Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
DrCoconut · 23/07/2023 22:28

Last year (inspired by the OMD song) DS did some research about Paul Tibbets and Enola Gay. There are accounts written by various people involved in the bombings on Japan available to read and it's very thought provoking.

melj1213 · 23/07/2023 22:27

I don’t know how historically accurate it is or if they’re painting him in a better light but he talks about his doubts and is convinced if he doesn’t help usa to get there first then the nazis will develop the bomb first and the consequences will be worse.

It's pretty historically accurate, all of those things his doubts and protests against the H Bomb etc were all things that were recorded at the time.

The film is based on a biography - American Prometheus: The Triumph and Tragedy of J. Robert Oppenheimer by Kai Bird and Martin Sherwin which goes into so much detail of Oppenheimer's life, it is a fascinating read but definitely one that requires a lot of time to process as it is hefty reading.

Ahsoka2001 · 23/07/2023 22:26

He's not being turned into a hero at all. The film makes the devastating impact of the bomb's creation very clear and how much he regretted helping make it

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 23/07/2023 22:21

Just seen it and really enjoyed it. He really should win an Oscar for best actor.

obviously I don’t know how historically accurate it is or if they’re painting him in a better light but he talks about his doubts and is convinced if he doesn’t help usa to get there first then the nazis will develop the bomb first and the consequences will be worse.

It shows him very troubled with ptsd flashbacks of people,dying, etc after the bomb was dropped and he tried to stop the USA developing the weapons further.

Gingerboy22 · 23/07/2023 21:54

Finally saw this today and no O is not feted as a hero. It follows the project, his resistance to developing the H bomb afterwards and investigations into him. It was about the politics of the time. You do need to have a certain amount of intelligence to understand this film and knowledge of world history perhaps unlike the ones coming out moaning that it was too long and they couldn't distinguish " one man from another". Maybe they thought it was going to be Peaky Blinders.

Gillbil · 23/07/2023 04:54

phoenixrosehere · 21/07/2023 23:59

Could say the same about the number of movies the UK has created about their involvement in the World Wars so..

Exactly...history is written by the victors

DuesToTheDirt · 22/07/2023 20:37

@Cyclebabble Flowers. How traumatic for you all.

There are a lot of terrible accounts on this thread Sad.

Cyclebabble · 22/07/2023 20:35

My family is Malaysian. During the war.the Japanease were responsible for.more than 1m deaths of largely civilians in the Malay federation excluding those held as prisoners of war. Sllave labour was common and my own grandfather was beheaded in front of his family. He had helped the British and Indian army in retreat.with supplies. British colianialism was not great for us in a number of ways but the Japanease occupation was truly awful. It is important when we consider colonialism that we remember that all colonists could behave very badly indeed. Not just the white ones either.

Hawkins0001 · 22/07/2023 20:32

knitnerd90 · 22/07/2023 20:01

The thing about the decision to drop the bomb is that we don't have conclusive proof of whether it was necessary or not. Historians genuinely disagree and each side marshals arguments (as in that Nation piece) to prove it. It's dishonest to present such an argument as definitive. We don't know and we're arguing with the benefit of hindsight.

for that matter you can find some hardcore pacifists arguing that the entire war was unnecessary (yes even against Hitler).

there was very real racism against the Japanese during the war itself: see the USA's absolutely shameful internment of Japanese-Americans.

as I said though, war is ugly. You can make the "but children" argument for every decision during a war. One of my grandfathers (American) was in the Navy in the Pacific during the war, the other (British) was in Europe in the Army. I don't think, from what they said about their experiences, that they had any illusions about it.

Also the various intelligence services files would have more information than even historians

knitnerd90 · 22/07/2023 20:01

The thing about the decision to drop the bomb is that we don't have conclusive proof of whether it was necessary or not. Historians genuinely disagree and each side marshals arguments (as in that Nation piece) to prove it. It's dishonest to present such an argument as definitive. We don't know and we're arguing with the benefit of hindsight.

for that matter you can find some hardcore pacifists arguing that the entire war was unnecessary (yes even against Hitler).

there was very real racism against the Japanese during the war itself: see the USA's absolutely shameful internment of Japanese-Americans.

as I said though, war is ugly. You can make the "but children" argument for every decision during a war. One of my grandfathers (American) was in the Navy in the Pacific during the war, the other (British) was in Europe in the Army. I don't think, from what they said about their experiences, that they had any illusions about it.

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 19:22

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 19:22

I’m not testing anything. I’m using the exact words.

You think there were definitely Japanese families who were relieved about being the target of a nuclear bomb?

Not twisting*

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 19:22

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 19:03

You have to twist things don't you. There were almost certainly families at home who would be relieved it was over, relieved their sons were coming home if they had been lucky enough to survive, relieved that their younger sons weren't going to have to go and sacrifice themselves.

There are probably some families who think it is great for their sons to go and die but it is hardly a normal reaction for a loving family.

I’m not testing anything. I’m using the exact words.

You think there were definitely Japanese families who were relieved about being the target of a nuclear bomb?

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 19:03

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 11:10

My general tone is that we shouldn’t use nuclear weapons.
That we shouldn’t target children.
That children’s lives should be prioritised over adults.
That no one would ever be grateful or relieved to be the target of an atom bomb.

I think it’s far more offensive to pretend the Japanese were RELIEVED to be nuked.

You have to twist things don't you. There were almost certainly families at home who would be relieved it was over, relieved their sons were coming home if they had been lucky enough to survive, relieved that their younger sons weren't going to have to go and sacrifice themselves.

There are probably some families who think it is great for their sons to go and die but it is hardly a normal reaction for a loving family.

Iwasafool · 22/07/2023 18:55

Whelm · 22/07/2023 16:45

Thalidomide was and remains an important drug. Chirality wasn't understood when it was licensed and therefore its consequences weren't foreseeable https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/02/160208124237.htm
Earlier posters criticised the lack of medical care for Japanese survivors of the bombs and allied military personnel who were exposed intentionally or not to the after-effects of the bombs or other nuclear tests.
The sad fact is that the harmful effects of radioactivity weren't understood and people would have had no idea of how to treat or help victims. Later obfuscation and cover-ups are unforgivable, but no less likely to happen today.
I would recommend Kate Moore's book The Radium Girls to anyone interested in how society, business, governments and the legal system react to harm caused by ignorance of novel discoveries. The rush to implement AI, EVs and renewable energy may lead to similar outcomes.

A long time ago I read a book about thalidomide and how they worked out what was causing the deformities. All the deformities can happen naturally but suddenly lots more were happening. One theory was it was pollution or nuclear fallout. They got their clue as America hadn't licensed it and while the children were being born with the thalidomide damage all over europe in US army bases the women weren't having the same issue.

I probably read it 50 years ago but it was a fascinating detective story.

Beneficialchampion2 · 22/07/2023 17:13

YABVU, you can't erase history.

Whelm · 22/07/2023 16:45

Thisismynewusername1 · 22/07/2023 14:31

Is there any indication Oppenheimer wasn’t “nice” though?

he was a scientist whose work in physics happened to lead to the development of a destructive weapon.

we know he was conflicted about it. But it wasn’t his choice to actually drop those bombs.

I wonder what the lead scientist who developed Thalidomide feels? Is it their fault thousands of babies were affected? Or was it the people who licensed it for morning sickness?

it’s not like Oppenheimer set out to kill millions, or ever intended to.

Thalidomide was and remains an important drug. Chirality wasn't understood when it was licensed and therefore its consequences weren't foreseeable https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/02/160208124237.htm
Earlier posters criticised the lack of medical care for Japanese survivors of the bombs and allied military personnel who were exposed intentionally or not to the after-effects of the bombs or other nuclear tests.
The sad fact is that the harmful effects of radioactivity weren't understood and people would have had no idea of how to treat or help victims. Later obfuscation and cover-ups are unforgivable, but no less likely to happen today.
I would recommend Kate Moore's book The Radium Girls to anyone interested in how society, business, governments and the legal system react to harm caused by ignorance of novel discoveries. The rush to implement AI, EVs and renewable energy may lead to similar outcomes.

Nature's mirror: The code for chirality: Understanding the Thalidomide tragedy: How biological molecules re-shape crystalline surfaces and why this could pave the way to the development of new drugs

How information is transferred from biological molecules to crystalline surfaces could pave the way for the development of new drugs and other synthetic materials.

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/02/160208124237.htm

Thisismynewusername1 · 22/07/2023 14:31

10HailMarys · 22/07/2023 13:58

Are we only allowed to make films about nice people and happy things now?

It’s a historical biopic. Making a film about Oppenheimer doesn’t imply any endorsement of his work, ffs.

Is there any indication Oppenheimer wasn’t “nice” though?

he was a scientist whose work in physics happened to lead to the development of a destructive weapon.

we know he was conflicted about it. But it wasn’t his choice to actually drop those bombs.

I wonder what the lead scientist who developed Thalidomide feels? Is it their fault thousands of babies were affected? Or was it the people who licensed it for morning sickness?

it’s not like Oppenheimer set out to kill millions, or ever intended to.

Biker47 · 22/07/2023 14:08

If total war was brought to the Japanese mainland, it would have killed more allied personnel, and especially a lot more Japanese people; than the two bombs ever did.

10HailMarys · 22/07/2023 13:58

Are we only allowed to make films about nice people and happy things now?

It’s a historical biopic. Making a film about Oppenheimer doesn’t imply any endorsement of his work, ffs.

JuvenileEmu · 22/07/2023 13:53

@DuesToTheDirt Yes, I think in Japan at the time, non-Japanese were definitely seen as inferior and separate. Look at how Chinese and Korean people were treated.

And then you've got the treatment of allied POWs, mainly due the cultural belief at the time that no honourable soldier would ever surrender.

Unfortunately, the Japanese regime in the 30s and 40s was as militaristic, brutal and racist as the Nazis were.

Rudderneck · 22/07/2023 13:30

DuesToTheDirt · 22/07/2023 12:05

They were a brutal race.

It's a strange thing. The numerous Japanese people I know are kind, polite and gentle, much more so than most British people. I wonder where the brutality of the war came from? Perhaps from a view that non-Japanese were inferior and separate?

Yes. This wasn't just confined to WWII. You might find it interesting to watch the film Silence, about Jesuit missionaries to Japan. Their view of outsiders was something most of us in the west find difficult to understand or imagine.

Though it's worth remembering that politeness is not always just about kindness. It can also have to do with hierarchy, knowing your place, honour, and other social values. Honour based societies can be both extremely polite and extremely brutal and unforgiving.

The surrender after WWII had a deep effect on the Japanese psyche. The idea that they could be the losers was deeply shaming to them, and it very much changed their attitude toward military endevours. Some people say that it changed their culture in a profound way.

Rudderneck · 22/07/2023 13:23

I suspect part of the reason so many find it difficult to see the Japanese in WWII as "bad guys" is that we have internalized to such an extreme degree the white-oppressor, non-white-victim narrative. There is an very deep assumption, that people don't realize they are making, that the Japanese, in this case, couldn't really be the aggressors, or as bad as reported at the time, surely that must be some kind of colonialist spin.

It's the same reason they struggle with the idea that some at that time tended to see the Japanese as a whole in a very negative way. I suspect that most of these people were well aware that some Japanese peasant on his farm might be a perfectly nice person and certainly wasn't making military decisions. And that the elite were pushing a certain agenda. But what they experienced and saw was not just the Emperor and a few baddies. They saw not just a few people, but what seemed like a whole culture that saw other human beings as sub-humans who could be treated in ways most British people would not treat their dogs, with a kind of deliberate, premeditated, highly intelligent, cruelty. The question they asked themselves, and I know this from my own grandmother, was what kind of culture produces so many people who would behave that way or even feel it was no big deal?

It's not very comparable to something like Muslim terrorism, because that does not seem to reflect normative attitudes among Muslims across the world.

It's very difficult to separate that kind of feeling about a culture from one's feelings about the people themselves.

As far as the wrongness of targeting civilians, yes, which is why it's now a crime. But it wasn't then and everyone did it.

notimagain · 22/07/2023 12:57

@Againstmachine

But nowhere in that quote mentions surrender, it just states an opinion that they were hopeless, doesn't mean the opinion was same on the Japanese side.

Agree with you on that, Okinawa had shown the US that even when a situation was hopeless many Japanese were going to continue to try and inflict casualties….not just stick their arms up in the air and surrender.

…and Admiral Halsey’s comment attached to that quote needs to be read with at least a bit of awareness of the level of intensity of inter service rivalry.

user9630721458 · 22/07/2023 12:42

I am very grateful to posters, particularly @MissyGirlie, who highlight the atrocities visited on Asia and especially China. I have often found people in the UK do not seem to know about what I have heard termed the 'forgotten holocaust.' I am glad there seems to be so much knowledge about it here, as it hurts to think of all that suffering being brushed under the carpet. My ancestors were lucky to escape Singapore, thanks to the ties with Britain, for which I am forever grateful. I have been told I am privileged to be critical of targeting of civilians, and that may be true, as I didn't live through the war. But as I mourn the civilians massacred in Nanking, I also mourn those killed in the nuking of Japan.

JuvenileEmu · 22/07/2023 12:38

@Lacucuracha if the Japanese were going to surrender before the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, how do you explain the timeline:
6th of August- Hiroshima was bombed
9th of August- Nagasaki was bombed
15th of August- Japan officially surrenders

So over a week between the bombing of Nagasaki and surrender. Why was that?