Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
Superfood · 21/07/2023 19:58

MotherofGorgons · 21/07/2023 19:11

I don't think either Oppenheimer or Barbie are what you think they are. Apparently, both are brilliantly subversive.

If the Barbie movie were in any way at all 'subversive', it wouldn't be an officially approved Barbie (TM) product.

But well done for taking all that marketing and PR at face value.

TheoTheopolis23 · 21/07/2023 19:56

I've had a woman on a flight tell me Syed never visit Turkey because of Turkish behaviour on Cyprus - they did a tour when visiting it and found out about how bad the Turks are.

I pointed out that the Turks who make policy and the Turks on Cyprus are a tiny nber of people.... And that, in the subject of policy, they are not even a democracy. The receptionist in our hotel in Turkey told us people who rebel against the state are interned indefinitely. That they )he and others who disagree with policies) are angry, but also scared there.

I said depriving them, ordinary people, of income was hardly the solution.
She had little to argue back.

This is similar to talking about ordinary civilian people in a state as being inclined or responsible for things they are not, anywhere (look at the UKs population's feelings about the invasion of Irak etc) let alone in non democracies.

MissyGirlie · 21/07/2023 19:56

it's not civilians, it's not the majority of people.
I can't speak for the civilians en bloc - and some of them were decent - but the army was rotten from cellar to attic. Yes, there was the odd 'good Japanese' in uniform, but the military culture was utterly brutal.

IMHO opinion, the atom bombs resulted in a net saving of lives. Not just the Allied troops who would have died fighting their way island by island, not the Japanese civilians and soldiers who would have been killed, but the thousands of Asian civilians who were dying under Japanese rule across vast chunks of Asia.

Frabbits · 21/07/2023 19:56

Won't somebody think of the children?

You haven't even seen it.

Maireas · 21/07/2023 19:56

Iwasafool · 21/07/2023 19:55

Maybe she thinks it glorifies Klaus Barbie?

😂😂

Iwasafool · 21/07/2023 19:55

PorpoiseWithPurpose · 21/07/2023 19:37

No one has a problem with it apart from OP.

Maybe she thinks it glorifies Klaus Barbie?

Maireas · 21/07/2023 19:55

Oppenheimer was a lifelong socialist. He only got clearance because the US needed his scientific expertise. In the McCarthy era he lost his clearance.
He was motivated to be part of the Manhattan project because he knew the Nazis were working on the Bomb. He knew they had to develop it first. Can you imagine if they had developed it? ...
He learned Sanskrit to read the Hindu scriptures, where "the destroyer of worlds" comes from.

EmmaPaella · 21/07/2023 19:54

How do you know it is from the Americans POV OP? What with not having seen it.

MissEDashwood19 · 21/07/2023 19:53

MissyGirlie · 21/07/2023 19:37

OP, I haven't RTFT, because I haven't the patience. I have however changed my user name, because what I am about to say will be very outing.

I would suggest that you catch up sharpish on the history of Asia under the Japanese, c1930-1945. The Japanese were brutal in China. They carried out medical experiments on many, many human beings, who they referred to as 'maruta' - logs. They killed thousands when they took Nanking.

I know the most about Malaya. My father's Eurasian family was there when the Japanese army came ashore (not having declared war). They were utterly, horrendously brutal. Somewhere over 20,000 Chinese were killed in what was call the Syonan Daikensho - the Great Singapore Inspection - in the course of about a month just after the fall of Singapore. Other Chinese were killed up and down the peninsula, in their hundreds and thousands, at least one whole village rounded up and the buildings set on fire with the people inside.

My own family had a terrible time. My father's father was killed when the ship in which he tried to leave Singapore, packed with civilians, was shelled and sunk by a Japanese destroyer whose captain knew that there were hundreds of civilians on board. My grandmother was interned and came out weighing about 5 stone. One of my uncles was recaptured with some others after escaping from a POW camp; he was beaten repeatedly and finally executed. It was botched, and none of the men was killed outright by the firing squad, they all had to finished off by an officer with a pistol (iirc).

My oldest cousin was also a POW (he was very much older than me). We don't know how he died, because the Japanese falsified the records of the camp he was in (Labuan - no survivors, none, not one) - to disguise the massacre at the end of the war, when the death marched the last of the men and finally shot them. Another cousin had a narrow escape from being forced into prostitution.

You think that's bad? The worst story of the lot was my father's uncle and aunt. They and another 60 or more people were massacred at the rubber estate where they had taken refuge. Men, women, and children, including babes in arms. Killed in cold blood, with bayonets. Nobody knows why: again, no survivors. At about the same time, there was a massacre of dozens of Chinese on a nearby pineapple estate.

Repeat that over and over and over again, through China, Burma, what is now Vietnam and Laos and Cambodia, what is now Indonesia, what is now Malaysia. Asians were chipped off in their thousands to work on the Burma-Siam railways; thousands died. Javanese were shipped over to work in Singapore. when the work ran out, the Japanese turned them out to starve in the streets: I used to know someone whose brother's (cousin's?) job at that time was taking a handcart round to collect up the bodies. By the end of the war, about 10,000 people A DAY were dying of starvation across Japanese-occupied Asia. The Japanese people were being urged to fight to the last man, woman and child. One faction in government was desperate to continue the war, and orders had been issued for the killing of all prisoners of war. All of them. Tens of thousands of people. In places, Japanese army supply lines had collapsed and the troops were (and this you will not believe, but plenty of accounts attest to it) eating their Indian POWs (see John Baptist Crasta, 'Eaten by the Japanese'.

So before you start feeling too awfully sorry for the Japanese, consider all this. Consider also that ALL Japanese war dead - including the war criminals like the man who was probably responsible for the death of my cousin - are enshrined at Yaukuni, and influential Japanese politicians still go and pay their respects there. Remember Shinzo Abe? Yup, he did.

I think the atom bombs were terrible, but I think that on balance they saved lives. I don't blame modern Japanese for what their forebears did. But I can't bear people condemning the Allies for the atom bombs when they have no idea what Japan did in Asia, mostly to Asians but also to tens of thousands of European and Indian POWs.

Thank you for sharing. The Japanese well and truly evaded justice for the crimes they committed. Japanese soldiers committed atrocities on an industrial scale. Most Europeans don't know enough about their crimes, so the continued lies and misrepresentation of the war by the Japanese goes unchallenged.

TheoTheopolis23 · 21/07/2023 19:52

*We need to make it clear it's a small group (relative to the entire population) leading a state or the military of that state.

TheoTheopolis23 · 21/07/2023 19:51

All this talk of Japan, the Japanese State, The Japanese ...... As with any state/country/group of states; it's not civilians, it's not the majority of people.

The people who were killed by by the atomic bombs in Japan were highly unlikely to have been responsible for any of the war crimes/killings etc. They were civilians, were they not; including women and children.

Same for any state, military of that state.

Why talk as though everyone or the majority of people were involved or responsible; they weren't. They are all victims, made so by their leaders decisions.
Japan want even democratic FFS. They had no vote, no say. They were ignorant of what was happening outside their local.area and we're subject to propaganda and censorship.

I think we need to be very careful in saying "Japan", "The Japanese State" etc (applies to any state, especially dictatorships .... We need to make it clear it's a small group (relative to the entire population) leading a state of the military of that state.

Maireas · 21/07/2023 19:50

twentyonepoundnote · 21/07/2023 18:26

YABU I can't stand films about the holocaust, such as Schindler's list - but other people have the option to watch them if they want to, and people learn from them

This.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/07/2023 19:49

ScentlessAprentice · 21/07/2023 18:55

Your passive aggressive calling people 'lovely', 'darling', and 'hon', along with the 'off you pop' when someone posted something that you disliked, suggests that you don't really want opinions at all.

I think you are correct.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/07/2023 19:49

I don't know much about him at all hence my thread,

Not able to google, even a cursory one?

That's not the basis of your thread anyway. Your thread is objecting to a film you haven't watched apparently glorifying a figure you know nothing about 🙄

TrueScrumptious · 21/07/2023 19:48

None of the promotional material I’ve seen makes him out to be a hero. Where have you got that from?

EarringsandLipstick · 21/07/2023 19:47

Don't get me started on why I won't watch Barbie, we'll be here all night and I've got shit to do.

I won't. And I didn't.

It was you who brought it up.

It seems throwing out casual uniformed one-liners, that you can't back up, is your thing.

Hibiscrubbed · 21/07/2023 19:47

Jesus Christ. 🤦🏼‍♀️

MissEDashwood19 · 21/07/2023 19:39

Justcallmebebes · 21/07/2023 19:24

Also OP, read up on the Japanese invasion of China pre World War 2. The Japanese did not cover themselves in glory at all

The Japanese were not the war's victims despite their myriad and continued attempts to paint themselves as such.

Chinese and Korean women and children, among their many other victims, were brutalised, raped and murdered in their millions. Somehow these barbarous acts are overlooked.

The bomb was horrible, but it does not negate the evil the Japan unleashed on its neighbours and allied PoWs.

The Emperor and his military junta were utterly criminal and Japanese civilians were collateral damage in the war of annihilation they were happy to wage on their "enemies". Most of these supremely evil people escaped justice, like the Emper who should have been executed for war crimes and crimes against humanity.

BarelyLiterate · 21/07/2023 19:37

I haven’t seen the movie, either, but it’s important to be understand the history. Japan was the aggressor in WWII, not the victim of aggression. The imperialist Japanese regime sought to invade & conquer other nations and subjugate their peoples to enrich themselves. Japan launched an unprovoked war of aggression against the U.S. with the (military brilliant & highly successful) attack on Pearl Harbor.
Dropping nuclear bombs on Hiroshima & Nagasaki forced the Japanese to surrender & shortened the war. Had it not happened, the US & its allies would have been forced to invade in order to defeat Japan, at the likely cost of millions of lives. President Trueman had no easy options in 1945, and most historians agree that he chose the least bad one.

PorpoiseWithPurpose · 21/07/2023 19:37

Nw22 · 21/07/2023 19:04

I’m intrigued what people think the problem with Barbie is

No one has a problem with it apart from OP.

MissyGirlie · 21/07/2023 19:37

OP, I haven't RTFT, because I haven't the patience. I have however changed my user name, because what I am about to say will be very outing.

I would suggest that you catch up sharpish on the history of Asia under the Japanese, c1930-1945. The Japanese were brutal in China. They carried out medical experiments on many, many human beings, who they referred to as 'maruta' - logs. They killed thousands when they took Nanking.

I know the most about Malaya. My father's Eurasian family was there when the Japanese army came ashore (not having declared war). They were utterly, horrendously brutal. Somewhere over 20,000 Chinese were killed in what was call the Syonan Daikensho - the Great Singapore Inspection - in the course of about a month just after the fall of Singapore. Other Chinese were killed up and down the peninsula, in their hundreds and thousands, at least one whole village rounded up and the buildings set on fire with the people inside.

My own family had a terrible time. My father's father was killed when the ship in which he tried to leave Singapore, packed with civilians, was shelled and sunk by a Japanese destroyer whose captain knew that there were hundreds of civilians on board. My grandmother was interned and came out weighing about 5 stone. One of my uncles was recaptured with some others after escaping from a POW camp; he was beaten repeatedly and finally executed. It was botched, and none of the men was killed outright by the firing squad, they all had to finished off by an officer with a pistol (iirc).

My oldest cousin was also a POW (he was very much older than me). We don't know how he died, because the Japanese falsified the records of the camp he was in (Labuan - no survivors, none, not one) - to disguise the massacre at the end of the war, when the death marched the last of the men and finally shot them. Another cousin had a narrow escape from being forced into prostitution.

You think that's bad? The worst story of the lot was my father's uncle and aunt. They and another 60 or more people were massacred at the rubber estate where they had taken refuge. Men, women, and children, including babes in arms. Killed in cold blood, with bayonets. Nobody knows why: again, no survivors. At about the same time, there was a massacre of dozens of Chinese on a nearby pineapple estate.

Repeat that over and over and over again, through China, Burma, what is now Vietnam and Laos and Cambodia, what is now Indonesia, what is now Malaysia. Asians were chipped off in their thousands to work on the Burma-Siam railways; thousands died. Javanese were shipped over to work in Singapore. when the work ran out, the Japanese turned them out to starve in the streets: I used to know someone whose brother's (cousin's?) job at that time was taking a handcart round to collect up the bodies. By the end of the war, about 10,000 people A DAY were dying of starvation across Japanese-occupied Asia. The Japanese people were being urged to fight to the last man, woman and child. One faction in government was desperate to continue the war, and orders had been issued for the killing of all prisoners of war. All of them. Tens of thousands of people. In places, Japanese army supply lines had collapsed and the troops were (and this you will not believe, but plenty of accounts attest to it) eating their Indian POWs (see John Baptist Crasta, 'Eaten by the Japanese'.

So before you start feeling too awfully sorry for the Japanese, consider all this. Consider also that ALL Japanese war dead - including the war criminals like the man who was probably responsible for the death of my cousin - are enshrined at Yaukuni, and influential Japanese politicians still go and pay their respects there. Remember Shinzo Abe? Yup, he did.

I think the atom bombs were terrible, but I think that on balance they saved lives. I don't blame modern Japanese for what their forebears did. But I can't bear people condemning the Allies for the atom bombs when they have no idea what Japan did in Asia, mostly to Asians but also to tens of thousands of European and Indian POWs.

readbooksdrinktea · 21/07/2023 19:35

BrandyandGinger thanks for posting the link.

SunnyEgg · 21/07/2023 19:32

I know nothing about the film but the Richard Rhodes book The Making of the Atomic Bomb is fascinating and totally changed my views on why we ended up where we did

StillWantingADog · 21/07/2023 19:32

readbooksdrinktea · 21/07/2023 18:31

YABU for saying it depicts him as a hero if you haven't even seen it.

This. None of the promotional stuff I have seen- or the reviews- suggest this is the case

saltinesandcoffeecups · 21/07/2023 19:29

To sum up this thread:

OP:There’s a thing I know very little about and don’t feel comfortable with the portrayal of this thing.

Everyone else:

  • Don’t watch it
  • It’s complicated
  • Here are some facts
OP: OMG Why are being mean to me