Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

44 and training to be a teacher?!

157 replies

AmIinsane2023 · 21/07/2023 13:17

Name changed for this, as a bit different to my normal posts.

I'm 44, currently unemployed, and - after health problems and being a SAHM - I want to get my life back in track and start contributing again.

I've been looking at PGCEs (Secondary English) or Primary 7-11.

A few people said I'm insane to be considering it a) because of my age and b) the way things are in schools these days.

AIBU to be considering this?!

Would love to hear people's experiences/opinions, both positive and negative.

OP posts:
daffodilandtulip · 22/07/2023 13:36

I started the PGCE when I was 38. It wasn't the teaching I couldn't hack but the actual course. Within two weeks, I was solo teaching classes with no supervision, prepping all the lessons and marking all the work - basically a teacher from day three with zero guidance. Then for every lesson I had to write a several page plan and evaluation for uni, plus two essays each half term. This was after being in school at 8 for a morning meeting, then staying til 6 twice a week for meetings and several parents evenings until 9. As a single parent of two, I drowned before Christmas.

Zanatdy · 22/07/2023 13:02

I’d discourage any of my kids from teaching. Join the civil service, good pension, good progression and very family friendly.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/07/2023 12:57

Macaroni46 · 22/07/2023 09:36

Because teaching is very hard on you physically and quite honestly, I couldn't manage it health wise anymore post 50.

Every teacher I’ve known has gone before 59 as they are just too physically and mentally wrecked to go any longer. Most have gone earlier. You get desperate. It’s beyond mentally and physically exhausting.

Macaroni46 · 22/07/2023 09:36

BungleandGeorge · 21/07/2023 19:17

I can’t understand why people would mention your age, you’ve got 24 years until retirement, perhaps they’re older and think you can retire much earlier?! A year for a pace is nothing although aren’t there other routes in where you can work and get QTS?

Because teaching is very hard on you physically and quite honestly, I couldn't manage it health wise anymore post 50.

Emily234 · 21/07/2023 22:37

@Shinyandnew1

Just to answer you as someone who has worked in England / NI. A lot is different in NI - I think it ultimately comes down to culture of how schools have traditionally been in trusting staff and also many schools have a very strong union presence.

Currently we are on work to rule - people follow this on a spectrum of levels but in theory each Head has to give every staff member a breakdown of their 1265 hours contracted and if a task if not on the breakdown then the staff member is instructed not to do the task and supported by the union. So if you have been allocated 20 hours of marking for the year and you have completed this then you refuse to mark anymore unless you are covered to do so. Same for report writing etc. These are the union action instructions Action Short of Strike Action Instructions 2022 (Northern Ireland) - from 3 April 2023 (nasuwt.org.uk)

Because of union action there are no inspections (schools refuse to cooperate), no monitoring, no books scoops / learning walks / lesson observations of any description unless you are EPD or not yet on UPS3. There is one afterschool meetings a term and staff can take their directed time at a place of their choosing - so if you have PPA first thing or last you can take this at home. There is no results analysis shared, students are sent home early and parents evenings are during the school day.

Whilst this is extreme at the minute even before action short of strike instructions I found teachers were trusted more and micro managed less than in England and had more ownership in their classrooms. There was much less frequent monitoring / observations / paperwork. Staff are paid extra for things like offering lunch time or afterschool clubs. Most schools seem to have very active union reps who are proactive with management in workload discussions.

https://www.nasuwt.org.uk/static/9ad5615c-a5d8-4541-b7e6d2700d85edf6/e0086d2a-0d7f-48b1-baec3e307a53c82b/Action-Short-of-Strike-Action-Instructions-2022-Northern-Ireland-from-3-April-2023.pdf

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 21/07/2023 21:04

FrippEnos · 21/07/2023 18:18

I am am not asking to know what they are but
Think about your health issues will how they affect you in a very demanding job.
Even if you coast through the training you may not like it.
You have to end up in the right school for you or it will break you.

Consider the amount of time that it will take away from your own child/ren, I know quite a few teachers that leave because they have no quality time at home with their own kids.

I agree with this. Age 45 l had no problems with my health. Age 55 l had lots of pain issues and it was getting harder and harder to deal with. Teaching is hard physically demanding work. And much harder in your 50’s.

I was just a normal sized normal weight teacher. l ended up with back and neck pain from bending over, horrible Achilles problems despite wearing proper shoes, knee problems just from wear and tear. Running up and down stairs became more and more difficult. Health issues need a lot of thought.

RBKB · 21/07/2023 20:03

I asked the ECT (newly qualified teacher) co-ordinator at my huge secondary about this, for an older friend. He said she would definitely be employable. She will be 67 when qualified. There is no ageism when recruiting teachers...they are inhorrifically short supply!!

clary · 21/07/2023 19:55

PrincessesRUs · 21/07/2023 17:13

Eg I have at least one hour free per day, often two for preparation and marking, I have gcse classes of 10-14 rather than 25+ which really helps with marking. There is obviously high expectations of results which brings its own pressures but I can genuinely say I love my job, look forward to every September etc

wow not my experience of teaching at secondary! I had GCSE classes of around 20 and I got 2/3 frees a week not a day! State school, not sure if that is the reason tho.

BungleandGeorge · 21/07/2023 19:17

I can’t understand why people would mention your age, you’ve got 24 years until retirement, perhaps they’re older and think you can retire much earlier?! A year for a pace is nothing although aren’t there other routes in where you can work and get QTS?

Sunnysunbun · 21/07/2023 19:01

Go for it. My mum did it and she was a single mum with four kids. She was 42!!

Shinyandnew1 · 21/07/2023 19:00

EllaB22 · 21/07/2023 18:38

Where are you based OP?

Makes a massive difference. Ive worked in England, Scotland and N.Ireland. Its been like three different jobs.

England workload is v difficult, Scotland is managable and N.Ireland is a much much lighter workload. I currently teach in N.Ireland and find myself working significantly less hours than when teaching in England yet have a middle leader role here. (N.I is currently on work to rule but even before this most staff did 8.45-4ish and took no work home).

What is it about NI that means the workload is less? I wonder if that should be looked at for sharing some good practice?!

Bogeyes · 21/07/2023 18:41

Sod that. I have experience of primary school teaching....no thanks.

bellocchild · 21/07/2023 18:40

I taught secondary English as a second career in a fairly tough school, for 14 years. It was always gruelling and exhausting, although often rewarding and sometimes even fun. But, and it was a very big but, there are limits to endurance and capacity in middle age: I ended with burnout, and a very long list of antibiotics consumed for the endless student-borne ENT infections. I left. On the plus side, I didn't need childcare because I worked roughly the same hours as my DC, and I understood how schools worked. (I returned to my original field for 10 happy, fulfilling years!)

EllaB22 · 21/07/2023 18:38

Where are you based OP?

Makes a massive difference. Ive worked in England, Scotland and N.Ireland. Its been like three different jobs.

England workload is v difficult, Scotland is managable and N.Ireland is a much much lighter workload. I currently teach in N.Ireland and find myself working significantly less hours than when teaching in England yet have a middle leader role here. (N.I is currently on work to rule but even before this most staff did 8.45-4ish and took no work home).

FrippEnos · 21/07/2023 18:18

I am am not asking to know what they are but
Think about your health issues will how they affect you in a very demanding job.
Even if you coast through the training you may not like it.
You have to end up in the right school for you or it will break you.

Consider the amount of time that it will take away from your own child/ren, I know quite a few teachers that leave because they have no quality time at home with their own kids.

Catusrusty · 21/07/2023 18:04

i know someone who retrained as a teacher in their forties.

Came from a very high stress commercial background, long commutes, long hours, time away from home etc.

Absolutely loves it, happiest he's ever been. Now only works 4 days a week locally. He said it was tough while he was training but once he was in a job and knew the kids, he's found it really easy and fulfilling compared to his previous roles in the private sector. He also loves the long holidays and importantly the school love him, so he's really landed on his feet.

I think the only way to find out is to try. As I have a friend who went into teaching not long after uni and found it all too much to cope with.

angstridden2 · 21/07/2023 18:02

Agree that choosing your school carefully is vital. I started teaching in my 40s at a really nice school.After a few years for various reasons the intake changed and behavioural problems and SEN increased. I left teaching a few years later, but suspect I would have continued if I had gone to the private sector.

I looked up Lucy Kellaway, she very quickly stopped teaching Maths and changed to Economics part time, presumably to sixth formers.

tracylamont13 · 21/07/2023 17:41

I was a teacher for 20 years (left 3 years ago). It's tough but there are great parts to it. I'd say, like others have, spend as much time in a school setting as you can just to see if you like being around teenagers. They can be tricky but are never dull! Take the time to talk to any many teachers as possible to get a realistic view of the role.

TheOccasionalFag · 21/07/2023 17:21

Not sure if anyone has commented anything similar, but your job satisfaction in teaching depends almost entirely on the school you take a post at, rather than the job itself.
At a good, supportive school where teachers have agency, are treated with professional respect, along with reasonable expectations in terms of workload - it can be the best job in the world!
A poorly managed school with an SLT who last taught several decades ago and therefore have no idea of the realities and the implications of their demands - it can be actual hell on earth.

This applies to the entire spectrum of schools out there btw, doesn't matter if its a classic Mumsnet 'leafy suburb' school, or a struggling school in a deprived area. The quality of the SLT make or break your experience.

So yes - go for it! No reason why you couldn't end up working in an excellently run setting. Just choose your posts EXTREMELY carefully once you qualify. Talk to everyone you possibly can who has any experience of the schools you're looking at.
It really is the difference between a fantastic experience and one that will break you.

Good luck!

LaMaG · 21/07/2023 17:20

My friend (in Ireland) just finished this week after a few years training. She has loved every minute of it and feels her life has a whole new purpose. She is turning 47 next month so was 43 probably when starting out. Go for it!!!

drunkpeacock · 21/07/2023 17:15

Could you afford to do a year as a TA first? You'll walk into a job and it will give you a proper idea of what Schools are like.

PrincessesRUs · 21/07/2023 17:13

But what attracted me was love of my subject - and I'm still in love with it 16 years on - you need that for secondary school

PrincessesRUs · 21/07/2023 17:13

Eg I have at least one hour free per day, often two for preparation and marking, I have gcse classes of 10-14 rather than 25+ which really helps with marking. There is obviously high expectations of results which brings its own pressures but I can genuinely say I love my job, look forward to every September etc

AmIinsane2023 · 21/07/2023 17:11

Will reply to individual comments later.

Had a lot of experience working with children in different settings, but have already applied to local schools (primary and secondary) for this Autumn. Worked with a lot of children from disadvantaged backgrounds and those with complex needs and/or SEN.

Physically healthier than I have been in over 5 years. I do a lot of cycling and walking and I've always been an high energy person.

There are so many things that draw me to it, but I'll check back in later to read all the comments properly and reply/write some more.

OP posts:
Questionsforyou · 21/07/2023 17:10

PrincessesRUs · 21/07/2023 17:08

I don't mean this to offend anyone but I'm a secondary teacher - it seems to me teaching in secondary school, whilst still challenging at times, is not as hard as primary teaching. I also find it's easier teaching in a private school!!

I also think secondary must be easier than primary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread