Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why use gender when you mean Sex ?

215 replies

Parsley1234 · 20/07/2023 21:25

Why do people ask the gender of their baby or have gender reveal parties ? The correct question is what sex is my baby or maybe I’m just getting totally fed up of woke nonsense.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Weal · 21/07/2023 08:53

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 08:26

It makes me so angry to see people proudly pronounce that they don't care. Imagine saying that about any other human rifhts movement? You should csre about women's rights and what kind of psychopath days they don't care that women are being aasa8anf abused? OP you're right with this one. Either gender is sex in which case GRA needs repealing or it isn't in which case it's a sex reveal party. Some people who proclaim it to be gender reveal also use gender as an identity thing. That confusion in language is a tool used by men's rights activists so yes it matters.

I actually don’t think people holding “gender reveal” parties for babies are the same people who view gender as an identity. People who speak about woman/man as a gender identity or about people feeling a gender identity for themselves are usually adamantly opposed to focus on biological body parts.

I think the people using gender in phrases like gender reveal are using it as a synonym for sex.

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 08:53

x2boys · 21/07/2023 08:45

Be angry then who.are you to tell.peoplewhat they should care about🙄
There are lots of things I care about that probably doesn't cross your mind but it doesn't make me angry .

I don't care if you're angry. I care if you promote anti human rights movements. There are people here proudly saying like that they don't care about women being abused. It's disgusting.

BCCoach · 21/07/2023 08:48

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 08:45

OP it is confusing because the language aims to confuse. Much as it shouldn't be, a biological man who is trans identifying is a transwoman. A transman is a biological woman who's trans. Think of the trans prefix as 'pretend' or 'wish I was a..'. So a transwoman is a pretend woman or a man who wishes he were a woman.

Presumably OP can get their head round ‘woman’ (wo-man) so I would hope that transman shouldn’t be too challenging a word. ‘Seahorse’ will probably blow their mind though.

x2boys · 21/07/2023 08:45

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 08:26

It makes me so angry to see people proudly pronounce that they don't care. Imagine saying that about any other human rifhts movement? You should csre about women's rights and what kind of psychopath days they don't care that women are being aasa8anf abused? OP you're right with this one. Either gender is sex in which case GRA needs repealing or it isn't in which case it's a sex reveal party. Some people who proclaim it to be gender reveal also use gender as an identity thing. That confusion in language is a tool used by men's rights activists so yes it matters.

Be angry then who.are you to tell.peoplewhat they should care about🙄
There are lots of things I care about that probably doesn't cross your mind but it doesn't make me angry .

BCCoach · 21/07/2023 08:45

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 08:40

@Flickersy can you not see the conflation is part of this ?
I am GC a trans man biologically is not a woman and a woman cannot have a dick or are you saying they can ? Just because a trans man say they are
I can self I’d as a 6ft black supermodel I am still 5ft 7 white not exactly a supermodel or I can self I’d as a donkey I still don’t have large ears or a tail
I cannot self I’d as anything because it’s not true that’s what I don’t understand why are we being gaslit into believing lies

Either you’ve hugely misunderstood usage or you are being deliberately obtuse. A transman is a female who thinks they are male. A transwoman is a male who thinks they are female.

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 08:45

OP it is confusing because the language aims to confuse. Much as it shouldn't be, a biological man who is trans identifying is a transwoman. A transman is a biological woman who's trans. Think of the trans prefix as 'pretend' or 'wish I was a..'. So a transwoman is a pretend woman or a man who wishes he were a woman.

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 08:42

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 08:40

@Flickersy can you not see the conflation is part of this ?
I am GC a trans man biologically is not a woman and a woman cannot have a dick or are you saying they can ? Just because a trans man say they are
I can self I’d as a 6ft black supermodel I am still 5ft 7 white not exactly a supermodel or I can self I’d as a donkey I still don’t have large ears or a tail
I cannot self I’d as anything because it’s not true that’s what I don’t understand why are we being gaslit into believing lies

For someone who is so het up about the correct use of the English language you're certainly mangling it quite wonderfully.

A trans man is a female. A woman. They identify as a man and present as such.

A trans woman is a male. A man. They identify as a woman and present as such.

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 08:40

@Flickersy can you not see the conflation is part of this ?
I am GC a trans man biologically is not a woman and a woman cannot have a dick or are you saying they can ? Just because a trans man say they are
I can self I’d as a 6ft black supermodel I am still 5ft 7 white not exactly a supermodel or I can self I’d as a donkey I still don’t have large ears or a tail
I cannot self I’d as anything because it’s not true that’s what I don’t understand why are we being gaslit into believing lies

OP posts:
Flickersy · 21/07/2023 08:32

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 08:23

@Moneynewpence or just incredulous about how we are having conversations - can a woman have a dick ? can a man be a woman just because he says he is ? Can a man compete fairly against women with a dick ? It’s just beyond belief my gay friends are just as bemused as me it seems a tiny % of sexual predators have started this insidious trend and if we all don’t agree we are cancelled. It seems the Be Kind movement made people not able to be honest when they see the truth aka a trans man cannot be a woman most of the time they have male genitalia and this gender reveal shows a lack of understanding of what really is going on

I think you have a lack of understanding yourself.

A trans man is a woman. Trans men are females who want to live and present as men.

Transwomen are males who want to live and present as women.

But you have nicely revealed your true agenda, which is to get people wound up about trans people and not in fact to discuss the conflation of sex and gender.

BCCoach · 21/07/2023 08:30

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 08:25

@marshmallowfinder you put it less clunky than I did a baby can only have a sex not a gender thank you

By any dictionary definition of gender prior to about 2010 babies definitely have a gender as it is just a synonym for biological sex (and has been from the 17th century right up until very recently). This is how most people still use the word and it is still a perfectly valid usage.

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 08:26

It makes me so angry to see people proudly pronounce that they don't care. Imagine saying that about any other human rifhts movement? You should csre about women's rights and what kind of psychopath days they don't care that women are being aasa8anf abused? OP you're right with this one. Either gender is sex in which case GRA needs repealing or it isn't in which case it's a sex reveal party. Some people who proclaim it to be gender reveal also use gender as an identity thing. That confusion in language is a tool used by men's rights activists so yes it matters.

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 08:25

@marshmallowfinder you put it less clunky than I did a baby can only have a sex not a gender thank you

OP posts:
NotTerfNorCis · 21/07/2023 08:24

I don't like it because it enables the harmful idea of gender identity, and elevates regressive cultural stereotypes. But then again, 'sex' does have a double meaning and 'gender' always used to be the polite word for it.

BCCoach · 21/07/2023 08:23

Because until very recently gender was simply a polite synonym for sex and this is how most people still use the word.

The distinction between biological sex (immutable) and sociological gender (whatever I fancy today) is very recent and most people are either unaware or think it’s a load of bollocks and carry on using the word in the same way that they and previous generations) have always done.

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 08:23

@Moneynewpence or just incredulous about how we are having conversations - can a woman have a dick ? can a man be a woman just because he says he is ? Can a man compete fairly against women with a dick ? It’s just beyond belief my gay friends are just as bemused as me it seems a tiny % of sexual predators have started this insidious trend and if we all don’t agree we are cancelled. It seems the Be Kind movement made people not able to be honest when they see the truth aka a trans man cannot be a woman most of the time they have male genitalia and this gender reveal shows a lack of understanding of what really is going on

OP posts:
marshmallowfinder · 21/07/2023 08:23

CallieQ · 21/07/2023 00:39

What's wrong with saying gender???

In the right context, it's fine, to discuss how people view themselves. But sex is irrefutable. Your DNA dictates you're either male or female and that cannot be changed. So an unborn baby cannot possibly have a gender. Only a sex.

DinnaeFashYersel · 21/07/2023 08:21

Because most people aren't immersed in politics and it's just a word that they regard as interchangeable with sex.

Weal · 21/07/2023 08:20

I always use the word sex now when I mean sex. I also have started using female more than woman. I don’t think I should have to really, but I want to be clear about who I’m talking about.

I think with the “gender reveal” thing those people don’t even think about the words. They’re just revealing if their child is male or female and use sex/gender interchangeably.

I see a lot of forms that ask for gender when I think they mean sex.

PerspiringElizabeth · 21/07/2023 08:20

Because ‘sex reveal’ sounds alarming.

I am camp No Reveal though, it’s all tacky in my book.

RufustheFactualReindeer · 21/07/2023 08:19

I honestly do not remember the word gender being used for sex in many if any of my conversations back in the day

i thought it was an Americanism, thats not to say obviously that there were not people and places that used it here but that it wasn’t commonplace in my circles

i am also positive that i had a private sex scan for ds2

but the meaning of gender seams to be changing to ‘identity’ in which case gender reveal parties don’t work anymore

i really don’t understand how gender can now mean ‘either male or female’ AND ‘how ever you identify out of a 100 types’

Lamelie · 21/07/2023 08:18

@Charlotteowensdodgydad @EmpressaurusOfCats
here you go, stubble and patient told the nurse was a man and didn’t receive smear test.

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 08:17

bellac11 · 20/07/2023 21:55

Has anyone seen the new neurophen advert, its addressing the 'gender pain gap' which is about WOMEN who arent really taken seriously about their pain (which is common)

But of course it is only biological females that get this sort of response from health providers, a man pretending to be a woman would no doubt be taken very seriously in terms of his health needs, compared to women

Therefore there is a SEX pain gap, people are discriminated in health care based on their SEX

But 'sex pain gap' can be interpreted very differently.

Women do actually experience more pain during sex than men. But I expect this isn't what you're thinking of.

In this case I think 'gender pain gap' is actually clearer.

RufustheFactualReindeer · 21/07/2023 08:14

Moneynewpence · 20/07/2023 23:39

Because they are different, simples. But you just wanted a nice dogwhistle to bring all the 'phobes to the yard.
Boring and immature.

You turned up…

Swipe left for the next trending thread