Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
Utahthecat · 21/07/2023 22:09

Watch the film OP.

I have seen it, it is more about ethics in science than heroizing Oppenheimer. It certainly doesn’t heroize the bombings or the man, it is a very humanizing , emotional film with a lot of nuance. I cried my way through most of the last hour and it has lingered with me….it is not a dumb blockbuster, it is extremely through provoking on a variety of levels and one of the most thought provoking films I’ve seen in years. No, it doesn’t give the Japanese perspective, it is the perspective of one brilliant but very flawed scientist.

Saschka · 21/07/2023 22:05

GrinAndVomit · 21/07/2023 21:57

War is nasty.
Atomic warfare is evil.

But is it more evil that firebombing civilians, or deliberate genocidal starvation of civilians, or medical experimentation on living people, or any of the other things mentioned in this thread?

Waitingroompurplecup · 21/07/2023 22:01

Don’t hun* them

Waitingroompurplecup · 21/07/2023 22:00

Sorry op but it sounds like a case of “I’ve visited the country and know people from there, so I know more than the rest of you and get to make a judgment that it’s all in bad taste.”

But really you’ve got a few impressions and snapshots of a country today, which far from resembles what was a very complex period of history.
Ironically it is similar to watching a movie trailer and making a conclusion without watching the full movie - but amplified by a million.

Maybe rather than take offense, try to see this thread as a turning point. If you recognize you have a judgment on something, and this usually applies to all topics, immerse yourself in it. With valuable and diverse sources. Keep on digging. If you still feel convinced, dig some more. Because few things are ever good vs. bad, black vs. white, 100 percent certain etc. Read the things you know you will hate. Hear the people out who have a different opinion to you. Don’t hub them. This is a good habit for most areas of life, especially if you feel yourself tempted to go keyboard warrior on it.

Desdemonadryeyes · 21/07/2023 22:00

All’s fair in love and war.

The past is another country

GrinAndVomit · 21/07/2023 21:57

Zippeedidodah · 21/07/2023 18:32

It was war it was nasty. I'm sure the Chinese will also have a story to tell on what the Japanese did to them.

War is nasty.
Atomic warfare is evil.

Kabbalah · 21/07/2023 21:57

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 21:39

The Soviets also saved our ass, we won WW2 because of them.

The fuel the Luftwaffe used in their aircraft to blitz Britain was supplied by the Soviets.

Gilmorehill · 21/07/2023 21:53

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 21:39

The Soviets also saved our ass, we won WW2 because of them.

That’s extremely simplistic. There were many factors which led to our victory.

Gilmorehill · 21/07/2023 21:51

Cyclebabble · 21/07/2023 18:26

His actions prevented the death of many allied personnel who would have been involved in the invasion of Japan. War is not a pretty business and Openheimer was a tortured sole. The film does not make him a hero. He comes across as very troubled indeed. Equally he is not a villain.

^ this

sydenhamhiller · 21/07/2023 21:48

vickibee · 21/07/2023 18:26

If it’s factually correct then it’s a good thing to learn about history
personally I feel more uncomfortable with Barbie 😂

I love this. Exactly.

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 21:39

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

The Soviets also saved our ass, we won WW2 because of them.

EffortlessDesmond · 21/07/2023 21:37

If you are interested, there are books written by people who have researched the subject intensively. You don't actually have to buy the glitzy Hollywood version of the story. Most of it happened in Portakabins.

Saschka · 21/07/2023 21:34

One poster mentioned that Germany and the individual Soviet soldiers committed many more crimes against civilians than the British and Americans. Watch the Berlin 1945 documentary. The Soviets were horrendous

The Nazis had been significantly more horrendous to Soviet civilians during Operation Barbarossa - about 20 million civilians died, and 8 million combatants. The later behaviour of the Soviet troops in Berlin was indeed horrendous, but it was seen as direct revenge.

Willyoujustbequiet · 21/07/2023 21:32

MissEDashwood19 · 21/07/2023 18:53

Quite. Perhaps read the "Rape of Nanking" or listen to interviews of PoWs and "comfort women" before turning the Japanese into innocent victims.

The likelihood of the Japanese surrendering without enormous loss of lives on both sides was remote. Absolutely horrendous for the poor civilians, but blame should also be apportioned to their beloved Emperor and the sadistic military for unleashing a blood-thirsty war and committing nurmerous atrocities.

This.

Kabbalah · 21/07/2023 21:31

The aim of the Manhattan Project was to develop a nuclear weapon before the Nazi's did and it was Einstien who brought it to the attention of the Allies.

But you seem to think the Japanese were wronged in some way: victims almost ?.

The Japanese started the war in the far east and treated both civilians and POWs in the most appalling way. They pursued a near genocide in China killing 3.9 million civilians and with barbaric savagery in Nanking. Then you have Unit 731 where they conducted experiments on live human beings - do some research to fully understand what happened there - it is estimated 300,000 people were murdered.

Perhaps the Japanese need to reflect on that too.

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 21:28

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 21:27

Okay, I’ll rephrase if you want. There’s never a good reason to hate a whole nation of people due to their race or ethnicity.

If that makes you feel more comfortable have at it.

Theres never a good reason.

Exactly.

Valeriekat · 21/07/2023 21:27

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:51

I don't know much about him at all hence my thread, I know a lot of people affected by his 'work' that's all.

You are being wilfully ignorant.

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 21:27

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 21:24

You misunderstand the "good reason" was to hate the Japanese not be racist. It's not the same thing.

Okay, I’ll rephrase if you want. There’s never a good reason to hate a whole nation of people due to their race or ethnicity.

If that makes you feel more comfortable have at it.

Theres never a good reason.

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 21:26

Louloulouenna · 21/07/2023 21:17

So would you condemn someone who lost their entire family in Belsen for not liking Germans?

Yes. That’s like saying all Germans are Nazi’s. Yes I would. As I say, I know people who’ve been through utter shit and don’t just automatically turn on a whole nation of people. It’s not an acceptable attitude to have, it’s how fucking racism starts and how it is allowed to continue.

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 21:24

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 21:16

Climb down of your high horse. As I said, I had a relative who went through similar. He was never racist towards anyone. And I wasn’t judging your relative, I was judging you and your choice of words. There is never a good reason to be racist. I don’t care what you say, there is no good reason to be racist end of.

You misunderstand the "good reason" was to hate the Japanese not be racist. It's not the same thing.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 21/07/2023 21:23

It's uncomfortable but it's history. We can't censor the past because it makes people feel feelings.

Abra1t · 21/07/2023 21:21

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:31

I'd like to say I don't know if the film does make him a hero but that's the impression I'm getting from the advertising so I'd feel uncomfortable going to watch it. I'm not trying to be inflammatory and I admit I'm no expert but I have spent quite a bit of time in the affected areas and whether or not many other people were saved (which I don't deny) it doesn't seem to make the loss easier. I've heard so many heartbreaking stories from that time from normal people, not soldiers or those directly involved in the war.

I don’t think you have read up about the film. There are lots of articles about it. It’s not at all a celebration of the bomb.

notimagain · 21/07/2023 21:20

Saschka · 21/07/2023 21:11

OP, if you think the A bomb has left untold scars on Japan, why is it that you don’t think Operation Meetinghouse did? After all, as you surely know given your deep knowledge of Japanese wartime history, the firebombing campaign in Tokyo killed many more civilians in one night than both nuclear bombs did.

And that firebombing campaign had already destroyed most of the major cities in Japan by the time the bomb was dropped on Hiroshima - there was literally nowhere else left to drop it.

Yep, Meetinghouse was horrific - that and similar raids are the reason why so many parts of major Japanese cities are concrete jungles...

there was literally nowhere else left to drop it.

Almost, by Aug 45 there were a few Japanese cities left undamaged and some sources have it that a deliberate decision was made to leave some built up areas intact.

Louloulouenna · 21/07/2023 21:17

So would you condemn someone who lost their entire family in Belsen for not liking Germans?

Swipe left for the next trending thread