Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 09:45

Readthebooks · 22/07/2023 09:31

You know what the Japanese did, right?

We should ignore history at our peril

^This. That bomb meant my grandad made it home alive after being held as a Pow for over 4 years, presumed dead for a long time. Weighed 5 stone and had various diseases. Him and his friends suffered horrendously at the hands of the Japanese, they were cruel fuckers.

Your grandfather made it home alive because Japan had already decided to surrender. The US knew this and still dropped the bombs.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 09:45

And it’s easy to say that with the benefit of 80 years hindsight & a full and complete understanding of what atomic weapons can do

a decision to drop an atomic bomb now would be made with 80 years of additional knowledge

FluffyMochi · 22/07/2023 09:45

I live in Nagasaki and am very keen to watch the film as an act of remembrance.

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:44

@GrinAndVomit I made this point - it is always "the others" who are the evil monsters. A foundation of justifying things like this is a firm belief in your own "goodness" and that your government and army never did and could never do anything really quite so bad to justify a similar attack on your family.

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:42

I do not believe that any use - ever - of nuclear weapons can be justified.

daisychaindays · 22/07/2023 09:42

@GrinAndVomit of course no one is comfortable with the death of children but are you actually saying allied soldiers lives didn't matter? Are you saying they should've been left there, joined by probably thousands more of US had not used the bomb?

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 09:42

If our government was committing atrocities, how many people would accept that it would be justifiable to drop an atom bomb on us and our children?

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 09:41

You grandad’s life is not more valuable than those of innocent children
Were Japanese children magically more innocent than those dying of hunger under Japanese rule elsewhere in Asia? Hunger induced entirely by Japan's aggression?

Or do they not count?

daisychaindays · 22/07/2023 09:40

Readthebooks · 22/07/2023 09:31

You know what the Japanese did, right?

We should ignore history at our peril

^This. That bomb meant my grandad made it home alive after being held as a Pow for over 4 years, presumed dead for a long time. Weighed 5 stone and had various diseases. Him and his friends suffered horrendously at the hands of the Japanese, they were cruel fuckers.

Agreed.

I'm sorry for what your grandad went through.

Kabbalah · 22/07/2023 09:39

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 09:38

You grandad’s life is not more valuable than those of innocent children

NANKING !!!!!!!

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 09:39

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:34

When the war in Ukraine began I've read a post here on Mumsnet by a woman who said that NATO should enter the war. Others pointed out to her that it could mean the end of life on Earth but she was adamant that for fairness and to punish the aggressor, there was no other way and needs must. It surprised me then but now I see how this thinking arises.

Maybe you misunderstood my post - if indeed this post of yours was aimed at me.

To my mind, the use of the bombs was justified as they reduced the net loss of life. Nothing to do with revenge on the Japanese, or punishment.
Deaths at Hiroshima and Nagasaki vs troops on both sides who would have died in continued fighting + civilians in Japan killed in continued fighting + people dying of hunger all over Asia (c10k/day) + continued high death rate of POWs and internees.

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 09:38

Readthebooks · 22/07/2023 09:31

You know what the Japanese did, right?

We should ignore history at our peril

^This. That bomb meant my grandad made it home alive after being held as a Pow for over 4 years, presumed dead for a long time. Weighed 5 stone and had various diseases. Him and his friends suffered horrendously at the hands of the Japanese, they were cruel fuckers.

You grandad’s life is not more valuable than those of innocent children

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:34

When the war in Ukraine began I've read a post here on Mumsnet by a woman who said that NATO should enter the war. Others pointed out to her that it could mean the end of life on Earth but she was adamant that for fairness and to punish the aggressor, there was no other way and needs must. It surprised me then but now I see how this thinking arises.

Readthebooks · 22/07/2023 09:31

You know what the Japanese did, right?

We should ignore history at our peril

^This. That bomb meant my grandad made it home alive after being held as a Pow for over 4 years, presumed dead for a long time. Weighed 5 stone and had various diseases. Him and his friends suffered horrendously at the hands of the Japanese, they were cruel fuckers.

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 09:30

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

echt · 22/07/2023 09:29

Japan had done some terrible things. This seems to keep on being conveniently forgotten by the Japan apologists on here

Such as? Funny how you don't quote or name.

No matter what the Japanese did, these were not the reasons the US government considered when dropping the bomb. They are reasons people come up with to justify the event later.

Even at the time, the entire uselessness of the targets was noted by US military, i.e they did not constitute significant targets to hinder the Japanese war effort.

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 09:28

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:03

@MissyGirlie
Your post exemplifies my point exactly. You say it was the lesser of two evils. Who are you to evaluate evils and make a judgement of which one is lesser? You just repeat an official popular American (maybe British-American) version of that history, but you're somehow convinced that it has superior access to truth and you allow yourself to occupy a moral position in relation to this atrocious act which makes you feel comfortable. This is just how ideology works.

@yogibutton I'm not sure that you read my earlier post. This is a topic about which I know far more than I would like, owing to my family background.

My 'moral position' on the atom bomb isn't something that makes me 'feel comfortable'. It's something I have examined in depth and re-examine every time the topic comes up. And equally, who are you to say (as you are effectively doing) that the lives of civilians of the aggressor nation (Japan) deserve more consideration than those of civilians under Japanese rule elsewhere in Asia?

To take one example, life at the end of the war in Singapore was horrendous. The Japanese admin had washed its hands of the Javanese labourers they had brought to the city and these men were, literally, dying in the gutters and on the five-foot-ways. There were virtually no cats left, because they had been eaten by the starving population.

Or how about Thailand, where entire families of slave labourers, more-or-less press-ganged in Malaya and shipped north, were hungry and riddled with illness, and were dying in their droves of dysentery and cholera? Do their lives not come into your consideration?

Because they sure as hell come into mine.

Wheretostartstitching · 22/07/2023 09:25

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 08:45

Half of the thread is filled with people saying the dropping of atomic bombs was justified. This means they are happy with children to be killed and disfigured, unimaginable suffering to ensue, and soil and environment be contaminated for thousands of years.

No it’s not the same.

Understanding it’s not black and white when there’s a war doesn’t mean they are happy for children to be killed, disfigured or any of the other things.

Just because you don’t understand the nuance of a conversation, it doesn’t mean you can make things up.

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 09:22

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

Katrinawaves · 22/07/2023 09:20

I went to see the film last night. It was a tour de force. It definitely did not make Oppenheimer out to be a hero for his work on the A and H bombs but it did portray how courageous he was in opposing the arms race and speaking truth to power after the war was over. He was depicted as being deeply conflicted about the use of the bomb in Japan even before the impact of that was known and haunted by the knowledge of the devastation it had wreaked for the rest of his life.

it was a very nuanced film and your concerns about it are entirelt misplaced @LKM23

Kabbalah · 22/07/2023 09:16

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 09:06

Good to see a voice of reason on the thread, amongst the posters who think it’s ok to drop bombs on a country that the US knew was surrendering.

But they weren't surrendering, even after Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Thats post-war BS. It took the intervention of the Emporer to bring that about.

Zonder · 22/07/2023 09:16

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:49

Don't get me started on why I won't watch Barbie, we'll be here all night and I've got shit to do.

My DD came home from seeing Barbie last night and said it had a really interesting feminist message!

I guess we all make presumptions about films and their messages.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 09:11

The japenese imperial Council met on 9th & 10th august (so after the bombing of Nagasaki) and even then after 2 nuclear bombs they were tied at 3-3 as to whether to surrender. It was only the intervention of the emperor who ordered them to surrender, that they finally did.

daisychaindays · 22/07/2023 09:10

MangosteenSoda · 22/07/2023 08:28

It’s far too complex of a situation to definitively say whether those bombings were ‘justified’ or ‘unjustifiable’ and sort of pointless imo. We have decades of hindsight, haven’t struggled through a years long war and aren’t on the precipice of the unknowns of the Cold War.

It’s too simplistic to ascribe the decision to one thing only. It surely lies within a huge web of context, some known at the time and some partially unknown and all of the options ending in wholesale death.

Japan couldn’t win at that point, but how long and at what cost would it take for the allies to win? Where is the situation with Russia going? How long will it take them to develop a nuclear weapon? What might they do with it? Will using the weapons to bomb Japan have a net positive effect on either of those things for us? Does that make it justifiable? How will history view this decision…

Agree

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 09:09

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.