal with this.

Also, if you want to call again instead of writing, have the bullet point timeline in front of you, so you can stick to the facts and not get sidetracked.

Sorry I wasn't clear :- We have on multiple times explained to the DVLA what has happened by letter, email and phone calls, not quite like you have so I will do that on the letter I send.

However I guess they are still seeing I'm the registered keeper so are upholding the fine.

OP posts:
hedgehoglurker · 22/07/2023 14:17

Cross-posted. Glad you have a plan of action!

Ourshoddyhouse · 22/07/2023 14:16

Contrary to popular belief, a V5C isn't actually proof of ownership. According to the DVLA, having your name on the document merely indicates you are the one 'who is responsible for registering and taxing the vehicle', not necessarily the one who owns it.

hedgehoglurker · 22/07/2023 14:15

How have you contacted the dvla to explain this? You've not been very clear on here, so perhaps they've had similar trouble in deciphering what has happened.

It might help to write to them. Put each step in bullet points about how this mess has occurred. Don't include anything unnecessary that didn't actually happen - sending to new owner, etc.

  • Paid £100 holding deposit on xx/xx/xx to [dealership].

  • Decided against purchase on xx/xx/xx, £100 holding deposit forfeited. Prospective sale cancelled by dealership.

  • Vehicle never in my possession or ownership.

  • V5C received in post on xx/xx/xx. Immediately contacted dealer who promised to rectify their mistake.

  • Dealer asked me to register New Keeper at Post Office with V5C, but I refused as I no longer had document and didn't think I should as I was never the owner.

  • Fine received...

  • Contacted DVLA ...

Etc.

Include copies of relevant documents and correspondence with the dealer.

Send recorded delivery or at least get proof of posting.

Good luck. I wouldn't pay the fine, but make sure you keep evidence that you have been trying to deal with this.

Also, if you want to call again instead of writing, have the bullet point timeline in front of you, so you can stick to the facts and not get sidetracked.