Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:51

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:46

Do you have sons? Can you imagine as the years of war pass and you see them going one after another and you know your leaders don't care and that if it goes on you will lose them all. My grandmother had 2 sons away fighting, she had another 5 at home. I don't know how she kept her sanity because I know I couldn't cope with that.

So do you think your grandma would have been grateful for the UK being nuked so that more boys weren’t sent off to war?

Papernotplastic · 22/07/2023 10:50

‘Pro-bombers’. Really?

No one thinks that killing children is a good thing.
No one thinks that dropping bombs on civilians is a good thing.
No one thinks that war is a good thing.
No one thinks that atomic bombs are a good thing.

Those particular bombs being dropped at that particular time, a time when conventional bombs were being dropped on civilians regularly, prevented a lot of future deaths. Does that make it morally right that those bombs were dropped? No. Does that mean that it was the wrong tactical decision to drop those bombs? No.

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 10:49

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

Sloth66 · 22/07/2023 10:47

The film is apparently based on American Prometheus.
oppenheimer had believed the bomb would lead to the end of all wars, when he fully understood the impact of his actions, he called for control and restraint.
I don’t believe this film seeks to glorify anything. It’s the exploration of a horrific event and the man tasked with delivering it.

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:46

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:35

There is no way that you genuinely believe anyone would ever be grateful for a nuclear attack on their country.
There is no way you’re discussing this in good faith.

Do you have sons? Can you imagine as the years of war pass and you see them going one after another and you know your leaders don't care and that if it goes on you will lose them all. My grandmother had 2 sons away fighting, she had another 5 at home. I don't know how she kept her sanity because I know I couldn't cope with that.

twelly · 22/07/2023 10:46

Films show the perspective of those who wrote the script and directed them - they are not necessarily accurate. I don't have an opinion on this film as haven't seem it and don't intend to as I prefer to watch films that are to harrowing. What I find take issue with is people who say -you must watch a particular film to educate yourself about history as that is not the case.

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 10:43

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

sunshineandstormclouds · 22/07/2023 10:38

Saw it last night - definitely not turning him into a hero. Odd to make those assumptions without seeing the film. I walked away thinking a lot about nuclear weapons and how we have ended up where we are. Maybe read a full review or go and see it?

DismantledKing · 22/07/2023 10:38

Coolhwip · 22/07/2023 10:27

I hope none of you rabid pro-bombers have been to Japan. I’d hate to see your smug faces there.

I’ve also been to Dresden, Hamburg, and Coventry. What’s your point?

Hadjab · 22/07/2023 10:35

*you’re

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:35

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:31

Do you really think they wouldn't be relieved that their sons weren't going to be thrown away as cannon fodder?

I have sons and grandsons and their lives matter more to me than who is winning a war.

There is no way that you genuinely believe anyone would ever be grateful for a nuclear attack on their country.
There is no way you’re discussing this in good faith.

Hadjab · 22/07/2023 10:35

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:34

Well yes, I DEFINITELY won't be watching Barbie!

Well your missing out then, because IT’S BLOODY FANTASTIC!

Bubblesoffun · 22/07/2023 10:34

I can’t believe how simplistic and idealistic some people are on here! You can not ascribe 21st century ideas and thinking to WWII. It must be lovely to see the world through your rose tinted lenses.

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:31

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:28

You seriously think a farmer would be grateful for his nation being the target of a nuclear attack?
Christ alive

Do you really think they wouldn't be relieved that their sons weren't going to be thrown away as cannon fodder?

I have sons and grandsons and their lives matter more to me than who is winning a war.

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:28

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:25

If I was a peasant farmer with a son of 14 or 15 who was likely to be taken to be a kamikaze pilot in the near future I think I would have been very very grateful that the war was over and that the leaders who were quite happy to treat my child as cannon fodder were gone.

You seriously think a farmer would be grateful for his nation being the target of a nuclear attack?
Christ alive

Coolhwip · 22/07/2023 10:27

I hope none of you rabid pro-bombers have been to Japan. I’d hate to see your smug faces there.

Heffapotamus · 22/07/2023 10:26

Saw the film yesterday. It is nuanced - as is the character of Oppenheimer.
It's worth a watch if you like films that make you think - and not just about the ethics of nuclear war. The relationship between science and politics, how voices are silenced for expediency and people "cancelled" is at times even more chilling than our ability to destroy the world.

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:25

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:21

Horrific.

Are you trying to say we did the Japanese a favour?

If I was a peasant farmer with a son of 14 or 15 who was likely to be taken to be a kamikaze pilot in the near future I think I would have been very very grateful that the war was over and that the leaders who were quite happy to treat my child as cannon fodder were gone.

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:24

This reply has been deleted

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

The excerpt from this link, which does cite sources.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrender_of_Japan

Surrender of Japan - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrender_of_Japan

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:23

yogibutton · 22/07/2023 09:03

@MissyGirlie
Your post exemplifies my point exactly. You say it was the lesser of two evils. Who are you to evaluate evils and make a judgement of which one is lesser? You just repeat an official popular American (maybe British-American) version of that history, but you're somehow convinced that it has superior access to truth and you allow yourself to occupy a moral position in relation to this atrocious act which makes you feel comfortable. This is just how ideology works.

Not doing anything was also making a judgement. Not stopping the war was making the judgement that the camps, civilians and military, could be left to suffer and die, that Japan could continue to terrorise millions of people in Asia.

Not doing their utmost to stop the war would not be a neutral act.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/07/2023 10:22

Exactly @DismantledKing and given that the emperor was regarded as divine in Japan at that time, the fact they even considered it speaks volumes of their mindset

For some, death was preferable to surrender

MissyGirlie · 22/07/2023 10:22

Why does it need to be all the leaders? They knew Japan wanted to surrender, they could have delayed the bombs.
SOME Japanese putting out peace feelers is not the same as the council agreeing that they were prepared to surrender unconditionally.

Prolonging the war was costing thousands of lives a day. But yeah, sure, drag things on by another fortnight and watch another 150,000 people go to their graves.

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 10:21

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 10:18

How do you feel about the Japanese children, young teenage boys, being forced into being Kamikaze pilots? Or the children dying of starvation in Japanese POW camps? Do those children matter.

Horrific.

Are you trying to say we did the Japanese a favour?

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:21

DismantledKing · 22/07/2023 10:19

You have a child’s understanding of history.

Well the commanding general of the US Army Air Forces must have been a child too then.

The commanding general of the US Army Air Forces, Henry “Hap” Arnold, gave a strong indication of his views in a public statement 11 days after Hiroshima was attacked. Asked on August 17 by a New York Times reporter whether the atomic bomb caused Japan to surrender, Arnold said that “the Japanese position was hopeless even before the first atomic bomb fell, because the Japanese had lost control of their own air.”

“It was a mistake.... [the scientists] had this toy and they wanted to try it out, so they dropped it.” —Adm. William “Bull” Halsey

Gingerboy22 · 22/07/2023 10:20

Lacucuracha · 22/07/2023 10:19

Why does it need to be all the leaders? They knew Japan wanted to surrender, they could have delayed the bombs.

But the US saw their chances to drop their toys were running out.

Now you are just being silly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread