Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 10:20

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

DismantledKing · 22/07/2023 10:19

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:19

Why does it need to be all the leaders? They knew Japan wanted to surrender, they could have delayed the bombs.

But the US saw their chances to drop their toys were running out.

You have a child’s understanding of history.

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:19

Gingerboy22 · 22/07/2023 10:16

Ummmm yes and that is what I was saying BUT it was not all of the Japanese leaders. If Japan really wanted to surrender then they hold their hands up - easy peasy.

Why does it need to be all the leaders? They knew Japan wanted to surrender, they could have delayed the bombs.

But the US saw their chances to drop their toys were running out.

DismantledKing · 22/07/2023 10:18

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 10:17

Yes there was a minority of high level of civilians in Japan trying to push for peace & hoping the Russians would help. The military commanders however would not countenance surrender and they held the power

That’s a world away from “had already decided to surrender”

And there was also an attempted coup by disaffected army officers even after the Emperor finally decided to surrender. They wanted to continue the war.

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:18

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:01

By saying we shouldn’t kill children or participate in nuclear war?

Give over

How do you feel about the Japanese children, young teenage boys, being forced into being Kamikaze pilots? Or the children dying of starvation in Japanese POW camps? Do those children matter.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 10:17

Yes there was a minority of high level of civilians in Japan trying to push for peace & hoping the Russians would help. The military commanders however would not countenance surrender and they held the power

That’s a world away from “had already decided to surrender”

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 10:16

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 10:06

I have to say, apart from MissyGirlie whose position at least is based on personal history and in that way understandable, the other defenders on this thread appear brainwashed - now talking about freedom (!) Soon they'll start on the axis of evil and civilisational conflict. And how America saves us all. I think I've seen enough so I'll bow out.

I actually find that quite patronising, which I suspect was not your intent.

I think it's perfectly possible to come at this argument 'cold', as it were, and still feel that a net saving of lives was a good idea.

Japan could have surrendered. There was a huge amount of infighting going on. Prolonging the war - which was the consequence of the infighting - was costing thousands upon thousands of lives a day, many of them the lives of non-combatants.

Obliterating cities is very obviously awful. Pyres of Tamil cholera victims deep in the mountains of Thailand are harder to see.

Gingerboy22 · 22/07/2023 10:16

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:14

Nope, the US was intercepting Japanese comms. They knew Japan wanted to surrender.

Ummmm yes and that is what I was saying BUT it was not all of the Japanese leaders. If Japan really wanted to surrender then they hold their hands up - easy peasy.

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 10:16

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:15

If the Japanese were so ready to surrender why didn't they surrender after Hiroshima? Why wait 3 days for another bomb to drop? Even then they didn't surrender until the 15th, another six days when more bombs could drop.

Russia didn't declare war on Japan until the 7th August 1945, the day after Hiroshima so how were the Japanese preparing to surrender because of the Russians before Hiroshima?

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 10:14

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

DismantledKing · 22/07/2023 10:14

My young grandfathers had just finished fighting their way across Europe. The next step would have been to transfer them to the far east to join in with the invasion of Japan. I’m glad that didn’t have to happen.

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:14

Gingerboy22 · 22/07/2023 10:12

No they did not have clear evidence - what they did have was a knowledge that a few members of the Emperor's Cabinet were unhappy and were testing out the Russians to see if they would intervene on their behalf. I would imagine rather like the fact that a few of Hitler's cohort were unhappy, knew the end was inevitable and were looking to save themselves in the future world. Should the Allies have stopped their advance on Berlin? Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Nope, the US was intercepting Japanese comms. They knew Japan wanted to surrender.

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:13

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 10:11

As I said you are entitled to your own opinion but not your own facts

japan documented their decisions very clearly throughout the war. Those records are clear. After the dropping of 2 atomic bombs, the imperial council was split on whether to surrender and the emperor had to order them to surrender

You’re entitled to your own opinion too, but not your own facts.

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:12

This reply has been deleted

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

Japan's leaders (the Supreme Council for the Direction of the War, also known as the "Big Six") were privately making entreaties to the publicly neutral Soviet Union to mediate peace on terms more favorable to the Japanese. While maintaining a sufficient level of diplomatic engagement with the Japanese to give them the impression they might be willing to mediate, the Soviets were covertly preparing to attack Japanese forces in Manchuria and Korea (in addition to South Sakhalin and the Kuril Islands) in fulfillment of promises they had secretly made to the United States and the United Kingdom at the Tehran and Yalta Conferences.

Supreme War Council (Japan) - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_War_Council_(Japan)

Gingerboy22 · 22/07/2023 10:12

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:06

No, the US had clear evidence that the Japanese wanted to surrender before the bombs.

The US argued over trivial things like whether the Emperor would be tried in a war crimes court. Because they wanted to drop the bombs.

No they did not have clear evidence - what they did have was a knowledge that a few members of the Emperor's Cabinet were unhappy and were testing out the Russians to see if they would intervene on their behalf. I would imagine rather like the fact that a few of Hitler's cohort were unhappy, knew the end was inevitable and were looking to save themselves in the future world. Should the Allies have stopped their advance on Berlin? Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

SunnyEgg · 22/07/2023 10:11

Off mn there’s schools of thought anyway, historians tend to divide into theories

https://ahf.nuclearmuseum.org/ahf/history/debate-over-japanese-surrender/

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 10:11

As I said you are entitled to your own opinion but not your own facts

japan documented their decisions very clearly throughout the war. Those records are clear. After the dropping of 2 atomic bombs, the imperial council was split on whether to surrender and the emperor had to order them to surrender

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 10:10

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

DismantledKing · 22/07/2023 10:09

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:09

They absolutely were trying to surrender. They had asked the Soviets to broker the terms before the bombs.

You’re just inventing your own history now.

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:09

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 10:08

And @Lacucuracha ??? That still doesn’t change the fact that they absolutely were not planning to surrender before Hiroshima and even after second atomic bomb they still had to be ordered by the emperor

They absolutely were trying to surrender. They had asked the Soviets to broker the terms before the bombs.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 10:08

And @Lacucuracha ??? That still doesn’t change the fact that they absolutely were not planning to surrender before Hiroshima and even after second atomic bomb they still had to be ordered by the emperor

DismantledKing · 22/07/2023 10:07

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 10:06

I have to say, apart from MissyGirlie whose position at least is based on personal history and in that way understandable, the other defenders on this thread appear brainwashed - now talking about freedom (!) Soon they'll start on the axis of evil and civilisational conflict. And how America saves us all. I think I've seen enough so I'll bow out.

You privilege is showing. If it wasn’t for the sacrifices of others then you wouldn’t have the freedom to express your daft opinions.

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 10:07

@yogibutton I agree, nuclear weapons are horrendous. In 1945 we didn't realise quite how horrendous.

I would urge you, though, to read up on what life was like in Asia under Japanese rule. It might give you an inkling of why I feel as I do. The suffering was horrific and affected all levels of society, people of every age. I've done a lot of primary research in this area (archives, interviews) so I do know what I am talking about.

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:07

DisquietintheRanks · 22/07/2023 10:03

Which innocent children would those be? Clearly not the Chinese ones, or the Malay ones or the ones starving in POW camps whose lives were saved by Japan surrendering when it did.

Obliterating entire cities full of innocent civilians is not the answer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread