Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 16:21

MavisMcMinty · 24/07/2023 14:27

I don’t have face blindness (and haven’t seen Oppenheimer yet), but would agree that in some films several of the actors look very like each other and it can be confusing to the plot. I think at the very least casting directors should choose actors with different hair colours and styles.

Come on now - would you be suggesting that in films where there is an obvious historical and ethnic cast too?

CasperGutman · 24/07/2023 15:42

In addition to what @notimagain said about hair style and length, it's a relevant to the story that many of the scientists at Los Alamos were Jewish. This helps in understanding why they may have been motivated to develop weapons which could be used to defeat Nazi Germany,* especially as they knew the Germans were ahead of them in trying to develop a nuclear weapon. It's therefore likely that they were mostly dark haired.

*Of course, in the end the bomb wasn't ready in time to use in Europe.

notimagain · 24/07/2023 15:13

... I think at the very least casting directors should choose actors with different hair colours and styles.

ProbIem is in the case of this film it is a WW2 supposedly fact based drama, and messing around with hairstyles just for the sake of easy ID would completely screw it's credibility in the eyes of those familiar with appearance of the historical figures being portrayed.

The military tended ever so slightly to have short hair, the "longhairs" at Los Alamos (the scientists) actually tended to be short/shortish hair as well (e.g. Oppenheimer and even the young rebels like Feynman at that time in his life) or bald (e.g. Fermi) .... TBH Einstein probably had the longest hair...

Not sure you can really change any of that.

MavisMcMinty · 24/07/2023 14:27

I don’t have face blindness (and haven’t seen Oppenheimer yet), but would agree that in some films several of the actors look very like each other and it can be confusing to the plot. I think at the very least casting directors should choose actors with different hair colours and styles.

CasperGutman · 24/07/2023 10:51

twentyonepoundnote · 24/07/2023 08:56

Being unable to distinguish one man from another is related to level of facial recognition, and face blindness, not intelligence- many highly intelligent people are face blind - it is unhelpful to be so dismissive of a very upsetting disability.

If film makers want people with facial recognition difficulties to watch their films them they need to make their characters easier to distinguish from each other.

This film will lose a lot of potential customers because it already has a reputation for failing to do that.

I'm surprised by this. I do often struggle with distinguishing characters in films, but didn't find this to be an issue here at all! Cilian Murphy is notably distinctive, and the other characters had a wide range of distinctive features other than face shape: some had strong accents, some were notably tall or short, or notably less slim than Oppenheimer, or wore rimless glasses (Lawrence) or heavy-framed glasses (Strauss) or uniforms (Groves, who also sported a moustache) etc.

And I didn't find the amount of "science talk" off-putting at all. It wasn't necessary to understand it in any depth to follow the plot, and most of it was just background - e.g., we see someone delivering the last line of a lecture, then the point of the scene is the conversation they have afterwards. I'm not really sure how a serious film about this topic could be made with any less scientific detail, to be honest!

Labtastic · 24/07/2023 10:49

A colleague just saw it and it and said it was dull. I'll give it a miss.

I get all the comments about face blindness, and not being able to keep up with all the characters - I think I'd have struggled a bit if I hadn't read the book, but dull? Dull?? I don't get this at all. I saw it on Saturday and cannot stop thinking about it. 3 hours went by in a flash. Best film I've seen for years.

melj1213 · 24/07/2023 10:26

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 10:18

I also noticed that the speech was very fast in this movie and then it is dealing with technical terms too.

That is also true - it is a very heavy film dealing with a massive subject so there is a lot for people to get their heads around, which isn't your normal requirement for a summer blockbuster.

I went in to the film having read the book it's based on and with a science background and was still a bit lost in places because I was trying to sort out the science jargon and again getting distracted from what was going on on the screen; I went with a friend who has no science knowledge at all beyond GCSE physics from 20 years ago and a lot of it just went over her head, but she wasn't bothered as she wasn't interested in figuring it out and was happy to just tune that out as "scientists talk science"; and a friend of mine in the US who is studying physics at Caltech who went to see it loved how much science jargon was included as it really enhanced the viewing for her (and there were a few throwaway lines here and there that had more significance if you understood the science but didn't take anything away if you didn't).

M4J4 · 24/07/2023 10:19

A colleague just saw it and it and said it was dull. I'll give it a miss.

My husband went to Japan and went to a museum about the bombings. He recorded a playing of a children's song/lullyaby from one of the school's when the bomb struck. It still gives me chills when I listen to it. So much innocencse lost needlessly.

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 10:18

I also noticed that the speech was very fast in this movie and then it is dealing with technical terms too.

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 10:17

And there was Tom Conti as Einstein - it was so strange for me to see Einstein in the movie as somehow that to me " was a long time ago".

melj1213 · 24/07/2023 10:15

I won't be going to see it, I have been warned by many people who have minimal difficulties that it is impossible to tell the characters apart.

It really isn't impossible. I suppose if you don't know any of the actors or the names of the scientists involved then it can be confusing as you're trying to put names and faces together with no context as to who the are and what significance they have, especially early on when we are introduced to a lot of characters in quick succession.

Yes there is the occasional moment when there's a large group of them together where it might take me a second to remember who they are but that's more because of the fact a lot of the cast are well known actors and I have heard of a lot of the scientists they were playing so I was doing the mental jigsaw in my head in the early stages and getting distracted. I was sitting there thinking "Who was speaking, oh that guy ... Where do I know him from ... Oh that's Rami Malek ... He's playing David Hill ... Why do I know Hill's name again ... Wait focus on the film ... what did that other guy just say? ... Where do I know him from ... Etcetc" and was then playing catch up but that was mostly my own attention span/ease of distraction rather than because it was impossible to tell them all apart.

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 10:07

Exactly and general lack of knowledge of the period.

twentyonepoundnote · 24/07/2023 10:07

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 09:54

That is so odd as the "white men in suits" are very identifiable by the very well known actors that portray them.

but I wouldn't identify a well known actor if they bit me in the leg! And lots of other people have not found it easy, so I am guessing that they may well use other cues to identify the actors, in other films - them being around fewer other similarly dressed men, might be one!

Of course there could also be people with no facial recognition difficulties who simply have not concentrated enough, as well

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 10:06

twentyonepoundnote · 24/07/2023 09:47

well, I am face blind myself, and know several others who are, but I don't know what percent of the population are. It is a spectrum however, and a lot of people who have minimal difficulties are struggling with this film. In real life, with both sexes and a mix of ethnic origins around you, you might have little or no trouble at all if you are only slightly face blind, but then have a lot of difficulty watching a film full of white men in suits with short hair.

As it's men, it would have been better to mix and match a bit with moustaches and beards, even if the characters didn't have these in real life - that is the advantage of men on screen, they can be differentiated like this - as opposed to a film full of white women with long blond hair, when there is little to no chance of telling them apart.

I won't be going to see it, I have been warned by many people who have minimal difficulties that it is impossible to tell the characters apart.

I'm not minimising your condition btw.

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 09:54

twentyonepoundnote · 24/07/2023 09:47

well, I am face blind myself, and know several others who are, but I don't know what percent of the population are. It is a spectrum however, and a lot of people who have minimal difficulties are struggling with this film. In real life, with both sexes and a mix of ethnic origins around you, you might have little or no trouble at all if you are only slightly face blind, but then have a lot of difficulty watching a film full of white men in suits with short hair.

As it's men, it would have been better to mix and match a bit with moustaches and beards, even if the characters didn't have these in real life - that is the advantage of men on screen, they can be differentiated like this - as opposed to a film full of white women with long blond hair, when there is little to no chance of telling them apart.

I won't be going to see it, I have been warned by many people who have minimal difficulties that it is impossible to tell the characters apart.

That is so odd as the "white men in suits" are very identifiable by the very well known actors that portray them.

twentyonepoundnote · 24/07/2023 09:47

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 09:35

While this is all very interesting what % of the population does it apply to? I wonder what % of that % were in the cinema I was in yesterday?

I tended to think it was a lack of knowledge and a lack of the ability to concentrate in the people I heard.

well, I am face blind myself, and know several others who are, but I don't know what percent of the population are. It is a spectrum however, and a lot of people who have minimal difficulties are struggling with this film. In real life, with both sexes and a mix of ethnic origins around you, you might have little or no trouble at all if you are only slightly face blind, but then have a lot of difficulty watching a film full of white men in suits with short hair.

As it's men, it would have been better to mix and match a bit with moustaches and beards, even if the characters didn't have these in real life - that is the advantage of men on screen, they can be differentiated like this - as opposed to a film full of white women with long blond hair, when there is little to no chance of telling them apart.

I won't be going to see it, I have been warned by many people who have minimal difficulties that it is impossible to tell the characters apart.

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 09:35

Freshair1 · 24/07/2023 06:51

I'm excited. Seeing it with subtitles tonight. First film I've seen in a few years. If the score is like Interstellar then I'll be a wreck.

The score is amazing - we saw it in an Imax!

Gingerboy22 · 24/07/2023 09:35

twentyonepoundnote · 24/07/2023 08:56

Being unable to distinguish one man from another is related to level of facial recognition, and face blindness, not intelligence- many highly intelligent people are face blind - it is unhelpful to be so dismissive of a very upsetting disability.

If film makers want people with facial recognition difficulties to watch their films them they need to make their characters easier to distinguish from each other.

This film will lose a lot of potential customers because it already has a reputation for failing to do that.

While this is all very interesting what % of the population does it apply to? I wonder what % of that % were in the cinema I was in yesterday?

I tended to think it was a lack of knowledge and a lack of the ability to concentrate in the people I heard.

Rocknrollstar · 24/07/2023 09:18

The film shows that he was a theoretician and perhaps naive. He was very remorseful that so many people died and tried to stop the American government from developing the H bomb. His life was destroyed because of this.

twentyonepoundnote · 24/07/2023 08:56

Gingerboy22 · 23/07/2023 21:54

Finally saw this today and no O is not feted as a hero. It follows the project, his resistance to developing the H bomb afterwards and investigations into him. It was about the politics of the time. You do need to have a certain amount of intelligence to understand this film and knowledge of world history perhaps unlike the ones coming out moaning that it was too long and they couldn't distinguish " one man from another". Maybe they thought it was going to be Peaky Blinders.

Being unable to distinguish one man from another is related to level of facial recognition, and face blindness, not intelligence- many highly intelligent people are face blind - it is unhelpful to be so dismissive of a very upsetting disability.

If film makers want people with facial recognition difficulties to watch their films them they need to make their characters easier to distinguish from each other.

This film will lose a lot of potential customers because it already has a reputation for failing to do that.

Freshair1 · 24/07/2023 06:51

I'm excited. Seeing it with subtitles tonight. First film I've seen in a few years. If the score is like Interstellar then I'll be a wreck.

CasperGutman · 24/07/2023 06:23

It really is an excellent film, and not in any way a hagiography o'r glorification of Oppenheimer. YABU to dismiss this work based on your guesses as to what it might be like. "Uncomfortable" is, however, a pretty appropriate word for the way the film leaves the viewer feeling!

logicisall · 24/07/2023 05:20

Exactly...history is written by the victors

I don't think that this applies nowadays as history is being revised with different conclusions being reached by current analysts.

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 23/07/2023 22:47

@melj1213 thank you, I’ll read the book next.

knitnerd90 · 23/07/2023 22:37

I saw it last night and thought it was excellent. I also thought that the film largely did an excellent job of showing the moral and historical complexities of the bomb program.