Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why use gender when you mean Sex ?

215 replies

Parsley1234 · 20/07/2023 21:25

Why do people ask the gender of their baby or have gender reveal parties ? The correct question is what sex is my baby or maybe I’m just getting totally fed up of woke nonsense.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
porridgecake · 21/07/2023 11:49

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 11:47

@porridgecake a man can never be a woman. Ever

I agree.
Humans cannot change sex.
I am trying to establish whether you understand what transman and transwoman mean.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 11:47

@porridgecake a man can never be a woman. Ever

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 11:44

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 11:35

@porridgecake "
A transman IS a biological woman.
A transwoman IS a biological man."

🤣🤣👍🏻 yes, ok then

Seriously, did you realise you had got it the wrong way round? Really, this is very important.
A transman is a biological woman who identifies as a man. This person may just dress in stereotypical male clothing, or take cross sex hormones, have a double mastectomy and, even worse, proceed to having all the flesh taken off one lower arm to create a facsimile of a penis.
The Cass review explains a lot more about this.

A transwoman is a biological male who identifies as a woman. They may take cross sex hormones, have breast implants, dress in stereotypical female clothing, wig, make up. Around 90% of these individuals have no hormone or surgical treatment whatsoever. Look up autogynephilia.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 11:35

@porridgecake "
A transman IS a biological woman.
A transwoman IS a biological man."

🤣🤣👍🏻 yes, ok then

bladebladebla1 · 21/07/2023 11:32

Who gives a fuck really

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 11:07

Anycrispsleft · 21/07/2023 10:56

I think it's two sides of the same coin - both sets of people think it's normal for people to stay within a very stereotypical, narrow window of behaviour depending on their sex. The trans people look as if they're rebelling against that binary but they're actually only saying that they personally are too special for it, not that it's wrong about everyone.

Yes. The trans movement only means anything if the assumption which trans ideologists make - that it's normal for people to feel very closely aligned with gender stereotpyes - is right. When you accept that most people are busy breaking down gender norms and do not actively support them, then you realise that to state that you are trans is a somewhat meaningless and actually pretty offensive statement. Meaningless because it's like 'yeah so what?' and offensive because it's actually saying that you think I have internalised gender stereotypes in an uncritical way and believe that they apply to me. Actually, that's something for me to say about myself if I believe it to be true, it's absolutely not respectful for you to assume that's how I feel and them jump up and down like a toddler who's told they can't have an ice-cream when I point out the error in your logic.

Anycrispsleft · 21/07/2023 10:56

LulooLemon · 20/07/2023 22:06

@EmpressaurusOfCats Absolutely!

Its astonishing that both pregnancy gender reveal parties and the 'choose-your-own-gender' transgender movement have boomed in popularity at the same time.

The first is basically saying that your gender is fixed - and it's pink fluffy air headed stuff for girls, blue manly stuff for boys.

The second is saying choose whichever gender you want.

Both are huge backward steps for women.

I think it's two sides of the same coin - both sets of people think it's normal for people to stay within a very stereotypical, narrow window of behaviour depending on their sex. The trans people look as if they're rebelling against that binary but they're actually only saying that they personally are too special for it, not that it's wrong about everyone.

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 10:56

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:54

It's not conflating and it's definitely not lazy. The language used to justify racism is the same language being used to justify women's oppression. The point is the opposite to what you're making.

@literalviolence - what I'm complaining of as 'conflated and lazy' is the uncritical, unthinking lumping of gender critical politics alongside Nazism as the more extreme example. This is the rhetoric coming from the TRA movement. It is lazy, because it absolves them of any requirement to thinking critically.

Feminists are weary of batting off this particular (offensive and inaccurate) accusation. Most GC feminists couldn't be less 'aligned' with the US alt right. They are misogynistic, they are racist, they are homophobic. To align self-professed feminists with a movement seeking rob women of their own bodily autonomy seems muddled thinking even for TRAs. It just goes to show how the lines between left and right have become obfuscated, and the colonization of the left by those who occupy the old far right ground is indeed an irony and does, I have to agree, follow the patterns of racism.

Colour blind policies supported a racist agenda. Language blind discussions support an anti woman agenda.

Accepted. I do recognise the real problems associated with supposed colour- blindness, and why this is tantamount to erasure. Calling us 'non-women' or reducing us to our anatomy is a similar strategy.

These are all, in addition, useful lines of defence against those who would lazily tarnish GC feminists with charges of racism. It's yet another instance of DARVO. It also must be incredibly frustrating for POC who have to contend with both.

Your latter two paragraphs below don't appear to be responding to me. I've clearly stated above that sex and gender are far from synonymous, and that this isn't a new thing.

"Sex and gender have been synonymous for centuries. It is only the way the use of gender has changed in the last decade or two that has caused this.

Your issue should be with the people who have changed the meaning of the word, not those who use it as it always has been used." Yes it is. But it is also with those people who are 'like who cares anyway' about it all. If those people want to say 'I care enough to want language to stay with the meaning it always used to have' then all good but that's caring isn't it?

Sounds like we agree then. The second bit was a quote from someone else. Apols for not putting their user name in. I had meant to do that.

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 10:54

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 10:35

So forced teaming is OK when it bolsters your argument, not when it contradicts it.

Understood.

It is remarkable how vociferous FWR and posters can be in condemnation of teaming the trans issue with racism etc, but how accepting they can be of it in other situations.

Forced teaming is not OK. Logical teaming is.

I am not anti teaming the trans issue with racism. Clearly it's no more acceptable for a man to identify as a woman than it is for a white person to identify as a person of colour.

Who do you think is anti seeing this connection?

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:54

It's not conflating and it's definitely not lazy. The language used to justify racism is the same language being used to justify women's oppression. The point is the opposite to what you're making.

@literalviolence - what I'm complaining of as 'conflated and lazy' is the uncritical, unthinking lumping of gender critical politics alongside Nazism as the more extreme example. This is the rhetoric coming from the TRA movement. It is lazy, because it absolves them of any requirement to thinking critically.

Feminists are weary of batting off this particular (offensive and inaccurate) accusation. Most GC feminists couldn't be less 'aligned' with the US alt right. They are misogynistic, they are racist, they are homophobic. To align self-professed feminists with a movement seeking rob women of their own bodily autonomy seems muddled thinking even for TRAs. It just goes to show how the lines between left and right have become obfuscated, and the colonization of the left by those who occupy the old far right ground is indeed an irony and does, I have to agree, follow the patterns of racism.

Colour blind policies supported a racist agenda. Language blind discussions support an anti woman agenda.

Accepted. I do recognise the real problems associated with supposed colour- blindness, and why this is tantamount to erasure. Calling us 'non-women' or reducing us to our anatomy is a similar strategy.

These are all, in addition, useful lines of defence against those who would lazily tarnish GC feminists with charges of racism. It's yet another instance of DARVO. It also must be incredibly frustrating for POC who have to contend with both.

Your latter two paragraphs below don't appear to be responding to me. I've clearly stated above that sex and gender are far from synonymous, and that this isn't a new thing.

"Sex and gender have been synonymous for centuries. It is only the way the use of gender has changed in the last decade or two that has caused this.

Your issue should be with the people who have changed the meaning of the word, not those who use it as it always has been used." Yes it is. But it is also with those people who are 'like who cares anyway' about it all. If those people want to say 'I care enough to want language to stay with the meaning it always used to have' then all good but that's caring isn't it?

DreamItDoIt · 21/07/2023 10:50

Historically 'gender' has been used instead of 'sex' because 'sex' has another meaning.

Society, for a long time, respected it as interchangeable and knew what was meant. In the same way that people respected that women use them womens and men the mens. Things that were accepted and agreed by society without it needing to be explained in detail, a sort of quiet understanding and respect.

There is a group who have tried and, in many cases succeeded, to disrupt these socially acceptable norms and constantly seek to take advantage of this 'understanding', they change, stamp their feet and/or question meanings to get their way. They are trying to erode the very things that act as safeguards in society.

This is what happens when you have weak leadership and people in power who can't seem to see the bigger picture and understand how to ensure laws are precise and not open to abuse.

I mean did anyone think that children were included in the rules around changing gender. Of course they didn't and this sloppiness and lack of definition of terms is being taken advantage of at every turn.

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 10:44

blahblahblah1654 · 21/07/2023 10:39

Serious question, is there a difference?

I think there must be in law because we have ridiculous laws which allow someone to 'change their gender' when of course, sex is immutable.

blahblahblah1654 · 21/07/2023 10:40

I've always used the word sex

blahblahblah1654 · 21/07/2023 10:39

Serious question, is there a difference?

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 10:39

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:36

I was responding to the lie that posters were "proudly" saying "I don't care about abused women".

I've not expressed myself clearly. I was responding to the point you raised: Posters have said that it's only on MN where people care about sex vs gender. I'm agreeing with your refutation of that point.

I didn't put that across too well. Sorry about the crossed wires.

Ah, my apologies. Clearly I have not had enough coffee this morning!

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:36

I was responding to the lie that posters were "proudly" saying "I don't care about abused women".

I've not expressed myself clearly. I was responding to the point you raised: Posters have said that it's only on MN where people care about sex vs gender. I'm agreeing with your refutation of that point.

I didn't put that across too well. Sorry about the crossed wires.

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 10:35

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 10:29

It's not conflating and it's definitely not lazy. The language used to justify racism is the same language being used to justify women's oppression. The point is the opposite to what you're making. Colour blind policies supported a racist agenda. Language blind discussions support an anti woman agenda.

"Sex and gender have been synonymous for centuries. It is only the way the use of gender has changed in the last decade or two that has caused this.

Your issue should be with the people who have changed the meaning of the word, not those who use it as it always has been used." Yes it is. But it is also with those people who are 'like who cares anyway' about it all. If those people want to say 'I care enough to want language to stay with the meaning it always used to have' then all good but that's caring isn't it?

So forced teaming is OK when it bolsters your argument, not when it contradicts it.

Understood.

It is remarkable how vociferous FWR and posters can be in condemnation of teaming the trans issue with racism etc, but how accepting they can be of it in other situations.

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 10:33

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:08

In which case, 'People' would be entirely wrong.

There are extensive networks both on and offline responding to the insidious land-grab of women's rights. Fair Play for Women, the Women's Rights Network, Standing For Women, Sex Matters, For Women Scotland, and Fair Cop, to name just the ones that come immediately to mind.

The story as to how Fair Cop came about is interesting in itself. Its co-founder is a barrister who, back in 2020, was at the receiving end of an anonymous tweet boasting that she now had a “record for life” as the result of allegedly hateful tweets. The tweets were along the lines of denying that transwomen are biological women and referring to male sex offenders housed in the female prison estate as “men”. She contacted the police who confirmed that 12 pages of tweets had been recorded as transphobic and religiously aggravated “non-crime hate incidents”.

She was on a police shit list without ever having committed a criminal offence. Conviction without trial, in a supposed democracy is beyond sinister. She fought it, crowd funded it, and Fair Cop came about. This is psychological abuse. This is criminalizing any opposition to gender ideology. It's throwing women's rights directly under the bus, which other women for some unaccountable reason seem happy to be complicit in doing.

Sex matters. A deliberate obfuscation of the boundary between sex and gender is what has allowed these situations to arise. Because 'it doesn't harm us'. Because 'Be Kind'.

All of the above does harm. It's no accident that the current social contagion of gender ideology amongst young people happened directly after an explosion of pinkification, pastels and glitter in the girls' aisles of Toys R Us et al from around the mid 1990s onward. The rigid gendering of expectations for boys and girls - far more extreme since these ideas started to take root - began as merely someone's marketing strategy. These expectations now begin in the womb.

It's only a personal theory, of course, but I don't believe the correlation between pinkification and the immediately subsequent spread of GI is a coincidence.

Yes, I know this. I am a member / subscribed to two of the organisations you mention above, if you want to know.

I was responding to the lie that posters were "proudly" saying "I don't care about abused women".

Greetingsfellows · 21/07/2023 10:29

Because not all people are offensive.

literalviolence · 21/07/2023 10:29

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:10

NB. It's really not helpful to conflate this issue with race. The issues may overlap but are separate, and there's already a lazy effort to lump in gender critical feminists with the US alt right and now, increasingly, Nazism.

It's lazy and inaccurate ideological compartmentalizing, and it helps no one.

It's not conflating and it's definitely not lazy. The language used to justify racism is the same language being used to justify women's oppression. The point is the opposite to what you're making. Colour blind policies supported a racist agenda. Language blind discussions support an anti woman agenda.

"Sex and gender have been synonymous for centuries. It is only the way the use of gender has changed in the last decade or two that has caused this.

Your issue should be with the people who have changed the meaning of the word, not those who use it as it always has been used." Yes it is. But it is also with those people who are 'like who cares anyway' about it all. If those people want to say 'I care enough to want language to stay with the meaning it always used to have' then all good but that's caring isn't it?

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:10

NB. It's really not helpful to conflate this issue with race. The issues may overlap but are separate, and there's already a lazy effort to lump in gender critical feminists with the US alt right and now, increasingly, Nazism.

It's lazy and inaccurate ideological compartmentalizing, and it helps no one.

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 10:09

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 10:02

For me a trans man will never be a woman no matter how much I'm told that. They are a man living and dressing as a woman and that's as far as it will go in my eyes.
Surely everyone's view needs to be respected. It's not a fact.

A transman IS a biological woman.
A transwoman IS a biological man.

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 10:08

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 09:20

So in fact no-one has said "I don't care about women being abused".

Posters have said that it's only on MN where people care about sex vs gender.

Not quite the same thing, is it now.

It's rather ridiculous to say that people have proudly said on here that they don't care about women being abused. You'll hurt your back reaching like that.

In which case, 'People' would be entirely wrong.

There are extensive networks both on and offline responding to the insidious land-grab of women's rights. Fair Play for Women, the Women's Rights Network, Standing For Women, Sex Matters, For Women Scotland, and Fair Cop, to name just the ones that come immediately to mind.

The story as to how Fair Cop came about is interesting in itself. Its co-founder is a barrister who, back in 2020, was at the receiving end of an anonymous tweet boasting that she now had a “record for life” as the result of allegedly hateful tweets. The tweets were along the lines of denying that transwomen are biological women and referring to male sex offenders housed in the female prison estate as “men”. She contacted the police who confirmed that 12 pages of tweets had been recorded as transphobic and religiously aggravated “non-crime hate incidents”.

She was on a police shit list without ever having committed a criminal offence. Conviction without trial, in a supposed democracy is beyond sinister. She fought it, crowd funded it, and Fair Cop came about. This is psychological abuse. This is criminalizing any opposition to gender ideology. It's throwing women's rights directly under the bus, which other women for some unaccountable reason seem happy to be complicit in doing.

Sex matters. A deliberate obfuscation of the boundary between sex and gender is what has allowed these situations to arise. Because 'it doesn't harm us'. Because 'Be Kind'.

All of the above does harm. It's no accident that the current social contagion of gender ideology amongst young people happened directly after an explosion of pinkification, pastels and glitter in the girls' aisles of Toys R Us et al from around the mid 1990s onward. The rigid gendering of expectations for boys and girls - far more extreme since these ideas started to take root - began as merely someone's marketing strategy. These expectations now begin in the womb.

It's only a personal theory, of course, but I don't believe the correlation between pinkification and the immediately subsequent spread of GI is a coincidence.

MrsFinkelstein · 21/07/2023 10:06

BeardieWeirdie · 20/07/2023 21:41

I’d rather go to a sex party than a naff gender reveal party. 🤮 Nobody gives a fuck about your baby’s genitals, they just ask out of politeness to fill the void in the conversation.

Same. Thank God they weren't really a thing 22 years ago when I had my twins & when my friends were pregnant.

amylou8 · 21/07/2023 10:04

Because until recently your sex was the same as your gender and it wasn't really necessary on a day to day level to differentiate. If you had a willy you went in the men's toilets, if you flashed that willy in swimming pool changing room in front of young girls you got arrested, and if you used it to rape someone you went to a mens prison. But now all the be kind brigade who think there are 945.3 genders are getting they/themselves all confused it really has become necessary to start doing things by sex rather than gender.

Swipe left for the next trending thread