Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
daisychaindays · 22/07/2023 09:09

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 08:45

Half of the thread is filled with people saying the dropping of atomic bombs was justified. This means they are happy with children to be killed and disfigured, unimaginable suffering to ensue, and soil and environment be contaminated for thousands of years.

That is a complete over simplification

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:08

@Lacucuracha Thanks! Good to see I am not alone. It has been a very sad thread indeed. I somehow wish I didn't know that this is what a lot of people think

mikado1 · 22/07/2023 09:07

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 18:26

YANBU if that’s true. I haven’t seen it but if he is being portrayed as a hero then that’s terrible.

The USA never needed to drop those bombs, the war was effectively over. They just wanted to play with their toys.

Agree, but assume he didn't make that vert wrong decision.

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 09:06

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 08:47

With atomic bombs, humanity invented its own end. We are living in the presence of the forever present possibility of nuclear annihilation of all life on the planet at any moment.

Good to see a voice of reason on the thread, amongst the posters who think it’s ok to drop bombs on a country that the US knew was surrendering.

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:03

@MissyGirlie
Your post exemplifies my point exactly. You say it was the lesser of two evils. Who are you to evaluate evils and make a judgement of which one is lesser? You just repeat an official popular American (maybe British-American) version of that history, but you're somehow convinced that it has superior access to truth and you allow yourself to occupy a moral position in relation to this atrocious act which makes you feel comfortable. This is just how ideology works.

SerendipityJane · 22/07/2023 09:02

LameBorzoi · 22/07/2023 00:30

If the UK had had the bomb during world war 2, would dropping it on Berlin have been the right thing to do?

People seem to have forgotten that the US needed the UKs approval to deploy the bombs in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Since the UK provided a lot of the research and materiel for the project.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 09:01

wars have never ever been fought without civilians suffering. It isn’t as if WW2 was the first time this had happened and prior to that wars had been confined nicely to armies, navy’s and later air force fighting each other & leaving everything else intact. 20% of Europe’s population was killed in the 30 years war, some areas list 65% of their population and that was in the 17th century. Crudely, civilians have nearly always born the brunt of war.

reading American Prometheus the book on which Oppenheimer is based, it’s very clear that he knew that they couldn’t unmake the knowledge they had acquired, they couldn’t put the genie back in the bottle and that there was no way only America would develop a bomb. Oppenheimer believed that they had to use the bomb to demonstrate its power. He hoped that by doing so it would put an end to war - all war - because with nuclear weapons, it was now quite possible to destroy the world. It was one of the reasons why he was appalled by Edward teller’s relentless push for the H bomb. They already had something capable of immense world ending destruction, why build something even bigger?

obviously we now know with the benefit of 80 years hindsight that he was naive to believe that could happen

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 08:57

@yogibutton you are setting up a false dichotomy. I think that the atom bombs were justified. This does not mean that I am 'happy' that children were killed. It was a case of the lesser of two evils. Asians were dying, in their thousands, all across Japanese-controlled areas, every day, many of them children, of hunger and malnutrition caused by the war. Civilians continued to die and to suffer the consequences of the war, some of them for the rest of their lives.

This idea that the war was over is fallacious. There was a war faction at high level in the Japanese government who tried to stop the surrender. There were Japanese commanders vowing to fight on. Japanese officers continued to kill unarmed 'undesirables' even after the surrender.

TheaBrandt · 22/07/2023 08:49

Exactly mango. Of course the bombs were horrific no one is pleased children in other countries were obliterated but they weren’t dropped out of the blue - the film is informative on the political situation at the time. There was genuine fear of the outcome if the nazi regime at the time got hold of these weapons and due to their cultural mindset the Japanese didn’t look like they would stop fighting.

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 08:48

@Ponoka7 'the British' did not 'invent concentration camps'.
IIRC, that honour goes to the Spanish.

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 08:47

With atomic bombs, humanity invented its own end. We are living in the presence of the forever present possibility of nuclear annihilation of all life on the planet at any moment.

TrueScrumptious · 22/07/2023 08:46

I’ve been reading recently about Unit 731 - a Japanese medical experimental centre in the war, where 300,000 people, including children and babies, were experimented on and tortured to death, vivisected, in the most horrific ways. Most victims were Chinese but lots of other nationalities too. I had never heard of this. The victims were regarded as “logs”. It’s horrendous. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

Unit 731 - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 08:45

Half of the thread is filled with people saying the dropping of atomic bombs was justified. This means they are happy with children to be killed and disfigured, unimaginable suffering to ensue, and soil and environment be contaminated for thousands of years.

Cyclebabble · 22/07/2023 08:43

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 18:31

Oh please. The USA never needed to drop the bombs, the war was effectively over.

Don't peddle lies.

Sorry but that is simply factually incorrect. The war was far from over and the US had lost very substantial numbers of personnel invading the islands around Japan. Even after the dropping of two bombs surrender was conditional on the Japanese Royal Family remaining in place.

Wheretostartstitching · 22/07/2023 08:43

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 08:36

It is one of the most distressing threads I've ever read on Mumsnet. Just the sheer scale of the amount of fake historians who are happy for other ethnicities' children to be killed and whole cities wiped out because they read some books. Of course, as long as no one touches them, because they are "good". And they should not bear any responsibility for what their armies or forebears ever did. Let's not think about it. It's others who are truly evil and cruel and deserved to be wiped put by nuclear explosions. But these musmnetters, no, they are fair and kind. Truly truly shocking

Where did anyone say they were happy for children to be killed?

and why would we take responsibility for decisions made by people born a century ago?

Do you believe Germans are responsible for the decision made by Nazis? Or that Japanese people today are responsible for the crimes of Japanese people almost a century ago?

How far back do that responsibility go?

Freshair1 · 22/07/2023 08:39

Oh for heaven's sake. Are we really this dumb? History is full of diabolical people. Cruelty. Torture. Crimes. Senseless destruction. This film is a character portrait of one man. It's... A.... Film!

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 08:36

It is one of the most distressing threads I've ever read on Mumsnet. Just the sheer scale of the amount of fake historians who are happy for other ethnicities' children to be killed and whole cities wiped out because they read some books. Of course, as long as no one touches them, because they are "good". And they should not bear any responsibility for what their armies or forebears ever did. Let's not think about it. It's others who are truly evil and cruel and deserved to be wiped put by nuclear explosions. But these musmnetters, no, they are fair and kind. Truly truly shocking

MangosteenSoda · 22/07/2023 08:28

It’s far too complex of a situation to definitively say whether those bombings were ‘justified’ or ‘unjustifiable’ and sort of pointless imo. We have decades of hindsight, haven’t struggled through a years long war and aren’t on the precipice of the unknowns of the Cold War.

It’s too simplistic to ascribe the decision to one thing only. It surely lies within a huge web of context, some known at the time and some partially unknown and all of the options ending in wholesale death.

Japan couldn’t win at that point, but how long and at what cost would it take for the allies to win? Where is the situation with Russia going? How long will it take them to develop a nuclear weapon? What might they do with it? Will using the weapons to bomb Japan have a net positive effect on either of those things for us? Does that make it justifiable? How will history view this decision…

elenacampana · 22/07/2023 08:20

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:41

I'm uncomfortable with the way it's being advertised, I feel that is glorifying him. Whether the film does or not I don't know but yes from what I've seen so far I think I might find it unpalatable which is why I'm asking 🤷‍♀️

Just watch it yourself. This is one of the stupidest threads I’ve seen in ages.

Go and see Barbie while you’re at at it, sounds like you need to relax and stop being so uptight.

notimagain · 22/07/2023 08:09

@mids2019

Hi

I guess if your mind is constantly immersed in the subtle beauties of the universe at a fundamental level do you have the bandwidth to contemplate politics and human psychology

I think you might know the answer to that, but for those that don't, a document sometimes referred to as "The Einstein-Szilard letter" might be of interest. It was written by Leo Szilard (Physicist) in 1939, signed by Einstein, sent to Roosevelt:

https://www.osti.gov/opennet/manhattan-project-history/Resources/einstein_letter_photograph.htm#1

Manhattan Project: Einstein's Letter to Roosevelt

https://www.osti.gov/opennet/manhattan-project-history/Resources/einstein_letter_photograph.htm#1

mids2019 · 22/07/2023 07:58

I think a really pertinent point is that the geniuses of theoretical physics to some extent found it hard to contemplate being in the same humanities that causes such atrocities. I guess if your mind is constantly immersed in the subtle beauties of the universe at a fundamental level do you have the bandwidth to contemplate politics and human psychology (maybe I am being stereotypical). I think the juxtaposition of a mind like Einstein's revising Newtonian mechanics with two simple postulates leading ultimately to energy mass equivalence and a mind that is truly cruel is really revealing of human nature.

I wonder what Oppenheimer would have made of the fate of the only country to ever have given up its nuclear arsenal?

Ponoka7 · 22/07/2023 07:42

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 07:00

At what points of history would it have been justifiable to a bomb the uk, pretending the technology was available?

Just to answer this question alone. There are lots of points, the campaigns against the Native Americans, those in Africa when the British invented concentration camps, the great Irish Famine, although I see these things as class struggles and agree with the socialist idea that we should have united and not fell for the racism/religious etc divides.

On a side note a film should be made about the taking of the land for testing. Let's hope Oppenheimer (which I want to see) helps that happen because of public interest.

sashh · 22/07/2023 07:28

Bubblesoffun · 22/07/2023 05:18

@JudyEdithPerry the uk did not consider the women and children of the cities they carpet bombed either.
@sashh the bombing of Nagasaki saved the life of my grandfather. Who was a pow. Along with the rest of the pows who had managed to survive that long. they were about to be executed so the evidence could be destroyed. The bomb went off and the Japanese fled. And the US army rescued them. To quote a phrase that I hate “educate yourself”

I was replying to a posted who said "His actions prevented the death of many allied personnel who would have been involved in the invasion of Japan." if your grandfather was a POW then he would not have been among the soldiers invading.

There is some discussion about whether there was an actual policy to kill POWs, it was almost certainly discussed at some camps but no documentation is around. Of course that could have been destroyed.

Your grandfather surviving is as much luck as anything else. I appreciate this is personal for you and I'm just looking at numbers.

Approximately 36000 allied POWs were in Japan at the end of the war. Several camps were bombed or bombarded killing allied soldiers including some in Nagasaki.

If the two bombs saved their lives then the people of the two cities paid a heavy price.

WhatsupWhatsApp · 22/07/2023 07:13

MissEDashwood19 · 21/07/2023 18:53

Quite. Perhaps read the "Rape of Nanking" or listen to interviews of PoWs and "comfort women" before turning the Japanese into innocent victims.

The likelihood of the Japanese surrendering without enormous loss of lives on both sides was remote. Absolutely horrendous for the poor civilians, but blame should also be apportioned to their beloved Emperor and the sadistic military for unleashing a blood-thirsty war and committing nurmerous atrocities.

So civilians and kids had to pay the price for action of their emperor and army.

2 cities were wiped out, can you imagine doing today? You can't defend nuclear bombing of cities

AlanGrantsNeckerchief · 22/07/2023 07:03

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 21/07/2023 19:16

The trailer is a good 7 minutes of people looking horrified including the man himself. I have Odeon Limitless. I have seen it many, many times.

sorry OT a bit but this made me chuckle @AndIKnewYouMeantIt i have a Cineworld Unlimited card and have been seeing the trailer for about 6 months before virtually every film. it’s become the standard “just popping to the loo” moment 😅