Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 21:16

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 20:43

He wasn't a racist. That's my point, sorry if it was a bit subtle for you. My Dad was there. I wasn't. You weren't. Your opinion is not informed. How dare you judge anyone from that generation that fought for our freedom.

Climb down of your high horse. As I said, I had a relative who went through similar. He was never racist towards anyone. And I wasn’t judging your relative, I was judging you and your choice of words. There is never a good reason to be racist. I don’t care what you say, there is no good reason to be racist end of.

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 21:15

anotherside · 21/07/2023 20:43

The USA never needed to drop those bombs, the war was effectively over. They just wanted to play with their toys.

I’m not sure there is any really reliable evidence that Japan and its army was willing to immediately surrender. The nation was absolutely crazed, as witnessed by the hideous war crimes it committed. It was beaten, but it would have taken 10s or 100s of thousands of lives with it on the way down.

All that being said, I generally dislike all war films that don’t have as their main focus the horror of war, as that above all is what war is. Though I guess the odd character study related to war is ok. But generally speaking if you want to know the details of this or that situation read a book/watch a documentary instead. I certainly won’t be watching as “Dunkirk” by same director was a load of shite - failing both to enlighten and entertain in equal measure.

“the U.S. had already intercepted communications from Japan showing that the emperor had asked the Russians to mediate a surrender, and almost every top U.S. military leader from the time later came forward saying that Japan was already defeated before the bombs were dropped. The remaining debate between historians is less about whether Japan was already going to surrender, and more about why the U.S. used the atomic bombs at all. On the one hand, some argue that President Truman saw the bomb as just one more legitimate weapon to continue fighting with until the end, but others insist that the actual purpose was to intimidate the Russians and secure the U.S. as the winner at the beginning of the Cold War.”

https://classroom.synonym.com/evidence-japan-going-surrender-10861.html

Evidence That Japan Was Going to Surrender | Synonym

World War II in the Pacific came to an end in August 1945, when Japan surrendered unconditionally to the Unites States and its allies. According to the standard story in the U.S., it was the American atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki that broug...

https://classroom.synonym.com/evidence-japan-going-surrender-10861.html

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 21:12

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/07/2023 20:42

My DGM's brother was captured when SIngapore fell. He was being taken with a whole shipful of POWs to Japan when the ship was torpedoed by a US submarine. The Japanese crew battened the hatches and left the ship to sink and the prisoners to drown - which took two days. If my DGM saw that as a good reason to hate the Japanese - which she did - I wasn't going to argue with her. Knock it off with this bleating of 'that's no reason to be racist.' I can assure you that post 1945 a lot of people had a lot of reason to hate the Japanese for what they did - a few examples of which are upthread if you can be bothered to read them.

I have read the thread. There’s no good reason to be racist. I had a dear relative who was in army and saw a lot of action. He had dear friends die. He saw awful things.

He never hated anyone else. He was never racist. I don’t care what excuses you might have. There’s no ‘good reason’ to be racist.

JudgeJ · 21/07/2023 21:12

YABU. Japan has been very successful in pushing a martyr narrative. They were utter, utter bastards before an during the war. They would have carried on being so. Maybe read up on it a bit?

Very well said.

notimagain · 21/07/2023 21:12

@Gelpen

Oppenheimer was indeed only part of the puzzle to creating the atomic bomb and I hope the film shows this. His name has become synonymous with atomic weapons, but just as with every event and discovery in history, he did not do it alone. The science didn’t spring into his head fully formed. It is perhaps unfair to him to label him solely with this inglorious achievement, particularly as he himself was so horrified by it.

Agreed.

melj1213 · 21/07/2023 21:12

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

Having just got back from watching it, you are 100% wrong.

This is why it's important to judge a movie on its content, not just on what you think it's going to be.

The film does not depict Oppenheimer as a hero, not does it depoct him as a demon, it explores his life and work that includes his involvement in the Manhattan project. It is very much an exploration of him, his life, his work and the team that put the atomic bomb together in the first place - I love science and there was still far more actual exploration of quantum mechanics and theoretical physics than I was expecting in a blockbuster movie - as well as the aftermath and the fallout from the project.

Saschka · 21/07/2023 21:11

OP, if you think the A bomb has left untold scars on Japan, why is it that you don’t think Operation Meetinghouse did? After all, as you surely know given your deep knowledge of Japanese wartime history, the firebombing campaign in Tokyo killed many more civilians in one night than both nuclear bombs did.

And that firebombing campaign had already destroyed most of the major cities in Japan by the time the bomb was dropped on Hiroshima - there was literally nowhere else left to drop it.

Threenow · 21/07/2023 21:10

The war in Japan was far from over and the Japanese had vowed to continue.

This! As usual this is all based on European experience. Just because the war in Europe was effectively over doesn't mean WW2 had ended - but of course, the rest of the world doesn't matter. Have you ever heard stories from anyone who was in a Japanese POW camp OP?

As often happens we have here an OP who asks for opinions, doesn't like the opinions she gets, and stamps her foot. I saw the trailer for the film last night and didn't get any sense of celebrating a hero.

Gelpen · 21/07/2023 21:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Deescot · 21/07/2023 21:09

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 20:43

He wasn't a racist. That's my point, sorry if it was a bit subtle for you. My Dad was there. I wasn't. You weren't. Your opinion is not informed. How dare you judge anyone from that generation that fought for our freedom.

Well said!!

Meowandthen · 21/07/2023 21:09

Spirallingdownwards · 21/07/2023 18:40

Isn't the whole point of Oppenheimer to show how much he regretted being involved and isn't Barbie in effect an antiBarbie girl empowerment film? I am failing to see why they would be a problem.

Quite. But how else to virtue signal? 🤔

Facts and history aren’t glorification and seems to me that knowledge is a good thing.

JudgeJ · 21/07/2023 21:09

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 18:26

YANBU if that’s true. I haven’t seen it but if he is being portrayed as a hero then that’s terrible.

The USA never needed to drop those bombs, the war was effectively over. They just wanted to play with their toys.

The war was most definitely not over, the Japanese would probably have dragged it out for years longer without the dropping of the bombs, dreadful as the result was. Oddly eough I was watching Who Do You Think You Are and the young man had a photo of Hiroshima from his grandfather's stuff. The expert told him that the sailors from the British warship that went to Japan for the surrender were taken on a tour of Hiroshima very shortly after it happened in open top vehicles, no consideration of radiation .

notimagain · 21/07/2023 21:08

@Ridemeginger

Couple of points with reference to the play you referred to about Oppenheimer:

. If he hadn't developed atomic energy first, other scientists in Germany or Russia would have.

But Oppenheimer didn't develop atomic energy first...it was a developing area of research for several decades pre WW2, and if anybody can claim to have been the first to harness nuclear energy it was Enrico Fermi, who had the first nuclear reactor up and running in '42...

He absolutely regretted the way his work was used to develop nuclear weapons

Oppenheimer did express regrets belatedly, but objectively there is no way around the fact that he did very much work, literally hands on at times, in developing the very first nuclear weapons....

I hope the film doesn't leave the same impression.

Deescot · 21/07/2023 21:08

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 20:38

The USA had intelligence that Japan were intending to surrender BEFORE the first bomb was dropped, and that Japan’s concern was reinstating their emperor post surrender.

The USA didn’t need to drop ANY bombs.

Wrong. This is a myth perpetrated by history revisionists.

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 21:07

Toprepandhowmuch · 21/07/2023 21:04

Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

It’s not hindsight when you know they’re surrendering.

Deescot · 21/07/2023 21:06

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 20:29

This is just racism.

Is it ok to dislike Germans? Americans? Brits?

What on earth is wrong with disliking others?

Hardertheyfall · 21/07/2023 21:05

@Cyclebabble you still believe that about saving Allied lives? No. It has long been acknowledged that the US dropped the bomb for Stalin and the Soviet Union. To shite them up.

Toprepandhowmuch · 21/07/2023 21:04

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 18:31

Oh please. The USA never needed to drop the bombs, the war was effectively over.

Don't peddle lies.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

MissyGirlie · 21/07/2023 21:04

Let's hope its truthful and includes the tens of thousands who was indiscriminately killed the moment the bomb hit and the torturous death of the other tens of thousands.
And let's hope it includes the romusha, the Asian slave labourers, dying of cholera on the Burma-Siam railway, and the civilian internees weighing 5 stone at the end of the war, and the starving civilians.
So we can understand why everyone wanted the war over as soon as possible.

DyslexicPoster · 21/07/2023 20:59

I hate the glorication of any war. Innocent people die. I don't know how the film portrays the story. Let's hope its truthful and includes the tens of thousands who was indiscriminately killed the moment the bomb hit and the torturous death of the other tens of thousands.

When my bil passed out I couldn't bring myself to look at the bombs but luckily bil seemed to understand. He joined up to stop deaths, as works in bomb disposal so I do see that the forces are nessary and there are hero's. But one person's marter is another's terrorist. Armed forced are nessary in our parasitic species. That's the human condition. We can't live in peace. It's beyound us. But unlike other species we have the ability for such large scale destruction.

Qbish · 21/07/2023 20:59

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

YABU. Japan has been very successful in pushing a martyr narrative. They were utter, utter bastards before an during the war. They would have carried on being so. Maybe read up on it a bit?

MaryWelly · 21/07/2023 20:59

Saw who do you think you are this week and thought it had a similar problem - didn't properly acknowledge what a horrible thing it was. Was strange viewing

Destinedforfakeness · 21/07/2023 20:57

I think you need to know if it glorifies him or is actually a look at his life and the implications of his work. You can't assume just because there's a film about someone it's a celebration. So Yabu to judge before you know much.

gingerguineapig · 21/07/2023 20:55

Chestnutlover · 21/07/2023 20:52

I know what you mean. I felt weird about it too. I understand people saying it’s history etc but why dramatize it? We can read about it in history books. The atomic bomb etc makes me feel sick.

Well you can say that about nearly every war film ever made.

gingerguineapig · 21/07/2023 20:53

Cyclebabble · 21/07/2023 18:26

His actions prevented the death of many allied personnel who would have been involved in the invasion of Japan. War is not a pretty business and Openheimer was a tortured sole. The film does not make him a hero. He comes across as very troubled indeed. Equally he is not a villain.

Yes. There are a lot of us who wouldn't be here if they'd not dropped the bombs in Japan because our fathers would have died in a land invasion. We can look back now in horror, but we can't impose 21st century peacetime norms on politicians in WW2.

Some of the attacks on Germany were pretty horrific with normal bombs, obviously Dresden, but see also Hamburg and even the Navy trying to blow up the island of Hel(i)goland after WW2 (which was the biggest ever non-nuclear explosion, although thankfully there was nobody there).

Not my sort of film but it's up to people if they want to make it and watch it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread