Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at DH for wanting finances car?

185 replies

hippygirllucky · 21/07/2023 01:58

DH has a car he bought 2 years ago, 2014 model. Runs fine, the air con has needed regassing but otherwise good.

Today he's announced that he's going to trade his car in for a much bigger car on finance. We have 1 DD with no plans for another at the moment and the only place he really drives regularly is 5 minutes to work and back. The total cost for new car is £41000 (seems an eye watering amount to me!)... it's not even a brand new car, it's an ex showroom car. He's already decided. We have about £5k in savings. He intends on trading in his old car against it and making almost £400 a month payments, with a £14000 lump sum payment at the end of 4 years.

AIBU for hitting the roof when he told me this? He seems to think £400 a month is nothing (it's half our mortgage payment!) and hasn't even seemed to start thinking about where the £14000 at the end is going to come from (he just said "I'll save up!"). We can technically afford it, if we make compromises... it's just such a pointless expense when he has a perfectly good car. He says he will pay for it entirely out of his salary but my argument is that this WILL affect me and DD. Do you think I'm being too controlling? Would you be upset or would you say "your decision"? He seems to think I'm being overly controlling.

OP posts:
ohtowinthelottery · 21/07/2023 08:13

Tell him to put £400pm in a savings account for 2 years first without touching it to prove you can afford it - I suspect not as you've only currently got £5k savings (unless you've just depleted savings by paying for something substantial).

Has he been living under a stone for the last couple of years and the COL crisis has past him by? Why on Earth does he want to spend that amount on a car that will spend most of the time parked up? And why is he even driving to work which is only 5 mins away? Tell him to get a bike!

PurpleButterflyWings · 21/07/2023 08:12

HighEndGrifters · 21/07/2023 02:07

We are very comfortable, we have no mortgage, no debt, and we drive around in second hand cars, both cars are in the region of fourteen years old, but we own them, we think leasing is a mugs game, and quite frankly this would be a deal breaker for me.

Personally, I would ask him to save the bubble payment first and transfer it to you, so at least that part of your annoyance is salved, I would then ask him to produce a budget to prove where the £400 a month is coming from and his contingency fund if he loses his job.

Finance is glossy and easy, but when you make him drill down and extrapolate he may think differently.

This ... ^ DH and I are financially comfortable now, and have no mortgage, and no debts, and we have a second hand car - 15 reg, (normal car like Astra and Focus type.) We were in a lot of debt in the past - and it really stressed us out, and we really struggled for some years. And it wasn't buying fucking flash £40K cars. Hmm This was just trying to live, support 2 kids, and fund a house/mortgage/house repairs etc...

This past decade, we have been debt free and mortgage free, and would take this over being in debt 100X over. Like fuck will we ever get in debt again. Pouring £40K into a car debt over a few years is madness. Just so he can look a bit flash. Hmm Like a few others here, this would be a deal breaker for me. Couldn't be doing with a man that always had to try and be the big shot, getting the family into debt to try and look like a big flash 'big man.'

A poster said how borrowing lots of money is fine because money makes money. What a load of rot. It makes no money for the person in debt. Hmm

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 21/07/2023 08:09

NoSquirrels · 21/07/2023 07:59

Why is £400 a big amount and not less than £400? Is it a trick question?

OP has shared that they could ‘just’ afford it if they juggle stuff around, that it puts a holiday next year off the table or very hard to afford and they only have £5,000 in savings. £400 a month is £4,800 a year. It would double their savings. They’re clearly not rolling in cash such that £400 a month is chump change, or they’d have more savings.

Exactly. If they had £100k in savings then yes, the £14k at the end would be a relative drop in the ocean. £5k isn't enough to be comfortable when there's the potential to add £400pcm to it.

Our last car was £12k for a 1 year old hybrid in 2022 and we paid cash.

Peony654 · 21/07/2023 08:09

He’s being an idiot driving 5 mins to work. No wonder there’s a climate and obesity crisis.

ToWonderWhyIBother · 21/07/2023 08:08

Has he factored in the insurance price difference ? Mine has just doubled for the renewal.

hettie · 21/07/2023 08:08

Unless your household income is north of 150k that's a stupid amount to spend monthly on a depreciating asset whose function could be delivered for free/less (with the existing car).
I couldn't share a life with someone so financially illiterate or who didn't see me as a joint and equal partner.

HakunaMatiÅ‚da · 21/07/2023 08:07

@hippygirllucky You should point out to your DH that the true cost is £700 a month to include the lump sum at the end. Otherwise he is paying £400 a month to borrow a car to drive in less than an hour a week…. So essentially paying £10 a day to get to and from work in something more shiny.

(not including running costs!)

holls8 · 21/07/2023 08:03

YANBU, he is being idiotic. If you can't afford to buy it outright then you can't afford it in my eyes. He needs to live within his means. We've always saved and bought outright when we can afford it.

weathervane1 · 21/07/2023 08:01

From own own experience of making a similar impulsive purchase in 2000 (BMW 5 M Series @ 19 mpg - I went to buy a bike and somehow came back being able to watch TV in my car and do 0 - 60 incredibly fast), I can state that the buzz that I had in the showroom vanished faster than Nigel Farage's Coutt's bank account. Within a week I had traded it back in for my old car, losing s small amount on the way. Whilst au could afford it, I resented the amount I was paying and in the cold light of day, realised I had been thinking with the wrong head and allowed some sort of ego to play a part. I'm now in the same car I bought in 2009 and it owes me nothing and am debt free. It's a much better feeling.

NoSquirrels · 21/07/2023 07:59

Swrigh1234 · 21/07/2023 07:52

This thread shows the double standards on MN. OP has shared nothing about her finances other than the mortgage payment. How much household income, how much do each of them earn. How else is it spent, etc. what if OP wanted to make a purchase and the husband didn’t agree. He would be called controlling. And why is £400 a month a big amount, why not £300, £200 or £1.50.

Being outraged without knowing the full financials situation is a bit hysterical.

Why is £400 a big amount and not less than £400? Is it a trick question?

OP has shared that they could ‘just’ afford it if they juggle stuff around, that it puts a holiday next year off the table or very hard to afford and they only have £5,000 in savings. £400 a month is £4,800 a year. It would double their savings. They’re clearly not rolling in cash such that £400 a month is chump change, or they’d have more savings.

SavedbytheBe11 · 21/07/2023 07:58

He is being an idiot. A real idiot. He can't do this.

catsnhats11 · 21/07/2023 07:56

If he doesn't need a bit new car and neither do you, who's he trying to impress?...

And no I wouldn't be happy, it's not like a one off spend, this will impact your finances for years, but really spends how affordable it is.

NoSquirrels · 21/07/2023 07:56

You’re a 2-car family, and he only drives 5 minutes to work? Do you even need 2 cars? That’s a luxury in itself, tbh.

Do you share finances?

Look, my DH can be a bit spendy and I have to rein him in but there’s absolutely no way he would do this. He’s going to fuck your joint finances and you can kiss goodbye to your holiday. Because once he’s got the car and £400 a month out of his pocket is feeling tight he’ll want to spend more on something else…

Swrigh1234 · 21/07/2023 07:52

This thread shows the double standards on MN. OP has shared nothing about her finances other than the mortgage payment. How much household income, how much do each of them earn. How else is it spent, etc. what if OP wanted to make a purchase and the husband didn’t agree. He would be called controlling. And why is £400 a month a big amount, why not £300, £200 or £1.50.

Being outraged without knowing the full financials situation is a bit hysterical.

LobsterCrab · 21/07/2023 07:49

I would absolutely hit the roof about this. What a gigantic and unnecessary waste of money!

SnarfleThree · 21/07/2023 07:47

Personal cars always in cash in my opinion.

Jeevesnotwooster · 21/07/2023 07:45

£41k on a car is bonkers I'm my opinion. Whether you can afford it or not.

hippygirllucky · 21/07/2023 07:39

Okay glad to know I wasn't being overly cautious. He won't show me the car but it's some sort of 4 x 4 (we live in a city...). I've at least managed to convince him to let me go with him to go and see it and hopefully talk him out of it, or at least be a voice of reason against a sales man, who I know on his own would have my dh signing on the dotted line in no time.

It doesn't help that I inherited a (2010!) car last year, and he keeps saying "you don't understand, you never have to pay for cars!" Because the one I had before that was a £500 2001 clio that I would have driven as long as it would go had I not inherited the other. He's right, I know nothing about cars but I know a lot about our finances. We'd like to go on holiday next year (first one since 2017) and won't be able to do that as easily when £400 of the monthly saving towards that will be going on a car!

OP posts:
Bravebunny · 21/07/2023 04:32

Hes being very unreasonable! So £400 a month for the finance, plus he’ll need to save £292 a month for the final payment at the end. Add in insurance on a large car, let’s say £40-£50 a month, plus road tax and MOT/service cost, and he’s looking at a total of £800 ish a month - that’s your mortgage payment.

That also doesn’t include tyres, any problems or repairs needed, or fuel. Regardless of it comes from his salary, that’s a minimum of nearly £10000 a year for something which will depreciate in value very quickly.

Huromjuicemaker · 21/07/2023 03:58

I think you need to ask why he feels he needs this new toy, I assume it's some kind of "prestige vehicle" are you in mid-life crisis territory? What's next a motorbike or some other cliche?

coffy11 · 21/07/2023 03:49

That's ALOT of money, of course you should have a say. My husband and I chat about and agree on purchases for a couple of hundred. We would both have to be on the same page about a new car.

The fact that he doesn't consider your opinion speaks volumes. You're not controlling, it's your money too. He sounds financially irresponsible.

StMarysTrainee · 21/07/2023 03:39

If you are accused of being overly controlling regarding something eminently cautious and family-orientated (Money issues), it’s generally by someone pouting and selfish trying to guilt you in to acquiescence. Poor ickle boy not getting his toy. Pathetic.

GlitterSquid · 21/07/2023 03:12

The average car finance spend is between 250-300pm now.
Anything in the 400+ range IS pricey to most budgets, but not uncommon.

Because of the preferential interest rates large manufacturers can offer, it can often be cheaper per month to buy new than say 1yr old on a whacking interest rate where you think you've avoided any showroom depreciation. Not so.

On PCP (which is a purchase plan, not a lease- every payment you make is one down on eventually owning the car) the end payment is a reflection of the anticipated future value of the car at that time and mileage.
Usually a good finance company will offer to refinance the end payment should he wish to keep the car, so the 14k isn't all due at once.
Or he can at that point trade in, hopefully be in positive equity and take forward a healthy deposit.
Or he could 'save up and pay it off' (hmm...chinny reckon)
Or he could simply hand back the keys to the finance company and walk away at the end of the finance term (assuming the car is in the expected condition and mileage). The last option is very rare as it isn't really financially beneficial to the customer, he may as well have actually leased and in reality all he has done is cover the depreciation.

What car is it? Vaguely...

Lastly, yes. Its unreasonable. He can't future proof your lives to ensure that £400pm will always be 'disposable'. It's a whacking amount.
You're not unreasonable to spend it if you both want and agree to it as a couple, who I assume work out their overall wealth generally on two salaries - but unilaterally? Bit shit.

LadyJ2023 · 21/07/2023 03:06

41000 for an ex car wow what the heck is it. I've just bought a brand new one for 34 and it has all the tech etc...either way I would never do finance personally and I would never get anything without hubby's support

CoffeeBeansGalore · 21/07/2023 03:03

You don't know how much mortgage payments & utilities will go up by. Could this vanity purchase end up affecting your ability to pay for your house?

£400 per month is a lot of money to find, and even more to save £14000 on top of the extra £400 .

Quite frankly he's being an idiot.

Can you get him to compromise? For the next 6 months he has to put aside all the money needed for the finance & saving (for the balloon payment). So approx £700 per month.

At the end of 6 months if it has not affected anything else & your lifestyle has not changed, all the bills & savings are still affordable, then he can buy the car.

But it then poses the question that if he is able to save £700 per month with no issue, why isn't he doing that now?

Swipe left for the next trending thread