Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DD told me to get an abortion.

310 replies

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 07:40

I've name changed because I know a few people who use MN,

OP posts:
SeulementUneFois · 21/07/2023 08:32

"Maybe tell her someone told you the same thing when you were pregnant with her, that will shut her up!"

This OP!!

Zanatdy · 21/07/2023 08:31

When you’re 15 small babies running around isn’t exactly as exciting as it is to the parent. Things you might normally do with teens you can’t do when they’ve got much younger siblings. She was out of order to suggest an abortion

drpet49 · 21/07/2023 08:31

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 08:00

Sorry, I posted with my first half sentence, not even sure how.
DD is 15. Its unlike her to be unkind, but recently I guess she's got it into her head she's going to make big big money when she leaves education, and that our careers have been insignificant. I get the impression we're just so "little" compared to where she views her life going.

She sounds like a spoilt brat with ideas above her station.

ilovesushi · 21/07/2023 08:29

I think she was probably acting like the majority of completely self absorbed teenagers. I think when they look at things like abortion in school, it is from a very emotionless perspective - the legal side, the ethics - so the idea that this could be hurtful to you is just not on her radar (or not much). I know exactly what you mean about being looked down on. My two do this. There seems to be a dissatisfaction with what we have compared to their friends. It is more a grass is greener situation. We are comfortably off but we live in an area where there is a lot of serious wealth and I think they have a skewed idea of reality because of that sometimes. It boils my blood though because my husband and I work very hard and sometimes I worry I am raising two very entitled teenagers. Congrats by the way!

Mischance · 21/07/2023 08:29

Ignore - just ignore.

The trouble with Mums getting pregnant is that you have to come to terms with the fact that your parents are "at it." ..... when of course they are far too old to be doing any such thing!!

She'll get over it.

NoTouch · 21/07/2023 08:27

I don't think I would have been keen to have another baby sibling as a teenager. There are lots of ways this is going to impact her so it is not unexpected she is hitting out if she has concerns. It is also likely those concerns are deeper and more complex than just money.

She is not going to have her mum on tap when she needs her during some of the more important years of her life - navigating her teen and exam years because mum is going to be very busy with two dependent infants. Most teens have a reasonably quiet house during study time as siblings are the same age, she will have noise and disruption.

While it is not her decision, you do need to listen to her and help her understand her concerns without invalidating them. Teens are hard work and need a lot of your time too.

NobodysNose · 21/07/2023 08:27

Hmm. I agree with picking your battles but I think at 15 it's fair to point out to her that she (no one) gets to tell a woman what to do about her pregnancy.

She could express concern over money and how the baby may impact her - but she doesn't get to tell you that you should have an abortion.

marblesthecat · 21/07/2023 08:25

FoodFann · 21/07/2023 08:19

Congratulations on your pregnancy OP.

This isn’t about money. Like you say, it certainly doesn’t sound like you’re living like you have money troubles. Multiple trips to USA and France, gigs etc, is a very wealthy lifestyle. Maybe she doesn’t want another sibling taking a slice of ‘her’ pie.

But, that’s irrelevant. What is relevant here is that your DD had the audacity and the insensitivity to tell you, another woman, with your own body, to get an abortion. If it was anyone else she was throwing this ‘advice’ out to, how would you feel? I would be disgusted in her, she needs to have a serious chat with you and her father to reeducate her on having respect for other people’s bodies and what an abortion actually entails physically and mentally.

I’m almost completely against abortions, so her willy-nilly attitude to killing a baby worries me. Does she have any idea of the seriousness of the procedure or does she think it’s as emotionless as taking a sweetie? You said she throws her clothes away when she feels like it, does she have the same attitude to babies? IMHO, that is very disturbing, especially as she enters her womanhood and needs to take responsibility for her own ability to bear children.

She had the audacity to tell anther woman to do with her body but then you say you are "almost completely against abortions". What does that mean? Also an early term abortion is not "killing a baby". I am not saying it's OK what her daughter said but you are deliberately using emotive language about embryos to push your agenda.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 21/07/2023 08:24

in regards to your financial situation: I misread. But I do think that a calm conversation about your finances would be a good idea.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 21/07/2023 08:24

1 she probably doesn’t want another sibling
2 she doesn’t want everyone to know her parents still have sex and your pregnancy is a clear indication you do

it’s not up to her. I’d just explain that it’s your body, your life, your choice.

TreesAreBloodyGreat · 21/07/2023 08:24

Is she an introvert OP? If she's already been raised in a quiet environment and has had to adjust to a screaming toddler she probably doesn't want more disruption. It was a callous thing to say and it's not her choice but I do understand her not wanting another sibling.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 21/07/2023 08:23

She’s 15, 15 isn’t an age most particularly known for empathy, altruism and balanced views.

I do think that for her, as an individual, a 2nd sibling probably (objectively) won’t be particularly ideal, no!
I am saying this as an older sister (my youngest half-sibling is 18 years younger than I am). I love my siblings, but their births and how my parents handled their/our childhood had some very negative consequences for me (as a teen and young adult).

as others have said:

  1. did you make her babysit, give her additional chores etc. when the 2nd child was born?
  2. I’m not sure I understand your financial situation. Is it possible that she has a lot of (hidden, because teenagers…) anxiety about it?
  3. are these her “full” siblings / do they have the same father? I could see there being some anxiety about her place in the family, especially if these are half siblings.
WellPlaced · 21/07/2023 08:22

She’s 15. She doesn’t mean it.

I said some awful things when I was that age because I knew it all, obviously.

PimpMyFridge · 21/07/2023 08:22

I'd tell her that isn't on the cards. Explain calmly that is a pretty cavalier thing to say about a serious and deep issue.
Discuss your money situation and give her some perspective and let her know that you realise what she said may not be at the heart of why she said it, in that a new baby is as big change and if she has worries or frustrations about the family absorbing a new sibling she can talk to you as you will understand the change affects her and want to support her as she adjusts and help understand the impacts so you can help to minimise any negative consequences.
While also saying the baby will be loved as she is and your family will enhanced by it's new member with all the rough and the smooth that comes with just as she enhanced things with her rough and smooths.

She's just being a callous selfish teen, not a horrible person, just a lot to learn yet.

Inkpotlover · 21/07/2023 08:22

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/07/2023 08:18

OP says they're "not just about managing to put food on the table" or that they are struggling to do it.

Ah, I misread then. It sounded like they weren’t managing.

WaltzingWaters · 21/07/2023 08:20

could it be that she’s worried another sibling will take time and attention away from her? Or that she’ll have to babysit lots? Has much changed with the relationship between you and her since your DS came along?
It’s probably a bit of fear of losing more mum time. Of course you shouldn’t get an abortion, but reassure her you’ll always have time for her.
Of course she could also just be a spoiled teen saying mean things and scared that the bank of mum and dad will thin out with another sibling. Sounds very wasteful only wearing outfits a couple times and throwing them out. That needs to stop!

Congratulations on the pregnancy OP. I hope your Dd changes her attitude and shows more love and excitement towards a new sibling.

FoodFann · 21/07/2023 08:19

Congratulations on your pregnancy OP.

This isn’t about money. Like you say, it certainly doesn’t sound like you’re living like you have money troubles. Multiple trips to USA and France, gigs etc, is a very wealthy lifestyle. Maybe she doesn’t want another sibling taking a slice of ‘her’ pie.

But, that’s irrelevant. What is relevant here is that your DD had the audacity and the insensitivity to tell you, another woman, with your own body, to get an abortion. If it was anyone else she was throwing this ‘advice’ out to, how would you feel? I would be disgusted in her, she needs to have a serious chat with you and her father to reeducate her on having respect for other people’s bodies and what an abortion actually entails physically and mentally.

I’m almost completely against abortions, so her willy-nilly attitude to killing a baby worries me. Does she have any idea of the seriousness of the procedure or does she think it’s as emotionless as taking a sweetie? You said she throws her clothes away when she feels like it, does she have the same attitude to babies? IMHO, that is very disturbing, especially as she enters her womanhood and needs to take responsibility for her own ability to bear children.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/07/2023 08:18

Inkpotlover · 21/07/2023 08:10

Putting her comment aside for a moment, you mention that you are worried about the CoL crisis and your DH's "financial decisions" and that you are "just about" putting food on the table but equally you have access to money for all her trips and trainers. What state are your finances really in? Are you relying on credit/in debt to get by? Is her concern about the financial impact on the family actually justified?

OP says they're "not just about managing to put food on the table" or that they are struggling to do it.

GiraffeDoor · 21/07/2023 08:17

Two little ones close in age changes the dynamic massively. She possibly feels like they'll be "proper" siblings, and she'll be the outsider in her own home.

I would talk this through really openly with her, and I would make sure I had plans in place in advance of the baby coming to ensure you still have plenty of time with/for your eldest (for example, not having to take the little ones with you to parents' evenings, or 6th form open days etc)

Rosieposy89 · 21/07/2023 08:15

She sounds completely spoilt. You never say no to her, so her reaction is unsurprising. She is used to getting her own way on everything

LaMaG · 21/07/2023 08:14

Totally get why she doesn't want another baby around, babies are annoying if you don't enjoy them. Her head is probably wrecked from the 15 mth olds demands and she is afraid she will be the babysitter. But she is way out of order here, just an insensitive teenage brat. Maybe tell her someone told you the same thing when you were pregnant with her, that will shut her up!!

WandaWonder · 21/07/2023 08:14

She may be worried you will use her for childcare?

OhmygodDont · 21/07/2023 08:14

A screaming newborn and then toddler ontop of an already toddler during gcse years and what not. Yeah I’m betting that’s why she’s said it and used money as the acceptable reason.

The teen years just get harder again and more demanding at gcse/a level stages it’s when she’s going to need the most input again since she was a baby.

Also do you / did you ask her to help a lot with the current sibling? Is she scared she’s going to have to spend all her free time helping a crying pooping baby? Rather than revising or actually getting down time from revising.

Obviously she should have been more diplomatic overall but she’s 15.

Janieforever · 21/07/2023 08:13

Inkpotlover · 21/07/2023 08:10

Putting her comment aside for a moment, you mention that you are worried about the CoL crisis and your DH's "financial decisions" and that you are "just about" putting food on the table but equally you have access to money for all her trips and trainers. What state are your finances really in? Are you relying on credit/in debt to get by? Is her concern about the financial impact on the family actually justified?

I wondered this, “ access to money” is an unusual way to phrase it and I don’t understand how you can be worried about putting food on the table but also have all this money for the extras. It is contradictory.

DisquietintheRanks · 21/07/2023 08:13

LobsterCrab · 21/07/2023 08:06

I think at 15yo, she isn't old enough to properly understand the emotional distress of having an abortion. To her it's more like a choice "shall I have a baby or not?" And she's thinking that it would be better not. Teens tend to have very black and white thought processes. I honestly don't think she means this to be as hurtful as it would be if an older person said it.

This. And although I am in no way suggesting you should terminate, it is absolutely true that the appearance of a second sibling is going to negatively impact her.

So no she shouldn't have said it and no you should have no guilt whatsoever in continuing with this pregnancy but I can understand how it got said.

As an aside my sister went from bring an only child at 13 to having 3 younger siblings by 17. Although she loves us now there's no doubt it was a rough transition for her, despite our parents best efforts and general optimism.