Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with the film Oppenheimer?

584 replies

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:23

I haven't seen the film, I'm sure it's a brilliant thriller and will be a Blockbuster hit. I don't think I'll watch it though, it makes my feel really uncomfortable.

It feels like a man who at the end of the day killed thousands of people and damaged millions is being celebrated and turned into a hero.

I lived in Japan for 10 years in my twenties. I visited both Hiroshima and Nagasaki and spent a lot of time with people both directly and indirectly affected by the dropping of the bombs. Those scars are real and still there and will be for a very very long time. It changed Japan and the people who live there forever and at the end of the day I think he was an awful person.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 07:02

echt · 22/07/2023 06:46

But it is not WHY the atomic weapons were used.

Agreed. The technology was suddenly available and, what would you know, they had an entire population of civilians who absolutely deserved for it to be to tested on… What luck!

WhatsupWhatsApp · 22/07/2023 07:02

Elvis1956 · 21/07/2023 19:08

Sorry but I think you are being deliberately goady. The whole Japanese state was evil at the time. Refused to apply the Geneva convention. Thousands of allied troops starved and it beaten to death to build the Burma railway. Mass rape. Internment in concentration camps for women and children.

For a toned down view of just have dreadful they were watch the BBC drama Tenko and the British film bridge over the river kwai.

You come across as an apologist for them. They would never have surrendered...just look at Guam and Guadalcanal...despite clearly losing the Japanese fought to the death

But civilians including kids didn't deserve to die for actions of their government and army.

GrinAndVomit · 22/07/2023 07:00

MissEDashwood19 · 21/07/2023 23:14

So the allies should have just allowed imperial Japan to continue its genocidal rampage through Asia unchecked and/or allowed millions more to die in an attritional war waged on the Japanese mainland?

By this rationale, Germany too would've been offered a negotiated peace to spare it the bombing and occupation by the allies.
Meanwhile, more Jews, Slavs, and assorted slave labourers would have been worked to death or shot/gassed.

I suppose the allies should have also left it to the Germans or Soviets to develop the bomb first to use at their discretion?

At what points of history would it have been justifiable to a bomb the uk, pretending the technology was available?

TheaBrandt · 22/07/2023 06:51

Saw it last night. Very good and educational lots I didn’t know. Much of it was based on the persecution of Oppenheimer afterwards. It was a nuanced film and dealt with his guilt. It’s rather silly to get your knickers in a twist about a film you haven’t actually seen.

echt · 22/07/2023 06:46

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:57

THIS!!💯⬆ALL of this!

But it is not WHY the atomic weapons were used.

knitnerd90 · 22/07/2023 06:45

The film is apparently quite faithful to the book, which emphasises that oppenheimer was not solely responsible for the bomb's development. But the book makes an excellent case that Oppenheimer was a singular figure and extraordinary person, and as I said, it covers the period after the war where he was accused of being a Communist and lost his security clearance.

War is an awful thing, and WWII was exceptionally so. It really isn't possible to take the bombs out of their context. The film Bridge on the River Kwai is fiction, but it's based on the real building of the Burma Railway--and the conditions were far worse than those in the film. 100,000 people died to build it, POWs and local civilians. (As a Jew whose family hails from Poland and Lithuania, I'm understandably biased on the European side of the war.)

SunnyEgg · 22/07/2023 06:35

mids2019 · 22/07/2023 06:24

I think this is pure hollywood.

Oppenheimer was amongst a group of brilliant physicists including Fermi and Feynman looking at the theoretical aspects of fission for the the Manhattan project. I don't actually think one man (or woman) can take credit for the atomic bomb actually as there were a series of advanced that led to its conception (including Einstein who thought of its possibility after populating his relativity principles).

nice to see a theoretical physicist in a blockbuster film but will this not just stereotype the profession needlessly? Oppenheimer did a lot of work on quantum theory as it applied to spectra for instance which I guess will hardly get a mention.

I think of interest is that a lot of these planet sized minds actually were pacifists fundamentally and dislikes the idea of armies of any hue and thought armed conflict barbaric. There was regret I think after the development and use of atomic bombs and the subsequent activism by scientists to prevent proliferation was ignored (but like climate change).

Yes the Rhodes book starts far enough back to show how so many contributed

It was interesting to me that many who were instrumental were forced to flee Germany

The pp outlining the Nanking atrocities were a hard read. I don’t have the words but just so terrible.

mids2019 · 22/07/2023 06:24

I think this is pure hollywood.

Oppenheimer was amongst a group of brilliant physicists including Fermi and Feynman looking at the theoretical aspects of fission for the the Manhattan project. I don't actually think one man (or woman) can take credit for the atomic bomb actually as there were a series of advanced that led to its conception (including Einstein who thought of its possibility after populating his relativity principles).

nice to see a theoretical physicist in a blockbuster film but will this not just stereotype the profession needlessly? Oppenheimer did a lot of work on quantum theory as it applied to spectra for instance which I guess will hardly get a mention.

I think of interest is that a lot of these planet sized minds actually were pacifists fundamentally and dislikes the idea of armies of any hue and thought armed conflict barbaric. There was regret I think after the development and use of atomic bombs and the subsequent activism by scientists to prevent proliferation was ignored (but like climate change).

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:57

Elvis1956 · 21/07/2023 19:08

Sorry but I think you are being deliberately goady. The whole Japanese state was evil at the time. Refused to apply the Geneva convention. Thousands of allied troops starved and it beaten to death to build the Burma railway. Mass rape. Internment in concentration camps for women and children.

For a toned down view of just have dreadful they were watch the BBC drama Tenko and the British film bridge over the river kwai.

You come across as an apologist for them. They would never have surrendered...just look at Guam and Guadalcanal...despite clearly losing the Japanese fought to the death

THIS!!💯⬆ALL of this!

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:54

DemonicCaveMaggot · 21/07/2023 19:08

There is no problem with Barbie. I got Astronaut Barbie and Vet Barbie for my children when they were little. They are at university studying science based subjects now and neither of them show much interest in wearing all pink or acting like airheads. I imagine the film is very silly and I plan on seeing it because I like silly stuff.

My sister got my Barbies when I outgrew them. She tore the head off a couple and she didn't become a serial killer.

At least I don't think she ever did.....

Perhaps a cereal killer, she loved her Rice Krispies!

Barbie was cool from the time of her black and white swimsuit to her bubble hairdo to now. Obviously very smart, being a teacher, a vet, an astronaut, a doctor. And she looks so good for her age!

I'll see myself out now. 🤐😉

WandaWonder · 22/07/2023 05:54

I take it the similar way as the person who 'invented' the gun they may have invented the mechanics but they didn't kill millions with it

echt · 22/07/2023 05:47

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:39

Thank you! Or the missionaries, teachers and children that were put into POW camps, tortured, raped, murdered whenever the camp commander wanted a thrill.

They tortured our POWs because, according to them, a soldier dies fighting or kills themselves but never, ever surrenders. Of course, that changed when they decided to finally surrender. The US did not make many of the Japanese military personnel pay for their war crimes, which bothered and hurt many of the POWs and their families.

I have read "The Rape of Nanking".

Hiroshima and Nagasaki were not bombed as some vengeance by the USA.

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:46

Indigotree · 21/07/2023 18:54

Umm wtf completely ignoring the difference between killing adult troops who choose to fight and be killed and the sudden mass killing of thousands of civilians, including children, with the creation of a weapon so horrific it led to the world living forever under threat of destruction?

So, you are saying that no civilians or children would have died in the two-three years it would have taken if Japan had been invaded? Those would be some pretty intelligent bombs. Many of those "children" would have been conscripted into the Japanese army after a couple of years.

How many children, babies and civilians were killed by Japanese troops in China? The Philippines? The rest of the countries they invaded?

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:39

MissEDashwood19 · 21/07/2023 18:53

Quite. Perhaps read the "Rape of Nanking" or listen to interviews of PoWs and "comfort women" before turning the Japanese into innocent victims.

The likelihood of the Japanese surrendering without enormous loss of lives on both sides was remote. Absolutely horrendous for the poor civilians, but blame should also be apportioned to their beloved Emperor and the sadistic military for unleashing a blood-thirsty war and committing nurmerous atrocities.

Thank you! Or the missionaries, teachers and children that were put into POW camps, tortured, raped, murdered whenever the camp commander wanted a thrill.

They tortured our POWs because, according to them, a soldier dies fighting or kills themselves but never, ever surrenders. Of course, that changed when they decided to finally surrender. The US did not make many of the Japanese military personnel pay for their war crimes, which bothered and hurt many of the POWs and their families.

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:33

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:51

I don't know much about him at all hence my thread, I know a lot of people affected by his 'work' that's all.

And I KNEW a lot of people that were affected by Japan's "work".

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:31

LKM23 · 21/07/2023 18:46

I don't do whataboutery hon

So, you only want to have rainbows and unicorns instead of the truth about Japan's atrocities in the war. Got it. 🙄

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:29

Lifeinlists · 21/07/2023 18:45

Max Hastings in his review in last Saturday's Times made the point that more than 300,000 people were killed in Tokyo, ie many more than ended up dead after both atomic bombs, and Japan still had no intention of surrendering.

War is nasty but I'm actually tempted to see it after reading his review. It seems to explore the conflicts, both personal and political.

Yes. A very "inconvenient truth" for some, but yet, indeed a truth.

Nanaof1 · 22/07/2023 05:19

missmollygreen · 21/07/2023 18:35

You know what the Japanese did, right?

We should ignore history at our peril

I think, like many times, history has been rewritten and scrubbed to make the truth be different from what it was.

Japan was asked many times to surrender, including after the first bomb. They refused, over and over and kept committing heinous crimes, each one as bad as the last.

The US was not willing to lose another 1M men by invading Japan, so they took the way of the least casualties for both sides. It may not have been pretty, but it was something that needed to be done. More lives were saved by dropping the bombs than if they had not. Truth may hurt but the facts matter.

Bubblesoffun · 22/07/2023 05:18

@JudyEdithPerry the uk did not consider the women and children of the cities they carpet bombed either.
@sashh the bombing of Nagasaki saved the life of my grandfather. Who was a pow. Along with the rest of the pows who had managed to survive that long. they were about to be executed so the evidence could be destroyed. The bomb went off and the Japanese fled. And the US army rescued them. To quote a phrase that I hate “educate yourself”

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 05:12

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

JudyEdithPerry · 22/07/2023 05:05

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

sashh · 22/07/2023 04:59

Cyclebabble · 21/07/2023 18:26

His actions prevented the death of many allied personnel who would have been involved in the invasion of Japan. War is not a pretty business and Openheimer was a tortured sole. The film does not make him a hero. He comes across as very troubled indeed. Equally he is not a villain.

They didn't save allied personnel.

Japan was already at the point of surrender, they wanted to keep their emperor, that was the only condition they asked for.

The allies wanted unconditional surrender, and then they let the Japanese keep their emperor anyway.

The USA dropped two bombs, one uranium the other plutonium. Yes I'm a cynic and I find the fact that they used two different types of bombs makes me think they wanted to drop two bombs.

They then sent in a group of doctors and scientists to examine the effects the bombs had had on the victims, they didn't offer treatment, they just studied the people.

Those people, are known as hibakusha are discriminated against to this day, as are their children and even their grandchildren.

Imagine your nearest large city outside London, imagine that flattened in an instant killing 40% of the population. The survivors have no hospitals, medical centres, even fire stations.

knitnerd90 · 22/07/2023 04:49

Historians have spent 80 years arguing if dropping the bombs was necessary or not. They still haven't settled the question, and no one here will either. The bomb was going to be developed, Oppenheimer or not. To assign him such massive responsibility for what happened is to miss the bigger picture. And of course, Oppenheimer felt that responsibility really keenly after the fact. His original motivation was based on thinking the bombs would be used against the Nazis. Oppenheimer was of German Jewish descent and sponsored relatives to leave Nazi Germany.

I have read the book the film is based on. It's an exceptional biography. Oppenheimer was a fascinating man. Worth pointing out that much of the film is about what happens after 1945 and how the US government blackballed him. I haven't seen the film yet, but it's a picture about an extraordinarily complex man, and I would absolutely not call the source material some gung-ho America version. (not to mention, British director, Irish star, other British cast... this is not some patriotic production)

MistressoftheDarkSide · 22/07/2023 04:47

Personally I want to see this film as I think it will help open up a realistic debate around nuclear warfare which is a long time coming.

The brutality of these weapons is terrifying.

The casualties from the two blasts were just the beginning of a horrific legacy that has gone on to impact our world both environmentally and also continues to impact servicemen and their descendants.

There have been in the region of 3000 nuclear / atomic weapons tests since WW2, both above and below ground. Weapons available now massively supersede the two original bombs in size and scope.

One must ask just how necessary this continued development of such weapons has been in order to maintain “world peace”.

I have skin on this game. My father is a nuclear test veteran who was in the navy and served 2 years in Maralinga. He developed splenic lymphoma and was part of the class action to try and get answers and possibly compensation for damage done to veterans and their descendants due to the effects of exposure contamination from the tests. The MOD has deliberately withheld evidence that might improve health outcomes for veterans and their descendants, have gas-lit and obfuscated and smeared them, suggesting that their issues are purely psychological because despite research and evidence garnered that shows exposure to radiation can caused genetic alterations to DNA, they claim that servicemen were never subsequently used as Guinea pigs.

Oppenheimer and his colleagues opened a can of worms so vast and devastating that the effects extend far beyond the horrors of the initial blasts.

The populous needs educating about this, and if this film opens people’s eyes to the true scale of potential catastrophe of these weapons, and the lengths that have been gone to to obscure the facts by governments and the military, I’m glad.

The true scale of the ongoing impact of these weapons should be exposed, and if this film opens up debate and further research then I’m glad.

It’s damn well about time that peoples eyes were opened up to the hypocrisy and lies and lengths that states will go to not just against perceived enemies, but also their own people.

Understanding the catalysts and processes is a start, and the rationalisation of the people who set this hellish ball rolling.

I am happy to be considered an enemy of the state on this particular subject.

echt · 22/07/2023 03:57

Paul Ham's Hiroshima Nagasaki is an excellent, utterly gripping and extensively-researched 500+words exploration of the lead up to the atomic bombing, the events and aftermaths. It uses contemporary testimonies and very moving accounts of the bombings.

In a nutshell the, US earlier bombings of Japanese cities were targeted against civilians. The atomic bombings were on cities where no advantage could be gained by obliterating them and, by modern standards, were a war crime.

Swipe left for the next trending thread