Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
Louloulouenna · 21/07/2023 20:53

It leaves a bad taste in the mouth to see people casually labelling victims of hideous Japanese war crimes as racist - would you say the same of holocaust victims or those who suffered so horrendously in the Mau Mau rebellion or the multitude of other genocidal crimes?

MissyGirlie · 21/07/2023 20:53

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 20:29

This is just racism.

Is it ok to dislike Germans? Americans? Brits?

Have you accepted the utter horror that the Japanese nation/government/army/whatever visited upon Asia from 1931-45?

And the thing is... Japan is not like Germany, where they have picked over their past. I had a long conversation with a Japanese woman once who wanted to talk to me about the war (she must have known something about my family background - see a few pages back for details) and she explained that she'd been taught nothing about it all in school, and felt deceived and betrayed as a consequence.

Chestnutlover · 21/07/2023 20:52

I know what you mean. I felt weird about it too. I understand people saying it’s history etc but why dramatize it? We can read about it in history books. The atomic bomb etc makes me feel sick.

Agapornis · 21/07/2023 20:50

Maybe you should look up Oppenheimer's work.
Maybe you should look up Christopher Nolan's work.
Maybe you should look up Cillian Murphy's work.

None of them are into mindless flag-waving hero worship.

Lifeomars · 21/07/2023 20:50

tulipheart · 21/07/2023 20:42

I have watched it this afternoon.
It is brilliantly acted and does not glamorise story. Really well done.
Three hours long but every minute of film I was gripped and learnt more about the history of it all although I had read about it before film.
It was one of the best films I have seen for a while. Overall it felt they showed more about him as a person than the making of the bomb. He was not portrayed as a hero in the film.
Well worth watching and felt sad many times throughout.

Thank you for this review, I have been in two minds about seeing it due to the subject matter as I tend to go for escapist stuff due to finding real life grim enough. You have made it sound really thought-provoking and balanced and I think I will go and see it now

Iwasafool · 21/07/2023 20:49

yogibutton · 21/07/2023 20:14

It's pathetic, people trying to justify the dropping of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki by Japanese war crimes. As if they are some Athena, the goddess of wisdom, evaluating who deserves to die in some kind of cosmic balance(???) I am just speechless that anyone would think the atrocity of Hiroshima and Nagasaki could be justified.

So we should have just left it to the Japanese criminal leadership to carry on with their murderous war? I'm sure their wisdom about who should die, and how they should die often in the most disgusting experiments is beyond reproach.

I wonder how many Japanese mothers were thankful for the end of the war as their teenage sons were being forced to be kamikazes pilots. The horror of seeing your terrified badly trained son going off to deliberately kill themselves is hard to contemplate.

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/07/2023 20:48

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 20:36

There no good reason to be racist.

I think that's over simplifying matters. We are all a product of our time and our experience. A person who's lived through extreme hardship and fear due to oppression by another race or country is bound to have been affected. My own grandparents were occupied by the Nazis. They had a lifelong dislike of Germans. There are probably plenty of Ukrainians who dislike Russians. If you're lucky enough to have lived in peace you can't really judge.

Midgewater · 21/07/2023 20:46

The Japanese would have fought to last or committed suicide, awful as it is, if the bombs weren't dropped more lives would have been lost.

"Ota Masahide, a survivor and Okinawa historian, wrote in an article for the Asia-Pacific Journal in 2014 that the military distributed hand-grenades to the civilian population as the means to commit suicide with loved ones. Those that survived the grenades “worried” about being alive and found other ways to kill themselves with other weapons such as scythes, razor blades, ropes, rocks, and sticks. Military propaganda had warned the civilian population that if they were captured, the Americans would torture, rape, and murder them."

https://ahf.nuclearmuseum.org/ahf/history/japanese-mass-suicides/

Japanese resistance fighters captured

Japanese Mass Suicides - Nuclear Museum

The War of the Pacific against Imperial Japan was marked by episodes of mass suicides by Japanese soldiers and civilians, notably in Saipan and Okinawa.

https://ahf.nuclearmuseum.org/ahf/history/japanese-mass-suicides

Ridemeginger · 21/07/2023 20:46

I've seen the play, Oppenheimer. I assume this film is based on the same book as the play. It certainly does not glorify him, although he was a brilliant mind. He was not responsible for the way politicians and the military used his work. If he hadn't developed atomic energy first, other scientists in Germany or Russia would have. He absolutely regretted the way his work was used to develop nuclear weapons, and the human suffering in Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

Tangled123 · 21/07/2023 20:45

I’ve just seen it. It didn’t glorify him really, it showed a man that got carried away with the science but then realised what he did after the bomb was actually made. There was one scene where they cheer him but it’s clear he’s not enjoying it.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 21/07/2023 20:43

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:34

Well yes, I DEFINITELY won't be watching Barbie!

Well it sounds as if you make value judgements about films without researching them... have you rwad much about the Barbie film. Guessing you get the underlying themes at least🤷‍♀️
As for Oppenheimer yabvu because you know nothing about the film, just somehow think it glorifies the topic, and not much, it seems, about this momentous part of our shared history

Feeling uncomfortable about this topic don't go and see it, but don't condemn the film makers for telling an important, true story... getting close to censorship

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 20:43

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 20:36

There no good reason to be racist.

He wasn't a racist. That's my point, sorry if it was a bit subtle for you. My Dad was there. I wasn't. You weren't. Your opinion is not informed. How dare you judge anyone from that generation that fought for our freedom.

anotherside · 21/07/2023 20:43

The USA never needed to drop those bombs, the war was effectively over. They just wanted to play with their toys.

I’m not sure there is any really reliable evidence that Japan and its army was willing to immediately surrender. The nation was absolutely crazed, as witnessed by the hideous war crimes it committed. It was beaten, but it would have taken 10s or 100s of thousands of lives with it on the way down.

All that being said, I generally dislike all war films that don’t have as their main focus the horror of war, as that above all is what war is. Though I guess the odd character study related to war is ok. But generally speaking if you want to know the details of this or that situation read a book/watch a documentary instead. I certainly won’t be watching as “Dunkirk” by same director was a load of shite - failing both to enlighten and entertain in equal measure.

Forestfriendlygarden · 21/07/2023 20:43

A biographer whose Pulitzer prize-winning book inspired the new movie Oppenheimer has expressed support for a US senator’s attempt to bar the use of artificial intelligence in nuclear weapons launches.

“Humans must always maintain sole control over nuclear weapons,” Kai Bird, author of American Prometheus, said in a statement reported by Politico.

Related: Christopher Nolan: ‘Very strong parallels’ between Oppenheimer and scientists worried about AI

“This technology is too dangerous to gamble with. This bill will send a powerful signal to the world that the United States will never take the reckless step of automating our nuclear command and control.”

In Washington on Thursday, Bird met Ed Markey, the Democratic Massachusetts senator who is attempting to add the AI-nuclear provision to a major defense spending bill.

Markey, Politico said, was a friend of Bird’s co-author, the late Tufts University professor Martin J Sherwin.

A spokesperson for the senator told Politico Markey and Bird “shared their mutual concerns over the proliferation of artificial intelligence in national security and defense without guardrails, and the risks of using nuclear weapons in south Asia and elsewhere.

Related video: The True Story Behind the Bombs From Oppenheimer (Dailymotion)

“They also discussed ways to increase awareness of nuclear issues among the younger set.”

J Robert Oppenheimer was the driving force behind US development of the atomic bomb, at the end of the second world war...

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/07/2023 20:42

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 20:36

There no good reason to be racist.

My DGM's brother was captured when SIngapore fell. He was being taken with a whole shipful of POWs to Japan when the ship was torpedoed by a US submarine. The Japanese crew battened the hatches and left the ship to sink and the prisoners to drown - which took two days. If my DGM saw that as a good reason to hate the Japanese - which she did - I wasn't going to argue with her. Knock it off with this bleating of 'that's no reason to be racist.' I can assure you that post 1945 a lot of people had a lot of reason to hate the Japanese for what they did - a few examples of which are upthread if you can be bothered to read them.

tulipheart · 21/07/2023 20:42

I have watched it this afternoon.
It is brilliantly acted and does not glamorise story. Really well done.
Three hours long but every minute of film I was gripped and learnt more about the history of it all although I had read about it before film.
It was one of the best films I have seen for a while. Overall it felt they showed more about him as a person than the making of the bomb. He was not portrayed as a hero in the film.
Well worth watching and felt sad many times throughout.

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/07/2023 20:39

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 20:28

You don’t drop atomic bombs in a nation to ‘chasten’ them after they have surrendered.

By your logic many countries working the world have the right to chasten us in Britain by dropping atomic bombs on us.

They hadn't surrendered when the bombs were dropped though, had they?

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 20:38

This reply has been deleted

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

The USA had intelligence that Japan were intending to surrender BEFORE the first bomb was dropped, and that Japan’s concern was reinstating their emperor post surrender.

The USA didn’t need to drop ANY bombs.

Wheretostartstitching · 21/07/2023 20:37

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 20:29

This is just racism.

Is it ok to dislike Germans? Americans? Brits?

Lots of people are quite fine with people openly disliking Germans, Americans and British people.

MavisMcMinty · 21/07/2023 20:37

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 20:34

My father (now deceased) the kindest man you could ever meet hated the Japanese with such a passion, he berated my friend when we were 17 for buying a second hand Datsun car (Nissan). Maybe it was racism, maybe he had good reason i.e. mates who suffered their concentration camps. I'm not judging because I wasn't there, I wasn't even born. Just saying.

Thanks for this, I was always surprised by my Dad’s dislike as he really isn’t prejudiced against anything or anyone else. War babies grow up on real-life war stories, I suppose.

lljkk · 21/07/2023 20:36

I'm looking forward to Barbie movie. I don't like serious films but others are free to enjoy them.

uncomfortable because you think it may not portray the story in a way that you find palatable?

That's My big beef with The Imitation Game. Turing was not a social misfit cruelly treated by people around him, especially as a child. All that is false. He was sociable if hard-working & quite respected. Anyway, Imitation Game is good flick but it is fiction. I can't watch it now, it's become unpalatable for me.

I can't get my head around Cillian Murphy as lead with American accent.

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 20:36

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 20:34

My father (now deceased) the kindest man you could ever meet hated the Japanese with such a passion, he berated my friend when we were 17 for buying a second hand Datsun car (Nissan). Maybe it was racism, maybe he had good reason i.e. mates who suffered their concentration camps. I'm not judging because I wasn't there, I wasn't even born. Just saying.

There no good reason to be racist.

ChristmasFluff · 21/07/2023 20:35

Love @MsAmerica 's response, which really made me think.

But why start a thread when you haven't watched the film?

You have no idea what message the film will give, or the questions it will raise. For all you know, the film may be designed to bring people's attention to exactly the issues you raise.

But hey, why waste a last chance to parade ignorance and bring even more publicity to a film you think you will hate.....

Or maybe you are one of those who still believes Life of Brian is blasphemous, out of never having watched it?

MavisMcMinty · 21/07/2023 20:35

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 20:29

This is just racism.

Is it ok to dislike Germans? Americans? Brits?

Yes, as I said, it was inexplicable to me previously, because he is not racist and has lived and worked all over the world, including Germany and south-east Asia. His RAF pilot brother in law was a prisoner of war after being shot down over Germany and always said he was grateful and lucky to have been a Nazi POW rather than a Japanese POW.