Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DD told me to get an abortion.

310 replies

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 07:40

I've name changed because I know a few people who use MN,

OP posts:
WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 13:02

Jigslaw · 21/07/2023 12:51

From what OP has said this is out of character for her DD, I don't think it's aspirational that you create an environment and dynamic where your children can't say how they feel to you. In this case of course it's right that OP talks to her and says that it's an unacceptable thing to say, but I actually think props to OP for her daughter feeling she can be honest with her about how she feels. As many have said on this thread much of the time teens will talk to their friends out of fear or worry of talking to their parents; that's sad.

Valid if she said she felt pushed out or big changes etc.

You need to get am abortion because I want the money is not to be applauded.

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 13:01

BadNomad · 21/07/2023 12:55

She sounds like she has a good head on her shoulders to think that finances should be a consideration when it comes to having children. The girl will go far with that attitude. She just needs to realise that she doesn't get to decide that for other people.

No she doesn't have a good head 🤣🤣

All shes worried about is her money tree, she is not assessing the financial situation of her mother altruistically.

BadNomad · 21/07/2023 12:55

She sounds like she has a good head on her shoulders to think that finances should be a consideration when it comes to having children. The girl will go far with that attitude. She just needs to realise that she doesn't get to decide that for other people.

Greenpin · 21/07/2023 12:55

I imagine this all about feeling" surpless to requirements" One sibling was manageable now she will have two close in age ,she's probably wondering where she fits into this new family group. She is obviously much loved but at the moment she probably needs alot of reassurance. Teens need so much help to navigate life . Parenting them is so hard.

justasking111 · 21/07/2023 12:51

Well reassure her that you're financially stable.

Tell her she never has to babysit.

She's got GCSEs coming up and remembers heard the last baby crying day and night. OP is going to be twice as distracted with a toddler and a baby. The toddler won't miraculously sleep through every night.

She'll need her own quiet space to get a full night's sleep and personal quiet space to revise.

My advice organise this now. Furniture, decor to enable her to get peace and quiet.

My teenage son caught hand, foot and mouth from his nieces. But he was much sicker and his finger nails came loose. We had to ban sick grandchildren while he was doing GCSEs and ALevels after that.

Jigslaw · 21/07/2023 12:51

Hummingbird89 · 21/07/2023 12:30

I’m often really shocked on mumsnet about what people feel is acceptable from teenagers and how they allow themselves to be spoken to.
no way would I allow a 15 year old to comment on my finances or reproductive choices. They wouldn’t DARE.
There was a thread the other day about teens having too much “power”-this is a perfect example of it.

From what OP has said this is out of character for her DD, I don't think it's aspirational that you create an environment and dynamic where your children can't say how they feel to you. In this case of course it's right that OP talks to her and says that it's an unacceptable thing to say, but I actually think props to OP for her daughter feeling she can be honest with her about how she feels. As many have said on this thread much of the time teens will talk to their friends out of fear or worry of talking to their parents; that's sad.

readbooksdrinktea · 21/07/2023 12:49

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 12:46

Why? Because your mother had another baby and dared to think ahout things other than you?

No. Because it's my mother's house and her decision that I would have no say in, rightly so, but I also wouldn't be thrilled at all about crying babies and toddlers all the time when trying to finish my education and have a social life. So, I'd do what I could to remove myself from the situation.

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 12:48

Hummingbird89 · 21/07/2023 12:43

@WildUnchartedWaters agreed. This thread is batshit.

Absolutely mental.

I assume all these women would be fine being policed bu their daughter and told to have an abortion.

Absolutely ridiculous, the majority of these posts. They must live in a world where everyone has 2.4 children spaced precisely 2 years apart.

It's no wonder there are spoilt selfish entitled young women like this DD , going by the example the women on this thread are leading.

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 12:46

readbooksdrinktea · 21/07/2023 12:43

I definitely don't blame her. I'd be doing the same and would be moving out as soon as possible.

Why? Because your mother had another baby and dared to think ahout things other than you?

BlackeyedSusan · 21/07/2023 12:45

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 08:00

Sorry, I posted with my first half sentence, not even sure how.
DD is 15. Its unlike her to be unkind, but recently I guess she's got it into her head she's going to make big big money when she leaves education, and that our careers have been insignificant. I get the impression we're just so "little" compared to where she views her life going.

ah yes, I have one of those too... it's tiresome.

readbooksdrinktea · 21/07/2023 12:43

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/07/2023 08:58

I can appreciate that she won't want babies around, how embarrassing for her but she is talking of spending as much time out of the house as she can.

I mean, in the nicest way, can you blame her?

I definitely don't blame her. I'd be doing the same and would be moving out as soon as possible.

Hummingbird89 · 21/07/2023 12:43

@WildUnchartedWaters agreed. This thread is batshit.

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 12:40

BestZebbie · 21/07/2023 12:09

I think she probably assumes you'd advise that she seriously consider abortion if she got pregnant (as she is 15), so she feels she is well within the bounds of your close relationship to suggest the same back to you. And she isn't wrong, really.

She doesn't get to enforce your reproductive choices any more than anyone else would, but she gets to have an opinion and that opinion can reasonably be that she thinks proceeding with another child at this point would be a terrible idea (especially for her, and looking forward to her forthcoming university/driving lesson costs etc).

You cant be serious.

You dont think there's a difference between a mother advising a 15 year old to have an abortion and a child telling her mum to because she doesnt like that shed have to share finances? Seriously?!

She doesnt get to have an opinion, at all.

WildUnchartedWaters · 21/07/2023 12:39

NoraBattysCurlers · 21/07/2023 12:28

She's 15 and lashed out. She doesn't want another baby sibling in the house and most 15 year-olds will feel the same. I wouldn't have wanted baby siblings when I was 14-15 either.

She is understandably worried about the future. I think you need to reassure her regarding finances and university, etc.

Yes , because it's all about DD.

fireflyloo · 21/07/2023 12:35

What she said was blunt and insensitive but the sentiment behind it- I don't want another sibling are valid. Did you ask for her opinion? Did you share any uncertainty about continuing the pregnancy?

From what you've written it sounds like she has a pretty cushy life! Have you over compensated for her having a new sibling?
Is she worried those things would stop?

Hummingbird89 · 21/07/2023 12:30

I’m often really shocked on mumsnet about what people feel is acceptable from teenagers and how they allow themselves to be spoken to.
no way would I allow a 15 year old to comment on my finances or reproductive choices. They wouldn’t DARE.
There was a thread the other day about teens having too much “power”-this is a perfect example of it.

NoraBattysCurlers · 21/07/2023 12:28

She's 15 and lashed out. She doesn't want another baby sibling in the house and most 15 year-olds will feel the same. I wouldn't have wanted baby siblings when I was 14-15 either.

She is understandably worried about the future. I think you need to reassure her regarding finances and university, etc.

Dixiechickonhols · 21/07/2023 12:22

It sounds like you’ve got everything covered financially I’d reassure her and just keep talking.
You mention she’s quite blunt and you obviously discuss abortion etc so she knows you are pro choice.
Teens see things quite black and white anyway, some more than others.
I’d definitely discuss social norms with her. Telling a married 35 yr old woman to get an abortion isn’t appropriate.
Congratulations and best wishes.

malificent7 · 21/07/2023 12:20

She dosn't want a sibling as it's competition for resources. Not up to her though.
My 15 year dd thinks that money grows on trees and that she will easily make ££££ when she leaves school. It might shock her to find it's not that easy although she does have a job.

Terzani · 21/07/2023 12:11

I don't feel like it's DDs place to even suggest an abortion, and I can't really see where the thought process is that we're having money problems.

OP, you answered your own question. What she says - it's not even that uncommon. Teenagers say all kind of absurd, awful or mean things to their parents, especially mothers. Sometimes they ask mother to adopt another child just because they envy a certain friend who seems to enjoy having a little sibling; sometimes they invent bad things about their siblings, out of pure childish jealousy. But she'll be just fine when the new brother or sister is born.

Thosepeskyseagulls · 21/07/2023 12:11

PinkDaffodil2 · 21/07/2023 08:01

Aged 15 she probably realised it’s more acceptable to suggest money as a reason than the actual reasons she doesn’t want you to have another baby? Less of your time, attention as she’s at a turbulent age. There’s not a lot of info about her in your post but how has she been emotionally since you had your second? Do you think I she’s trying to upset you, or just scared / upset?

Yes I agree with all of this. I would look behind this for the real reasons she is feeling so negative about your news.

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 12:10

Dixiechickonhols · 21/07/2023 11:43

If Op and her DH are on £29,000 each, girl only gets minimum maintenance loan with expected parental contribution around £5000 a year outside London.
Min loan won’t even cover her accommodation.
Fine if parents know and have saved but lots assume everyone can borrow same maintenance loan or have no idea how much parents are now expected to contribute.
Op will have 2 in childcare when dc goes to Uni. It’s a huge amount to pay from net income if they haven’t saved.
Obviously better ways to express it but she’s 15. If her dream is to go away go Uni I can see why she would be concerned about your financial situation.

Thank you for this! Are you the poster who has posted about student maintenance a few times on the thread? - apologies if not! I'd like to thank them too.
This is actually something that I will be discussing with DD, because I don't want her to worry for her future.

We're also quite lucky in the fact that I do pay minimal childcare- me and DHs hours overlap sometimes- but rarely so that's an expense that could be massive that isn't

OP posts:
BestZebbie · 21/07/2023 12:09

I think she probably assumes you'd advise that she seriously consider abortion if she got pregnant (as she is 15), so she feels she is well within the bounds of your close relationship to suggest the same back to you. And she isn't wrong, really.

She doesn't get to enforce your reproductive choices any more than anyone else would, but she gets to have an opinion and that opinion can reasonably be that she thinks proceeding with another child at this point would be a terrible idea (especially for her, and looking forward to her forthcoming university/driving lesson costs etc).

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 12:06

Thank you all for your responses, there's definitely food for thought.

I really want to stress that she isn't a spoilt or nasty girl. This is partially why I name changed, because there are enough details about our lives here that people I know on mumsnet would absolutely recognise us.
She does have what I consider to be a fair amount materially, BUT this is because I didn't have anything growing up, which was part of why I had her at 17. I didn't envision my life being about anything more than struggling, but when she was here in the flesh, I wanted her to have everything that I could ever reach for her.
I didn't want her to grow up being bullied for having less, or feeling lesser than anyone, or grow up to expect that she would struggle to meet her needs.

So I've modelled to her, you work hard, you pay for what you need to, the roof over your head, your council tax, other priority bills, you put some money towards future expenses, then you make sure you enjoy your life...and I happily pass on most of that to my eldest.

This thread really does focus on what DD receives financially because that is the concern she has brought up. One poster says I'm overanalyzing the financial aspect now to see if there's any truth. I absolutely am!

If she were to sight she hasn't seen me enough, I'd be analysing how present I've been, but she didn't say that.

I'm taking on board lots of people saying that she might feel like I've had a second family, and that she might be feeling left out. Ouch, that must hurt her, and I'll definitely discuss that with her because that's absolutely not the intention or thought and I would hate her to feel that way

Maybe we also need to address concerns for her future.

The plan has always been when she's in further education £100 a week transferred directly to her. In the first year of her further education, she can either be taken to and from by me, or she can access public transport, or use a mixture.
By the end of the first year, I would very much like her to be driving. We have planned that she can have her driving lessons and tests paid for by us and there is provision for an £8k car, we will meet insurance costs.
If she's going off to university following the 2nd year of the course she's planning on doing, then I assume there are excellent transport links around and halls are going to be travellable to uni (I never went, I don't know. I'm lucky to earn fairly well without having attended)
Then the plan is that she sells her car, and has a decent lump sum towards her costs at uni, whilst still receiving the £100pw from us. If the COL issues continue into then, we may then also give her the savings we make on not paying her car insurance. Ontop of the loans, I've always assumed that would give her a fairly comfortable (for a student) lifestyle.

The trips I've listed, are all trips out she's jad with myself or DH or as a family with care being taken to ensure most attention is on her- since birth of her sibling, so things will continue on much the same when there are two.

I apologise for being long winded. I'm trying to keep up with all points!

It's clear we have some conversations to have. Not necessarily me telling her to wind her neck in, or punishment, but to really discuss things in depth, with the insight from this thread, I can maybe use some of people's thoughts to put possible concerns out there, and allay them.

She really is a good kid. Thoughtful, sensitive. Nice. I hate that I've pretty much put her worst foot forward here on this post. Anyone who knows her, thinks really highly of her.

Someone said that this may just be the way that she thinks, being good at engineering subjects, I think that could be right, but she's often not quite so blunt.

Thank you everyone.

OP posts:
KingsHeath53 · 21/07/2023 11:46

ladyvivienne · 21/07/2023 11:15

It's your choice, but a 15 year age gap is enormous. Were you very young when you had her? She did want a sibling but she didn't get that until it was too late (in her eyes) and now you're providing that child with a sibling?

I imagine she's feeling very very pushed out.

Do all 3 children have the same father?

Personally i would have been concentrating on the family I had, not making another one (that's how she's probably seeing it) but obviously that's your choice. And honestly it's nothing to do with her. But she is entitled to feel pushed out and that's how it's come across.

My brother (full brother, same mum and dad since apparently that's relevant) was born when I was a teenager and he was a total ray of sunshine in my otherwise selfish teenage life. A big age gap can be lovely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread