Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
pornyshroudofturin · 21/07/2023 23:04

Those who are saying that Japan was on the brink of surrender and there was no need to drop the bomb- if that was the case, why did they not surrender immediately after Hiroshima?

milveycrohn · 21/07/2023 23:00

Oppenheimer is not a film I especially want to watch.
However, I do not necessarily blame the man who invented it.
It is how these things are used that is the problem.
What I mean is, that these inventions can often be used for purposes that were not intended, and further advancement should maybe be welcomed.
BUT, it is not a subject I feel comfortable about watching as entertainment, so I won't.
(I have seen the trailer and tha's enough for me)

Papernotplastic · 21/07/2023 22:59

You think war is a place for the moral high ground? Or for ‘men … to sort it out with other men’?

Bubblesoffun · 21/07/2023 22:57

I feel some on here are failing to appreciate the mindset of Japan at the time. Kill or be killed.
It was not a case of “you can’t win this so let’s talk it all out and every thing will be fine by lunchtime” it’s a very narrow 21st century idealistic view. This can not be applied to the time and the situation.

Sirius3030 · 21/07/2023 22:55

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 18:26

YANBU if that’s true. I haven’t seen it but if he is being portrayed as a hero then that’s terrible.

The USA never needed to drop those bombs, the war was effectively over. They just wanted to play with their toys.

It’s not true, he is not made out to be a hero.
You haven’t seen the film.
You clearly know nothing about the history of WW2. The war was not over, and millions more would have died in a bloody invasion of Japan.
It was a horrific time, and FFS it wasn’t about playing with toys.

FranticHare · 21/07/2023 22:54

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 22:31

Don’t be ridiculous, it’s isn’t a generational thing. People are dying around the world in war today. I have heard Ukrainians say they don’t hate Russia, they hate Putin and his cronies but not the Russian people who take no part in the war. Of course the shit that happened during wars was barbaric and I cannot imagine what it felt like to go through it, but saying it’s okay they’re racist or xenophobic because they’re of that generation is bollocks.

I’ll repeat to you what I said to the other poster:

Do you think it’s acceptable for anyone who was in or affected by 7/7 or 9/11 to ‘hate all Muslims’? Of course not. But this is how the thinking starts.

I have a friend who fought in Iraq, of course he doesn’t hate Iraqi’s, no matter what some of them did to him and his comrades.

Come on, this thinking is unacceptable and you know it. It excuses xenophobia and racism. It allows racist/xenophobic thinking and lets it continue, encourages it to grow. It’s what racists pray upon. Dont excuse his hatred of a nation of people, many of whom were and are innocent. There are no good reasons

9/11 was a terrible event - like many I watched it unfold on TV in horror at what happened. But it’s not comparable. At all. And I think you know that.

It was a horrific few hours - but nothing like WW2 which went on for years. There was no torture. There was no starvation. There was no forced labour. There were no ongoing beatings. Emaciated bodies weren’t left lying around. There was no canabalism to simply try and survive. And the numbers don’t come close.

To correct your penultimate sentence - all current Japanese are innocent of the atrocities of WW2. But please don’t minimise what happened at the time. That just makes you look a little naive. Nothing like WW2 has happened since to the (majority) UK population - and I hope it never does again.

Perhaps read about the treatment people went through - put yourself in their shoes. (For the record, I acknowledge no parties in the war were perfect, and understand completely why people would hate the Allies because of what they suffered. It’s not a one way thing - but it’s commonly recognised the Japanese army of the time were particularly viscous).

twentyonepoundnote · 21/07/2023 22:51

Gingerboy22 · 21/07/2023 19:23

Surely that is a completely different scenario or are you comparing the Nazis to Oppenheimer?

why is it a different scenario? both killed millions, both histories are horrifying beyond imagining.

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 22:50

Yes, it was horrible, but the Japanese in 1945 were not the nation they are today.

What the actual fuck?

Ghosttofu99 · 21/07/2023 22:49

MavisMcMinty · 21/07/2023 22:37

The Japanese killed millions of civilians, mainly Chinese. Millions more than the Nazis killed, and over a longer period.

Still doesn’t explain why men didn’t want to sort it out with other men. You can say you are happy to murder children of one nation in revenge for the murders of children in another nation as long as you can see that you have no moral high ground, that it’s no noble deed and it’s no way for people to live or treat each other.

Lincslady53 · 21/07/2023 22:47

My dad was preparing himself for being called up in 1945, to assist in the Allied invasion of Japan. The bomb stopped that, and as he was apprenticed in the building trade he never did get called up. He escaped call up for the Korean War too. My old Headmaster was a prisoner of the Japanese in Singapore. If you read of the inhumane way they treated their prisoners the quicker that theatre of war was brought to an end the better. The two bombs were also a message to the Soviets and other belligerant states that they would not win a war against the allies without risking total annihilation. Yes, it was horrible, but the Japanese in 1945 were not the nation they are today.

Ghosttofu99 · 21/07/2023 22:44

Waitingroompurplecup · 21/07/2023 22:00

Sorry op but it sounds like a case of “I’ve visited the country and know people from there, so I know more than the rest of you and get to make a judgment that it’s all in bad taste.”

But really you’ve got a few impressions and snapshots of a country today, which far from resembles what was a very complex period of history.
Ironically it is similar to watching a movie trailer and making a conclusion without watching the full movie - but amplified by a million.

Maybe rather than take offense, try to see this thread as a turning point. If you recognize you have a judgment on something, and this usually applies to all topics, immerse yourself in it. With valuable and diverse sources. Keep on digging. If you still feel convinced, dig some more. Because few things are ever good vs. bad, black vs. white, 100 percent certain etc. Read the things you know you will hate. Hear the people out who have a different opinion to you. Don’t hub them. This is a good habit for most areas of life, especially if you feel yourself tempted to go keyboard warrior on it.

Putting the film aside, just because there were bad men and women in Japan who did many evil things still doesn’t justify on any level children having their clothes burned off or dying from burns and radiation sickness. Maybe you could immerse yourself in photographs of the aftermath of those atrocities and see if it has any impact on your perspective.

Papernotplastic · 21/07/2023 22:42

I’m talking about hatred of a regime.

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 22:41

MavisMcMinty · 21/07/2023 22:37

The Japanese killed millions of civilians, mainly Chinese. Millions more than the Nazis killed, and over a longer period.

None of that justifies dropping atomic bombs over a nation that the US knew was surrendering.

Lacucuracha · 21/07/2023 22:40

Papernotplastic · 21/07/2023 22:35

In WW2, the Japanese believed themselves to be the master race and that every other race was sub human. I think hatred of the Japanese on that basis is akin to hatred of the Nazis.

You just showed your own hypocrisy there. Why do you say hatred of the Nazis and not Germans? Why are you willing to separate Nazis from Germans?

MavisMcMinty · 21/07/2023 22:37

Ghosttofu99 · 21/07/2023 22:32

Allied personnel were men who were trained for battle. The children who had their clothes burned off of them were children so no it’s not a fair comparison. There is no justification for killing civilians in War imo.

I think it’s important to learn about horrific events like Hiroshima or the Holocaust but I agree that some of the discourse online about people’s excitement to see the film has been uncomfortable and doesn’t reflect the serious nature of the subject matter. I haven’t actually seen it yet so will reserve judgement on the actual film itself.

The Japanese killed millions of civilians, mainly Chinese. Millions more than the Nazis killed, and over a longer period.

Papernotplastic · 21/07/2023 22:35

In WW2, the Japanese believed themselves to be the master race and that every other race was sub human. I think hatred of the Japanese on that basis is akin to hatred of the Nazis.

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 22:35

FranticHare · 21/07/2023 22:28

I think what you’re saying is true in a perfect world, but doesn’t take into account extremes.

Generations that are alive today, no, there is no justification to hate anyone because of their race. None.

But the war generation experienced something that (I really hope) we’ll never have to. It was extreme. It’s something we cannot possibly understand. Like others on this thread, I have (had) relatives who were Japanese POW’s. Their treatment was beyond barbaric. While one relative survived, he had many long term issues as a result of his treatment. It was never ever spoken about. Even when the compensation payments were made, I was gifted the full amount - he wanted nothing to do with the blood money (as he thought it) and wanted a younger generation to use it in a positive way.

Could I blame him for not being particularly fond of Japan and her people? No! Obviously it would be wrong if I continued that hate - I don’t. I can fully recognise that the current Japanese population had nothing to do with what happened then. But don’t blame the war generation for their very valid feelings.

I’ll be interested to see this film.

Thank you. A very eloquent post. I can't tell you what a wonderful man my dad was. He would do anything for anybody. Do I blame him for hating the Japanese? No. Do I hate this current Japanese generation? Of course not.

Ghosttofu99 · 21/07/2023 22:32

Cyclebabble · 21/07/2023 18:26

His actions prevented the death of many allied personnel who would have been involved in the invasion of Japan. War is not a pretty business and Openheimer was a tortured sole. The film does not make him a hero. He comes across as very troubled indeed. Equally he is not a villain.

Allied personnel were men who were trained for battle. The children who had their clothes burned off of them were children so no it’s not a fair comparison. There is no justification for killing civilians in War imo.

I think it’s important to learn about horrific events like Hiroshima or the Holocaust but I agree that some of the discourse online about people’s excitement to see the film has been uncomfortable and doesn’t reflect the serious nature of the subject matter. I haven’t actually seen it yet so will reserve judgement on the actual film itself.

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 22:31

FranticHare · 21/07/2023 22:28

I think what you’re saying is true in a perfect world, but doesn’t take into account extremes.

Generations that are alive today, no, there is no justification to hate anyone because of their race. None.

But the war generation experienced something that (I really hope) we’ll never have to. It was extreme. It’s something we cannot possibly understand. Like others on this thread, I have (had) relatives who were Japanese POW’s. Their treatment was beyond barbaric. While one relative survived, he had many long term issues as a result of his treatment. It was never ever spoken about. Even when the compensation payments were made, I was gifted the full amount - he wanted nothing to do with the blood money (as he thought it) and wanted a younger generation to use it in a positive way.

Could I blame him for not being particularly fond of Japan and her people? No! Obviously it would be wrong if I continued that hate - I don’t. I can fully recognise that the current Japanese population had nothing to do with what happened then. But don’t blame the war generation for their very valid feelings.

I’ll be interested to see this film.

Don’t be ridiculous, it’s isn’t a generational thing. People are dying around the world in war today. I have heard Ukrainians say they don’t hate Russia, they hate Putin and his cronies but not the Russian people who take no part in the war. Of course the shit that happened during wars was barbaric and I cannot imagine what it felt like to go through it, but saying it’s okay they’re racist or xenophobic because they’re of that generation is bollocks.

I’ll repeat to you what I said to the other poster:

Do you think it’s acceptable for anyone who was in or affected by 7/7 or 9/11 to ‘hate all Muslims’? Of course not. But this is how the thinking starts.

I have a friend who fought in Iraq, of course he doesn’t hate Iraqi’s, no matter what some of them did to him and his comrades.

Come on, this thinking is unacceptable and you know it. It excuses xenophobia and racism. It allows racist/xenophobic thinking and lets it continue, encourages it to grow. It’s what racists pray upon. Dont excuse his hatred of a nation of people, many of whom were and are innocent. There are no good reasons

Saschka · 21/07/2023 22:28

GrinAndVomit · 21/07/2023 22:13

It’s all evil. What’s your point? That Japanese civilians deserved it more?

You said the rest of WW2 was just “nasty”, but the A bomb was “evil”. I’m pointing out there was plenty of evil on both sides, the A bomb wasn’t uniquely evil in comparison with everything else that was going on at the time.

I’m not suggesting we should drop any more, just pointing out the historical context. I’m a pacifist, I don’t think we should have any wars. I just can’t see a difference between dropping a nuclear bomb and firebombing a city, if the same number of people end up dying very similar deaths as a result.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 21/07/2023 22:28

MavisMcMinty · 21/07/2023 20:28

That Wiki page on Japanese war crimes is gruesome, had to scroll pretty fast in places.

My 87 year old Dad is a very peaceable global leftie liberal who was just 9 when WW2 ended, but he has always had (what seemed to me an inexplicable) dislike of “the Japanese” because of their inhumane treatment of so many millions of non-Japanese over the decades up to the end of WW2.

The Wiki page makes it more understandable.

The book is very good but very hard to read.

FranticHare · 21/07/2023 22:28

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 21:27

Okay, I’ll rephrase if you want. There’s never a good reason to hate a whole nation of people due to their race or ethnicity.

If that makes you feel more comfortable have at it.

Theres never a good reason.

I think what you’re saying is true in a perfect world, but doesn’t take into account extremes.

Generations that are alive today, no, there is no justification to hate anyone because of their race. None.

But the war generation experienced something that (I really hope) we’ll never have to. It was extreme. It’s something we cannot possibly understand. Like others on this thread, I have (had) relatives who were Japanese POW’s. Their treatment was beyond barbaric. While one relative survived, he had many long term issues as a result of his treatment. It was never ever spoken about. Even when the compensation payments were made, I was gifted the full amount - he wanted nothing to do with the blood money (as he thought it) and wanted a younger generation to use it in a positive way.

Could I blame him for not being particularly fond of Japan and her people? No! Obviously it would be wrong if I continued that hate - I don’t. I can fully recognise that the current Japanese population had nothing to do with what happened then. But don’t blame the war generation for their very valid feelings.

I’ll be interested to see this film.

MechanicalGoat · 21/07/2023 22:27

saveforthat · 21/07/2023 21:24

You misunderstand the "good reason" was to hate the Japanese not be racist. It's not the same thing.

Do you think it’s acceptable for anyone who was in or affected by 7/7 or 9/11 to ‘hate all Muslims’? Of course not. But this is how the thinking starts.

I have a friend who fought in Iraq, of course he doesn’t hate Iraqi’s, no matter what some of them did to him and his comrades.

Come on, this thinking is unacceptable and you know it. It excuses xenophobia and racism. It allows racist/xenophobic thinking and lets it continue, encourages it to grow. It’s what racists pray upon. Dont excuse his hatred of a nation of people, many of whom were and are innocent. There are no good reasons.

Indigotree · 21/07/2023 22:15

Saschka · 21/07/2023 22:05

But is it more evil that firebombing civilians, or deliberate genocidal starvation of civilians, or medical experimentation on living people, or any of the other things mentioned in this thread?

It's a very much larger range of destruction and power, from far away in safety rather than in combat, annihilation in an instant without warning and rendering the land uninhabitable for years to come. Very different type and scale of threat and it threatens to wipe out much of the world.

GrinAndVomit · 21/07/2023 22:13

Saschka · 21/07/2023 22:05

But is it more evil that firebombing civilians, or deliberate genocidal starvation of civilians, or medical experimentation on living people, or any of the other things mentioned in this thread?

It’s all evil. What’s your point? That Japanese civilians deserved it more?

Swipe left for the next trending thread