Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DD told me to get an abortion.

310 replies

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 07:40

I've name changed because I know a few people who use MN,

OP posts:
WeWereInParis · 21/07/2023 09:34

JazbayGrapes · 21/07/2023 09:33

I would never have said that in her position, no. I wouldn’t even have THOUGHT it.

Decades of feminst mantra that abortion is a greater good...

Believing that access to abortion is a good thing isn't the same as demanding someone else has one.

bemorelemmy · 21/07/2023 09:33

bungletru · 21/07/2023 09:26

I was born after 3 kids. Eldest age gap 13 years. She says I was the best thing that ever happened to her. All 3 siblings wanted a baby sis or brother. Even if they were teen/approaching that age. And back then money WAS an issue.

but they had each other as well- not the same for op's daughter

JazbayGrapes · 21/07/2023 09:33

I would never have said that in her position, no. I wouldn’t even have THOUGHT it.

Decades of feminst mantra that abortion is a greater good...

Jigslaw · 21/07/2023 09:32

bungletru · 21/07/2023 09:23

She’s 15. She needs to be a kid. She is a kid.

uni fees = Uni loan. Why are u expecting op to pay for this like it’s normal lol

Because it is expected now that parents contribute, the amount you can borrow depends on parental income too so if their income is decent the loan amount is lower. If parents have a child who is keen to go to university then yes it should be considered, if household income is low then there isn't much that can be done which is fair enough- if you make active decisions to increase your outgoings and don't consider financial support for uni for your child that's sad.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 21/07/2023 09:31

Yes kids and especially teens do say insensitive things. But I think in this case describing it as insensitive is understating it.

Daughter needs to learn and be made to understand what a horrible thing that is to say to another human being. She may think she's grown up and the dogs bollocks with all this earning potential but she's clearly emotionally very immature and I do not think all 15 year olds would say something so vile. Emotional intelligence is important too. I hope she cries when she realises what a vile thing she has said to you OP. Maybe one day when she's in your shoes she will understand.

Ap24 · 21/07/2023 09:31

bungletru · 21/07/2023 09:23

She’s 15. She needs to be a kid. She is a kid.

uni fees = Uni loan. Why are u expecting op to pay for this like it’s normal lol

No parents are expected to make a contribution depending on income. The loan doesn't even cover some students accommodation cost.

JusthereforXmas · 21/07/2023 09:30

LoikeanOverner · 21/07/2023 09:15

I’m an accidental pregnancy outcome, it’s obvious as my siblings are way older than me, 20 year gap is the largest. My older siblings hated the disruption. My sister that’s 14 years older than me always says I ruined her teen years as she was made to babysit. Last time it was mentioned she was about 65 @whiteroseredrose your friend felt exactly like my sister.

I hate that attitude that its 'obviously accidental'... people assume that about us, NO.

A decade of infertility, desperately trying, health problems and IVF left a big gap there was no 'accident'... it couldn't be further from an accident if we tried.

Same with my mam, she had severe health issue that could risk her life but wanted another child. She tried for all my childhood and experienced loss after loss. Non of those pregnancies where accidental.

My friend has a 15 year old and is suffering secondary infertility.

Someone literally told me the other day I should have 'planned better' when hearing my kids age gap... its hard not to just yell 'fuck off' at the ignorance.

JazbayGrapes · 21/07/2023 09:29

uni fees = Uni loan. Why are u expecting op to pay for this like it’s normal lol

They probably would have, but now they probably won't. Hello huge student debt...

Gingerboy22 · 21/07/2023 09:27

Life is very black and white when you are this age and we did all think we knew it all. I'm sure she didn't really mean to hurt you. This is the problem - we try to raise independent young people but then we get troubled/upset/hurt when they hold different views to us. It's tough but there is no grey with teens this age.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 21/07/2023 09:27

JusthereforXmas · 21/07/2023 09:24

We have all been teenagers... several of us IN her position and no I would NEVER had said that, its actually abhorrent that those words left her mouth.

I would never have said that in her position, no. I wouldn’t even have THOUGHT it.

as an adult? Remembering certain things, working through it in therapy? I sometimes can’t help but think it!
and I can’t help but wonder how much freer and unburdened I could have been.

Newbutoldfather · 21/07/2023 09:26

@Kyokyo ,

I think if we always validate teens’ feelings and don’t explain to them why they are not appropriate (to voice them, at least), then they will legitimately believe that they are the most important person there.

I have been surprised by teens in both directions (as a teacher), both by how wantonly cruel they can be, but also how kind and empathetic some are.

It is up to parents and teachers to encourage the ‘good’ bits and discourage the bad. In this case, IMO, it means explaining that they won’t be bankrupt, but she will have to take the sibling as part of the very nice package deal she is enjoying with her parents.

bungletru · 21/07/2023 09:26

I was born after 3 kids. Eldest age gap 13 years. She says I was the best thing that ever happened to her. All 3 siblings wanted a baby sis or brother. Even if they were teen/approaching that age. And back then money WAS an issue.

FeedMeSantiago · 21/07/2023 09:25

She will be feeling pushed out I expect. All my siblings are half siblings from my Dad's first marriage. There's a big age gap (16-20 years) and they grew up together. They're very close, they're similar ages and had a shared childhood. I don't have any of that with them, we grew up in very different places, in different decades. I've always been the odd one out.

Your DD has the reverse of that. She's the oldest and they will be full siblings, close in age and with shared childhoods she will be excluded from.

She may also be worrying about the impact of two small children on her GCSE and A level revision, your ability to take her to Uni open days etc.

The abortion comment is very out of order though.

JusthereforXmas · 21/07/2023 09:24

bemorelemmy · 21/07/2023 09:17

Your having another baby IS her business- it will have a massive effect on her- she has already experienced this with her other sibling.
I've seen before on mumsnet the clear impact much younger siblings can have on teens and how dismissive parents can be of anything that might be a negative for the older child. I'm not saying a much younger sibling doesn't also bring happiness to the teen but they absolutely take the parents' time and attention in a way that a sibling with a smaller age gap would not.
At secondary school teens need their parents emotionally and, frankly, you're not going to be very available in the throes of yet more baby/toddler years.
Anyone criticising her supposed insensitivity clearly doesn't understand teenagers! It's not up to her to pussyfoot around your feelings: no she doesn't understand what abortion can mean emotionally but that isn't her problem.
She knows the toll that having another, much younger sibling will take on her though.

We have all been teenagers... several of us IN her position and no I would NEVER had said that, its actually abhorrent that those words left her mouth.

bungletru · 21/07/2023 09:23

JazbayGrapes · 21/07/2023 09:20

She is obviously scared. Re-money -- she will need to go to university soon enough. How will you be able to afford that with a new baby?

She’s 15. She needs to be a kid. She is a kid.

uni fees = Uni loan. Why are u expecting op to pay for this like it’s normal lol

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 21/07/2023 09:23

LoikeanOverner · 21/07/2023 09:15

I’m an accidental pregnancy outcome, it’s obvious as my siblings are way older than me, 20 year gap is the largest. My older siblings hated the disruption. My sister that’s 14 years older than me always says I ruined her teen years as she was made to babysit. Last time it was mentioned she was about 65 @whiteroseredrose your friend felt exactly like my sister.

I love my sister (11 years younger). But yes, I was made to babysit, basically parent her etc. and was burdened with so much responsibility and guilt in my teens and twenties. I have been working through that resentment but every now and then it just bubbles up.

and I was obviously directly impacted by the massive financial impact this had on my mother’s earning potential…

it was better with my DF’s 2 sons / my half brothers, who are even younger than my DSis. But it wasn’t always easy either. Feeling like an outsider, child friendly activities when going to my DF etc. My half brothers and I get along very well, but we do not have a “traditional” sibling relationship. I think I have more of a young aunt / older cousin role 🤔🤔

itsmyp4rty · 21/07/2023 09:23

If dd is spoilt then why would anyone be angry at dd? It's the adults that have spoilt her. Everyone keeps saying 'she sounds totally spoilt and entitled' like it's her fault it's happened.

Who wants two baby siblings when they're 15? I think her distain and desire for 'better' things are good. If she couldn't wait for another baby and thought maybe she should get pregnant at the same time so they'd be like siblings, then it would be worrying.

I think you're underestimating how much stability teens still need, and having one baby and then getting pregnant with another shortly after is not really considering her needs IMO. I have a teenager and couldn't even imagine it, he would be horrified.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/07/2023 09:23

marblesthecat · 21/07/2023 09:12

@JustFrustrated Ah that must have been so rough for you. I always think the impact of much younger siblings on teens must be huge.

I completely agree yet it's so often dismissed on threads like this because apparently the parents' desire for another baby is more important than the impact on the existing children.

Obviously everyone is free to make their own choices but it's hardly surprising that a 15yo is a bit pissed off about suddenly having to deal with two very young siblings.

My DH was the youngest by a considerable way and the resentment from his older siblings was huge. His parents were also much better off by the time he came along and his childhood was definitely much nicer and easier than theirs had been, which didn't help matters.

They're all adults now and barely have a relationship.

bungletru · 21/07/2023 09:22

MichelleScarn · 21/07/2023 08:04

From your second post ot sounds like she's spoiled and selfish and what she wants she usually gets, so why wouldn't she except you to have an abortion if that's what she wants!

This.

she’s still a child. You probably need to sit her down and explain how this demand of hers is unkind and listen to her reasons.
maybe she’s worried there won’t be enough money to continue to spoil her the way she is with another kid around.

JazbayGrapes · 21/07/2023 09:20

She is obviously scared. Re-money -- she will need to go to university soon enough. How will you be able to afford that with a new baby?

MummyLaLa88 · 21/07/2023 09:19

Sorry, I meant to say - I hope you are ok and congratulations!!

Kyokyo · 21/07/2023 09:19

Teenagers aren't the most empathetic people! Sounds like she made a very flippant comment (perhaps coming from a selfish place, thinking that if you have another baby then it would mean less money, which in turn would negatively impact her).

I know that makes her sound terrible, but I just think teenagers are quite selfish and often don't think about the bigger picture. I don't think she had any thought about how that comment might have hurt you.

I would just sit her down and explain what you've said here - that financially you can support another child and that your excited to have another baby after struggling to conceive for years. Remind her that she should be careful making comments about someone's personal choices, that it was a heartless comment and hurt you.

Also maybe ask her to explain why she thinks your not doing well financially, when she's been on holidays, to gigs and is given regular spending money ?

JusthereforXmas · 21/07/2023 09:19

Kids are notoriously selfish.

I bugged my mam for siblings because I didn't understand her health circumstances... I just wanted what everyone else had. I finally got a sibling a decade or so later, I was not unhappy at all but being older the excitement has waned. I left home at 16 when my sibling was still in pre-school.

Given that my sibling was from a second marriage I did worry I was being 'replaced'. I never said it but I felt it (and it was kind of true, I know my mam always loved me but my step-dad did 'push me out of the nest').

My oldest also bugged me for a sibling. I went through 10 years of secondary infertility trying for another, plus cancer, a MMC and IVF, finally got pregnant when he was 10. He cried... they where NOT happy tears.

We then had a magic surprise pregnancy (typical 10 years of trying and then one once we stop) a few years later and he locked himself in the bathroom crying and refused to talk to anyone.

He utterly ADORES both his siblings now and did from the second they where born.

Crimblecrumble1990 · 21/07/2023 09:19

Was it an initial reaction? She is likely feeling jealous that another person will be taking your attention away. Assuming she has some big exams coming up and life changes, she might be worried she will not have your full support.

She probably feels like you have another little family now. Especially since she won't even physically be there if she is at uni. The two little ones will be siblings to each other but to be honest she probably still feels like an only child.

I also had lofty ambitions when I was 15/16 about what I was going to do with my career and how I looked down on my parents 'small life'. They still earn more than I do and they are retired now! Teens are just full of crap so I wouldn't worry about that part.

MummyLaLa88 · 21/07/2023 09:18

Op, this is unacceptable in my opinion. She has no right or place to even voice such a thing. She is 14, a teenager and you are the adult. I hope you are