Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why use gender when you mean Sex ?

215 replies

Parsley1234 · 20/07/2023 21:25

Why do people ask the gender of their baby or have gender reveal parties ? The correct question is what sex is my baby or maybe I’m just getting totally fed up of woke nonsense.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
FlirtsWithRhinos · 21/07/2023 17:47

DarenthInterchange · 21/07/2023 14:52

So on the one hand trans women are bad because they uphold narrow definitions of what it means to be a woman, but on the other hand trans women are bad because they challenge what it is that a woman has to look like?

Yes. In switching the definition of woman from "any kind of person, as long as she has a female body" to "any kind of body, as long as she has a woman's personality" they are going back to old fashioned and sexist ideas about how women's minds work. It is very definitely a narrower definition of womanhood than simple recognition of body sex.

It hurts women (original female people) twice. It hurts us by limiting expectations of women mentally from fully rounded humans to a prescribed set of "womanly" character traits, and it hurts us by removing the recognition of how our biological differences to men affect our lives and therefore prevents us getting the female-specific support we need, whether that is PPE that fits, or working patterns that allow for nursing infants, or women-only football.

noapologies · 21/07/2023 17:41

It's a gender reveal party because if you say you're having a sex party, people get the wrong idea...

FlirtsWithRhinos · 21/07/2023 17:37

winelove · 21/07/2023 14:08

who the fuck gets to decide the difference between sex or gender....... they are just words.

Words are used to write laws and policies.

You may believe sex and gender are the same thing, but if those who write and enforce laws and policies don't, you will find very quickly that rights and protections you thought you had based on your sex, like the right to say you want your smear test done by a person the same sex as you (female), are actually based on gender, and all you have is the right to say you want your smear test done by a person who believes they are the same gender as you, a person who could be either male or female as long as they declare they feel like a woman.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 16:53

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 16:40

The only thing getting attention about a transman giving birth is whether the cross sex hormones they have been taking prior to pregnancy are harmful to the fetus. Otherwise there is nothing unusual about a woman giving birth, regardless of how that woman identifies.
Also, if a woman feels so dysphoric about her sexed body that she has to take cross sex hormones and present as a man, surely being pregnant and giving birth would be extremely distressing.

She shouldn't have got pregnant then.

LakieLady · 21/07/2023 16:49

CuriousLadyBird · 20/07/2023 21:33

Because inviting people to a sex party would cause some confusion.

😂😂😂😂

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 16:40

The only thing getting attention about a transman giving birth is whether the cross sex hormones they have been taking prior to pregnancy are harmful to the fetus. Otherwise there is nothing unusual about a woman giving birth, regardless of how that woman identifies.
Also, if a woman feels so dysphoric about her sexed body that she has to take cross sex hormones and present as a man, surely being pregnant and giving birth would be extremely distressing.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 16:28

Should read "woman gives birth" what a shock!! Not sure how I didn't get all this attention when I gave birth three times 🤔

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 21/07/2023 16:23

Next up it'll be "man gives birth"

Oh wait that's already been done

IsGoodIsDon · 21/07/2023 15:23

I couldn’t ever see myself inviting guests to a sex reveal party.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 21/07/2023 15:21

Trans women are men and don’t belong in women’s single sex spaces. Other than that they can dress and present however they like

a man presenting as a woman (however women present - i mean I assume we’re not all sat here wearing identical clothes) can’t challenge how a woman looks because they’re not a woman. He can however challenge what a man looks like

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 15:17

Transwomen are men. They don't have the right to say what a woman should look like or to define what a woman is.

DarenthInterchange · 21/07/2023 14:52

So on the one hand trans women are bad because they uphold narrow definitions of what it means to be a woman, but on the other hand trans women are bad because they challenge what it is that a woman has to look like?

Katiesaidthat · 21/07/2023 14:34

Because for reasons better know to themselves some people think sex and gender are interchangeable. And also some muppets can´t pronounce the word S E X without getting the vapours...

Verv · 21/07/2023 14:29

Swansandcustard · 21/07/2023 13:54

God, here we go again, same boring bollocks. Not something I give any thought to, does it actually matter ffs.

It matters when males use their "gender identity" to invade and occupy female sex protected spaces.

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 14:11

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 13:55

Exactly.
The extent of institutional capture never ceases to amaze me.
In school, children are being taught that there are many, many genders.
They are being taught that if you are female and like boys toys it is possible to change sex to conform to your gender (which must be male). If you are male and like pink/dolls, you can change sex to align with your gender (which must be female).
Every parent should be concerned about this.
That poor little girl in Scotland who was kidnapped and raped got into a car with a man in a dress and wig because men in dresses and wigs are women, according to current gender ideology.
It is insidious and relies on people not being interested.

Yes. Not missing here, that academia - Oxbridge in particular - is amongst the most captured institutions out there. Yes, that would be our supposedly intelligent, once world-class higher education system.

It was Cambridge NUS, if I remember correctly, who first hoofed out Germaine Greer. University of Sussex - not RG but a highly-regarded institution - whose lecturers, alongside students, hounded Kathleen stock out her post, supported by a nefarious union.

We've seen what happens to established academics - all most all of them female it's interesting to note - who have attempted to argue against this insidious land-grab.

winelove · 21/07/2023 14:08

who the fuck gets to decide the difference between sex or gender....... they are just words.

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 14:08

BCCoach · 21/07/2023 13:59

Sorry, are you saying that a dictionary shouldn’t list words that are offensive and outdated?

Read the definition above. It doesn't refer to the listing for 'Intersex', with a clause that the term is now obsolete and can be considered offensive. There would be no problem at all with that. I'm not advocating for a newspeak dictionary (perish the thought, given what's happening to the word 'woman').

It appears under the usual elusive, ill-defined bollocks that usually comes part and parcel of 'gender'. It's also fundamentally inaccurate in the way it's defined here.

BCCoach · 21/07/2023 13:59

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:46

I'm aware what the OED says. Excuse the arrogance of this response - but they're wrong.

As for Cambridge, if they're still using the term 'Intersex' it shows how far with the programme they've got. It's a outdated, inaccurate, even offensive term - alongside cretin and moron which surely no one still uses - and people with DSDs have repeatedly asked not to be referred to as such - or to have their medical condition misappropriated for the purposes of identity politics.

Those with DSDs are still either male or female. One sex produces large, the other small, gametes. There has not been one recorded human being, for the whole history of our species, with the ability to produce both.

Sorry, are you saying that a dictionary shouldn’t list words that are offensive and outdated?

porridgecake · 21/07/2023 13:55

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:46

I'm aware what the OED says. Excuse the arrogance of this response - but they're wrong.

As for Cambridge, if they're still using the term 'Intersex' it shows how far with the programme they've got. It's a outdated, inaccurate, even offensive term - alongside cretin and moron which surely no one still uses - and people with DSDs have repeatedly asked not to be referred to as such - or to have their medical condition misappropriated for the purposes of identity politics.

Those with DSDs are still either male or female. One sex produces large, the other small, gametes. There has not been one recorded human being, for the whole history of our species, with the ability to produce both.

Exactly.
The extent of institutional capture never ceases to amaze me.
In school, children are being taught that there are many, many genders.
They are being taught that if you are female and like boys toys it is possible to change sex to conform to your gender (which must be male). If you are male and like pink/dolls, you can change sex to align with your gender (which must be female).
Every parent should be concerned about this.
That poor little girl in Scotland who was kidnapped and raped got into a car with a man in a dress and wig because men in dresses and wigs are women, according to current gender ideology.
It is insidious and relies on people not being interested.

Swansandcustard · 21/07/2023 13:54

God, here we go again, same boring bollocks. Not something I give any thought to, does it actually matter ffs.

BubziOwl · 21/07/2023 13:53

A dictionary is essentially a document that is put together to reflect what people mean when they use words.

If the majority of English speakers use sex and gender interchangeably, then the dictionary will reflect that. It's not incorrect - it's a correct reflection of language usage. It's why words like "irregardless" have entered the dictionary - it may have started life as an error and indeed it's not a word that most people would use in proper speech or writing today, but plenty of words we today regard as perfectly correct originated from misspeaking and misspellings. If it becomes common enough then given enough time it becomes 'correct'.

If some academics decide that it's worthwhile to differentiate between sex and gender whilst writing then that's fine, but they cannot dictate how people use words. If people's usage doesn't change, then the dictionary definition doesn't change.

Flickersy · 21/07/2023 13:52

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:46

I'm aware what the OED says. Excuse the arrogance of this response - but they're wrong.

As for Cambridge, if they're still using the term 'Intersex' it shows how far with the programme they've got. It's a outdated, inaccurate, even offensive term - alongside cretin and moron which surely no one still uses - and people with DSDs have repeatedly asked not to be referred to as such - or to have their medical condition misappropriated for the purposes of identity politics.

Those with DSDs are still either male or female. One sex produces large, the other small, gametes. There has not been one recorded human being, for the whole history of our species, with the ability to produce both.

Then you need to write to them and tell them they're wrong and get it corrected.

I personally will take the definition from the OED, Cambridge, Webster's, Samuel Johnson etc. Which all list one of the definitions of gender as being sex, or describing it as a synonym for sex.

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/gender#:~:text=%3A%20the%20behavioral%2C%20cultural%2C%20or%20emotional%20traits%20typically%20associated%20with,other%20words%20or%20grammatical%20forms

https://johnsonsdictionaryonline.com/views/search.php?term=Gender

It should be abundantly clear to anyone that it has been used as a synonym for centuries and that is one of the correct definitions in the English language.

Definition of GENDER

a subclass within a grammatical class (such as noun, pronoun, adjective, or verb) of a language that is partly arbitrary but also partly based on distinguishable characteristics (such as shape, social rank, manner of existence, or sex) and that determi...

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/gender#:~:text=%3A%20the%20behavioral%2C%20cultural%2C%20or%20emotional%20traits%20typically%20associated%20with,other%20words%20or%20grammatical%20forms

motleymop · 21/07/2023 13:51

BeardieWeirdie · 20/07/2023 21:41

I’d rather go to a sex party than a naff gender reveal party. 🤮 Nobody gives a fuck about your baby’s genitals, they just ask out of politeness to fill the void in the conversation.

Could not agree more. Who gives a fuck? No one.

SerafinasGoose · 21/07/2023 13:47

NB. 'Gender' is also defined in linguistic terms as masculine, feminine and neuter. Now there's one to keep us up at night ...