Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DD told me to get an abortion.

310 replies

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 07:40

I've name changed because I know a few people who use MN,

OP posts:
JustFrustrated · 21/07/2023 08:53

I always find threads like this fascinating.

If OPs DD was a step daughter everyone would be defending her as the first child.

What she said was unpleasant yes, and shouldn't have been said but she's a teen who probably doesn't even understand how and why she feels that way, well enough to be able to articulate it.

Having been a teen when both of my parents, separately, went on to have further children, it's not all roses. I love my little sibling now but at the time the resentment was high, in fact at times it still is.

He wasn't a "sibling" he was a child my parent and their partner decided to have, he became the reason people missed my parents evenings, that i had to move bedrooms, when they were already struggling (less than I was younger but still) I had even less when actually I needed more...I needed new clothes and hygiene products and to have time spent on me (as did my elder siblings) instead we watched us get pushed to the side in our key years (GCSEs for me and my sister) and him get lavished with everything we wanted and deserved.

Even now as all adults, he's like the prodigal son and we try to live up to him.

It's not easy being the outsider, but it's even less easy to communicate how you feel when everyone else is excited and happy.

So you need to separate the baby issue and the general disrespect (throwing clothes after a couple of wears?! At least sell them) and deal with them as separate things.

TheDogthatDug · 21/07/2023 08:50

DD sounds like a spoiled little madam. If she wants money for clothes suggest to her that she gets weekend employment like teenagers used to in the days before they expected the world on a plate.

justasking111 · 21/07/2023 08:50

@Wowokthanks just a thought is your partner thrilled to be a father again?

justasking111 · 21/07/2023 08:48

We never discussed finances in front of our children. They do worry.

My DS was doing his A levels when I got pregnant, he was mortified. He was abroad celebrating end of exams when baby arrived. He adored him as did his older brother once he had arrived.

Teateaandmoretea · 21/07/2023 08:46

Newbutoldfather · 21/07/2023 08:38

She does sound spoilt, I am afraid.

I would say that discussing finances in front of children is not the best thing, as they tend to have a partial understanding, and get stressed if you see, worried.

I would ask her to make a sensible budget for herself and discuss it with her. Then, within reason, she will see that she can still do things even with the additional expense of a new baby (I mean you agreeing a budget for her, not contextualising it within your own finances, which are none of her business).

I have known teens (as a teacher) get very excited and very involved with new babies! It is not always true it is not exciting for them, although I guess this is the second within a couple of years.

I think that kids need to know how much it costs to have a comfortable life. When asked my teen daughter estimated our household income at less than half what it actually is. Because they very often rank how well off they think they are against size of house, how expensive cars are, how flash your holidays are, how expensive your clothes are, how often you get your nails done etc. We live a fairly modest life in some ways in comparison to some other people.

It’s funny because once she realised it she kind of wound her neck in - she knows we’re better off than many of her friends parents (although comparable to some) and she’s quite aware/ sensitive to it.

Foxblue · 21/07/2023 08:45

Totally not the point of the thread but she throws clothes away after only a couple of wears??? God that must make you furious!

WeWereInParis · 21/07/2023 08:45

I don't blame her for not being thrilled. But I'd be making it extremely clear that it is absolutely not her place to tell anyone to have an abortion. I'd be really cross if I had a teenager who said that to me (and I have had an abortion, I'm not anti them).

She can talk about her worries for how the baby will affect her without telling you to have an abortion.

New baby aside, she sounds a bit spoilt. Wearing clothes once or twice and then throwing them away???

Newbutoldfather · 21/07/2023 08:44

@OhmygodDont ,

You are totally catastrophing!

There are plenty of holidays with children’s/young people’s (up to 17) clubs. I doubt she will be expected to hang around the young ones. Within a couple of years, she can also go away with friends.

Also, she is a teen. She should be going to coffee shops with her mates, not tagging along to soft play.

There is no perfect family structure. Close together can be lovely but it can also be unbelievably tense. Far apart and you can never (well, not for a long time) play together as equals.

And, for a teen, having much younger siblings is a great opportunity to earn babysitting money!

Scienceadvisory · 21/07/2023 08:44

@FoodFann and as part of this educating her daughter over what abortion entails physically and mentally are you also going to suggest the OP does that for pregnancy and childbirth? Or is all the harm that can cause not worth knowing because who wants educated girls and women?

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 21/07/2023 08:43

Having read your 3 posts, OP, she is sounding quite spoiled and entitled.

Thinking you should have an abortion would have been shocking, but to actually say it to you is quite shocking and out of order. And you need to sit her down and pull her up on it this weekend once school is out and you have some time to address her attitude and expectations.

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 08:42

Janieforever · 21/07/2023 08:13

I wondered this, “ access to money” is an unusual way to phrase it and I don’t understand how you can be worried about putting food on the table but also have all this money for the extras. It is contradictory.

Sorry, what I said was, we aren't just about putting food on the table. In example, we're not just about meeting our essential needs, there is extra money. Money is there when it's needed or wanted.

Access to money is probably an odd term. Not sure why I use that, but it is the way I tend to talk,
Access to money, access to food, access to transport.... I use the word access a lot lol.

OP posts:
Angliski · 21/07/2023 08:41

Sounds like rather a spoilt nasty madam to me. I feel for you as teens are very superior and can behave in very ugly ways

Scienceadvisory · 21/07/2023 08:41

FoodFann · 21/07/2023 08:19

Congratulations on your pregnancy OP.

This isn’t about money. Like you say, it certainly doesn’t sound like you’re living like you have money troubles. Multiple trips to USA and France, gigs etc, is a very wealthy lifestyle. Maybe she doesn’t want another sibling taking a slice of ‘her’ pie.

But, that’s irrelevant. What is relevant here is that your DD had the audacity and the insensitivity to tell you, another woman, with your own body, to get an abortion. If it was anyone else she was throwing this ‘advice’ out to, how would you feel? I would be disgusted in her, she needs to have a serious chat with you and her father to reeducate her on having respect for other people’s bodies and what an abortion actually entails physically and mentally.

I’m almost completely against abortions, so her willy-nilly attitude to killing a baby worries me. Does she have any idea of the seriousness of the procedure or does she think it’s as emotionless as taking a sweetie? You said she throws her clothes away when she feels like it, does she have the same attitude to babies? IMHO, that is very disturbing, especially as she enters her womanhood and needs to take responsibility for her own ability to bear children.

Interesting. Your penultimate paragraph says it's oh so horrible someone to tell a woman what they should do with their own body but your final paragraph outs this as a total lie and you just think women should do what you want them to do.

Oh and taking responsibility can mean getting an abortion if it's right for the individual. You sound like a forced childbirther who hates women having control of their own bodies.

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/07/2023 08:39

Is she worried for your health?

OhmygodDont · 21/07/2023 08:39

I mean at 15/16 I would have ran far away from home with my mum having babies tbh so I can’t blame her either for wanting to get out to halls for further education.

little children are loud and to teenagers annoying. Just where she’s old enough for coffee shops and more grown up things with mum, mum goes and adds babies. Back to soft play and such, holidays more geared to toddlers while she’s just the tag along now.

What she sees is you creating a new family without her basically from the sounds of her wanted to move far away asap.

Newbutoldfather · 21/07/2023 08:38

She does sound spoilt, I am afraid.

I would say that discussing finances in front of children is not the best thing, as they tend to have a partial understanding, and get stressed if you see, worried.

I would ask her to make a sensible budget for herself and discuss it with her. Then, within reason, she will see that she can still do things even with the additional expense of a new baby (I mean you agreeing a budget for her, not contextualising it within your own finances, which are none of her business).

I have known teens (as a teacher) get very excited and very involved with new babies! It is not always true it is not exciting for them, although I guess this is the second within a couple of years.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/07/2023 08:36

DonnaBanana · 21/07/2023 08:06

Kids will say insensitive things from time to time, don’t hang this over her head. At the same time tell her it’s not her decision. I wouldn’t be hugely offended by it, it’s not worth the hassle. Plus there’s nothing inherently wrong with abortion.

This.

And i can't blame her for not wanting life upended again. She'll be even more the odd one out.

Scalottia · 21/07/2023 08:34

It's none of her business and not her place to say that to you OP. You should do what YOU feel is right.

NewName122 · 21/07/2023 08:34

Mine actually told me just yesterday that if I have a baby he is moving out 🤣

Kokeshi123 · 21/07/2023 08:34

At age 15 she seems like she has a almighty sensible head on her shoulders. I say that because you've been going on about the cost of living to her, and she's obviously concerned about money.

She apparently throws clothes in the bin after a wear or two, so I doubt that's it!

ParentPerson · 21/07/2023 08:34

Do some of the previous posters not remember what it’s like to be a teenager?! She’s 15. She’s pissed she has to share her Mum yet again with a child who she can’t relate to because there’s such a big age gap. 15 year olds, unless they love little kids, aren’t going to be thrilled with all the mess/chaos/attention that goes with a newborn, especially so close to having done it previously with another much wanted and longed for sibling.

Teenagers, on the whole, don’t have the emotional literacy or understanding to be able to vocalise exactly how they feel, so make often hurtful throw away comments to portray how they feel instead.

Id have a conversation with her by herself, when she’s calm, about what is really going on with how she feels. An honest conversation about money/entitlement/effects of abortion wouldn’t go amiss either. Waters tend to run deeper than people think with children and young people, from my experience anyway.

Wowokthanks · 21/07/2023 08:33

Thank you all for the responses, I wasn't expecting quite so many!

Just a few things, she's a pretty sensitive kid, well liked by her teachers because she's responsible and kind. Usually she's kind to the point I worry about her so this is a shock.

Maybe it matters, maybe it doesn't but I had her at 17, so I've had a child with no money and no plan, and our lives are completely different to what they were...or probably should have been! So her citing money reasons is a bit of a punch in the gut.

We have everything from when the youngest was born,
Minus their 0-3m clothes because I gave them to someone who needed them, but everything else is in the house still so a baby wouldn't necessarily need any "big" items.

We would need to change our car, which I have been discussing doing anyway because FIL is going to have to stop driving soon, and it'll enable me to pick up the PILS.

The financial discussions often happen when DD is around, because we're trying to model that as things change economically around us, we need to change our behaviours to remain comfortable.... maybe I need to address that, but we do talk about financial planning and the importance of setting herself up financially (in a way that I didn't have the opportunity to)
Writing it out, maybe she's seeing that I'm saying don't be like me and thinking, well of course they're broke! I think I might need to discuss that with her.

Also, discussions around abortion have happened frequently in our house- her plan was to live in the US for a few years when she's older, the new abortion laws have been the basis of the discussion of women's rights being taken away. So maybe she's also of the view that I think abortions are an easy, no consequence option? Again, maybe I'll need to address the way we discuss things. Maybe she doesn't understand the emotional turmoil that an abortion often is?

She doesn't get involved with parenting. She's done the odd stint of babysitting, I mean 15 minutes when I needed to leave for work and DH was in traffic- and we paid her better than we pay the childminder! I dont want to expose her to the responsibilities of a baby that isn't hers. We live in a townhouse, and the youngest isn't even in his own room because its on the same floor as hers, because I don't want to risk her being woken up by him if he cries in the night.

She does have a career in mind, engineering. She's a smart kid, she knows what she wants to do, and all of her mock GCSE results meet the criteria already for her to get into the further education she wants to do directly after school.

I can appreciate that she won't want babies around, how embarrassing for her but she is talking of spending as much time out of the house as she can.
She leaves school next year, she wants a part time job, she wants to attend further education 45 minutes away, then she's going to university- she's adamant she's going to one far away so she can stay in halls and she wants her own life so I can't see her being around that much for the young ones to cramp her style too much.

Maybe we just need to revisit the conversation when emotions aren't quite so high. She's a nice kid usually, and I'm not sure that feeling as hurt as I do, I'm going to be able to see past the hurt of what she's said.

OP posts:
Kokeshi123 · 21/07/2023 08:33

She sounds a bit of a spoiled brat.

I'd love to know what sort of "career" she thinks she's going to have...

AlanJohnsonsBeamer · 21/07/2023 08:33

Just ignore her. She made a thoughtless and hurtful comment which I guarantee will play on her mind when she's older.

I once said something insensitive to my stepdad (who raised me since 3) not being my real dad at around that age. I often think about it and have apologised more than once in adulthood.

NewName122 · 21/07/2023 08:32

At age 15 she seems like she has a almighty sensible head on her shoulders. I say that because you've been going on about the cost of living to her, and she's obviously concerned about money. I have a teen and haven't gone on about the cost of living to them. Just telp her you can afford a new baby.