Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why use gender when you mean Sex ?

215 replies

Parsley1234 · 20/07/2023 21:25

Why do people ask the gender of their baby or have gender reveal parties ? The correct question is what sex is my baby or maybe I’m just getting totally fed up of woke nonsense.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:46

I'm aware what the OED says. Excuse the arrogance of this response - but they're wrong.

As for Cambridge, if they're still using the term 'Intersex' it shows how far with the programme they've got. It's a outdated, inaccurate, even offensive term - alongside cretin and moron which surely no one still uses - and people with DSDs have repeatedly asked not to be referred to as such - or to have their medical condition misappropriated for the purposes of identity politics.

Those with DSDs are still either male or female. One sex produces large, the other small, gametes. There has not been one recorded human being, for the whole history of our species, with the ability to produce both.

BubziOwl · 21/07/2023 13:45

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:32

Sex and gender are not interchangeable. They are not synonymous. If they're being used in that way, they're being used incorrectly.

One is a material body. The other is a social construct, the actual substance of which is difficult to determine as it changes according to historical time and geographical place. As far back as the 60s, the likes of Millett and de Beauvoir were chewing the fat about the very real distinctions between 'female' and 'feminine'.

A sexed body is the physical reality of our (dimorphic) species. Gender is the basis on which one of these sex classes asserts its dominance and the other is oppressed. 'Woman' and 'man' are not a feeling in someone's head. It would be impossible for me to 'feel like a man', because I'm not a man. That knowledge is therefore beyond the remit of my understanding or experience.

Sex and gender are antonyms.

But you're talking about academia. Words often have definitions for academic purposes that don't quite correlation to popular usage. And some academic circles and disciplines use different definitions to other circles and disciplines.

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 13:40

Also from the Cambridge dictionary, one of the definitions of gender is:

"used to refer to the condition of being physically male, female, or intersex (= having a body that has both male and female characteristics):
Does this test show the gender of the baby?
Forensic scientists can tell the gender of the victim from the skeleton.
Synonym
sex (MALE/FEMALE)"

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/gender

gender

1. a group of people in a society who share particular qualities or ways of…

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/gender

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 13:38

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:32

Sex and gender are not interchangeable. They are not synonymous. If they're being used in that way, they're being used incorrectly.

One is a material body. The other is a social construct, the actual substance of which is difficult to determine as it changes according to historical time and geographical place. As far back as the 60s, the likes of Millett and de Beauvoir were chewing the fat about the very real distinctions between 'female' and 'feminine'.

A sexed body is the physical reality of our (dimorphic) species. Gender is the basis on which one of these sex classes asserts its dominance and the other is oppressed. 'Woman' and 'man' are not a feeling in someone's head. It would be impossible for me to 'feel like a man', because I'm not a man. That knowledge is therefore beyond the remit of my understanding or experience.

Sex and gender are antonyms.

Not according to the OED.

https://www.oed.com/dictionary/gender_n#:~:text=The%20state%20of%20being%20male,group%20characterized%20in%20this%20way.

One of the definitions of gender (along with the others about expression) reads as follows:

"3.a.1474–
gen. Males or females viewed as a group; = sex n.1 1. Also: the property or fact of belonging to one of these groups."

Gender can be used interchangeably with sex, and it is not incorrect. It has been used this way for centuries.

gender, n. meanings, etymology and more | Oxford English Dictionary

gender, n. meanings, etymology, pronunciation and more in the Oxford English Dictionary

https://www.oed.com/dictionary/gender_n#:~:text=The%20state%20of%20being%20male,group%20characterized%20in%20this%20way.

Maddy70 · 21/07/2023 13:37

phoenixrosehere · 21/07/2023 12:50

Good grief. Not everything is an American import. People have been using sex and gender interchangeable for decades.

I meant "gender reveal parties "

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:32

Sex and gender are not interchangeable. They are not synonymous. If they're being used in that way, they're being used incorrectly.

One is a material body. The other is a social construct, the actual substance of which is difficult to determine as it changes according to historical time and geographical place. As far back as the 60s, the likes of Millett and de Beauvoir were chewing the fat about the very real distinctions between 'female' and 'feminine'.

A sexed body is the physical reality of our (dimorphic) species. Gender is the basis on which one of these sex classes asserts its dominance and the other is oppressed. 'Woman' and 'man' are not a feeling in someone's head. It would be impossible for me to 'feel like a man', because I'm not a man. That knowledge is therefore beyond the remit of my understanding or experience.

Sex and gender are antonyms.

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:23

Verv · 21/07/2023 13:14

Yes he is.

Yeah, straight white blokes telling the rest of us what to do.

I'm shocked. Shocked, I tell ye ...

Verv · 21/07/2023 13:14

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 12:49

Born a man and is now a lesbian?? So he's a straight man 🤣

Yes he is.

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 13:11

@thebloodycatwontstopmeowing I am waiting to see

OP posts:
thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 13:01

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 12:52

@EmmaOvary how can he be a she with a dick testicles and a beard HOW !?!?!

I can't even believe it's up for questioning!

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 12:52

@EmmaOvary how can he be a she with a dick testicles and a beard HOW !?!?!

OP posts:
BCCoach · 21/07/2023 12:51

marshmallowfinder · 21/07/2023 08:23

In the right context, it's fine, to discuss how people view themselves. But sex is irrefutable. Your DNA dictates you're either male or female and that cannot be changed. So an unborn baby cannot possibly have a gender. Only a sex.

Of course a baby can have a gender. One of the meanings of gender is ‘biological sex’ and this is how the majority of people use it. Look in any dictionary. You are using a very recent meaning of gender and not the one most people mean when they use the word. Just like they don’t mean grammatical gender when they are using the word to describe a baby.

phoenixrosehere · 21/07/2023 12:50

Maddy70 · 21/07/2023 09:44

Because it's an American import and they use gender

Good grief. Not everything is an American import. People have been using sex and gender interchangeable for decades.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 12:49

Born a man and is now a lesbian?? So he's a straight man 🤣

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 12:48

Who really gives a shit anyway? I've only ever seen this discussed on mumsnet.

EmmaOvary · 21/07/2023 12:43

nonman · 20/07/2023 23:49

here’s what will never happen, this is Alex Drummond who was born male and is now a lesbian. Alex has not had surgery or hormones and has decided to keeps the naturally grown beard, penis and testicles.

You are a bigot if you object to someone like Alex giving you personal care if you ask for a female care giver.
https://www.buzzfeed.com/patrickstrudwick/this-transgender-woman-has-a-full-beard-and-she-couldnt-be-h

What if she shaved off her beard?

BCCoach · 21/07/2023 12:41

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 09:11

I wonder if the women who are naturally looking forward to their much loved baby realise that those children will be taught in school that humans can change sex, can be put on drugs to arrest puberty, make them sterile, be offered surgery to remove developing breasts, castration either chemical or physical, all in the name of Gender.
Language matters and the deliberate conflation of sex and gender in recent years is gaslighting. Parents need to understand this.
Women on Mumsnet are rightly very concerned about this. At least, after several years, the mainstream media is beginning to wake up.
It isn't just about men in women's sports, refuges, toilets, changing rooms. It is a massive safeguarding issue for children.
Read the Cass Review.
Irreversible Damage by Abigail Shrier
Time to Think by Hannah Barnes
Trans by Helen Joyce

There is no conflation between sex and gender. They are synonyms as any dictionary will tell you. There is a more recent meaning of gender (dating since the 2010s) which means “whatever I feel like today”. This is not the meaning that people are using when they talk about the gender of their babies. They are using the meaning that has been in common usage for 300 years: a synonym for biological sex. I honestly don’t understand why so many GC people accept this new meaning of the word. I’m GC and when I say gender (assuming I’m not talking about grammar) I use it as a synonym for sex, as English-speaking people have done since the 17th century.

Parsley1234 · 21/07/2023 12:40

It’s so depressing when we have to fight for our right to single sex spaces without igniting the Be Kind narrative and TERF being punched in the face all you apologists for TWAW need to really look at the bigger picture. Women’s rights are being eroded Roe vs Wade, men competing in women’s sports, mixed wards and a million other examples

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 12:31

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 11:52

@porridgecake not sure why you're so bothered what I understand. They are men dressing and living as women or vice versa.

People are bothered because women and trans women are two distinct groups. And there are some occasions when the needs, rights and dignity of these groups conflict.

Forced teaming on the part of TRAs insist this is not so, because trans women are women. Yet it's biologically and anatomically impossible to change sex. Any deviation from these 'rules' has been silenced with accusations of transphobia.

There are times when sex matters and should rightly override the recent prioritizing of gender. Prisons, fair competition in sports, spaces where women are vulnerable or in a state of undress, etc.: are all scenarios in which the needs of women override the 'wants' of self-gender determination. Women are being told they have to roll over and capitulate these wants to ensure others' comfort.

To hell with theirs - even in scenarios where trans women are distributing pictures of their arousal when standing in the queue for the Ladies'.

No, thank you.

NO.

StEtienne93 · 21/07/2023 12:12

It's ridiculous. I noticed on my employers HR system it asks you "what is your gender" and also "what gender do you identify as". To me that's the same question worded differently. I've selected "prefer not to say" for both questions because I personally don't recognise gender.

Verv · 21/07/2023 12:08

Gender used to be a polite manner of determining sex, and was used to avoid the sniggering and "yes please!" responses.
It refers to man/woman rather than male/female.

Sex needs to return as the primary identifier as gender has become a corrupt term.

Maddy70 · 21/07/2023 12:04

ilovesooty · 20/07/2023 21:55

In wider society I don't think people care as much as they appear to on here.

Can't get past the persistent use of "woke" anyway.

Yes. This!

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 12:00

@porridgecake no benefit for me thanks.

Glad we agree on the first part.

Not sure what relevance your point about activists has to this..?

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 11:56

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 11:52

@porridgecake not sure why you're so bothered what I understand. They are men dressing and living as women or vice versa.

I think it really does matter if you are using the wrong words though!
You said that a transman is a man dressing as a woman. That is completely wrong. A so called transman is a woman dressing as a man.
We are both in agreement here that humans cannot change sex, but you can't argue the point if you get the descriptors the wrong way round.
I am just trying to clarify for the benefit of others on this thread who may not know.
If you look at all the violent, masked transactivist males threatening and abusing women, they are holding signs saying "Transwomen are women".

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 11:52

@porridgecake not sure why you're so bothered what I understand. They are men dressing and living as women or vice versa.