Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at DH for wanting finances car?

185 replies

hippygirllucky · 21/07/2023 01:58

DH has a car he bought 2 years ago, 2014 model. Runs fine, the air con has needed regassing but otherwise good.

Today he's announced that he's going to trade his car in for a much bigger car on finance. We have 1 DD with no plans for another at the moment and the only place he really drives regularly is 5 minutes to work and back. The total cost for new car is £41000 (seems an eye watering amount to me!)... it's not even a brand new car, it's an ex showroom car. He's already decided. We have about £5k in savings. He intends on trading in his old car against it and making almost £400 a month payments, with a £14000 lump sum payment at the end of 4 years.

AIBU for hitting the roof when he told me this? He seems to think £400 a month is nothing (it's half our mortgage payment!) and hasn't even seemed to start thinking about where the £14000 at the end is going to come from (he just said "I'll save up!"). We can technically afford it, if we make compromises... it's just such a pointless expense when he has a perfectly good car. He says he will pay for it entirely out of his salary but my argument is that this WILL affect me and DD. Do you think I'm being too controlling? Would you be upset or would you say "your decision"? He seems to think I'm being overly controlling.

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 22/07/2023 08:02

Thirdchapterdilemma · 22/07/2023 07:51

(Misses point of thread) - if it only takes 5 mins to drive to work that’s an absolute maximum of 5 miles (at 60mph), so he should be cycling (5 miles) or walking (anything up to 2 miles), especially as you also say you live in a city!

If it's a 5 minute drive in a city, it's highly likely it's significantly less than 5 miles.

The OP hasn't said anything about him travelling for work or receiving a car allowance, so unlikely to be relevant.

She's also said that they can only afford it if they make compromises and has specifically mentioned that they won't be able to afford a holiday if he gets this car, which he doesn't need as he has a perfectly decent car already.

They also only have £5k in savings which, while more than a lot of people, won't go very far if they need to do work on the house, suffer job loss, etc.

He's basically proposing to spend the family's holiday budget and then some on his own wants.

Abbimae · 22/07/2023 08:01

If it’s PCP just swap at the end of the term

Aprilx · 22/07/2023 07:54

Swrigh1234 · 21/07/2023 07:52

This thread shows the double standards on MN. OP has shared nothing about her finances other than the mortgage payment. How much household income, how much do each of them earn. How else is it spent, etc. what if OP wanted to make a purchase and the husband didn’t agree. He would be called controlling. And why is £400 a month a big amount, why not £300, £200 or £1.50.

Being outraged without knowing the full financials situation is a bit hysterical.

@Swrigh1234

I must admit I was thinking this, although I do think a car needs to be a joint purchase, I can’t get outraged at £400 a month without knowing what the joint income is. I have been thinking I would like to change my car soon, I have had it nine years and there are some things I would like in a car that it doesn’t have. I hope my husband will be open to considering it and won’t just refuse to consider it (we consider our money as out and I won’t do it without his agreement).

Thirdchapterdilemma · 22/07/2023 07:51

(Misses point of thread) - if it only takes 5 mins to drive to work that’s an absolute maximum of 5 miles (at 60mph), so he should be cycling (5 miles) or walking (anything up to 2 miles), especially as you also say you live in a city!

Glittertwins · 22/07/2023 07:29

It might be that the OP's DH has a car allowance from work (hasn't said) meaning he would have to use that on a car with conditions on the age and type and be expected to go to other places on business as this is tied into both mine and DH's. Our taxes allowances virtually cover the monthly car expenses however it still was discussed before either car was bought and we do not have to pay the end bubble payment - we hand the car back.
I'm also not that far from my company office but my out of hours commitments make it impossible for me walk or ride a bike, I simply don't have the time nor the ability to transport everything when I need to.

BarbaraofSeville · 22/07/2023 06:42

Shade17 · 21/07/2023 22:19

Who the hell spends that much on a car? Footballers and teenage boys. Not grown men.

Are you joking? £41k would barely get you a new base 3-series. Most people I know spend more than that on cars whether they’re new or second hand. Even a decent Volvo is £50-60k or more these days. Most things that are genuinely desirable are £100k+!

Gotta love Mumsnet to never fail to minimise huge amounts of money that are far beyond the experience of most people with examples that only apply if you never leave a tiny bubble.

'Most people I know spend far more than £40k on a car'.

See also '£50k isn't much of a salary, I earned more than that as a graduate trainee in 2001'

and 'I don't know anyone who pays less than £2k a month for their mortgage'

etc etc

Ihadenough22 · 22/07/2023 04:57

I would feel the same as you about him buying this car. The reality is that your both working, and have a baby.
Between a car loan of £400 pm and saving another £14,000 for 4 years your probably looking at payment of £790pm. That far to much in your current circumstances when you only have £5000 in savings and their is a col crises also. What happens if you have a large unexpected expense? What happens if either of you lost your jobs or you're work hours were cut?
Show him what Dave Ramsey says about car payments and about savings and building wealth.

Rather than take on debit you need to build up your savings and start to bit aside each weed/month for a holiday next year.

If you had £400 pm to put towards building up your savings, then to overpay your mortgage and put more into your pensions long term you end up far better off.

watersprites · 22/07/2023 04:01

The only person I know who ever spent money like that on a car was my old cleaner... I move in a middle class professional sphere and the most anyone else I know has ever spent on a car was 12k!

You seem a little sheltered tbh. Plenty of mc people have expensive cars.

There's nothing inherently wrong about wanting to spend money on a car, people like different things. I'm not interested in cars so keep the budget low but my shoe spends/eating out makes up for it. However it needs to be affordable and a joint decision

watersprites · 22/07/2023 03:51

This mania for huge status cars amongst people who have no spare money is utterly nuts

It's nit nuts though is it, it's very human. Obviously the billionaire driving the banger doesn't care what people think because he's a billionaire!

Fairhsa · 22/07/2023 03:41

You are totally correct. This is sheer lunacy. It sounds like you have a sensible attitude to money and your husband does not. This is going to be a bigger issue going forward so if you cannot get him to listen now,.be careful.

Souleater · 22/07/2023 03:08

If you divorce him, you don't have to worry about it anymore

sandyhappypeople · 22/07/2023 00:56

user1471267414 · 21/07/2023 21:20

You are missing the point. If you genuinely think it’s acceptable to ask your partner to save a deposit and transfer it to you then do a budget to show they can afford a something there is really something wrong. This is not ok. It’s dreadful, belittling and controlling behaviour. I am actually shocked that people think just because they are married they can be like this. We are all our own people! If someone works hard and wants a new car and can afford it then leave them to it! Perhaps that will be his pleasure in life!!! No wonder so many people are miserable in the world if they have someone like that controlling them. Awful.

Yes why not, leave them to it, go and get the new car that costs £41000.. meanwhile the kids haven’t had a holiday since 2017..

i don’t agree with you on the controlling side of things, it’s not controlling to not want your partner to go and buy something with family money that they don’t need, they can’t afford and has no benefit whatsoever to the rest of the family, if this is genuinely the only pleasure he has in life then he’s a selfish waste of space.

But no matter, he can have his ‘pleasure in life’ while the kids freeze in the winter because they can’t afford to have the heating on...

there’s a happy medium compromise here and this certainly ain’t it.

Notinmynamethx · 21/07/2023 23:38

He wants to drive a 10 minute round trip in a city in a 4 x 4 whilst throwing 400 a month down the toilet? Absolutely insane on so many levels. I'd get a twizy if that's all I ever drove!

Milkand2sugarsplease · 21/07/2023 23:30

I guess it depends on your financial set up.

If you have shared finances then it's not really just his decision.

If you have split finances and therefore "personal spends" each month, then it depends on if he has £400 to spend on himself as well as everything else he needs (including saving for the balloon payment).

DH would never consider buying a car without it being a joint and considered decision.

Britroy · 21/07/2023 23:24

I don’t know if anyone has already highlighted this as there are so many responses but the monthly repayment is not £400. It is in fact £691 ish because to make the £14k payment at the end that’s how much needs to be saved alongside the repayments each month for the final payment. Once this is factored in with the depreciation over a 4 year period it’s easier to see the validity of the investment. You could look at the same car currently at 4 years old second hand to get an idea of how much it could be worth in 4 years time v your costs to see how worthwhile it might be. There are obv a lot of tech factors to consider but this is a more objective analysis. YANU for wanting to explore this further.

Magnoliafarm · 21/07/2023 23:13

The only person I know who ever spent money like that on a car was my old cleaner... I move in a middle class professional sphere and the most anyone else I know has ever spent on a car was 12k!

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/07/2023 23:12

xogossipgirlxo · Today 21:56

It's bonkers thinking 2014 is old car “

Unfortunately, not so much environmentally.

Dontworkmondays · 21/07/2023 23:12

That is absurd to spend that much when you have so little savings… and a child. Your car should cost no more than 1 or 2 months salary. This is an ego decision that will keep you feeling poor for years.

Magnoliafarm · 21/07/2023 23:10

But then I did go to test drive a car recently and overheard the salesman having a pep talk from his boss on how to lock in the sale... As I was walking out the door :') bless him. Got the same car with the same mileage for a quarter of the price from a smaller dealership a few weeks later

Magnoliafarm · 21/07/2023 23:06

I don't understand all these pp saying his money let him do what he wants with it. They have a kid and a mortgage together... If they haven't been on holiday for years, have an £800 a month mortgage and only have 5k in savings right now then the amount he would spend on the car is life changing. There are never ending costs with having a child that change as the kid grows older-nursery, shoes for ever growing feet, the next stage of car seat, the next size of bed, a birthday party somewhere that can accommodate the whole class... When you have a kid you can't just split bills you have to think about who is doing all the child spending. Also when is your mortgage up for renewal? Or is it variable? We just had to renew our mortgage and it's gone up by £400 per month (was £950 before) and a day after we locked in that deal we looked again and would have been even more if we hadn't locked in that deal! If the mortgage is up in the next 4 years then it's ludicrous!

bigalt · 21/07/2023 23:04

Shade17 · 21/07/2023 22:19

Who the hell spends that much on a car? Footballers and teenage boys. Not grown men.

Are you joking? £41k would barely get you a new base 3-series. Most people I know spend more than that on cars whether they’re new or second hand. Even a decent Volvo is £50-60k or more these days. Most things that are genuinely desirable are £100k+!

Unfortunately this is true and a sign of the times.

Speaking to friends in car sales, if you include the average deposit people put down into the monthlies over 4 years, most are paying around £450 a month. That will get you a mid level 3 year old VW Golf.

I mean he works 5 minutes away, bloody walk you lazy sod then invest in a decent Rolex that will appreciate if you need to blow off some financial steam

Shade17 · 21/07/2023 22:19

Who the hell spends that much on a car? Footballers and teenage boys. Not grown men.

Are you joking? £41k would barely get you a new base 3-series. Most people I know spend more than that on cars whether they’re new or second hand. Even a decent Volvo is £50-60k or more these days. Most things that are genuinely desirable are £100k+!

Bonfire23 · 21/07/2023 22:12

Just looked at what similar cars to mine are selling for and it's between 5-8k
Definitely not changing it!

Catusrusty · 21/07/2023 22:03

xogossipgirlxo · 21/07/2023 21:56

It's bonkers thinking 2014 is old car 🤐

Mine is 2014 and on the odd occasion I wash it, it still looks new. I have it fully professionally valeted once a year to keep the inside fresh.

I won't get a new one until I absolutely need to, the embedded energy in making a car is enormous.

Catusrusty · 21/07/2023 22:00

user1471267414 · 21/07/2023 21:20

You are missing the point. If you genuinely think it’s acceptable to ask your partner to save a deposit and transfer it to you then do a budget to show they can afford a something there is really something wrong. This is not ok. It’s dreadful, belittling and controlling behaviour. I am actually shocked that people think just because they are married they can be like this. We are all our own people! If someone works hard and wants a new car and can afford it then leave them to it! Perhaps that will be his pleasure in life!!! No wonder so many people are miserable in the world if they have someone like that controlling them. Awful.

Not when your partner is financially incontinent it isn't awful.

Not when finances are joint and this will affect your life and your kids life it isn't awful.

With the repayment, the monthly saving required for the bubble payment and the increased maintenance costs, the monthly financial input into this vanity project is enormous.

That in itself might be okay if it didn't impact on the rest of the family, but it clearly does.

It's far more controlling and awful for the husband to just decide to spend a huge chunk of family finance without consultation

Oh and I'm sure the OP works hard too.