Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone with parents in their early 70’s?

187 replies

Ivebeenslimed · 20/07/2023 19:29

How much involvement do they have in your child’s/childrens life?
My parents are early 70’s (dad 74, mum just turned 70)
Dd is 5, they’ve never once babysat her, they’re staying with us at the moment (live too far to just pop by) I have to work 2-3 mornings for 3 hours, I asked if they wanted me to keep the babysitter or if they’d be at home with her, they said they thought it was better to keep the babysitter. The babysitter comes around, they go out somewhere for walk/coffee and I pick them up.
They used to babysit my sisters kids having them overnight some weekends, whilst my sister worked, even once for a week whilst she went on holiday.
I asked my mum why it was different for me/us, she said because of their ages now, yes they are older than back then, but still go out every day and are active. She also said Dd is energetic, I said if she wanted to, she could literally stick the tv on and just chat to her as it was only 3 hours. I also said it would be nice for them to bond, which she looked surprised/confused/not that bothered about.
Aibu to feel sad about this? Am I expecting too much and are they too old to do this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
5thclassstamps · 21/07/2023 19:05

It’s not an age thing, it’s an attitude thing. My DM, mid 70s, healthy, is about to take my 2 children camping for 10 days. We’ve been staying in DHs hometown the past 10 days. MIL, just turned 70, healthy has spent 5 hours with us, and 1 of those hours was complaining that she never gets to spend any time with DGC…..she lives in a different country, hasn’t visited us since a year before Covid, refuses to do anything we try to include her in except shopping and now, the fact that 1/2 our AL is used up ‘visiting’ them, apparently that isn’t enough.

southernbelles · 21/07/2023 19:03

My parents are 64, my children are 6 & 1. They've had the 6 year old once overnight so we could go away (but phoned the morning after at 8am!) & almost never have him during the day. They live 5 minutes from us. Their take is they 'did their time' when we were kids. It makes me sad that they don't seem all that interested in building a relationship, & it's challenging (read: impossible!) for me & DH to do anything just the 2 of us.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 21/07/2023 19:01

Ivebeenslimed · 20/07/2023 23:07

@Otzi I suppose I just don’t see early 70’s as that old at all or them as being that old. They still travel, drive, dress up and drink for nights out, walk for miles etc

Perhaps they don’t like your DD? Or at least, find her difficult to manage ( in both senses of the word)

‘Gentle parenting’ ‘child led’ etc etc has generated a cohort of children that many older people find quite hard to cope with.

A friend confided in me recently that she doesn’t like her DGC much ( she loves them , she would jump in the river with her boots on to save them, but she doesn’t like them. ) She doesn’t enjoy their company, they shriek, they run around knocking into each other and the furniture, they do not respect her things, her home or her pet. Their parents are appalled at the idea that dGM might tell them not to do these things, might tell them in a raised voice, the horror.

Coupled with the natural fatigue of being elderly, it’s just not pleasant.

I spent a lot of time with my GM , I loved her dearly and still do, though she died more than fifty years ago. She was ‘ strict’, I was only allowed one set of toys out at a time, I had to clear my own plate after meals, I went to bed when she said it was bedtime. I can’t imagine most children now being expected to submit to this sort of environment, or their parents approving it.

DragonflyLady · 21/07/2023 18:54

My parents were similar ages when my daughter was five. They were very involved and had her one day a week before she started school. Collected her one evening a week when she started school.

Shiftingparadigm · 21/07/2023 18:41

Oldnproud · 21/07/2023 18:30

@Shiftingparadigm
All this means is that the parents who have helped more will have more priority with help from us and the grandchildren in old age when they need it. If the disinterested ones are happy to accept that then its fine for everyone then. We wouldn't leave them in the shit, but we wouldn't go out of our way to do anything special either.

It rarely works like that in reality, as you might find out yourself in the future. My parents were fantastic grandparents, but now that old age (90) has arrived, those grandchildren are, understandably, far too busy with their own young families to give even think of offering any help.

Yes I guess that is true. My gm gets visited a lot still by her adult grandchildren, maybe not help, but it's company. If that bond isn't there because you were not interested when they are younger it's unlikely to come out of the blue when they are adults. She is on her own in her home since gf died years ago, so it means a lot to her. I guess if you aren't into gc, then you probably aren't bothered by being alone in old age either.

Oldnproud · 21/07/2023 18:30

@Shiftingparadigm
All this means is that the parents who have helped more will have more priority with help from us and the grandchildren in old age when they need it. If the disinterested ones are happy to accept that then its fine for everyone then. We wouldn't leave them in the shit, but we wouldn't go out of our way to do anything special either.

It rarely works like that in reality, as you might find out yourself in the future. My parents were fantastic grandparents, but now that old age (90) has arrived, those grandchildren are, understandably, far too busy with their own young families to give even think of offering any help.

Fizbosshoes · 21/07/2023 18:15

Jujubes5 · 20/07/2023 19:46

I would say with the first born GChild there is a great hooha, everyone interested, everyone helping and I think it goes downhill, with interest waning after that!

I would say this is partly true. My IL told me on DDs 1st birthday they hadn't got a present because "the novelty had worn off "
They already had 6 gc at that stage. (Although I think DS possibly ended up getting a bit more attention as he was the last gc of 10)

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 21/07/2023 18:01

My parents (70 and 76) were very involved grandparents when younger, often looking after their GC independently, even overnight and on a couple of occasions for a whole week.

They are still involved grandparents but their GC is an adult so doesn't require care, and in fact can help them.

They love having friends and family with little children to visit and enjoy entertaining them, but were really quite worried when a friend was in a tight spot and asked them to look after a preschooler for 2-3hrs. They agreed and had a plan in place but were very relieved when no longer required. They just aren't as mobile or energetic anymore and worried about what they would do if he refused to co-operate or tried to run away.

I would suggest making opportunities to spend time with them and your DD so they can build a relationship. Things might change if they feel more confident about how she responds to them and so on. I know a few older people who were happy looking after a child they knew was well behaved and co-operative but much more reluctant about a more energetic and difficult child.

5128gap · 21/07/2023 16:44

Always surprises me that people with expectations of GP childcare seem to discover to their shock and outrage its not forthcoming AFTER the event.
If you feel so strongly GP childcare is needed, did none of you think to run it past your parents before having your children?
In no other circumstances would a person in their 70s (or any age for that matter) be presented with a job without being asked beforehand whether they'd be prepared to do it. So why base one of the most important tasks anyone can do for you on assumptions rather than prior agreement?

Starseeking · 21/07/2023 16:35

I forgot to mention that my DPs are also happy to do overnights, though I rarely ask for this as I'm conscious that one of my DC is a lot harder for them to look after at their ages due to additional needs.

Starseeking · 21/07/2023 16:32

My DM is 70 used to do more when they were younger; had each DC full-time from when I went back to work after 7 months - 1 year when they joined nursery, had them 1 day a week. Now only has them occasionally if I'm really stuck.

My DF is just about to turn 75, and babysits a couple of times a week if I'm stuck at work and can't get back in time for childcare to leave. He also takes my DC for days out regularly. He will also look after them for longer if I want to go out for an evening (I'm a single parent), though I rarely do this.

Stompythedinosaur · 21/07/2023 16:23

Both dm and dmil are that age, and did quite a lot of childcare (like, dmil had the dc two days a week for three years, dm came up for a week every seven weeks to help when I have a tricky rota week).

But, this was clearly above and beyond what I could have reasonably expected them to do.

Shiftingparadigm · 21/07/2023 16:21

Nanny0gg · 21/07/2023 14:58

You do realise that grandparents are entitled to their own lives, yes?

Sadly this is the case. One set of GPs don't work, live closer than us (20 min drive) and we see them a few times a year. Other parents are a bit further away and we see them weekly/fortnightly. They are also younger than the other gps. It upsets my eldest, but I just tell them they are a bit self obsessed (they are a bit) and it's not his fault. He seems to understand this and isn't massively keen on them anyway due to a lack of bond. It's a life lesson I guess that not every grandparent is a Disney grandparent (but probably makes out to their friends that they are 😂).

All this means is that the parents who have helped more will have more priority with help from us and the grandchildren in old age when they need it. If the disinterested ones are happy to accept that then its fine for everyone then. We wouldn't leave them in the shit, but we wouldn't go out of our way to do anything special either.

EsmeSusanOgg · 21/07/2023 16:19

My dad, mid-70s is frail due to past illness, my mum just turned 70 is hail and hearty. They are both relatively involved with their GC (oldest is nearly 5) but my siblings and I are not miles away. Baby sitting is more as hoc and for a couple of hours tops. But that works for everyone.

ImNotReallySpartacus · 21/07/2023 16:02

If anyone had the gall to tell me what I should be doing in my retirement years I would not be having a relationship with that person at all, let alone providing free child care.

Shiftingparadigm · 21/07/2023 15:54

I think it's their age and the age of the kids too. My mum pops over,its a bit of a drive and my son has ASD. She used to babysit while I worked, but it wasnt great tbh, so now she sees us when we are both free. I could do chores or exercise while she briefly has my child, but I'd rather spend time with her, and if anything does happen and she is hurt or ill, my son would get into trouble quickly.

With my first son she was much more active with him. There is a big difference between 63 and 70 and looking after a 2yr old and an 11 year old who can get help if needed. Same with other gp, he is fearful of being on his own with them due to this. They are both in pretty good health, but of an age when it can surprise you!

Other GPs have always been a bit lazy and not very interested in our kids.

I have always found it more reliable to have paid childcare if you can afford to. GPs have been a bit flakey at times as it is a favour and not an obligation, although I have alway appreciated anything they have offered. They have saved my arse a few times!

locketrocket · 21/07/2023 15:54

It's a strange one and can see why it gets to you.

DP now in their early 70s and although very fit and active, they do have age related health issues.

My dc are now 18 & 16, and my parents loved looking after them when they were little (they often comment that it was perfect timing and they have such a lovely relationship)
However if my dsis was to have children now, then there's no way they could help her as much as they helped me, iykwim.

5128gap · 21/07/2023 15:33

If they say they feel too old for it you have to respect that. No good ever comes from trying to encourage, persuade, or shame someone into doing something for you that they feel is beyond their capacity.
For what it's worth at 54 I do a lot of childcare for my existing DGC. I already know from the demands it places on me that I won't be doing it at 70 for any future DGC.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/07/2023 15:21

Mind you I don’t feel like looking after a baby or a toddler and I’m 44!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/07/2023 15:21

My parents are in their early to mid 70s.

They do have much less energy now than they did in the 60s.

I’m lucky that my kids are now 14 and 9, so the “having energy” side of it is less relevant than if they were under 5s, although my 9 yo is very energetic as he has ADHD.

They will have one or both of them to stay in the school holidays still which is really kind of them, but I think they would struggle if they had a regular commitment, and would definitely not feel able for a toddler still.

The 14 yo is like having an adult to stay tbh!

Katiesaidthat · 21/07/2023 15:15

My mum is 77, my dad died when he was 56. There is no way my mum can look after my daughter for anything above an hour. As it is, when I have visited I have put the child to bed and she has baby-sat a sleeping kid. She would be better at home if needs must but couldn´t go out with my daughter as couldn´t keep up with her. It depends on the grandparents.

Nanny0gg · 21/07/2023 15:12

Otzi · 20/07/2023 23:33

Ok, so what do you have planned? You have house guests and are hosting a family get together. Have you got things in mind? Even things like board games and such? Have you suggested specific activities that your mum can do with DD? Told her what DD likes doing, thought about what your mum might like to share doing with her? Any nice places you can all go out for walks nearby?

Really if you're just switching telly on then people will sit and watch it in the absence of anything else.

Why does her mum have to be micro-managed?

Can't she just come and visit?

Nanny0gg · 21/07/2023 15:10

Ivebeenslimed · 20/07/2023 23:17

@Otzi What am I doing? Trying to encourage my mum to play/talk with Dd more, but she generally just sits and watches tv, it’s like Dd is an annoyance in a way

Stop 'encouraging'

Butt out. If your mum is kind even if disinterested then let her be.

When/at what age do your parents get to choose what happens in their own lives?

HollaHolla · 21/07/2023 15:09

Oh, and my brother and his family are nearby, whereas my sister's lot are a couple of hours away, so less day to day involvement.

We only had one grandparent (dad grew up in care, and mum had lost her mum when my sister was a baby), who was an hour away. Grandad was in his 50s when we were born, and still working, so we saw him more at weekends, and school holidays. I think times have changed, as mum stayed at home with the three of us until we were all at School. So, less hands-on childcare needed.

Nanny0gg · 21/07/2023 15:08

Ivebeenslimed · 20/07/2023 23:10

It’s not me being entitled at all, it’s not about childcare. I can afford it and am fine with having my babysitter/nanny. It’s that quality time with her and getting to know her more. Dad is better and plays with her and chats with her a fair amount, mum is quite critical to be honest and I see my Dd isn’t as comfortable with her and clearly adores her grandad. I just wish she’d take the time to seem to want to be with her

If that bothered your mum she'd do something about it.

There is very little 'Live and Let Live' on this thread.

It's all about what is expected of grandparents, be it physically or emotionally.

They don't seem to get a choice