Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To immediately remove my child from childminder

214 replies

Ohriley · 21/07/2023 16:17

My child has been going to a childminder for 2 years - with 2 days a week at a preschool and the remainder with her. I don't like her at all, she's becoming more and more unhinged in how she deals with me - however I've kept them with her because they enjoy their time there and have nothing negative to say.

This week, my child has told me that they're sometimes left alone in the car while the childminder goes to the shop. They're not one for making up stories.

They start school in September so only 6 weeks to go and I can scrabble together alternative care until then.

Would you upset your child's routine for your own sanity / the safety issue or would you stick it out for a further 6 weeks?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FuchsAndMöhr · 26/07/2023 22:19

ChaosCrew · 26/07/2023 20:41

Even that isn’t allowed. As a childminder, she should ensure her vehicle has sufficient amount of fuel in it for the day. It is not permitted to fill up with fuel when you are childminding.

Yeah, you made that up 🙄

KateyCuckoo · 26/07/2023 21:24

ChaosCrew · 26/07/2023 20:41

Even that isn’t allowed. As a childminder, she should ensure her vehicle has sufficient amount of fuel in it for the day. It is not permitted to fill up with fuel when you are childminding.

Would love you to link to this 'rule'.

Don't make things up!

I use a local drive through fuel station and that works perfectly well.

Divadoc · 26/07/2023 21:21

ChaosCrew · 26/07/2023 20:41

Even that isn’t allowed. As a childminder, she should ensure her vehicle has sufficient amount of fuel in it for the day. It is not permitted to fill up with fuel when you are childminding.

Of course a childminder can fuel their car whilst working. I use pay at pump, I work long hours and at times it just isn’t possible for me to go out late at night to fill my car 🤷🏼‍♀️

ChaosCrew · 26/07/2023 20:41

Even that isn’t allowed. As a childminder, she should ensure her vehicle has sufficient amount of fuel in it for the day. It is not permitted to fill up with fuel when you are childminding.

CathyFitzs · 25/07/2023 12:47

Please, please remove them. The childminder obviously doesn’t like you and is demonising both you and your children. You will never be able to please them. They’re happy to go because that’s all
they know. I’m sure she will
also be criticising you to them or in their earshot. Good luck, I know it’s an upsetting thing to have to do.

adriftinadenofvipers · 24/07/2023 20:32

curaçao · 24/07/2023 01:06

Whispering in front of others us rude, and peeing on the bathroom floor needs addressing too, so I dint think either of those examples hold water.If she is parked right outside the shop she can maybe see the kids the whole time, or, more likely, it didn't happen at all

Hopefully the bathroom floor held water.

sueelleker · 24/07/2023 10:36

curaçao · 24/07/2023 01:06

Whispering in front of others us rude, and peeing on the bathroom floor needs addressing too, so I dint think either of those examples hold water.If she is parked right outside the shop she can maybe see the kids the whole time, or, more likely, it didn't happen at all

And the childminder shows up!

Ninalon · 24/07/2023 03:25

Unfortunately I’ve worked with many childcarers from nannies to childminder’s and inside nurseries and I have to say there are so many that choose this line of work for all the wrong reason’s. They think it’s easy and they get to be with their own children if working from home. Sadly it attracts the wrong people.
I’ve always loved children but when I saw how they were been treated I had to stand up and say something. I believe karma always calls and the truth always escapes sooner or later. Remember your children are your precious little gifts and the childminder should be honoured you are letting her take care of them. Any childcarer knows how difficult it is for a mother to let go of their baby. I’d waited 25 years for my little bundle of joy then six weeks later I have a accident and numb from hips down. I’d looked after so many babies and toddlers for my employers but now my son needed me and I couldn’t look after him or protect him from this awful childminder.
But something much worse happened later on. Everyone needs to beware of what can happen. My child was marked at primary school a teacher wanted my son. They got a friend of hers who was a social worker and they did everything to remove my child. I did everything they asked but it was never enough. I started writing to everyone who’d listen and after around six months the head of social services came to my home. I played her audio of the social worker threatening me and also my young son. She removed the social worker off our case and I agreed for another worker to be assigned. When the new social worker took over she was horrified by the file and she couldn’t understand why they were taking me to court to remove my son. Within days the case was closed and I was told my son had been marked by teacher at his school and they were unable to have children and they’d just been approved for fostering and adoption. This teacher had been taking my son for special afternoon teas while at school and told my son they were their secret. I always believed social services were there for children who were abused and needed help. They made a mockery out of the whole system what they did to my family. They decided to come after me because he was my son and because I have a spinal injury and they thought I wouldn’t work it out what they were doing. If my son had any friends over to play or stay the night then poor children were interrogated by the teacher. My son came home crying telling me they are spying on him. When I finally got the social services report they’d lied all the way through. It was disgusting how baby p had just been murdered yet they were pursuing us like we were going to abuse and hurt our son. We are now in the process of taking them to court after the harm they did to my son and our family.
people need to know there are predators and people that will harm our children all around us including in agencies that should protect our children. Teachers have way to much power and sadly some use it to lie and get what they want. The reason she wanted my son was because he is sweet innocent trusting loving and kind we’ve always encouraged manners and right from wrong and every teacher described him like a breath of fresh air because he loves to learn and be with his so polite and kind. Even now at 18 teachers still say how wonderful he is.
while all this was happening I remember if anyone knocked on the door he’d hide because they’d told him he’d be taken away soon and live with them. It was heartbreaking I knew I needed help. The social worker told everyone I was mad and not to listen to me. I ended up having a full psychological and IQ assessments that took over a week to prove I wasn’t mad or stupid. The only thing they found was OCD with cleaning and my IQ came back at 145 which I was told was good. Yet this social worker was making lots of lies up about me. Finally when the head of social services came her excuse really hurt me, she said this worker had obviously taken a dislike to us and wanted to cause us problems. She said this worker had never acted like this before.She was always professional unfortunately she was anything but professional with us or our son.
i think people need to be aware with what can happen and how nasty and awful people can be. I’d love to share our whole story because it needs to be told to warn others of the dangers of school teachers treating your child differently isn’t a good thing. I just thought she was helping him read not having secret tea parties in her offices and having little chats.
I finally got the courage at a meeting and asked to speak to the headteacher and told her straight if she carried on with her lies and unprofessional behaviour I’d report her to every government agency and also to the board of governors. Again everything changed they were all aiding and a betting and I have audio and video evidence of it all. We recorded the meeting we had and when it went to court I was appointed a solicitor what a joke! He wouldn’t do anything he told me to just accept it and move on with my life he told me if I stood up or asked questions I’d loose my son. I did stand and didn’t listen to my legal team. I demanded all evidence and wow when I got it it was like reading about a very unhinged abusive family who didn’t care for there child. They even said my son looked dirty and unkept for school. Yet the headmaster said my son was in the top 10% that is immaculately dressed and bathed daily.. They also said we never helped him with his projects that family gets involved with so in court we pulled a Roman shield out full size that him and his dad had made and this huge A3 picture with small square of foam shaped has a lion. He always got first prize and voted best project by other students. They also said we allowed him to stay up until midnight. Which again we could prove wrong since the day he was born bath at 7 pm bedtime story at 7.30pm and lights out for whole house at 8pm because we get up at 5 am. They also said we brought him inappropriate books and toys because we bought him David Williams books aimed at our sons then age. My husband bought him a drone because they loved taking remote control things out and flying and driving them. Yet we are been told it’s inappropriate. We also bought him science kits eg solar powered robot and clock that are some at our son’s age yet again we were told inappropriate.
The worst part of the report goes on about my son has gastroenteritis and I took him to doctors and within a few minutes need to bring him home because of accident, this time I took a pile of clean clothes just encase he was He had the runs again. While we were waiting to see our Gp he messed himself twice more and I put him one of my pads on to catch any accidents. When I got home social worker was at the door and she wanted to know why he wasn’t at school. She then saw the pad in the back of my sons trousers and told me to remove it. I explained I just put it in while we were out. I thought that was it, but no she wrote in her report that I was trying to regress my child back in nappies even though it was a one off and it was a pad not a nappy. Some sick people make evil out of the most innocent situation. All because I was trying to keep my son clean. The whole thing was a total nightmare. Always trust your gut it saved my family.

curaçao · 24/07/2023 01:06

Whispering in front of others us rude, and peeing on the bathroom floor needs addressing too, so I dint think either of those examples hold water.If she is parked right outside the shop she can maybe see the kids the whole time, or, more likely, it didn't happen at all

Ninalon · 24/07/2023 00:43

I’m sorry that’s not true at all. I started nannying when I was just 14 years old I was also studying fine art and used the wage to pay for my education and save.
I then decided I loved working with children and I decided to get childcare and do first aid and then did childcare development and education. I did every course I could including the Triple p babies to toddlers. 5 -12 and teen years.
When I was a nanny I made sure everything in the house also got done. I worked my socks off for each family but I never had to look for work because I had a schedule and worked for the whole area. If you choose childcare it really is a blessing and a honour that parents leave their precious babies in your care. I mainly worked for teachers and social workers and CEO. They all treated me like one of the family I never lived in but I was there to get the children up at 7.30 and they’d be bathed and ready for bed by 7 pm. Plus I looked after their family pets two huge dogs that I also walked. Just because you choose childcare doesn’t mean you’ve not got a college /university education. Some people choose childcare because they love children. It really is such a thrill when a child comes running up to you so excited over the coming holidays and your helping them make tree decorations for their mum’s and dad’s. When they hug you and are so excited for their next story time adventure. What I love about children is how they learn so fast and they have such imaginations. I really miss it all😓
yes I saw so many people that shouldn’t be allowed to look after animal let alone a baby. Which I tried to do something about, this nanny would come over for a coffee morning that I’d arrange for a play date both babies were 8 month old but the baby I was taking care of could sit unsupported but I still always made sure there was support for her and we’d play and sing nursery rhymes and the other little boy really struggled to sit up. I remember him falling back and smashing his little head on the toys. Instead of comforting the little boy she would shout get up you fat get. I couldn’t believe how she treated him. This also wasn’t a one off. I spoke to my employer and asked their advice and they advised me to go around and see the parents, which I did . I felt so sorry for that little innocent little boy and for his parents who are both doctors. The sad thing is they thought their nanny was amazing. yet she didn’t do any household chores and they just wanted her to sit watching the baby. All she did was read her magazines and have friends over.
Good childcare workers don’t do it for the money they do it because doing the job brings them so much joy and reward seeing each child grow and develop and move forward. I can honestly. say even now I miss the children I’ve looked after.
You don’t have to give up work rather then employ a childcarer there are many good employees out there you just have to look do background checks and phone OFSTED ask other childcare workers. Ask friends for recommendations and trust your gut feeling. If the childcarer when meeting your children gets down on their level and starts to interact and play and the children are engaging that’s a great sign. I always insisted that I shadowed the mum for a few weeks so I knew their routine and it also allows the children time to bond.
Just because you leave your children you have the right to expect the same standards as if you were home taking care of themselves. Been a nanny or childminder you are extremely privileged been trusted to take care of their precious little ones. When I had my son I really understand how difficult it must have been for them mothers. When many clearly wanted to be at home taking care of their family. No mother should feel guilty for trying to do their best for their children and if that’s working to make ends meet then they sacrifice that time and I’ve seen so many mothers hate leaving their babies, it really is heartbreaking and not a easy choice for any mother.

adriftinadenofvipers · 23/07/2023 19:32

Ninalon · 23/07/2023 19:28

I feel the same way, she only took my son to nursery and the odd morning because I’d had a bad accident and ended up with a spinal injury. I wanted my son to mix rather then be trapped in the house with me. All the time she was hitting him and punching him. I felt so awful and betrayed. I tried to warn other mums about her behaviour but she told Terrible lies about me she even reported me to social services because I made a formal complaint about her. All I can say is always trust your gut.

I don't know how you kept your hands off her, and I have never hit anyone in my life!

TG he wasn't there much.

adriftinadenofvipers · 23/07/2023 19:31

Yamatoosogani · 23/07/2023 09:42

My point is that childminders are usually considered a less skiled job, and you get what you pay for in terms of their composition.

I gave up my career for my family to avoid that problem.

Well bully for you.

Ninalon · 23/07/2023 19:28

I feel the same way, she only took my son to nursery and the odd morning because I’d had a bad accident and ended up with a spinal injury. I wanted my son to mix rather then be trapped in the house with me. All the time she was hitting him and punching him. I felt so awful and betrayed. I tried to warn other mums about her behaviour but she told Terrible lies about me she even reported me to social services because I made a formal complaint about her. All I can say is always trust your gut.

adriftinadenofvipers · 23/07/2023 19:27

@Ninalon that's awful, and exactly the reason I shied away from reporting my POS childminder. She was vicious and perfectly capable of making up lies and I was afraid to. I gave her notice but had to remove my children sooner as she was being so horrible to them, like making them drink water while the other mindees got juice, etc!!

Ninalon · 23/07/2023 19:18

something similar happened to me, I didn’t get the full truth until my son knew he wouldn’t be seeing the childminder again. He then told me that she was hitting him, I was heartbroken and told my son he must never lie. He then opened up and told me everything. I confronted the childminder and she became so angry but I knew by her reaction my son was telling the truth. I reported her to ofsted and they looked into the report. Few weeks later social services turned up at my door someone had reported me for child abuse. Obviously I knew straight away how this had happened. So if you do decide to take action she may get nasty. My ex childminder also tried to cause problems for me when my son went to a school she started picking and dropping children off. If you honestly believe your childminder is unhinged there is no way I’d leave my children with them.
I was a nanny for many years and I would never leave any child alone in a car not even for a second. A childminder who I knew well left children in the car with the car set in park. That car and the children ended up in front of someone’s lovely home, lucky the children were okay just cuts and bruises. I wouldn’t risk any of my children that way. You treat the children you look after like you would your own. You safeguard them from any risk’s and if ofsted knew children were been left unattended there would be a investigation. I loved my job and I felt highly honoured to have parents trust of looking after their children.
remember they are your children and children get used to a change in routine very easily and it will also give you peace of mind. You won’t need to worry if she’s leaving your children in the car unattended or if she’s behaving more unhinged around your children. Plus once you don’t have her in your life anymore you’ll feel so much better but be prepared because your children will probably tell you do much more.
I wish you well

Nononsensemumsy · 23/07/2023 15:01

Remove without hesitation. I ignored some early signals all wasn’t right with my now grown up eldest’s childminder. The things I found out after I’d moved him to a new childminder I still can’t think about because it gives me goosebumps and it’s 24 years ago! There’s nothing more reliable than a parent’s instinct, never ignore your gut feeling.

Retiredfromearlyyears · 23/07/2023 14:55

There should be a couple of minutes leeway either side. I always encouraged it to allow parents time to remove their coats and outdoor shoes.Also to say goodbye properly. Did you ask the childcare why the clock was taped to the door?

T1Dmama · 23/07/2023 13:38

I’m glad you’ve made a decision and have help with childcare over the summer.
I have to ask though, why do you pay for a day that you don’t ever use?? Was there some sort of minimum hour contract with her??
I would be making sure I paid the notice period and not a penny more!

Leannemma · 23/07/2023 12:12

I think the fact you said in one sentence you don’t like her and she’s unhinged should be enough. I wouldn’t send my kids with someone I didn’t like. Think you answered your own question really.

Ellyess · 23/07/2023 12:07

Jenelliot

I can see you have had a lot to deal with. From your descriptions I think you are more experienced and professional than the Childminder in this OP's experience. I agree that Parents differ very widely, I used to teach, so met many. Dealing with them when your job is to teach or look after their children can be the most difficult thing in the world at times. I think Childminders need support. Often they work alone.

I think the case here has been explained very clearly and the OP has demonstrated she has given the Childminder a lot of time to resolve the problems but sadly things have only got worse. If the Childminder just cries and is not able to discuss things professionally, that does not help. The OP's descriptions show she has not been confrontational or unreasonable, but acted politely and normally. The clock on the door really does sound excessive. I think by taking her child away now, the OP is making the best move for both sides, but most of all, she has to feel sure her child is safe.

Ellyess · 23/07/2023 11:52

Ohriley. Although it was an hour before I posted, I didn't see your last message saying;
"As its now escalated I've made the decision to remove my child".
That's great! I'm glad you've been able to decide.

Have a lovely Summer. Wishing you and your little one lots of love and happiness.

Jenelliot · 23/07/2023 11:50

As a retired childminder myself ( after 30 years ) I only ever had 2 children that did not settle with me as hard as I tried. I like to think I had a good relationship with the parents. Only occasionally did I find a parent so full of guilt for leaving their child anything I did was wrong, I lifted a child from my car one awful winter night heavy rain , and then strapped him the buggy and switched the tv on, as I went to get my own son out of the car plus a 3 year old the mother arrived , and in a temper said I NEVER put him in front of the tv, I explained my son was still in the car so what would she of preferred?
A few days later she arrived at my house with the same child sat on her knee on front seat while she was getting a lift to work with both her and driver sharing a cigarette! Another time I was asked to drop him at her home after a day out, she then told me to leave him on the front open lawn to have a play, he was 16 months old. If your child is not fretting before going to childminder not making a real fuss going in ( after the settling in period) I would assume her issues are with some parents taking advantage, and not being mean to the children. As for leaving them in the car to get a loaf of bread, would it be safer to lift 3 /4 children out of a car into a shop instead? It is One of the hardest jobs ever, I did it because I genuinely like children and did not want anyone else to look after mine, we all have choices. Some of the comments on this subject are rude, reporting people to ofsted? For what exactly. We have a parent locally who’s children are obese, she has been with several childminders including myself and had reported every one of them, she does it to escape payments, I took her to court, she was ordered to pay me , but failed after two payments. It is a difficult job, but most people doing it live having children in their home, I know I did. If your gut tells you you are not happy with your childcare, work on that.

Ellyess · 23/07/2023 11:47

Ohriley I would do what you have suggested. Take him away and put in place the other arrangements.
You clearly have given this a lot of thought and are being very reasonable, taking the money hit in your stride as 'collateral damage'. I'd try and disregard the people who make remarks about going out to work or about any other things some people might try to say about you. On MN you have to think of them as 'collateral damage' too and shrug them off. You know that you gave this woman a fair chance and that things have got worse.

When it's an issue of safety, as far as I am concerned, there is no alternative but to take action to keep your child safe. The toilet issue too sounds as though she is not able to deal with boys. Regarding his little friend, I'd try to arrange to invite him to tea, or make an arrangement with his mum to let them play together.
It sounds to me that you are a very hard-working, sensible and good mum. I'm a Granny so feel I can say that without sounding patronising. I know how hard it is to make ends meet and to organise everything when you are a single working mum and I have nothing but admiration for you.

The summer will fly by and soon he will be a school-boy! Be proud of yourself for how you have given him such a good start.

Ohriley · 23/07/2023 10:37

@erral I hope you're never in a position where someone seemingly reasonable changes over time and you yourself are judged for it.

I put up with her attitude towards me because I believed she was caring for my child well, and they were always happy to go there. I thought I was doing a good thing for my child by keeping him with someone he trusts and never mind the stress she caused me. Maybe that was naive but I was trying to l genuinely wanted to avoid disruption to my child if I possibly could.

As its now escalated I've made the decision to remove my child.

OP posts:
Ohriley · 23/07/2023 10:32

@Yamatoosogani I don't see looking after children as a less skilled or indeed a less important role, so I expect professional behaviour from professionals in those positions. Given what I pay for one child, and the fact that they have 5 of them, we probably take home a similar amount - not that it's relevant to anyone. Some people do it for the love of working with kids, for some it fits with their lifestyle and others might have other reasons.

Please don't think there's some sort of superiority thing going on here - I think I have reasonable expectations - I don't mind personal errands going on with my child in tow, I don't mind that they probably watch way too much TV etc. I do mind lots of the other things that are happening and I don't like the thought that there could be a grain of truth in my child being left in a car alone while she pops into the corner shop. I'm aware it's not illegal, I'm aware other people do it - I don't, and I've lost trust in the childminder that may have done it.

I know great people who work in childcare and I don't think she is a reflection on the profession as a whole. I also have no interest in trying to withhold payment or similar

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread