Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why use gender when you mean Sex ?

215 replies

Parsley1234 · 20/07/2023 21:25

Why do people ask the gender of their baby or have gender reveal parties ? The correct question is what sex is my baby or maybe I’m just getting totally fed up of woke nonsense.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Lamelie · 21/07/2023 08:07

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 20/07/2023 23:37

@EmpressaurusOfCats sorry but if a trans woman had a beard I’m certain a female patient would decline care (as would I) and I suspect the chances of that ever happening are zilch.
Otoh a trans female without a beard, more tricky.

This comes under the “it’s never happened” argument about trans rights and it happens time and time again. Documented. I’ll post links in a minute, phone about to run out of charge.

whereaw · 21/07/2023 06:29

@swayingstreetlamp that is true. Although, from experience, most people use the pink and blue to give some identity and meaning to very young babies because there isn't anything else to go by. I have found this tends to only be a 'thing' with very young babies, who go on to develop their own likes and dislikes and personalities, and most parents are led by that.
I do think that sex difference is more than genitalia, although I agree with you that the whole excessive gender stereotyping is damaging. Girls and boys should like what they like and wear or do what they want.
But I do think it serves as pretty clear evidence for where most people see the binary of m/f as fundamental. 20,30,40 genders is nonsense.

DiscoBeat · 21/07/2023 01:12

Because inviting people to a sex party would cause some confusion.

Perfect answer there!

maddening · 21/07/2023 01:00

Gender has been used interchangeably with sex for longer than the woke shite has been around - by taking issue with people using words you are buying into the nonsense. You let them steal your words at your peril.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 00:48

whereaw · 20/07/2023 22:08

To be honest, I actually think it's a good thing - there are two sexes, male and female. The average person knows that and also ascribes gender to mean the same thing- ie there are two, male or female, masculine or feminine. It's just proof that people ultimately aren't blind or stupid and can see the distinction between male or female, no matter what pronouns a person is displaying or what they are wearing or how they try to present themselves. The 'new' meaning of gender is just total nonsense and would be better termed as personality, not an identity.

Totally agree 👍🏻

CallieQ · 21/07/2023 00:39

WhatADrabCarpet · 20/07/2023 21:33

Because they're thick?

Charming

CallieQ · 21/07/2023 00:39

What's wrong with saying gender???

Twyford · 21/07/2023 00:24

What on earth has it got to do with being woke? Surely if anything it's the opposite, and you're the one being woke, OP.

MagnificentMagnolia · 20/07/2023 23:56

SummaLuvin · 20/07/2023 21:32

the same reason loads of people people say dice when they mean die - when words are used incorrectly often enough their exact correct meaning isn't always passed on, so more people then use the words in the same incorrect way.

This is the answer

JFDIYOLO · 20/07/2023 23:55

Victorians were fine with 'sex'. Shakespeare was.
The Suffragettes were.

But somehow someone decided that sex was an embarrassing word.

In many languages things have gender, which largely isn't a thing in English (apart from oddities like calling a ship she). So you get the situation in French where breast is masculine and beard is feminine. It's bonkers.

Then someone misappropriated the grammatical term gender as a euphemism for sex and for a while on we went.

Then things got complicated and sometimes it's still used as a euphemism for sex such as the gender pay gap, and sometimes for what trans people believe they should be.

It's a mess of people trying to 'be kind', be coy, go along with the flow.

I won't use the terms all gender / gender neutral / universal toilets - I calmly refer to mixed sex toilets.

I hope it will all be untangled soon.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 20/07/2023 23:54

To me gender and sex are the same thing. There's two, male (or man) or female (or woman) and you can't change what you're born with.

It's not that I don't understand the difference, I simply don't agree with it.

swayingstreetlamp · 20/07/2023 23:52

whereaw · 20/07/2023 22:08

To be honest, I actually think it's a good thing - there are two sexes, male and female. The average person knows that and also ascribes gender to mean the same thing- ie there are two, male or female, masculine or feminine. It's just proof that people ultimately aren't blind or stupid and can see the distinction between male or female, no matter what pronouns a person is displaying or what they are wearing or how they try to present themselves. The 'new' meaning of gender is just total nonsense and would be better termed as personality, not an identity.

I see where you're coming from but I don't actually think that's true, because at these parties people always celebrate the result with certain stereotypes, e.g. blue and trucks for boys, pink and princesses for girls. They're buying in to all the "gendered" layer above the sex. It's not just about genitals.

nonman · 20/07/2023 23:49

here’s what will never happen, this is Alex Drummond who was born male and is now a lesbian. Alex has not had surgery or hormones and has decided to keeps the naturally grown beard, penis and testicles.

You are a bigot if you object to someone like Alex giving you personal care if you ask for a female care giver.
https://www.buzzfeed.com/patrickstrudwick/this-transgender-woman-has-a-full-beard-and-she-couldnt-be-h

This Trans Woman Kept Her Beard And Couldn't Be Happier

"I'm widening the bandwidth of how to be a woman." Alex Drummond talks to BuzzFeed News about why she kept her beard after transitioning – and how others react.

https://www.buzzfeed.com/patrickstrudwick/this-transgender-woman-has-a-full-beard-and-she-couldnt-be-h

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 20/07/2023 23:40

@parsley meant to say a transwoman with a beard. Even male nurses have to ask consent and most would be very reluctant to give intimate care without a chaperone.

Moneynewpence · 20/07/2023 23:39

Parsley1234 · 20/07/2023 21:25

Why do people ask the gender of their baby or have gender reveal parties ? The correct question is what sex is my baby or maybe I’m just getting totally fed up of woke nonsense.

Because they are different, simples. But you just wanted a nice dogwhistle to bring all the 'phobes to the yard.
Boring and immature.

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 20/07/2023 23:37

@EmpressaurusOfCats sorry but if a trans woman had a beard I’m certain a female patient would decline care (as would I) and I suspect the chances of that ever happening are zilch.
Otoh a trans female without a beard, more tricky.

Cantthinkof1rightnow · 20/07/2023 23:03

Yanbu, and I couldn't agree more. It infuriates me when I see 'gender; m/f' on a form when they mean 'sex: m/f', especially when that form is from a medical or educational setting.

I always cross it out and write 'Sex' with an explanation alongside it as to why I've done so and how damaging it is to conflate the 2.

AnoyDad2023 · 20/07/2023 22:49

Trans women aren't women.

Lamelie · 20/07/2023 22:43

nonman · 20/07/2023 22:28

Sex and gender are different and the conflation of the two is making it possible for men to break social boundaries and harm women’s rights

Beautifully and succinctly put.

Lamelie · 20/07/2023 22:42

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 20/07/2023 22:28

@Lamelie a man with a beard wouldn’t give intimate care to a female patient as a rule unless the woman consented to it.

That’s exactly what self ID means and recent NHS advice “encourages NHS providers to unlawfully discriminate against female patients”.
Here
It’s a turgid and depressing read.

https://www.nhsconfed.org/system/files/2023-06/Leading-for-all-supporting-trans-non-binary-healthcare-staff_2023.pdf

Seasidemumma77 · 20/07/2023 22:37

BeardieWeirdie · 20/07/2023 21:41

I’d rather go to a sex party than a naff gender reveal party. 🤮 Nobody gives a fuck about your baby’s genitals, they just ask out of politeness to fill the void in the conversation.

🤣🤣🤣

EmpressaurusOfCats · 20/07/2023 22:35

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 20/07/2023 22:28

@Lamelie a man with a beard wouldn’t give intimate care to a female patient as a rule unless the woman consented to it.

Except if the beard owner identifies a woman, the female patient risks being accused of transphobia - and you’re also making the assumption that said patient is capable of consenting.

cocksstrideintheevening · 20/07/2023 22:35

Because the vast majority apparently don't understand the difference.

Parsley1234 · 20/07/2023 22:34

@Charlotteowensdodgydad wgst if the man with a beard identifies as a woman they could give intimate care then and as for where I’m coming from what are you alluding to ?

OP posts: