Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DD told me to get an abortion.

310 replies

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 07:40

I've name changed because I know a few people who use MN,

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 21/07/2023 11:43

ImNotReallySpartacus · 21/07/2023 09:56

Presumably she will take out a student loan and get a part time job, which is what most students do these days.

If Op and her DH are on £29,000 each, girl only gets minimum maintenance loan with expected parental contribution around £5000 a year outside London.
Min loan won’t even cover her accommodation.
Fine if parents know and have saved but lots assume everyone can borrow same maintenance loan or have no idea how much parents are now expected to contribute.
Op will have 2 in childcare when dc goes to Uni. It’s a huge amount to pay from net income if they haven’t saved.
Obviously better ways to express it but she’s 15. If her dream is to go away go Uni I can see why she would be concerned about your financial situation.

aSofaNearYou · 21/07/2023 11:40

She sounds a bit spoilt. I'd start making her work more for her many luxuries.

FuppingEll · 21/07/2023 11:35

My first thought is that she may feel that you are creating another family that is going to grow up in her absence. She will be leaving soon and you guys will be all together and she isn't going to be part of that no matter how hard you try. It will be new family and her on the outside.

MrsMiddleMother · 21/07/2023 11:33

I think it's disgusting that she thinks it is okay for her to say something like that to her mother and you need to teach her some boundaries before she really turns into a nasty spoilt girl.

Cucucucu · 21/07/2023 11:31

Your daughter is out of place as it’s not up to her to suggest anything!
I think you might have created this issue by spoiling her rotten without giving her any boundaries .
You clearly want this baby so go ahead and have it . Congratulations by the way .

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 11:25

OP, she sounds incredibly spoilt and selfish and all about me me me.

I do wonder if underneath it there is insecurity about the changes, but shes still bang out of order.

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 11:24

DonnaBanana · 21/07/2023 08:06

Kids will say insensitive things from time to time, don’t hang this over her head. At the same time tell her it’s not her decision. I wouldn’t be hugely offended by it, it’s not worth the hassle. Plus there’s nothing inherently wrong with abortion.

What on earth????

Dixiechickonhols · 21/07/2023 11:23

I’d let dust settle and chat to her. I find just two of us car good for chats less pressure.
It sounds like she’s sensible planning college, uni, pt job.
Reassure her you are fine financially.
Do discuss you plans for funding her at college - bus fare won’t be cheap, lunch, any allowance. Will you pick her up if she gets a pt job with late night hours.
Reassure her you can meet expected contributions for Uni and won’t leave her unable to go away as she wants to. If she’s looked and seen min loan won’t even cover halls she could be really worried.
Other expenses that probably are at forefront of her mind are prom dress, driving lessons (I pay £70 a 2 hour lesson for dc) and Uni open days (have spent hundreds in train fares visiting)

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/07/2023 11:21

bungletru · 21/07/2023 09:23

She’s 15. She needs to be a kid. She is a kid.

uni fees = Uni loan. Why are u expecting op to pay for this like it’s normal lol

@JazbayGrapes
exactly!

ManateeFair · 21/07/2023 11:15

She's 15 and she doesn't want another sibling. I wouldn't wanted baby siblings when I was 14-15 either, to be honest. Of course 'You should have an abortion' is a rotten thing to say and she shouldn't have said it, but I doubt she really understands the emotions you're feeling in relation to your pregnancy.

I certainly don't think it's unusual for a teenager not to be pleased that their mother is pregnant. I certainly know other people who got fairly harsh reactions from teenagers when they got pregnant again late in life. The teens came round every time in the end, though. I think at that age, teenagers tend to react to things very impulsively and throw a strop before they've really had time to process it all.

ladyvivienne · 21/07/2023 11:15

It's your choice, but a 15 year age gap is enormous. Were you very young when you had her? She did want a sibling but she didn't get that until it was too late (in her eyes) and now you're providing that child with a sibling?

I imagine she's feeling very very pushed out.

Do all 3 children have the same father?

Personally i would have been concentrating on the family I had, not making another one (that's how she's probably seeing it) but obviously that's your choice. And honestly it's nothing to do with her. But she is entitled to feel pushed out and that's how it's come across.

CarolynKnappShappy · 21/07/2023 11:14

MichelleScarn · 21/07/2023 08:04

From your second post ot sounds like she's spoiled and selfish and what she wants she usually gets, so why wouldn't she except you to have an abortion if that's what she wants!

This. I actually think she is old enough to know better - what a hurtful horrible thing to say as well as being well out of her decision making.
I think I wouldn’t be holding my thoughts back eg

  1. was she asked for her opinion, no, then don’t give it
  2. my body my rights - no one has the right to tell me what I should or shouldn’t do
  3. That money is not the issue but if she didn’t appreciate the gym memberships etc that are a privilege they can be removed
  4. that she needs empathy lessons instead of a gym membership ….
Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 21/07/2023 11:09

It really isn't her decision but she obviously just doesn't want to have the disruption of another baby in the house. Of course its going to have an impact on her life, as babies have to take priority. In a few years you are going to be paying for driving lessons, university, etc all whilst your household has taken a financial hit with one of you being on maternity/ paternity leave and quite likely working part time around childcare. All of this is obviously making her feel insecure about what this means for her. She's 15, you know how it works, the world revolves around her!

1967buglet · 21/07/2023 11:08

How much childcare for her siblings has she been doing, and will that amount increase...is that where the anxiety is coming from? I was parentified way too early as the eldest daughter taking care of a younger sibling, so I may be overly sensitive about this issue. Whilst it wasn't the greatest comment on her part, she's 15 and she may feel that when she leaves for university, she's not really part of your new family. Good luck with your pregnancy and the birth of your next child.

WhatsupWhatsApp · 21/07/2023 11:03

Catspyjamas17 · 21/07/2023 10:34

In another post, people were defending a 17 year old dd being spoilt with designer bags and expensive holidays and not wanting to do summer job, here people are blaming a 15 year old for having new trainers or saying she will make big money. She is still a kid and a kid whose home has changed so much in first 2 teen years.

Mumsnet has a massive number of users, so different thread, different people posting. It's not a hive mind.

Of course, but I see a few regular posters on both threads

Dixiechickonhols · 21/07/2023 11:01

I don’t think she should have said that but can understand why she isn’t thrilled but it’s your and your husband’s decision.
I had a friend whose mum and dad had another after a 15 yr old gap then another quickly to be a sibling to little one. They were all full siblings but it was like a 2nd family situation. She was embarrassed as people commented and the whole parents having sex thing.
My dc has a friend with a toddler sibling and she ends up doing a lot of childcare. She is also embarrassed about the teen mum thing (people stare and make assumptions)
Have you checked your Uni expected parents contribution? To be honest that would worry me. Only households on under £25,000 get full maintenance loan. If you earn over £58,000 combined which isn’t uncommon then she’s minimum loan and you’ll be expected to top up just under £5000 from your net out of London and £7000 London a year. No allowance for outgoings eg childcare x 2. Unless you’ve got a college fund for her I can see her worrying you’ll limit her chances eg say you can’t pay what you are required to and limit her to a local uni.
Mine’s 17 and I’ve found she’s needed more input recently eg uni open days, driving practice.

grey12 · 21/07/2023 11:00

@sueelleker it says she goes on holidays a lot and she had a fun birthday (?) and a concert with her dad.

I meant going for a one to one lunch with her mum, going to get her nails done, I don't know. Bonding time. It may be difficult with a 15mo but OP maybe needs to make her see that having baby siblings doesn't stop their close connection

skyfalldown · 21/07/2023 10:56

Seems like a typical teenage reaction. When I was a teen, my older cousin announced her pregnancy and I asked if she was keeping it. In my head, it seemed the obvious question to ask. Don't think others saw it that way!

KingsHeath53 · 21/07/2023 10:48

@CinderRosie if you want another baby have another baby. My brother was born when i was a teenager and i was totally unimpressed by the whole thing. But then he arrived and it was just… magic. Honestly I couldn’t have loved him more, still do. I have a few mates with massive age gaps between their kids and the elder ones always adore the babies. Give your son some credit, i’m sure he’ll be an amazing big brother x

WhatsupWhatsApp · 21/07/2023 10:46

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 09:46

Sorry I'm trying to keep up, and get out of the house for swimming with the littlest one!

DDs life has changed since the youngest arrived, infact we make more of an effort for her to do things that are age appropriate for her. She's had numerous outings with DH, geek conventions, an anime thing, both her sort of thing, not DHs but it was quality time, she's been to see Kings of Leon and Kaiser Chiefs with me (again, a her thing) red hot chilli peppers with DH.
We aim most of our days out around her interests, for example we've made trips to the area of where she wants to go for further education, tried to figure out how she would be most comfortable getting there- I've offered to drive her to and from if she would like. Last weekend, went to a museum that she wanted. I timed it so her brother slept through, so we had the time.
We go to the cinema together, grab the odd coffee together, and one of us goes to the gym with her a few times a week so DD still gets a fair bit of time.
I've asked if we can get our nails done together, we sometimes get our hair dine together too. Stuff that's just for us.

Her holidays haven't changed. We've always done the same things, except this year we're going to Daytona and the nasa space centre because they're her interests.

Also, someone did ask about DH, he isn't DDs bio dad, but both of them feel their relationship is close, she won't hear he isn't her dad, and he would never hear that she is not his daughter.
We've been together almost 13 years.
Hes excited for another baby, but she hasn't asked him this.

I don't think she's worried about my health.

Also, the intent to run away and start her own life, living in halls at 18, then travel the world has been her plan since she was about 11. She's always been adamant that she will have a bedroom at home, but she wants to spread her wings.

I will try to respond as much as I can, but I've got to get this baby swimming so I can return to collect DD- half day on her last day of the school year.

Maybe it matters, maybe it doesn't but I had her at 17, so I've had a child with no money and no plan, and our lives are completely different to what they were...or probably should have been! So her citing money reasons is a bit of a punch in the gut.

Her citing money reasons is a punch in the gut??

In all posts, you have talked about your emotions, and how you have given her more money for babysitting than normal, that their rooms are not on same level, so she is not impacted by baby's cries.

What about her emotions? You are talking of money, how you are giving her more and than wondering why she wants to earn big money.

Her life is completely changed since her early teens, her mother is understandably busy with a very small child. But someone who was only child till 13, suddenly has her parents busy with a baby, classes etc.
She is a teen, she is in a emotionally vulnerable stage of life and her mother is not available.

It seems like, you have no time to even consider impact of all this on her. Also, maybe she is a bit jealous that her sibling has it better than she did as a young child because you are in a financially secure place.

KingsHeath53 · 21/07/2023 10:44

Just give her a cuddle.

Of course she doesn’t get a say in this. But she does have feelings and the feelings are clearly stressed / anxious ones.

You are overthinking this trying to dig into whether her comments about money are rational or if there is any truth in the idea she gets less attention or whatever. It’s not a rational response from her, it’s an emotional one. And the reaction I think as a mum when your kid is emotional is just to love them and be there for them and not give oxygen to her attempts to rationalise her big feelings

Tohaveandtohold · 21/07/2023 10:43

I think she’s just shocked and maybe embarrassed to be having another baby in the house.
To be fair, you’re only early or mid thirties and people who are your age mates are just having their first child now so you’re not too old to be having another baby but I think as you already have a teenager, it changes the dynamics.
Its not up to her to tell you what to do with your body as it’s your choice really and ultimately not her decision however it’s a big change for her after so many years of being an only child so it’s a big adjustment and her response though insensitive is something I can quite understand

whumpthereitis · 21/07/2023 10:39

Well, she’s expressed how she feels. Some teenagers would welcome a new baby, some wouldn’t at all. It’s not like there’s a set rule where a teenager will naturally be ecstatic about her parents having another kid.

it obviously isn’t her choice, but it’s obviously going to have a big impact on her life until she’s in a position to leave. She may or may not come round to the new baby - again, that isn’t something that can be predicted.

WandaWonder · 21/07/2023 10:39

I mean in general but why kids have to be happy because their parents have another baby?

Parents want to keep on having children, sure they don't need their childs permission but it does affect the current children they do have

thatsnotmylifeitstoocrazy · 21/07/2023 10:35

What stuck out to me was she wanted new glasses so off you popped and got her some?? Surely you only get new ones when needed. She sounds spoiled.